10 WAY Better Endings For Recent Movies
Here's how you fix Army of the Dead's atrocious ending.
How a movie ends is so, so important - it's arguably more crucial than any other part of the film. Get it right and it can massively elevate even a mediocre movie, but screw it up and you can destroy two hours' worth of viewer goodwill.
These 10 movies all concluded in highly divisive fashion which left audiences fervently debating what they'd just seen.
In some cases the climax was simply a deflating end to a good movie, while in others it felt like a major creative misstep and actively damaged the rest of the story.
Then there are those endings that just could've gone a little further and delivered a more satisfying experience overall.
In each case, these films would've all benefitted massively from reworked endings which considered what audiences actually wanted to see, and what best suited the mood of the piece and perhaps also the franchise moving forward.
From films that killed off the wrong character to those that just didn't know when to call it quits, these films could've ended in vastly superior fashion with a few relatively simple changes...
10. Allyson Dies - Halloween Kills
Halloween Kills was a generally disappointing follow-up to 2018's franchise-saving sequel, concluding with a laughably predictable ending that just about everybody saw coming.
Given that Kills was presented as the second film in a new trilogy of Halloween movies, it was incredibly easy to guess that it would end on a downcast cliffhanger - an Empire Strikes Back-esque bummer that set the stage for an emotionally charged "final" showdown in next year's Halloween Ends.
And the most obvious choice was to kill off Laurie's (Jamie Lee Curtis) daughter Karen (Judy Greer), who is indeed brutally stabbed to death by Michael Myers in the final moments of the film.
But if filmmaker David Gordon Green wanted to deliver a truly shocking ending, he would've gone one step further and killed Laurie's granddaughter Allyson (Andi Matichak) instead.
This would've been far more impactful for several reasons - for starters, it would've subverted the passing-of-the-torch expectation in years-later sequels, that the young descendant of the hero is basically guaranteed to survive.
It also would've been the worst possible thing Michael could've done to both Laurie and Karen, to literally kill the youngest member of their bloodline, annihilating their future while teeing up a finale that couldn't be more personal.
On top of this, Karen's death was a genuine bummer because she's shown to be one of the film's most resourceful characters, only to pick up the idiot ball in the final moments and wander off to Judith Myers' old bedroom unaccompanied.
Conversely Allyson is shown to be reckless throughout the film, joining the group that's hunting Michael, and so her demise would seem a lot more plausible.
Imagine if, when Karen is luring Michael out of the house by holding his mask, Michael instead just closes the front door and butches Allyson. Roll credits. Now that is an ending.
9. Cassie's Killer Gets Away With It - Promising Young Woman
Promising Young Woman is undeniably one of the most controversial and fiercely debated movies of the last year, with particular regard to its ending.
The film follows Cassie Thomas (Carey Mulligan) as she plots revenge on Al Monroe (Chris Lowell), the man who raped her best friend Nina years earlier, as lead to Nina's suicide.
Cassie hatches her plan at the end of the movie, but in a shocking twist, she's overpowered by Al, who smothers her to death with a pillow and, with the help of his friend Joe (Max Greenfield), burns her corpse before going to his wedding.
It's a chilling outcome, albeit one which has its edges smoothed away by a tacked-on epilogue where it's revealed that Cassie had made elaborate arrangements to ensure Al would be caught in the event that he killed her.
Though it provides sure catharsis after Cassie's devastating demise, it's also incredibly convoluted, even silly, coming at the end of a film that had so much to say about the realities of women struggling to be believed and also male privilege.
It feels like a reshoot ending mandated by the studio, because when you look at the world today, isn't an ending where Al gets away with killing Cassie just a lot more realistic?
Oscar-winning writer-director Emerald Fennell later stated that she indeed originally intended to end the film with Cassie's murder, but at the behest of her financiers decided to make it slightly less depressing.
8. Cole Becomes Johnny Cage - Mortal Kombat
Many Mortal Kombat fans wondered why the new movie's protagonist was an entirely original character, martial artist Cole Young (Lewis Tan), enough that the totally believable rumour emerged that Cole was actually a secret origin story for franchise legend Johnny Cage.
It made a lot of sense - beyond the baffling decision to include an audience insert character, Cole is literally a cage fighter with movie star good looks.
And yet, the film comes and goes without any such reveal. Instead, Cole is indeed just a random human created for the movie, who at film's end heads to Hollywood to seek out the actual Johnny Cage.
It would've made this basically pointless inclusion of a new human character well worth it if he took up the Johnny Cage mantle at the end.
The sequel could then open a few years later with Cage an established martial artist embarking on a career in Hollywood, before the third film saw him slink into his more typical cocky a**hole persona from the games.
But alas, it seems more likely that if we do end up with any sequels, Cole is going to be tagging along as the third wheel protagonist nobody asked for.
7. Natasha Returns To Ohio - Black Widow
Now in the case of Black Widow, the superior ending was actually filmed and even released as an extra on Disney+, but was ultimately ditched in favour of something much less interesting.
The film ends with Natasha (Scarlett Johansson) saving the day and Rick Mason (O. T. Fagbenle) supplying her with the Quinjet, as leads into the events of Avengers: Infinity War. It's tidy, but a pretty boring, un-emotional send-off for one of the mainline Avengers.
The deleted epilogue however sees Nat return to Ohio where she grew up, and where a group of children are playing while pretending to be the Avengers.
A young girl who styles herself as Black Widow walks up to Nat and playfully raises her fist, before Nat smiles and does the same, followed by a hard cut to black. The end.
Having Nat return home and see the positive impact she has had on young girls would've been a much more thematically resonant ending, especially given Nat and Yelena's (Florence Pugh) heated conversation about Nat's dubious status as a role model earlier in the movie.
This would've been so much more impactful and memorable as an ending than Nat just getting in the Quinjet and flying off.
6. Candyman DESTROYS The Police - Candyman
Despite the undeniable craft that went into it, the recent Jordan Peele-produced Candyman sequel was a bit of a disappointment, particularly the cynical means through which it brought back the original Candyman, Daniel Robitaille (Tony Todd).
Though the marketing suggested that Todd's Candyman would have a major role in the film, he ends up being relegated to a seconds-long cameo in the final moments, as the recently summoned Candyman (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II) transforms into the earlier Robitaille version via a digitally de-aged Todd.
As neat as it is was to see Brianna (Teyonah Parris) summon Candyman to avenge her partner Anthony (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II), who was shot by the police, Candyman's standoff with the cops is too brief and restrained to be much satisfying.
If the filmmakers wanted to present a truly daring and visceral engagement with modern day issues of "blue-on-Black" violence, they would've devoted the third act to Candyman basically taking on the entire surrounding police force.
Imagine the police station assault from The Terminator, except it's Robitaille slashing his way through the cop shop and avenging the thousands of Black people needlessly slain by police.
It wouldn't have been subtle and would've definitely proved controversial, but considering how abruptly Candyman ends, it really felt like it needed to do more and take its brutal vision much, much further. If you're going to prod the bear of systemic racism, at least do it with full conviction.
5. The Blind Man Dies For Real - Don't Breathe 2
Don't Breathe 2 wasn't a great sequel, though it gets some credit for boldly attempting to reinvent the Blind Man aka Norman (Stephen Lang) as an anti-hero of-sorts.
A lot of fans questioned the decision to try and make the audience root for Norman given that the first film outed him as a rapist and abuser, and while the sequel doesn't shy away from his terrible past, it makes one fatal misstep when executing his redemptive arc.
Norman spends the film caring for his 11-year-old adopted daughter Phoenix (Madelyn Grace), who is later revealed to be the daughter of meth cooks who wish to get Phoenix back in order to transplant her organs into her dying mother (Fiona O'Shaughnessy).
Basically, Norman is a piece of s**t, but Phoenix's parents are even worse. This comes to a head in the film's finale, where Norman confesses his terrible actions to Phoenix before being mortally wounded by Phoenix's father.
As he appears to die, he remarks to Phoenix that she saved his soul, the implication being that by saving her from her parents he at least somewhat re-balanced the karmic scales for his own monstrous actions.
Yet this idea is unfortunately undone by a post-credits scene which shows Phoenix's father's dog approaching Norman's body and licking his fingers, which move slightly, suggesting that there's still some life left in him yet.
While Norman dying for his sins doesn't let him off the hook for everything he did in the first film, it does feel like a fitting end for a complicated individual.
That the filmmakers couldn't resist but include some last-minute sequel-bait, then, feels like a total slap in the face to any dramatic integrity the ending almost had.
4. The "Bad" Guys Win - Old
M. Night Shyamalan's new thriller Old may be uneven, but it sure is a wild ride alright.
The film reaches a natural end-point when the middle-aged versions of Maddox (Embeth Davidtz) and Trent (Emun Elliott) get trapped in an underwater coral passage, seemingly drowning, before it's revealed that the resort is actually a secret research facility conducting clinical trials of new life-saving drugs.
The shadowy pharma company has used the beach's time-accelerating properties to conduct their long-form trials in mere days, allowing them to make major medical breakthroughs in a ridiculously short amount of time.
It's a neat, Twilight Zone-esque kicker of an ending - if it were the ending, at least. Instead, the film continues for another 10 minutes with a more crowd-pleasing finale that feels as though tacked-on after poor test screening feedback.
In this extended finale, we see that Maddox and Trent are actually still alive and have brought the authorities to the resort who immediately shut the company's activities down.
It's just a little too neat and sunny for an otherwise bleak and disturbing film, when the reality is that mere mortals rarely triumph over monolithic corporations.
Plus, the fact that the company was actually doing something good for humanity in the grand scheme of things - albeit at an horrific ethical cost - would make their victory that much more provocative.
Instead, we got a generic happy ending to send the popcorn-gobbling masses home happy. Boo.
3. Abby Doesn't Take Harper Back - Happiest Season
In what must surely be the most contentious and argued-about ending to any Christmas-themed lesbian rom-com ever made, Happiest Season concludes with Abby (Kristen Stewart) deciding to stay with her partner Harper (Mackenzie Davis), whose refusal to tell her parents about their relationship caused a tremendous amount of anguish for Abby.
As much as the film is centered around the difficulties of coming out, especially to conservative, closed-minded families like Harper's, the happy ending still felt unearned in a lot of people's eyes, that Abby deserved better than to be with someone who had to be so radically persuaded to fully embrace their relationship.
When the film skips forward a year to reveal that Abby and Harper are engaged, many saw it as hollow and inauthentic, because we've seen none of the penance Harper has presumably done to earn Abby's trust again.
Viewers took to social media to express their frustration that Abby didn't end up with Harper's ex Riley (Aubrey Plaza) instead, with whom she demonstrated easy chemistry earlier in the film.
Even Abby simply refusing to take Harper back would've been better, and while it wouldn't have made for the most typically Christmas-y of endings, a scene where the pair meet up at a coffee shop a year later and have grown as people could've helped smooth over the bummer factor.
Either way, Abby and Harper getting back together just felt like a sentimental indulgence, one intended to appease undemanding holiday viewers rather than, you know, anyone looking for satisfying character arcs or actually believable behaviour.
2. Kate Dies, Scott Survives - Army Of The Dead
Zack Snyder's barmy new zombie film Army of the Dead ends with the not-terribly-surprising outcome that Scott Ward (Dave Bautista) is bitten and turned into a zombie, leading his daughter Kate (Ella Purnell) to kill him out of mercy and take off as the heist's sole survivor.
It was a tremendously unsatisfying ending for one major reason: audiences actually cared about Scott, and nobody gave a damn about Kate.
This is largely due to her character being written to have an obnoxiously low regard for the wellbeing of herself and everybody else around her.
Kate tagging along on the mission to seek out her missing friend Geeta (Huma Qureshi) causes a massive headache for everyone and results in several other unnecessary deaths, such that by film's end it's very tough to root for her survival.
It would've been infinitely more gratifying for Kate to become a zombie and Scott have to painfully reckon with putting his own daughter out of her misery.
A bummer ending? Perhaps, but it would've given Snyder and Bautista the chance to deliver something truly powerful, rather than simply leave a sour taste as the opposite outcome did.
All in all, is anyone interested in seeing Kate back in the planned sequel Planet of the Dead?
Needless to say, Scott would've made for an infinitely more appealing franchise protagonist, especially if he bore the weight of killing his own daughter moving forward.
1. Black Ops Priests Battle A Demon - Demonic
Neill Blomkamp's Demonic is one of the most dispiriting misses of the year, and yet further proof that the District 9 director has lost the mojo that once suggested he was a prodigious talent.
This low-budget sci-fi horror is centered around the intriguing idea of a woman, Carly (Carly Pope), accidentally unleashing demons after entering a simulation to interact with the mental remnants of her comatose mother.
The marketing lingered on the deliciously enticing idea that the third act would feature a clan of black ops priests teaming up to battle a demonic entity as it rampages around, but perhaps due to budgetary or pandemic-related restrictions, it never happens.
Just as we expect a neat, Aliens-esque bug hunt to kick off, Carly arrives at the site of the conflict only to find the priests have all been butchered off-screen. Talk about an anti-climax.
What follows is instead a hot load of nonsense as Carly slays the demon, rather than delivering the promised showdown between a fleet of badass black ops priests and the creature. Lame isn't even the word.