10 Ways J.K. Rowling Has Ruined Harry Potter

Can we go back to the happy post-Deathly Hallows bubble please?

ron hermione
Warner Bros.

J.K. Rowling has become an increasingly divisive figure over the past few years.

While still heralded as the queen of children's literature and a defining figure in the childhoods of millions, her days as a universally loved figure are long gone.

Between questionable choices regarding the mainstream continuation of the series, small but terrible pieces of extra information and her general behaviour on social media, her image is in tatters when compared to its height ten years ago.

The discourse surrounding Harry Potter and its related property has changed well and truly for the worse, and a lot of it is thanks to the personal conduct and oversharing of its creator.

It doesn't help that its sequel series Fantastic Beasts has taken a complete nosedive in terms of storytelling competence and general quality, indicating that the franchise is starting to outstay its welcome. And with three movies in the series still to come, it seems unlikely the problems will stop any time soon.

While it's always important for a public figure to flourish and express themselves outside of the restrictions set by their work from decades ago, Rowling certainly has questionable ways of going about it all.

10. Made The Cursed Child Canon

Harry Potter Cursed Child Potters
Warner Bros.

No matter how hardcore a Harry Potter fan you are or how much you loved the staged version of the play, it's likely you absolutely detest the plot.

So many things in the play are problematic and contradictory to the source material, like the fact that Harry is a terrible father who tells his kid he wishes he'd never been born because he's in Slytherin. The 19 Years Later section of Deathly Hallows very specifically told us Harry would support his son no matter what because of Snape's legacy, so this is ridiculously out-of-character.

There's also the fun stuff like breaking timeturner lore and Voldemort - the monster whose whole arc is that he's incapable of love - having a child with Bellatrix Lestrange. It reads like bad fanfiction, and the fact that J.K. Rowling had nothing to do with the actual writing of the script isn't hard to believe.

The problem is that the play has Rowling's blessing as canon to her books. Which is just wrong, and pretty much every Potter fan disregards Rowling's proclamation that it's a story from her head.

Still, this terrible story is canon to Rowling's universe, meaning all material going forward has to be viewed in light of The Cursed Child. Bummer.


9. Joined Twitter

JK Rowling Twitter
Twitter, @jk_rowling

Back in simpler times, J.K. Rowling would log into her Twitter account once a year and tweet out the exact same tweet about how she preferred pen and paper to social media and to not expect her to use it much.

Oh how times have changed.

Many of the infamous ways Rowling has ruined Harry Potter still to come on this list are thanks to her decision to properly make use of her Twitter account and her inability to let it go.

Her use of the platform has allowed her to share many a sentiment about her world that, quite frankly, everyone could have done without.


8. Wrote The Script For Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindewald

The Crimes Of Grindelwald
Warner Bros.

The first Fantastic Beasts movie is fine. The Crimes of Grindelwald is not.

This movie's script is horrendous and introduced so many issues to the Harry Potter universe. The convoluted exposition scene of Leta Lestrange's backstory is laughable. The out-of-character switches (looking at you, Queenie) give the audience whiplash. Both Grindelwald and Dumbledore are criminally underused.

This movie is a mess, and there are still three left. Fun.

It's a shame because the movies are still beautiful to look at and hold potential for a thrilling new series. But from what we've seen so far, The Crimes of Grindelwald indicates a sad departure from the well-crafted series the world has grown to love. Here's hoping Rowling can bring it all back with the remaining instalments, but as it stands this film is a tragic fall from grace.


7. Aurelius Dumbledore

Fantastic Beasts The Crimes Of Grindelwald Credence
Warner Bros. Pictures

Speaking of The Crimes of Grindelwald, a new, five-part series means plot twists and new revelations aplenty. While the Nagini debacle is a separate matter, the one that really takes the cake is Credence being Dumbledore's secret brother.

This doesn't work for so many reasons, the main being that the entire crux of Dumbledore's family history explored in Deathly Hallows is his relationship with his brother Aberforth and sister Ariana. This certainly does not include his secret brother Aurelius that he's definitely going to find out about in the next movie.

It completely undermines the nuance of what we were led to believe were the dark personal struggles hidden from Harry throughout the series. We're introduced to a new conflict that's essentially just a cheap plot twist, but is also confusingly set in the past before the original series.

The problem is that we view Dumbledore in a new light after his death based on Harry's perspective. Harry doesn't know about Aurelius, so it doesn't matter.

It's retconning for the sake of family drama, and the fact that we're seeing it in the inferior prequel series kinda sucks.


6. The Ron/Hermione/Harry Love Triangle Debate

Ron harry hermione
Warner Bros

There was a time when the only new bits of information fans had to work with in a post-Potter world was from Pottermore, and it was all pretty plain sailing.

But once Rowling became more of a personal presence for giving new information, she started to reflect on her plot points and decision making.

In an infamous interview with Emma Watson a few years ago, Rowling explained how putting Ron and Hermione together was 'wish fulfilment' for her younger self, and that she actually felt more of a connection between Hermione and Harry when writing Deathly Hallows.

This is a totally fair reflection for Rowling to have shared, and the problems don't lie in her revelation itself. Rather it lies in the years and years of arguing amongst fans that has dominated discussions around the characters. The long-time Harry/Hermione shippers felt validated against the Ron/Hermione shippers, and it's all just been a bit of a mess.

With arguments over whether the book's happy ending or Rowling's later doubts over her choice dictate the canon state of Ron and Hermione's marriage, this was the first real big time in the post-Potter space where fans could argue over Rowling's comments. And it would only get worse...


5. Claimed She's Known Conveniently Timed Information For "Years"

Fantastic Beasts The Crimes Of Grindelwald Nagini
Warner Bros. Pictures

Back when the trailer for The Crimes of Grindewald revealing that Nagini was actually a transforming human woman trapped in a curse came out, fans wondered how long this idea had been sitting with Rowling. They wondered whether it was another Aurelius Dumbledore instance of plot twists for the sake of nostalgic drama.

Rowling's response? "Only for around twenty years."

Yeah... unlikely. No way would Rowling have been sitting on this information for that long without any indication of it in her book series (or even that curses like Nagini's existed at all) or in her post-Potter but pre-Fantastic Beasts material.

This revelation was very conveniently timed for not just a plot twist in her new series, but also as a way to get more meaningful diversity into the world after years of criticism by having Nagini be a woman of Asian origin (though her backstory for the specific nationality of Nagini and the actress who plays her still doesn't match up).

Looking at it this way, it's easy to make links back to the big "Dumbledore is gay" reveal after the books had been released without any indication of his sexuality in the original material for representation points (not that it's really worked out that way).


4. Her Desperation To Disprove Her Lack Of Diversity

J K Rowling
© POOL/Reuters/Corbis

While you can appreciate that she's trying, Rowling certainly has questionable ways of defending her lack of diversity in the series up until this point.

A big questionable Twitter defence came when Rowling was asked if there were any Jewish students at Hogwarts, to which Rowling simply tweeted back the name Anthony Goldstein, a Ravenclaw mentioned so briefly in the books that even a hardcore fan would be pressed to remember him without prompting. He doesn't appear in the films and primarily appears in the video game series, again without any reference to Judaism. This is hardly a praise-worthy inclusivity example.

Rowling has also contradicted her own material when faced with the criticism of Hermione's The Cursed Child depiction being played by black actresses. This isn't an issue in itself as regardless of book description it really isn't a big deal, but Rowling attempted to defend this move by claiming she never described Hermione's skin tone in the book at all and left it up to interpretation... which simply isn't true.

Besides Hermione being specifically cast as white in the movies and every book front cover she's depicted on clearly being a white-skinned girl, she's also actually described to have a "white face" in the books, which doesn't exactly scream open to interpretation.

Diversity is certainly a huge problem in the Harry Potter series, and it's admirable that Rowling should be trying to fix this. But she's going about it in the complete wrong way, seemingly patting herself on the back for inclusivity that simply was never there.


3. The Infamous Hogwarts Toilet Revelation

Harry Potter Hogwarts
Warner Bros.

Of all the little bits of random information provided by Rowling on the internet, this is truly the worst of them all.

The revelation that wizards didn't actually use muggle plumbing in Hogwarts until the eighteenth century and would literally defecate on the floor then magic away the evidence is so ridiculous and disturbing that it's bizarre this would even be a thought to J.K. Rowling, let alone something she'd choose to share in 2019.

It's such a stupid and nonsensical piece of information to reveal that it's now the Harry Potter example of when oversharing goes wrong, becoming a source of ridicule on the internet upon its revelation.

It's an image of the halls of Hogwarts that absolutely no one needed. Thanks, J.K.


2. Failed To Write The Dumbledore/Grindelwald Subtext Clearer In The Crimes Of Grindelwald

Fantastic Beasts The Crimes Of Grindelwald Dumbledore
Warner Bros.

Dumbledore's sexuality has been through a journey.

At first he was a secretly (in terms of what the books tells us) gay character all along, and had a crush on Grindelwald that was only confirmed by Rowling after the series' conclusion. No indication was given that it was an actual relationship until the lead up to Crimes of Grindelwald.

Despite the decision to make it a relationship, the filmmakers clearly stated they didn't want to explore it in the movie, leading to fan outrage.

The subtext is still there in the film despite these previously stated intentions, but only for those familiar with the information. As an introduction to their relationship, it's not clear enough. Sure, waiting for it could make it more effective down the line. But with all the critique aimed at her lack of representation and her later attempts to retcon it, a little more clarity would have gone a long way.


1. Made Her Characters Political

Vernon Dursley
Warner Bros.

J.K. Rowling is pretty outspoken when it comes to her political opinions, which is fine. Public figures should absolutely be able to use their social media platforms and public appearances to speak their mind.

But Rowling decided to use her characters to express her political agenda back in 2016, confirming a joke from a user that Vernon Dursley would have voted Leave in the Brexit referendum.

It was probably meant to be funny and is ultimately pretty harmless, but using a character from a children's book series - no matter how foul the character - can be seen as a pretty bad way to get your agenda across. Even though she's within her right, it immediately transforms the characters from fictional escapism to real world examples.

With general attitudes towards Rowling and her treatment of her beloved series ever decreasing, stuff like this just doesn't bode well for its future.


In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Chances are I’m watching a movie or replaying Mass Effect rather than doing anything productive.