10 Ways Star Wars Actors FIXED Scenes They Hated

Harrison Ford held nothing back when it came to George Lucas' ropey dialogue.

Star Wars
Lucasfilm

The Star Wars franchise is such a colossal behemoth with so many moving parts that actors surely can't expect to have too much input on the creative side of things.

Nevertheless, that hasn't prevented the series' more bold-minded cast members from putting their foot down and placing their own stamp on scenes that just weren't working.

Inspired by a recent Reddit thread on the subject, these Star Wars actors all decided to fix scenes they couldn't stand during shooting, whether offering up a more creative solution themselves or simply refusing to perform it as written.

While you might assume that Star Wars movies are pretty much set in stone and rarely deviate from the script, occasionally those in front of the camera made their concerns clear and insisted the scene be tried another way.

And in the case of these 10 scenes - most of them, anyway - they were absolutely correct, using their instincts as performers to rework scenes in ways they found more personally satisfying.

Sometimes all it took was speaking to the director, while other times it required employing considerably greater tact...

10. Mark Hamill Wore The Vader Mask (Because He Hated The Prop Head) - The Empire Strikes Back

Star Wars The Empire Strikes Back Luke
Disney

In The Empire Strikes Back's iconic Dark Side Cave scene, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) has a vision of being attacked by Darth Vader (David Prowse), but when Luke decapitates him with a lightsaber, he sees his own head staring back at him inside Vader's destroyed mask.

It's a chilling, brilliantly executed scene, but one which wasn't quite coming together for Mark Hamill during shooting. Originally, a prosthetic of Luke's head was going to be placed within Vader's mask for the shot of Luke's face staring up, but Hamill was dissatisfied with the quality of the prop.

And so, the scene was re-shot with Hamill simply poking his head up from underneath the set's stage and into the Vader mask, ensuring Luke's decapitated head looked considerably more realistic, not being a prop and all.

This scene proves yet again that the simplest solution is often the right one. No fancy effects needed - just a guy shoving his head through a hole in the set.

On Twitter, however, Hamill added that shooting the scene this way did present an additional challenge: trying not to blink when the smoke wafted across his face.


9. Tim Rose Refused To Have Admiral Ackbar Celebrate The Empire's Defeat - Return Of The Jedi

Star Wars Return Of The Jedi Admiral Ackbar
Disney

Return of the Jedi of course ends with the destruction of the second Death Star, and all the Rebels around the galaxy euphorically celebrating their victory over the Empire.

But Tim Rose, the puppeteer who portrayed Admiral Ackbar on set, objected to a request from director Richard Marquand, that he and the other Mon Calamari characters onboard his ship "dance around and celebrate" following the victory.

Rose strongly felt that Ackbar would react in more solemn fashion to the Empire's defeat, and so refused to perform the scene as Marquand requested. In a 2019 interview, Rose said:

"I was at the stage where I came within 200 numbers of being drafted for Vietnam. So I had very strong views about war at the time. While I think it's something to be proud of but not something to celebrate. There's a big difference. So in Akbar's last scene they put the camera on him… I thought about our people who died, their people who died, and the weight of it sunk me down in the chair.
And [Marquand] got really angry and he said, 'Right, we're gonna do this again and this time you get up and dance around.' I said, 'If you want Akbar to dance around, you can put somebody else in the suit. You got my performance.' And they left it in."

Rose was absolutely right here - seeing Ackbar slump down in his chair is infinitely more suitable and impactful than watching him do a jig around his ship.


8. Carrie Fisher Spoke Her Least Favourite Line Of Dialogue In An English Accent - A New Hope

Star Wars A New Hope Leia
Disney

Sometimes actors resort to desperate measures in an attempt to "fix" a scene they can't stand, and that was most certainly the case with Carrie Fisher when she filmed A New Hope's iconic holographic recording of Princess Leia.

In a panel discussion shortly before her death, Fisher confirmed that she absolutely loathed one particular line from this sequence, when Leia says:

"I have placed information vital to the survival of the Rebellion into the memory systems of this R2 unit."

Fisher's frustration with the clunky, unnatural-sounding dialogue prompted her to perform it in an English accent, because she felt that it wouldn't sound right coming from an American tongue.

Now, did Fisher really fix the dialogue? Given that fans routinely point out how jarring Leia's English accent is in the film's establishing scenes, probably not, but she at least tried to do something to make it fit better, even if it ultimately didn't work.

Hilariously, Fisher also admitted that this single scene is what prompted her to embark on a second career as a Hollywood script doctor after the end of original trilogy, working for many years polishing scripts for some of the biggest movies of the 1990s.


7. Mark Hamill Had Luke Wink At C-3PO (Rather Than Ignore Him) - The Last Jedi

Star Wars The Last Jedi Luke
Disney

Mark Hamill has made it incredibly clear that he didn't fully agree with the creative direction for Luke Skywalker in The Last Jedi, yet nevertheless gave himself over to Rian Johnson's expectation-subverting vision.

For the most part, anyway.

Hamill did pipe up, however, while shooting his reunion with Leia, R2-D2 (Jimmy Vee), and C-3PO (Anthony Daniels), because as written, Luke didn't acknowledge C-3PO at all.

Hamill felt strongly that Luke wouldn't ignore him, and so insisted to Johnson that he get a brief moment with the droid. In his own words:

"Initially, I didn't acknowledge Threepio, I walked right past him. I said, 'Rian, look, after all those years of service, even though we haven't been in contact in recent years, Threepio was the closest to a sidekick I had.' Harrison had Chewie and I had Artoo and Threepio, but he's so accommodating and so collaborative. He said, 'Oh, absolutely, you should go over there.' We didn't really have time to script anything... just to acknowledge him, and that's what I did."

And so, the scene ended with Luke giving Threepio a quick wink before moving on. It's a small addition, but one that ensured fans didn't cry foul that Luke straight-up blanked his old buddy.


6. Donnie Yen Made Chirrut Less Of A Stereotype - Rogue One

Star Wars Rogue One Chirrut
Lucasfilm

Donnie Yen proved to be a scene stealer in Rogue One with his performance as blind Jedi Chirrut Îmwe, yet he initially had some serious misgivings with the character as written, and insisted that he make some major changes to Chirrut's characterisation.

In an interview with GQ, Yen revealed that he told the filmmakers that Chirrut was written as a stereotype - a typical, humourless martial arts master.

Ultimately he not only suggested that Chirrut be blind, but fought for him to get a sense of humour and even improvised jokes during shooting - such as the memorable line, "Are you kidding me? I'm blind!"

Yen, an accomplished multi-hyphenate in his own right, insisted to director Gareth Edwards that he had far more to offer the film than merely acting, telling him, "When you hire me, you're not just getting an actor - you are getting a choreographer, a director."

And so, rather than simply grumble his way through an underwhelming part for the sake of a fat Disney paycheck, Yen spoke up and immeasurably improved the character, and in turn the film, in the process.


5. Oscar Isaac Persuaded J.J. Abrams To Scrap Poe's Death - The Force Awakens

Star Wars The Force Awakens Poe
Lucasfilm

Originally when Oscar Isaac signed up to play Poe Dameron in The Force Awakens, it was written to be a relatively small role, because Poe would be killed off at the end of the first act when he and Finn (John Boyega) crash-landed on Jakku while fleeing the First Order.

As excited as Isaac was to appear in a Star Wars movie, he wasn't terribly thrilled about being killed off so soon, especially after recently shooting four separate movies where he died early on.

And so, Isaac made his reservations clear to Abrams, who around a week later told Isaac that they had found a way to give Poe a stay of execution, ensuring he stuck around for the rest of the movie - and ultimately, the trilogy.

If Poe felt like the lesser of the sequel trilogy's three heroic leads, it's probably because he wasn't originally supposed to be one at all.


4. Samuel L. Jackson Requested A Purple Lightsaber To Stand Out On Geonosis - Attack Of The Clones

Star Wars Attack Of The Clones Mace Windu Geonosis
Disney

Samuel L. Jackson's time on the Star Wars prequels reached a fever pitch of frustration while shooting Attack of the Clones' Battle of Geonosis, when Jackson realised that his character, Mace Windu, wouldn't stand out amid the chaos of the battle.

And so, Jackson went directly to George Lucas and asked if, to help him pop among the literally hundreds of characters in the scene, Windu could have a purple lightsaber.

Though Lucas reminded him that Jedi lightsabers are typically only blue and green, Jackson retorted that he was playing "the second baddest Jedi in the universe next to Yoda."

Ultimately that was that, but when Jackson was summoned back for reshoots, Lucas called him over and showed him footage of the battle where Windu was indeed rocking a purple lightsaber, much to his delight.

Few actors would've had the confidence to make such a bold request of Lucas, let alone the clout to actually persuade him. Bravo.


3. Mark Hamill Convinced George Lucas To Scrap An AWFUL Line Of Dialogue - A New Hope

Star Wars A New Hope Luke
Lucasfilm

It's no secret that A New Hope in particular has its fair share of ropey dialogue, but in one scene it eventually became too much for Mark Hamill, who convinced George Lucas to scrap the offending verbiage entirely.

Shortly after the destruction of Alderaan, Luke and Han Solo (Harrison Ford) were meant to have an exchange on the Millennium Falcon, where Han mentions that he's going to drop Luke and company off on the nearest asteroid, and Luke replies with the following word-salad:

"But we can't turn back, fear is their greatest defence. I doubt if the actual security there is any greater than it was on Aquilae or Sullust and what there is is most likely directed towards a large-scale assault."

Hilariously, Hamill bluntly told Lucas what he thought of the dialogue. He said:

"Who talks like this, George?... This is really not fair, because you know we're the ones who are gonna get vegetables thrown at us. Not you!"

And his appeal ultimately won out, as Lucas binned the cumbersome dialogue in favour of more plainly-spoken chatter between the two. Praise be.


2. Harrison Ford Changed "I Love You Too" To "I Know" - The Empire Strikes Back

Star Wars The Empire Strikes Back Han Solo
Disney

Now for what's by far the most famous of all the on-the-fly changes made by frustrated Star Wars actors.

At the end of The Empire Strikes Back when Han is about to be frozen in carbonite, Leia tells him, "I love you," and Han was originally scripted to say back, "I love you, too."

But Harrison Ford felt that it wasn't consistent with Han's established character for him to say this to Leia, and so improvised a more on-brand retort, with Han instead telling her, "I know."

This more aloof, distant response was absolutely better-suited to Han's character, and remains both one of the character's defining moments and one of the most memorable beats in the entire Star Wars franchise.

Though Ford did shoot a version of the scene as scripted for safety's sake, when both versions were tested in front of an audience, it was clear that his improvised revision was the one to go with. And like that, cinematic history was made.


1. Ray Park Refused To Blink As Darth Maul - The Phantom Menace

Maul Phantom Menace
Lucasfilm

Sometimes actors just need to figure things out themselves when a scene isn't working for them, but in the case of Darth Maul actor Ray Park, it was pretty much the entire Phantom Menace shoot which caused him issues.

The problem? The coloured red-yellow contact lenses he had to wear to portray the Sith Lord were extremely irritating, enough that they caused discomfort whenever he blinked. You know, the thing we all do every couple of seconds in our waking lives.

As a result, Park decided to blink as little as humanly possible while playing Maul - a flourish which was primarily for his own comfort on set, and yet ended up only enhancing the character's unnerving quality.

As it turns out, Maul only blinks three times on-screen during The Phantom Menace, which while underlining his overall creepiness, was largely Park trying to spare himself some ocular agony.

For all of George Lucas' love of ground-breaking CGI in the prequels, could he really not just spare Park the hassle and colour his eyes in post?


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Wars
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.