10 Ways To Reboot The Amazing Spider-Man Correctly

Is it time to rip up and start again with the web-slinging hero?

The cinematic future of everyone's friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man is currently very uncertain. After the lukewarm reception received by this past summer's The Amazing Spider-Man 2, it seems that Sony has gotten cold feet about continuing the current incarnation of the franchise. Officially, The Amazing Spider-Man 3 has been pushed back to a May 2018 release, leaving a 2016 release date free for Sinister Six, a spin-off focusing on a popular group of Spider-villains. Current rumours even suggest that the Spider-Man that will appear in Sinister Six might not even be played by Andrew Garfield, but at the very least, it seems Sony are hedging their bets on deciding whether to forge ahead with more solo Spidey movies until after Sinister Six sinks or swims. This all might sound like something of an over-reaction when you consider that The Amazing Spider-Man 2 made $708 million worldwide, which by most other franchise's standards would be considered a massive hit. However, if one looks at the box-office performance of each film, it shows a steady decline in revenue. Each subsequent movie has made less money than the previous one, both domestically and worldwide. To put the disappointing performance into even sharper focus, Raimi's Spider-Man made $821 million worldwide and that was in 2002, a full 12 years ago. Consequently, the word 'reboot' will have surely been bandied about in the Sony offices recently, and this article will detail ten different ideas they could implement if they chose to hit the reset button on Spidey again. We're not entirely sure whether it would be the right thing to do, as two different reboots of the same character in less than 15 years would surely be a bridge too far in terms of audience goodwill. Sony would certainly be accused (again) of being creatively bereft when it comes to their Spider-Man licence, but nonetheless, we'll play devil's advocate for this article anyway. The first five entries in our list apply to Sony, assuming they maintain the rights to the character. But the top five entries deal with the (perhaps unlikely, but definitely awesome) possibility that Marvel Studios manage to wrestle the rights back.

10. Let Peter Parker Grow Up

One of the most popular elements of Spider-Man is that Peter Parker started crime-fighting as a teenager and is his own hero, not a sidekick to an adult character. It gives his stories a different feel than other superhero tales and many observers note that it is easier for younger viewers and readers to relate to the character, as Parker is not that far removed from them. However, given that Sony have used a teenage Peter in Raimi's first movie and then pushed this aspect of the character even more in the two Amazing films, we reckon it's high time they let Peter Parker grow up a bit. In the comics, Peter has not always been a teenager for the 50 plus years he has been in publication. In fact, he grew up, went to college, married Mary Jane Watson and even became a high school science teacher when in his thirties. Sony might be reluctant to head this route, especially as they put so much effort into targeting the Amazing movies to the teen crowds, what with all the high-school romance and dub-step music. But, as we've already noted, the box-office is at an all-time low, so maybe the more mature crowd of Spidey fans felt alienated by such an overtly teen movie. To be fair to Sam Raimi, he let Peter grow up to college age in Spider-Man 2, so it's already been tried and tested. We just hope Sony let Peter age even more. We could then be spared more of the obviously 31 year old Andrew Garfield trying his hardest to convince us he's actually seventeen. No amount of big hair and skateboards was ever really going to accomplish that, we're afraid.

9. No More Villains That Are The Result Of Science Experiments Gone Wrong

By our count, the only villain used in all five Spider-Man movies so far whose origins didn't lie in 'science experiment gone tragically/horrifically wrong' territory was Topher Grace's Venom, in Spider-Man 3. Every other villain fell into this category, from the Green Goblin (Norman and Harry Osborn varieties) to Doctor Octopus; from the Sandman to The Lizard and Electro. Heck, even the Rhino was wearing a big, mechanical super-suit that was designed by Oscorp. Now, we know that perhaps the reason for this is that a large, overwhelming percentage of Spider-Man villains from the comics are the result of science gone wrong, so Sony is only being true to the source material. Spider-Man has always had a strong basis in science and invention, so it is only fitting that his villains follow suit. But we can't help but feel that the average audience member may have thought by now that these villain origins are all getting a bit repetitive. They're just too similar, simply substituting a tank full of electric eels with a glowing fusion reactor. Add one crusading scientist with a quirk, a tragic accident and hey presto, instant supervillain. Maybe next time Sony could take a gamble on Kraven the Hunter or Mysterio. They could even introduce Carnage and take another crack at Venom (although it seems likely that he will be getting his own spin-off movie).

8. Try Something (A Bit) Darker

Both Amazing Spider-Man movies, while they definitely have their merits, left a lot of viewers feeling like they lacked substance. They were fun, sure, but there wasn't really much dramatic material to chew on. One tried and tested method of creating drama in a franchise is to go 'darker' with a sequel. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 does admittedly have a very tragic ending, so in that sense it could be argued that they already went darker. But we're talking more about setting a tone for the entire movie, a sense that the stakes have been raised and danger abounds, rather than tacking an unexpectedly sad ending onto a pretty flighty movie. We actually think that Sam Raimi was on the right track with Spider-Man 3, with the introduction of the black suit and Venom giving the story an edge that was lacking before. Sadly, the ham-fisted execution of Venom (and the obvious disdain that Raimi felt for the character) meant that the story never actually went to the places it could have, and instead we got emo-fringe Peter Parker. We feel there is a more mature Spider-Man story waiting to be told on the big screen. We're not suggesting that they do a Dark Knight or anything, as that would not be appropriate for the character, but there are definitely ways to achieve that edge without betraying the nature of the Spider-Man universe. Perhaps inspiration could be taken from a story like Kraven's Last Hunt, a powerful tale that transformed a previously silly villain into a credible threat while also revealing untapped levels of tragedy in the character.

7. Please, Do Away With The Awkward Teen Romance

We touched upon this issue in our entry about letting Peter Parker grow up, but feel like it warrants more development. Unless you were in your teens when the two Amazing Spider-Man movies hit cinema screens, chances are you may have felt like you didn't belong to the target audience that Sony was aiming for. Everyone can relate to the first pangs of unrequited love in high school, that feeling of nobody understanding you and the desire to make the prettiest girl in school notice you somehow. But, if you are long past reading the Twilight books, or obsessing over which boy Katniss will pick in The Hunger Games, then awkward teen romance is unlikely to be what you want from a Spider-Man movie. We feel that Sony narrowed their focus far too much with The Amazing Spider-Man, appealing pretty much solely to only one demographic and nowhere is this more obvious than with Peter and Gwen Stacy's romance. Don't get us wrong, Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone have excellent screen chemistry, miles better than the damp squib that was Tobey Maguire and Kirsten Dunst in the Raimi movies. But it still left us pretty cold, we have to say. A reboot could introduce a more stable, adult relationship for Peter Parker, one that a few more groups of people in the audience will find relatable.

6. Please, Don't Give Us Another Origin Story

Our number one gripe with The Amazing Spider-Man was the sheer redundancy of it all. Sony went to the trouble of rebooting Spider-Man (a mere five years after the last Raimi film), changing the entire cast and director, only to give us a movie that elongated the first hour of Raimi's film to feature length. The differences were really only skin deep and the similarities glaringly obvious (both the Green Goblin and The Lizard were potential father-figure scientists driven to monstrous evil by their experiments, and both talked to themselves in an evil monologue inside their heads). Don't even get us started on the needlessly convoluted and awkward way they got out of having Uncle Ben say 'With great power comes great responsibility'. But the biggest redundancy of all was the very fact that Sony felt that the world needed to see Spider-Man's origin story. Again. By this point, it's pretty much common knowledge the world over that Peter Parker was bitten by a radioactive spider and became a costumed do-gooder. No one needed to see this story play out again, but that's what Sony gave us. It just meant that we were left feeling like the whole endeavour was vaguely pointless, aside from as an attempt to squeeze more money out of a franchise that was running low on ideas. So, if Sony does indeed reboot Spidey again, we beg of them to skip the origin story. If they were to start the thing with Peter already established as Spider-Man and hit the ground running, maybe they could be on to a winner.

5. Tell A Street-Level Spidey Story, Perhaps Teaming Him With Daredevil

Allow us to play devil's advocate from this point on, and let's assume that Marvel Studios were able to regain control of the Spider-Man property. After the fan rejoicing period that would ensue if this glorious pipe dream were to become reality, Marvel would have to sit down and plan out how to introduce the Wallcrawler into their Cinematic Universe. One suggestion we would have is to team him up with The Man Without Fear, who of course is due to star in his own Netflix-produced TV series in 2015. It would be very interesting to see Charlie Cox's version of Matt Murdock hit the big screen with a brand-new Peter Parker in tow. It has already been confirmed that Marvel's Netflix shows do indeed take place in the Cinematic Universe, so the notion of them transitioning to film is within the realms of possibility. Spider-Man and Daredevil have shared a lot of stories through the annals of comics history, and they play very well off each other, with Murdock the darker, more serious vigilante and Parker the wise-cracking, fun hero. The dynamic is there for a brilliant superhero odd couple. It would make sense for them to go up against the Kingpin, for example, as Wilson Fisk has antagonised both heroes in almost equal measure over the years. Of course, this is all pretty far-fetched. We don't even know if Charlie Cox's Daredevil will be any good, or if the show will find a decent sized audience. There is also the nagging sense that Marvel would consider Spider-Man to be too popular to team with a more niche character like Daredevil. But hey, we'd just love to see ol' Hornhead and Spidey busting heads together, so we are happy to ponder this most unlikely of scenarios.

4. Peter Parker Meets Miles Morales?

Speaking of unlikely scenarios, this suggestion might fall into that category as well. But, as improbable as it might seem, a live-action introduction of Brian Michael Bendis' extremely popular Miles Morales character just might have the potential to hit big. Miles Morales is the current Spider-Man in Marvel's Ultimate comic book line, which takes place in its own continuity separate to the main Marvel Universe. In the Ultimate world, their Peter Parker died and Miles took over as Spider-Man in his honour. Miles is the first African-American character to take on the identity of Spider-Man and while their was initially criticism in some quarters that Marvel had simply created him as a publicity stunt and attempt at political correctness, common sense prevailed when it turned out that Bendis was telling some great stories. Miles and Peter Parker of the regular Marvel Universe actually met up in the 2012 series Spider-Men, a mind-bending and fun story that we believe would make for a pretty cool film. As an interesting aside, part of the inspiration for Miles came from actor Donald Glover on cult comedy TV series Community. Glover campaigned online with the goal of securing an audition for the role of Peter Parker in The Amazing Spider-Man, but was unsuccessful. He then appeared in an episode of Community wearing Spider-Man pyjamas, and Bendis has been quoted as saying he saw him and thought 'I would like to read that book'. So he created Miles Morales. Nifty, huh?

3. Try A Cinematic Version Of The Clone Saga. Only, You Know, Make It Good.

The mere mention of the words 'The Clone Saga' is enough to bring certain fans to a level of apoplectic rage. To say this storyline was controversial is something of an understatement and it is mostly considered as a creative low-point in Spider-Man history, a hopelessly convoluted and far too lengthy story with numerous plot holes and secrets dangled that ultimately led nowhere. So, why would we be suggesting The Clone Saga as a potential way to reboot Spidey on-screen? Well, because the initial idea for the story is very cool. What if an exact duplicate of Peter Parker appeared, claiming that he was in fact the real Peter and the man that we had known all these years is actually a clone? This concept would make for a very strong film, with the theme of identity making for a dramatic core for the story. Of course, the screenwriter would have to sift through all the unnecessary elements of the comic book story, and considering it lasted for over two years, with comics published every week across four Spider-titles, that makes for A LOT of material to be jettisoned. But we definitely reckon it could work, perhaps by focussing on Peter and only two clones, Ben Reilly and Kaine. The general movie-going populace wouldn't know a Clone Saga from a Knightfall epic, so the baggage associated with the story isn't really there for the mainstream. Marvel would have to deal with a lot of angry geeks, we suppose, but isn't that par for the course with these movies?

2. Spider-Man. The Avengers. 'Nuff Said.

Here we have it, the single most glaringly obvious avenue for Marvel Studios to take in rebooting Spider-Man. The level of fan nirvana that would be achieved if we were able to see Spidey join Iron Man, Captain America, Thor and Hulk etc on-screen would be stratospheric and it would surely spur the franchise on to make approximately three hundred squillion dollars at the box-office. Give or take a few bucks. In all seriousness, Marvel regaining control of one of their crown jewels and inserting him into the insanely popular Avengers series of films would be amazing. The amount of stories opened up to the filmmakers would be enormous, as Spider-Man shares so much comic book history with The Earth's Mightiest Heroes, having been a member of a few Avengers teams over the last decade in the comics. He would add an intriguing dynamic to the team and could function as a very compelling audience identification character. The only way that Marvel would be able to top this would be if they wrangled the X-Men rights back and Wolverine came along for the party as well. The sheer thought of that hits so many awesome buttons in our head that it is hard to comprehend.

1. Above All, Be Different Than The Previous Two Sony Iterations

In the end, the main thing we imagine fans want from another Spider-Man reboot is that it be significantly different from the previous two incarnations, while staying true to the roots of the character. We've already been saddled with one reboot that is far too similar to the original trilogy and could do without another one. In many ways it is sad that these rumours have even started to trickle out from Sony, as it strikes us that thinking in Hollywood is starting to extend purely to 'This isn't working as well as we'd hoped. Let's just start again'. The success of certain reboots, like Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy, has convinced executives that this is the answer to any of their tricky franchise problems. Chances are, however, that if they don't take a long hard look at the problems they are experiencing, any reboot may be doomed to repeat the same mistakes, which is what we feel happened with The Amazing Spider-Man. Judging by the crossroads Sony is currently sitting at, it appears that they didn't exactly iron out the kinks of their previous franchise the way they had hoped. The buzzword therefore is 'different'. Give us something new and fresh with Spider-Man and we're positive that audiences will come flocking back. What do you think? Are there any other viable options for rebooting the Webhead? Should he even be rebooted again at all? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Comics. Movies. TV. Wrestling. Video Games. Husband. Father. Geek.