10 Villains DC Movies Got Completely Wrong

Joel Schumacher isn't the only one guilty of this.

Jared Leto The Joker
Warner Bros.

Superhero comic book adaptations can be notoriously tricky to pull off. What works on the page won't necessarily translate well to the screen, so filmmakers within this genre need to be creative in their interpretation of the subject matter.

This occasionally means deconstructing classic characters and remoulding them in a way that's a better fit for cinema, and Hollywood doesn't always get this right, especially when it comes to the villains.

Warner Bros' unofficially-named DC Extended Universe keeps making this mistake. Justice League was met with lacklustre reviews and one of the most frequent criticisms you'll hear is its interpretation of the main antagonist.

This is a problem that dates back not just to the early days of the franchise, but to much earlier DC films, ones that were released long before the cinematic universe model was apparently the only viable way to make comic book films.

Sure, there are many notable exceptions, from Gene Hackman's Lex Luthor to Heath Ledger's Joker, but the list of botched DC villains on the big screen seems to be growing, and there are some pretty bad offenders.

10. Lex Luthor (Batman V Superman)

Lex Luthor
Warner Bros.

Lex Luthor's plan to unleash Doomsday on Metropolis in Batman v Superman's final act was patently ridiculous, and was only ever going to result in him winding up in jail or going down with the stricken city.

Muddled motivation and plotholes big enough to fly a Kryptonian spacecraft through aren't the only reasons Jesse Eisenberg's take on the villain didn't work. This was a reinterpretation of an iconic character, but the vision underpinning it was uninspired.

Luthor, who is supposed to be cold, calculating and dignified in his evil genius, came across like an oddball mash-up of Mark Zuckerberg and Heath Ledger's Joker, and was ultimately none of those things.

No doubt Zack Snyder tried something different with the villain because there had already been two big-screen versions of him by this point, but there are so many aspects of traditional Luthor that this incarnation needed. More masculinity and less twitchy weirdness would have been a good start.

Presumably Warner is well aware of the negativity surrounding Eisenberg's portrayal, hence why they benched his character for most of Justice League.


9. Enchantress (Suicide Squad)

Suicide Squad Enchantress
Warner Bros.

Like Suicide Squad itself, Cara Delevigne's Enchantress failed to live up to the hype and it was disappointing when she turned out to be the movie's main villain.

The biggest problems have little to do with Delevigne's portrayal, more the fact the character was criminally underwritten. Her powers are barley explained and her mystical backstory is glossed over, along with her relationship with Rick Flag.

Although there was five decades of DC Comics lore for director David Ayer to draw on when bringing Enchantress to life, he demanded little from Delevigne beyond parading around in a series of skimpy outfits and a bit of body gyrating.

Suicide Squad had the chance get creative with strong female characters, and having one as the main antagonist would have been a bold move if they'd made an effort to flesh her out.

The movie's problems were only exacerbated when it introduced Enchantress' brother Incubus, who was barely a character at all. It's more accurate to describe her fiery protector as a mess of CGI that landed in the film straight off the set of Brendan Fraser's The Mummy.


8. Hector Hammond (Green Lantern)

Hector Hammond Green Lantern.jpg
Warner Bros.

Everyone knows bad CGI was the main villain in Green Lantern (and that's not just a reference to Parallax) but it wasn't the only evil the movie handled poorly.

It's take on Hector Hammond completely missed the mark, failing to tap into the tragic aspects of the character and instead fast-tracking his descent into generic villainy.

Green Lantern introduces Peter Sarsgaard's character as an eccentric loner, a timid man who's basically downtrodden from the first act. Throw in some unrequited love and the movie's recipe for villainy is complete.

Hammond's background essentially makes him a bad guy as much as the yellow energy of fear from Parallax, but never is he presented as a victim of circumstance, something that would have given the movie a semblance of depth.

Ryan Reynolds's Hal Jordan is everything Hammond: strong, courageous, good looking, witty (allegedly) - but the dichotomy between the two characters only brings out the worst in the hero, casting a reflection of smarmy arrogance from the dark mirror.


7. Bane (Batman & Robin)

10 Bane Batman And Robin 1 W1200 H630
Warner Bros

Between George Clooney's bat nipples and Arnie's ice puns, Batman & Robin didn't need to give the audience another reason to storm out of the theatre, but it provided one nonetheless with its portrayal of Bane.

This is the powerhouse who broke the Batman in DC Comics, a formidable bad guy who's physical strength is matched only by his own intellect, yet Joel Schumacher saw it fit to boil him down to little more than a bad parody.

Batman & Robin's Bane is the lowest common denominator and Schumacher's decision to relegate him to henchman felt like an attempt to troll the fans.

Gone was his intellect, replaced by monosyllabic grunts, and he was closer in design to a villain from an unmade Nacho Libre sequel than his comic book counterpart. That ridiculous Mexican wrestling mask! Ugh!

Wrestler Robert Swenson played Bane in Batman & Robin and took the crown as the movie's worst villain, which is quite the feat considering he had Schumacher's takes on Poison Ivy and Mister Freeze to compete with,


6. Steppenwolf (Justice League)

Justice League Steppenwolf
Warner Bros.

One of the chief criticisms of the recent Justice League movie is its handling of the main villain, Steppenwolf. The New God is portrayed as nothing more than a big alien punching bag for the heroes, with little motivation beyond being evil in the most black and white sense of the word.

To portray the alien warlord three dimensionally, the filmmakers could have explored Apokoliptian lore and delved into his relationship with the other New Gods, but they showed no ambition to make him anything more than walking malevolence.

As if underwriting a classic bad guy wan't enough, Steppenwolf is marred by terrible CGI and looks barely more convincing than a character from an early PlayStation 3 game, and on par with Henry Cavill's digital shave.

Actor Ciaran Hinds did his best providing the villain's thunderous vocals and mo-cap work, but there was little he could do about the wafer-thin script and poor CGI.


5. The Riddler (Batman Forever)

Riddler Newspaper
Warner Bros.

The Riddler was often portrayed as a tongue-in-cheek villain in some of the early DC Comics, but the family-friendly Batman Forever took this too far by casting Jim Carrey in the role and giving him free reign to go full comedy.

Carrey's spandex-clad Edward Nygma was the character that made the first film of the Joel Schumacher era a throwback to the days of Adam West - his portrayal was over the top and just downright silly.

The biggest problem was the movie's tone. In search of bigger box office bucks, Warner Bros took Batman into PG territory and a pantomime-style Riddler, offset against the somewhat grittier Two Face, was deemed the best fit for this style.

Like numerous other characters, Nygma was a victim of Schumacher's approach because the Riddler is a character ripe for reinvention on the big screen. In an age of mass surveillance and Wikileaks, the puzzle-obsessed baddie could be reinterpreted as a master cypher who tests Bruce Wayne's detective skills to the max.

Alternately, he could be remoulded as a Saw-style villain, who snares Batman in a series of complex traps that can only be escaped through advanced problem solving.

But, back in the 1990s, Schumacher played it safe with a family-friendly Batman movie, and the Riddler was one of the characters who suffered most.


4. Doomsday (Batman V Superman)

Batman V Superman Doomsday
Warner Bros.

Batman v Superman's Doomsday must be a frequent attendee at the support group for comic book villains ruined by crap CGI, along with Incubus and Steppenwolf.

In this instance, the issue is entirely an image problem because there's nothing else to Doomsday besides rage, destruction and raw power, and the movie portrayed that well enough.

The quality of the CGI used to create him, however, was as questionable as Lex Luthor's methods for doing so. The end result looked more like a Lord of the Rings Cave Troll than the alien monster who killed Superman in the comics, but the worst part is that the digital effects were no less convincing than those used in 2001's Fellowship of the Ring.

Botching the creature's design was't enough for Batman v Superman. The movie also went and ruined his final-act arrival in one of its trailers, spoiling a potentially surprising twist. Good job, guys.


3. The Joker (Suicide Squad)

1255786

You'll read a lot of mixed things about Jared Leto's Joker from Suicide Squad. Some fans were won over by his grungy look and decision to go full method for the role, while others feel he failed miserably in his attempts to fill Heath Ledger's massive clown shoes.

The reality of the situation is that there was merit in Leto's approach to the role. He channelled menace, screen presence and devilish charm in his few scenes that didn't end up on the cutting room floor, but was ultimately given a raw deal because of the way his character was handled.

Warner Bros' mistake with its latest Joker was choosing the wrong film to introduce him in, and then giving him little precious little to do in that movie. It feels as though Suicide Squad included The Joker purely because the studio said it could, to add some comic book star power to its cast.

Leto's main contribution to the film is hovering on the periphery of the story and abusing Harley Quinn in flashback sequences, and half of those were cut during the overzealous editing sessions.

This version of the Joker could have been so much more if Warner and DC had allowed him to put his best foot forward as Suicide Squad's main villain, or better yet, introduced him in a Batman solo film to play him off the Caped Crusader.


2. Two Face (Batman Forever)

Tommy Lee Jones Two Face
Warner Brothers

Like everything else in Batman Forever, Two Face wasn't so much watered down as he was drowned within an inch of his life. Harvey Dent is one of the most complex and tragic rogues in the Bat gallery, and his duality and downfall have given writers across multiple mediums plenty of substance to explore.

Casting Tommy Lee Jones, a veteran actor capable of channelling true gravitas, should have helped the movie plumb some of that depth, but sadly Joel Schumacher had zero ambition to do that. His version of Two Face was a second-rate rehash of Jack Nicholson's Joker.

Jones's Dent cackles manically when hatching a diabolical scheme and throws a tantrum when they don't pan out. The role was supposed to be a conflicted exploration of dark duality, inner turmoil and a heartbreaking downfall, but deviation from the comic books saw it descend into cliche.

While Zack Snyder has been criticises for deconstructing characters in the current DCEU, at least there was vision underpinning his process. Schumacher deconstructed DC heroes and villains and left only their bones behind.


1. Mr. Freeze (Batman & Robin)

Mr Freeze
Warner Bros.

Arnold Schwarzenegger's performance as Batman & Robin's Mr. Freeze is so cartoony that it made Batman: The Animated Series look like live-action. This was comic book movie villainy at its most satirical: cringe-worthy ice puns every two seconds and an evil scheme that wouldn't have even made sense in Bizarro World.

It's impossible to take his plot to turn Gotham into a giant icicle seriously at face value, let alone with Arnie reeling off clangers like "let's kick some ice".

Victor Fries's genius-level intellect and the tragic backstory involving his wife is barely touched on as Schumacher and Schwarzenegger mostly played for laughs, with the Terminator star's portrayal parodying the genre better than Doctor Evil ever could.

Bane may be the furthest thing in the Schumacher Bat universe to his comic book counterpart, but Mr. Freeze is by far the most cheesy, which is quite the accomplishment considering he's up against Jim Carrey's Riddler.


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw