10 Weirdest Things Actors Were Cast As

These actors took to our screens in the weirdest of ways...

antichrist willem dafoe
Artificial Eye/IFC Films

Whether they've been plying their trade in show business for several decades or just dipping their toes in the performance waters, just about every actor working today will confess to loving the idea of challenging themselves as a thespian.

For some this can come in the form of stepping into a deeply challenging, layered, and often pulsating personality for a feature that is sure to capture the imagination of both general audiences and critics alike. Whereas others find that very same thrill and rush in simply offering their name and abilities to some downright outrageous characters.

With that in mind, it's time to shine a spotlight on those movie and TV roles that, while wholeheartedly unexpected and often massively barmy, still take up a notable place on each of the following star's CV.

From lending their voices to some of the most hilariously odd animated bathroom accessories to being drafted in as a straight-up d*ck, each of the following actors all played their part in some of the most shocking, side-splitting, and all-out ridiculous performances ever to grace a screen... for better or worse.

10. Horst Baron Steps In Because Willem Dafoe's Penis Is Too "Enormous" - Antichrist

antichrist willem dafoe
Artificial Eye/IFC Films

Keeping in the vein of the darker side of the film and TV-making world, Lars Von Trier's Antichrist sees Willem Dafoe's He embroiled in a rather freakish and deeply unnerving sexual exchange with Charlotte Gainsbourg's She at one point in the largely experimental horror flick.

And though the scene itself can undoubtedly be classed as one of the weirdest back-and-forth's you're ever likely to see pop up on a television screen, a piece of casting that went into bringing it to life is arguably even stranger still... mostly due to the reasons behind it coming into play.

With Dafoe himself offering to strip down and show himself off completely for the moment, Von Trier was forced to inform his actor that he just could not allow him to appear fully in the buff for the moment in question. Simply put; his junk was "too big" for the film.

As the director would explain, he had to pull the plug on Dafoe's dude being seen "because everybody got very confused when they saw it", opting for porn star Horst Baron to step in for the moment where he disturbingly ejaculates blood in the feature instead. Lovely.


9. Hugh Jackman Is The "Chin Ballsack Guy" - Movie 43

Movie 43 Hugh Jackman
Relativity Media

Stepping into more farcical waters now, to a film that feels like it was actually released in an entirely different universe, it has to be said.

But sadly, though, Movie 43 did very much get unleashed onto our universe and forced us to witness Wolverine himself Hugh Jackman donning one of the most peculiar prosthetics any actor has likely ever been asked to perform with. With Jackman playing a character classed as the city's most eligible bachelor, Kate Winslet's Beth is stunned to discover that Davis is actually hiding a rather unanticipated physical characteristic - a set of balls dangling from his chin.

Attempted hilarity ensues as Winslet tries to get through the dinner without eye-balling the, erm, vegetables as Jackman wiggles and shakes his guys in a true test of his ability to get through a scene without questioning his career choices.

It came as little surprise to see Jackman and the rest of the star-studded ensemble thoroughly duck promotional duties for this shockingly unfunny sketch flick, with director Peter Farrely even admitting:

"They clearly wanted out! But we wouldn’t let them."

Thankfully, this is one of the only roles Jackman has ever truly ballsed up...


8. Tom Kenny As King Jellybean - Rick & Morty

Jellybean Rick
Adult Swim

The ludicrous world of Rick and Morty crafted by Justin Roiland and Dan Harmon isn't exactly a stranger to outlandish and shockingly funny personalities. This is the same animated series that dedicates substantial time to an alcoholic mad scientist turning himself into a pickle and another character by the name of Mr. Poopybutthole, after all.

However, the honour of being arguably the most surreal face on show throughout the show's run so far has to go to the unsettlingly bizarre King Jellybean.

This massive anthropomorphic jelly bean, voiced by veteran voiceover actor Tom Kenny, at first appears to be an innocent enough giant confectionary treat, though his demeanour and attitude suddenly take a turn for the uncomfortable when Mr. Jellybean suddenly forces himself on Morty in a bathroom.

Morty is thankfully able to beat the living p*ss out of the creepy force before he's taken advantage of, with Rick eventually blasting the sexual predator village king into smithereens upon figuring out what had actually gone down.

As far as weird and unpleasant characters go, Tom Kenny's animated jelly certainly takes the bean.


7. Frank Miller Plays Man With Pen In Head - Daredevil

Man Pen
Fox

There's nothing quite like a knowing tip of the cap to one of the original creators of a well-known and much-adored character in the form of a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo.

Yet, while the many Marvel salutes to the undoubted god of said superhero universe that is Stan Lee were often as heart-warming as they were memorable, another comic book legend didn't get off quite that easy.

Brought in as one of the unlucky lads to be bested and dispatched by Colin Farrell's Bullseye over the course of 2003's limp Daredevil adaptation, Frank Miller was given his moment in the on-screen sun as his dead body lay on the ground post-defeat.

Adding further insult to injury, the highly influential comic book titan would actually be credited as Man with Pen in Head because, well, that's precisely the fate that ultimately heads Miller's unfortunate way in the end. A credit is a credit, however, and Miller made the most of his hollow stare into the middle-distance...


6. Nick Kroll Is A Douche - Sausage Party

Sausage Party Douche
Sony Pictures

Famed for creating and starring in very much jaw-dropping projects like Netflix's Big Mouth, it does often feel like absolutely no character is off limits when it comes to deciding precisely what Nick Kroll will try his devilish hand at next.

Sure enough, when the time came to cast 2016's animated attack on the senses that was Sausage Party, and the role of a certain Douche became up for grabs, Kroll simply could not resist playing this R-rated CGI flick's big bad.

The minute humans leave a supermarket in this unfiltered fictional land, just about everything available to them in the store, including horny hot dogs, highly intelligent pieces of gum, and feminine hygiene products, comes to life.

Kroll's depiction of that last usually inanimate object sees the comedy actor go full a-hole, producing an insufferable bro-ey twang that was once set to be shelved in favour of a villainous British accent.

After going fully insane upon having his nozzle broken and not being able to reach 'The Great Beyond", everything from highly disturbing juice box drinking to human manipulation via anus make for one of the most freakish animated beings you're ever likely to digest.


5. Samuel L. Jackson Is A Penguin Narrator - Farce Of The Penguins

Farce of the Penguins
Permut Presentations

Possessing one of the most distinct and recognisable voices in all of pop culture, any project that boasts the vocal qualities of one Samuel L. Jackson is always worth a minute of your time.

However, few of said features and TV offerings hold a candle to one particular parody documentary that was brought into existence by the late Bob Saget back in 2007 when it comes to sheer insanity.

Acting as a direct comedic response to 2005's much-publicised March of the Penguins, Saget takes on the role of Carl the Emperor penguin, with the writer-director also bringing in the likes of Christina Applegate, Whoopi Goldberg, and Tracy Morgan along for the farcical ride that uses real-life footage of penguins to create comedy gold.

Yet, the sound of Jackson brilliantly narrating all of the action alone is enough to make you question what was in the popcorn you were stuffing in your mouth as the opening credits unrolled.

Hell, the sequence that sees Jackson verbally sparring with a penguin he classes as a "nut-less motherf***er" has to rank as one of the most surreal and priceless unexpected duels in cinematic history.


4. Nicolas Cage Is A Version Of Himself - The Unbearable Weight Of Massive Talent

Willy's Wonderland Nicolas Cage
Screen Media Flms

Now, it's not exactly uncommon for a star to take on a role they were literally born to play on the big screen.

The likes of John Malkovich, Bill Murray, Ben Affleck, and Matt Damon have all taken to films as heightened and comical versions of themselves over the years. But the barmiest of all performances of one's self is arguably yet to come with the announcement of Tom Gormicon's The Unbearable Weight Of Massive Talent.

This feature will see the already infamously bizarre and all-round larger than life presence of Nicolas Cage playing, as he puts it, a "highly-neurotic, anxiety-ridden" version of himself.

In fact, the project is said to be so downright nuts, that the actor has even gone on record to admit that he'll struggle to sit down and watch the meta action comedy, as it's "too much of a whacked-out trip" for him to endure.

With Gormican reportedly pushing Cage to fully embrace "neurotic Cage" throughout shooting and bring some of his most iconic characters to life, brace yourselves for one of the weirdest and likely most enjoyable turns of 2022 this April.


3. Vin Diesel Only Says Three Words As A Talking Tree - Guardians Of The Galaxy

Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 Teen Groot
Marvel Studios

It may be taken for granted today, but when news broke of Vin Diesel being brought on board to star in one of Marvel Studios' incoming Phase 2 projects by the name of Guardians of the Galaxy, more than a few heads were turned at the reveal of precisely who the Fast and Furious megastar would be bringing to life.

Instead of lending his sizeable frame to a hulking hero in the same mould as a Thor or Captain America, Diesel would be occupying the MCU in purely a vocal form. And to add more strangeness to proceedings, big Vin would also only be required to ever say, for the most part, three specific words as his GOTG talking tree, Groot.

Almost a decade on, it's hard to imagine anyone else lacing the phrase "I am Groot" into each of the unmistakable Flora colossus' appearances either in James Gunn's Guardians outings or the ensemble epics that were Infinity War and Endgame.

But that still doesn't change the fact that this, alongside a talking racoon vocally realised by Bradley Cooper, sits as one of the curious characters ever to be cast in a superhero property.


2. Jason Mantzoukas Brings A Penis To Life - Pam & Tommy

Pam and Tommy Sebastian Stan Lily James
Hulu

You'd be forgiven for assuming that your writer was about to embark on another tale of a famous actor being swapped out in favour of a double when it came time to show off their junk in a production with this entry. But, you'd be mistaken as this next star has actually been brought on board the Pam & Tommy Hulu ride to play none other than the voice of Tommy Lee's member.

Holding this illustrious honour is none other than Brooklyn Nine-Nine and The Good Place's Jason Mantzoukas as the always-side-splitting comedy star is due to add his vocal tones to an animatronic penis in the upcoming Disney+-streaming biographical drama series.

When talking about how this feat was, ahem, pulled off in the show, director Craig Gillespie would note to Variety:

"You’ve got four puppeteers working with an animatronic penis. And then, how much is too much, and do you start to lose his emotional torment of what’s going on? Hopefully, it works,"

Stating the absolute obvious, Gillespie would also describe the process as "just awkward" before Sebastian Stan, playing Lee, would reveal:

"By the end of it, I treated it like it was an intimate buddy conversation that one might have when they’re falling in love,"

How do you follow that?


1. Taika Waititi Is An Imaginary Friend... Who's Also Hitler - Jojo Rabbit

Taika Waititi Hitler Jojo Rabbit
Fox Searchlight

Known for his often quirky and eccentric style of filmmaking, infusing brilliantly dry humour into genuinely heartwarming tales, the news of Taika Waititi penning the script, directing, and ultimately starring in a film involving a young boy who frequently confides in his imaginary best pal, Adolf Hitler, felt like an unexpected move even for him.

But in typical Taika fashion, he more than made the concept work and decided that, after being "blackmailed" into appearing as the infamous Nazi leader in the flick by Fox Searchlight, he would put zero effort into actually researching the man in an attempt to present an "authentic portrayal" of Hitler; in short, he didn't think he deserved it.

What followed was a darkly slapstick turn from Waititi that takes every opportunity available to poke fun at the frightening figure, and a film that would ultimately lead to the outstanding director's first-ever Academy Awards win, picking up the gong for Best Adapted Screenplay in 2020.

Waititi definitely seems like the sort of person who revels in making it up as he goes along. But even he must've been left scratching his head at the sight of him as an imaginary iteration of an evil dictator being at the centre of the work that sits as arguably his most acclaimed to date. Madness.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Antichrist
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!