10 Weird Movie Plot Twists That Just Don't Work

Don't just twist for twist's sake.

Vanilla Sky Tom Cruise Mask
Paramount Pictures

The great movie plot twists rank among the most unforgettable moments from film history. Janet Leigh's shock early exit, it was Earth all along,"I am your father," he's been dead the whole time! All great surprises that add whole new dimensions to the films in question, cementing them as classics.

Of course, sometimes accepting a twist means taking a lot on faith. Let's face it, the revelation of Luke Skywalker's parentage in The Empire Strikes Back does rather come out of nowhere and if you think it all through logically it makes very little sense that Vader would reveal it at that point, without having done anything about it in the years prior.

Still, while in the case of Star Wars we can suspend disbelief just a tad, there have been other attempts at big surprise plot twists that really don't stand up to closer scrutiny. But even when a twist doesn't necessarily turn the whole film on its head, sometimes they're just too misjudged to take seriously.

Sometimes, such creative decisions can be dismissed as a minor misconception, other times, they sour the film completely.

10. Laurie Is Michael's Sister - Halloween II

halloween 2
Dimension

The Set-Up: the 1978 original established that homicidal maniac Michael Myers breaks out of a mental institution and returns to his hometown of Haddonfield to go on a killing spree, 15 years to the day after killing his own big sister. The first film ends with him seemingly shot dead, but then mysteriously vanishing; the sequel, set later that same night, sees him to come back to get final girl Laurie (Jamie Lee Curtis) in the hospital.

The Twist: it turns out Michael wasn't just out to kill random teenagers that Halloween night: he was specifically targeting Laurie, because - although she didn't know it - she is actually his little sister!

Why It Doesn't Work: Admittedly there's a lot about Michael Myers we need to take with a pinch of salt: how does he know it's Halloween, know how to find his home town, or know how to drive a car when he's been catatonic since he was 6?

The fact that he also knows this girl he's never met is his sibling, when almost no one else is aware of this, is a stretch too far. Worse yet, it robs the original of much of its mystery.


9. Mandy Was In On The Murders - All The Boys Love Mandy Lane

All The Boys Love Mandy Lane
Optimum Releasing/RADiUS-TWC

The Set-Up: one-time high school misfit Mandy Lane (Amber Heard) finds herself coveted by the popular kids as she grows into an attractive young woman. She joins her new friends for a weekend away at a remote ranch, where they come under attack from a hooded serial killer.

The Twist: it turns out that Mandy was in on it the whole time. The murders are being committed by her old best friend, in revenge for the way the high school alphas have treated them over the years

Why It Doesn't Work: The ending of director Jonathan Levine's 2006 debut feature reflects the problems of the rest of the film: it's trying too hard to be smart and edgy, when it's ultimately a very simple slasher.

It just doesn't make sense that Mandy would play innocent all the way to the end when she had her victims where she wanted them for so long, so far from civilisation.


8. The Whole Religious Cult Thing - Kill List

Kill List
Optimum Releasing

The Set-Up: Semi-retired hitman Jay (Neil Maskell) is lured back on the job with his old friend Gal (Michael Smiley) for a lucrative contract taking out three seemingly unrelated individuals for a shadowy organisation.

The Twist: after some strange, unnerving circumstances earlier in the job, things get utterly bizarre when the final mark on the list leads Jay and Gal to some sort of occult ceremony. This ultimately sees Jay forcibly masked and thrown into a ritualistic knife fight with a masked hunchback - but once he wins the fight, his fatally wounded opponent is uncloaked to reveal his own wife Shel (MyAnna Burning) with their son strapped to her back.

Why It Doesn't Work: It's one thing for a film to take a left-field turn late in the day, but there has to be some sort of internal logic to proceedings. Kill List, however, comes off as if it was all made up on the spot. The cult and their motivations make no sense whatsoever.

Particularly nonsensical is how the dying Shel appears to be in on the cult's business, laughing as she dies. Why, then, did she open fire on attacking cult members earlier on, when Jay wasn't even present?


7. Apes Conquered Earth - Planet Of The Apes (2001)

Planet Of The Apes Lincoln
20th Century Fox

The Set-Up: Astronaut Leo Davidson (Mark Wahlberg) is accidentally sucked through a wormhole which takes him to a far-off world in the distant future where militant simians rule with an iron fist, and humanity is enslaved.

The Twist: After fighting his way to get off the planet, Leo goes back through the wormhole and returns home - only to find that apes have taken over there, and a statue of the evil General Thade (Tim Roth) is sitting where the Lincoln Memorial should be in Washington DC.

Why It Doesn't Work: Okay, so Tim Burton and co didn't want to directly recreate the original 1968 Planet of the Apes, hence they avoided the familiar twist that the planet was actually Earth all along. This is acceptable.

However, given the fame of the original's conclusion (plus the fact that twist endings were back in fashion after The Sixth Sense), they clearly felt that needed a climactic surprise - but the one they settled on is just stupid.

We're meant to believe that Thade somehow got through the wormhole before Leo, went further back in time and conquered Earth (or at least America), when there is absolutely zero indication of when or how he did this?


6. Maya's A Villain! Oh Wait, No She Isn't - Iron Man 3

Iron Man 3 Maya Hansen Rebecca Hall
Marvel Studios

The Set-Up: When Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr, obviously) threatens terrorist leader The Mandarin, he is suddenly visited by old flame Maya (Rebecca Hall), a scientist who has been working with Stark rival Killian (Guy Pearce) on the deadly Extremis project.

The Twist: Maya and Pepper (Gwyneth Paltrow) escape, and Maya seems regretful for working on Extremis: but then, she hands Pepper directly over to Killian, revealing that she's one of the bad guys after all. However, just as Killian moves to use Extremis on Pepper, Maya has a sudden change of heart - and not long thereafter, Killian just shoots her.

Why It Doesn't Work: The fumbling of Maya is one of the biggest black marks on Marvel's record. Infamously, she was at one point intended to be the principle villain of Iron Man 3, but the studio caved over concerns about (sigh) toy sales, and so the focus shifted to Pearce's Killian.

As such, Maya's whole character arc is a futile dead end, wasting a potentially interesting character and a fine actress in Rebecca Hall. Her ultimate demise just feels like an afterthought - which, no doubt, it really was.


5. It's Really Set In The Present - The Village

The Village M Night Shyamalan
Buena Vista

The Set-Up: at some unspecified point in centuries gone by, an isolated woodland community in North America deliberately cuts itself from the rest of the world, whilst living in fear of mysterious monsters which stalk the woods. But when tragedy strikes, young blind woman Ivy (Bryce Dallas Howard) must venture beyond the woods for help.

The Twist: first off, it turns out there are no monsters. These are merely costumes worn by the village elders to keep their children in line and to hide them from the truth: it is actually the present day, and the village - founded in the 1970s by hippies - exists in the centre of a wildlife preserve.

Why It Doesn't Work: You knew we couldn't get through a list like this without M Night Shyamalan coming into it at least once. This 2004 effort was the director's fourth film in five years, and by this point the climactic twist was such a signature Shyamalan move, it had become tedious.

While the conclusion tries to make it all seem logical (e.g. payments are made to the government to keep the the skies above the village a no-fly zone), it all just seems too unfeasible, and leaves the whole film feeling rather pointless.


4. He's Living In A VR Dreamworld - Open Your Eyes/Vanilla Sky

Vanilla Sky Tom Cruise mirror
Paramount

The Set-Up: basically the same in both Alejandro AmenĂ¡bar's 1997 original, and Tom Cruise and Cameron Crowe's 2001 remake: a wealthy playboy suffers a traumatic car accident, wrecking his face and derailing his hedonistic lifestyle. Bit by bit, as he experiences increasingly bizarre happenings, he finds himself losing his mind.

The Twist: it turns out our hero is in fact in stasis, living in a virtual reality simulation modelled on his idealised life. He signed himself up to be cryogenically frozen after his death and killed himself not long after his injury, so all the events since halfway through the movie have been a dream.

Why It Doesn't Work: A bold step in an unexpected direction is one thing, but this is just a bit... silly, isn't it? Sure, it's signposted to a degree; we do hear of the Life Extension company early on. And perhaps the hero's rejection of his fantasy world in some way highlights how our imagined perfect world can never measure up to genuine life experience.

Even so, this eleventh-hour sidestep into science fiction seems an absurd way to conclude what had been a fairly intense and grounded psychological thriller.


3. John Harrison Is Really Khan - Star Trek Into Darkness

Star Trek Into Darkness Khan
Paramount Pictures

The Set-Up: in the first sequel to the rebooted Star Trek, Captain Kirk (Chris Pine) takes the USS Enterprise into forbidden territory to capture John Harrison (Benedict Cumberbatch), a terrorist responsible for the deaths of many Starfleet officers.

The Twist: John Harrison reveals he is actually Khan, leader of a clan of genetically engineered super-beings who have spent centuries in suspended animation.

Why It Doesn't Work: Fan service can be such a double-edged sword, as Trekkers everywhere were outraged by Star Trek Into Darkness's use of Khan. In fairness, this was more to do with how the film was publicised throughout production, with numerous official denials that Cumberbatch was playing Khan; subsequently, the final film left fans feelings cheated by this needless subterfuge.

Beyond this, though, the 'revelation' of Khan's true identity is meaningless, as in this new, alternate timeline, the young Enterprise crew have never even heard of him before.

It all just feels like a crass attempt to capitalise on the continuing popularity of Ricardo Montalban's character from the original 1960s TV series and 1982's Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, surely the most widely loved Star Trek movie.


2. Take Your Pick, Really! - The Cloverfield Paradox

The Cloverfield Paradox
Netflix

The Set-Up: an experiment on an orbiting space station accidentally transports the station and its crew to a parallel universe.

The Twist: where to begin... as if the space station hopping universes wasn't enough, the accident also leads to a slew of random reality-warping events on board, as well as unleashing hell back on Earth in the form of attacks from giant monsters.

Why It Doesn't Work: The Cloverfield Paradox's excess twists are the perfect example of filmmakers over-egging the pudding. Perhaps in its initial form as The God Particle it might have been okay, but producer JJ Abrams' insistence on retrofitting it to the Cloverfield movies - and worse yet, attempting to form a coherent link across the very loosely related films - backfires horribly.

There's just way too much going on that distracts from what might have been a gripping enough central narrative, and when the final seconds cement the link to the original 2008 Cloverfield via the sudden emergence of a gargantuan 'Clovie,' it's just too ridiculous for words.

Still, at least now the aliens from the end of 10 Cloverfield Lane don't seem quite so silly by comparison.


1. Blofeld Is Bond's Adoptive Brother - Spectre

Spectre Christoph Waltz Blofeld.jpg
MGM

The Set-Up: Bond (Daniel Craig) is hot on the trail of an ultra-secretive criminal organisation named Spectre, headed up by a man from his past, Franz Oberhauser (Christoph Waltz).

The Twist: Oberhauser is revealed to be Bond's adoptive brother, the young orphan having been taken in by Oberhauser Sr. after the death of Bond's parents. Jealous of Bond for stealing his father's affections, Franz set out to ruin Bond's life, which is ultimately the entire purpose of his gargantuan evil organisation which was also covertly responsible for the adversaries Bond faced off against in the previous 3 films. Also, Franz changed his name to Ernst Stavro Blofeld.

Why It Doesn't Work: It's just moronic. Not only does it beggar belief that Blofeld could have been behind literally everything bad that happened to Bond in the Craig years, but for the primary motivation of this global crime syndicate to be the persecution of one lowly spy, all because of some Daddy issues? Pathetic.

And that's not even touching on the pointlessness of revealing Oberhauser as Blofeld in the final act, given the name Blofeld means nothing in the context of the Craig-era timeline. Clearly, Eon Productions learned nothing from the Star Trek Into Darkness/Khan debacle.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Vanilla Sky
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Ben Bussey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.