10 Unexpectedly Disturbing Film Performances

Thanks for making us feel real uncomfortable, talented Hollywood actors.

Acting is a one of a kind profession, when you think about it. In what other line of work is it not only acceptable, but widely encouraged, for you act as unhinged and outright creepy as possible? Throughout the history of cinema, actors have built up a profile and an image; it's an inevitable association the world begins to have with a performer. For example, we all know well that Nicolas Cage will, regardless of the nature of the film he's in, break out into a full on yelling-ball-of-crazy at least once in every role. Similarly, Tom Cruise is widely regarded as appearing in, sprinting inexplicably in, and ultimately saving the day in, a mega-money blockbuster. These are roles we've simply accepted as "the norm." However, there are times when we are caught out by our assumptions, and an actor pulls off a performance which ends up staying with us for years. If this performance is a serious/drama role, they'll win awards. If it's funny, they'll warm our hearts. But if the performance is disturbing, we'll all take notice out of complete and utter shock - who'd have thought it possible? Yes, sometimes the performance will disturb us due to the previous profile of an actor, whereas other times it'll be simply down to the fact that the actor did not look suitable for the role in the first place. So let's get down to the nitty gritty and take a look through the 10 most unexpectedly disturbing performances in film to date...

10. Leonardo DiCaprio As Calvin Candie (Django Unchained)

Django Unchained was packed full of mesmerising performances. You had Jamie Foxx being unfathomably badass, Christoph Waltz stealing the show and Samuel L. Jackson being utterly detestable. But the one that stood out as being completely hate-inspiring was Leonardo DiCaprio as plantation owner Calvin Candie. DiCaprio is known for two things: first, he's the rough around the edges romance interest for the female audience, and second, he's the star of more thoughtful thrillers. But more to the point, DiCaprio is almost always the good guy; he's the oppressed, not the oppressor. Turn that all upside down for Django, as DiCaprio is the main antagonist, a rich man with a plantation, slave owner and mandingo aficionado. He is stupendously racist, right down to thinking that there is a science which proves black people are inferior, and isn't frightened to demonstrate his beliefs, often with the use of a hammer and the skull of a victim. What made DiCaprio even more disturbing was the manner in which he portrayed the character with a fine balance of childish nature and suavity. He was very much the Southern Gentleman, but he had a bubbling fury which could burst out of him in a juvenile tantrum when things did not go to his plan.

9. Javier Bardem As Anton Chigurh (No Country For Old Men)

Before the release of No Country For Old Men (easily one of the best films of the last decade), Javier Bardem was a barely known name outside of the Spanish-speaking cinematic world. More to the point, even within his Spanish filmography, the majority of his roles were softer, even romantic ones. That's a pretty good reason as to why his turn as Anton Chigurh was so disturbing; that it was simply not expected of someone with such a low profile. However, Bardem bores himself into your mind from his performance as a whole. Chigurh is a cold, isolated and extremely detached serial killer. He is utterly psychotic and relentless in his spree, and although he claims to have his reasons, we're never really sure what those justifications may be. Furthermore, the man looks huge, and extremely intimidating enough, even before you check out the bolt pistol he uses to carry out his acts of righteousness. It's almost as if the people he encounters are his cattle to be put down as he pleases. In the film, Chigurh kills almost every single character he encounters, sometimes simply deciding their fate with the toss of a coin. Chigurh believes he's following a moral code (known only to him), but also seems to take great pleasure in dishing out his punishment: he is truly disturbing to behold, should you picture him appearing in you doorway.

8. Kevin Spacey As John Doe - Se7en

Similar to Bardem, Kevin Spacey's career had not yet properly taken off until the release of this film, but thanks to his more than noticeable appearance in Se7en, we simply could not get enough of him. Until the film came out, Spacey was a minor player of scarcely noteworthy movies and television shows, utilising his pleasant and calm-sounding voice to appear as harmless and likable as possible. All that changed hugely thanks to his performance as John Doe, the genius serial killer who picks off victims in accordance to the seven deadly sins. The fact that we barely see the character until the film begins to reach a culmination point helps here, as we're constantly trying to figure out and picture our own version of what the killer will look and act like. When Doe announces himself to be the mastermind, he does so in the middle of the police department head quarters, shouting the name of the detectives trying to catch him. That's unsettling as it is, as he does so without an ounce of fear or remorse, giving himself up freely in order to perfect his master plan. But add to that not only his deeds, but the cool, calm voice he uses at all times and you have something which goes deeper than just being creepy and unhinged. Doe is calculated and collected at all times, he always appears to be in control, regardless of whether he's in police custody or not. Spacey delivers a performance so disturbing, it broke new grounds in the mold of modern movie serial killers.

7. Oliver Reed As Bill Sikes - Oliver!

Whilst Oliver Reed had rightly earned himself a reputation as a tough and often hard man, even reflecting these qualities in the roles he took, it was his appearance in the cinematic adaption of Oliver Twist which will stand out as being the most memorable for most. When thinking of Oliver!, most people will tend to think of the musical numbers and a band of orphans who get up to some lovable hijinks whilst the eponymous hero strives to find parental love once more. So when you place a notorious hard man in the middle of all that, you have a recipe for discomfort. Reed's Bill Sikes is the black heart of the film; he never shows any form of emotion other than when he is dealing out brutality to helpless victims. Not only does he callously abuse both the groups of orphans and their elderly leader, Fagin, but Sikes also murders his own wife in a fit of violent rage at her protection of Oliver. Nancy was the closest thing to a mother that Oliver has in the story, and so for Sikes to kill her in cold blood is one thing, but for it to happen in the midst of an otherwise family friendly musical is another matter entirely. Reed's icy stare and grumbled delivery gives the character the perfect foundation from which to perform his skin-crawling deeds.

6. Dennis Hopper As Frank Booth - Blue Velvet

Dennis Hopper was most certainly not an unknown quantity when he appeared in Blue Velvet in 1986. However, his career had stagnated somewhat, and he'd taken to appearing in trashier films, quite often action and horror flicks, so it wasn't exactly unusual to see him play the creepier, manic role. But his appearance as Frank Booth in David Lynch's mystery masterpiece is easily one of the most disturbing you're likely to see in film. Frank is nothing short of psychotic. He has the temper of a mentally unsound invalid in the body of a fully grown maniac. He is a pervert of incalculable measures, and constantly takes hits from an unidentified gas which seems to only make him more erratic. But bizarrely, all of Frank's almost over-the-top characteristics are not the only thing which make him so disturbing, but Hopper himself aids that facet. Hopper's performance is so exaggerated in order to match the character, that you could be quite forgiven for believing that the director had simply raided a prison for the criminally insane and allowed the most unstable inmate to rant and rave with the rest of the cast in front of a camera. Hopper's trademarked manic style of acting is truly unnerving, and makes you shuffle uncomfortably in your seat as he dances through his acts of depravity.

5. Ted Levine As Buffalo Bill - Silence Of The Lambs

When looking at a film which also stars an actor with a reputation as high as Anthony Hopkins portraying a super-intelligent but incarcerated serial killer/cannibal, it probably seems a bit odd to include the other villain of the piece as being disturbing instead. But that is precisely the reason why Ted Levine's appearance in Silence Of The Lambs is more unexpectedly unsettling. Although it is well noted that Hopkins does not feature on screen for very long at all, a lot of the film pivots upon the scenes involving him, so our attention is mainly focused upon the actions of Hannibal Lecter. This leaves room for Levine's character, Buffalo Bill (who is also a serial killer) to wreak his havoc upon our minds. Think about it; Lecter has been asked by the police to assist them in catching Bill, which is immediately an uneasy situation to think about, as it could possibly suggest that the police see Bill as a threat of equal severity to Lecter. Furthermore, there's the fact that Levine manages to turn himself into what can only be described as the most horrifying transvestite Jon Bon Jovi tribute the world has ever witnessed. Levine is the unsung hero of the film, as his character is unbelievably disturbing, given that he is at large, where Hannibal is in captivity.

4. Kathy Bates As Annie Wilks - Misery

Like a number of actors on this list, Kathy Bates was not a particularly well known name when she starred in her most disturbing of roles, but no doubts about it, her appearance as Annie Wilkes in Misery will be the role that she is most remembered for. But the added factor to this particular role is simple: she is female. Bates takes the role of what is essentially a groupie of an author, and combines it with a sociopath. Bates is a homely and gentle looking character, which is immediately disarming, and this is translated in the film as she at first appears attentive and caring for her guest. But all that is flipped when it is revealed that she is in fact holding Paul Sheldon hostage, with no scene standing out so infamously as the sledgehammer-to-the-ankles one. The very fact that Bates is female, partnered with her victim being played by a man with a reputation of playing tough guys, in James Caan, adds a particularly disturbing finish to the performance. It is a total shift of traditional power roles in film, and almost single-handed opened the door for female characters to be just as unhinged and unsettling as their male counterparts.

3. Elijah Wood As Kevin - Sin City

Sin City was a film which gathered a cast of actors noted for their almost stereotyped roles and warped them to phenomenal effect and success. Mickey Rourke became a brute with a heart of gold and Clive Owen became a gritty and believable action hero. But the most astounding divergence from the norm came in Elijah Wood as Kevin. Up until this point, Elijah Wood was known as one of two things: the heroic Frodo, hobbit hero of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, or the plucky if annoying youngster of countless nineties movies. So to have him cast as a mute, cannibalistic serial killer with a particular penchant for murdering prostitutes, whilst living alone in an unbelievably creepy house set out in the woods, was a somewhat a break from tradition. Wood's trademark gigantic staring eyes are used to magnificent effect here, piercing mercilessly into the eyes of his victims, opponents and the audience, making us all feel a lot less comfortable. Add to this that he is seemingly invincible and is left beaten and at the mercy of his own hungry pet wolf...having already been tortured and his limbs sawn off. Most disturbing of all though, is the fact that during all of this, he sits placidly, with a wide, blissful grin on his face.

2. Heath Ledger As The Joker - The Dark Knight

When it was announced that Heath Ledger would be donning the clown paint and doing battle with Batman in Christopher Nolan's highly anticipated The Dark Knight, the film community more or less imploded under the weight of displease and disgust. Ledger was, at the time known for romantic comedies and one excellent performance in Brokeback Mountain. He was, in short, seen as totally inappropriate to play the chaotic lunatic that is Batman's number one enemy. It almost needs no explaining just how wrong everyone was, as it is largely recognised that Ledger's portrayal of the iconic character has fast become one of the most memorable, if not definitive versions yet seen. Ledger immersed himself in the role, and discounting the make up, was completely unrecognisable . His voice was immediately unnerving, with a perfect blend of subdued, croaky insanity and controlled ranting. His movements were meticulously controlled and planned, right down to the incessant licking of the lips between words, which just added another shudder-inducing moment for the audience. The character had been kicked into the more realistic vision of Gotham Nolan had been projecting, and it simply would not have worked were it not for the efforts of Ledger. This is the role that the man will be remembered for, and it's almost a shame that it will be linked to his death (being as it was one of his final roles), as had he lived a full life, we would still be talking about how creepy-yet-morbidly amusing his Joker was.

1. Robin Williams As Sy Parrish - One Hour Photo

Disregarding his stand-up career, Robin Williams has spent roughly thirty years as a face well-loved by children, and being a shoe-in for family-friendly comedy movies. He has a natural talent for being a flamboyant entertainer in a way that particularly appeals to children, with roles in Aladdin, Mrs. Doubtfire and Flubber solidifying his stature in the nineties. And that's why his role in thriller One Hour Photo is so utterly disturbing. Williams plays photograph technician Sy Parrish, who develops an extremely unhealthy relationship with a family whose photos he produces. Gradually, as his behavior becomes more erratic and his discrepancies are uncovered by his employer, he is fired, which triggers him to snap, and seek revenge on the father of the family, whom he had previously discovered is cheating on his wife. Sy appears to be simultaneously emotionless and extremely emotionally unstable, having a customer service persona of blandness lying precariously over a violently lonely personality beneath. The character stalks the family without their knowledge or even suspicion, to the point where his is seen sat alone, watching their son play baseball, which is immediately an unsettling image, regardless of his intentions. Furthermore, the changes to Williams' appearance are also somewhat unnerving, as his bleached blond hair and bright blue eyes make him seem somehow robotic, and most definitely not human. His overall performance, coupled with his history of being in family-friendly productions means that Robin Williams takes the glory of having the most unexpectedly disturbing performance I have yet seen in film. Has anyone been missed out? Do you agree or disagree with the choices made? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

English MA Graduate, passionate about film, Sunderland A.F.C., tv and music with guitars found somewhere in it.