10 What If? MCU Scenarios Marvel Should Explore

Turns out Vision might be secretly evil.

Punisher Captain America
Marvel

Marvel's recently announced 2021 What If? TV series certainly has no shortage of comic material to reference from. The main What If? comic series managed to span twelve volumes and a stunning 200+ issues to match it, all complete with wild and wonderful alternative scenarios to the comics that have made our heroes what they are today.

As much as it is clear that some of the shows episodes will vary from copying the comics - as cast inclusions like Michael Rooker as Yondu and Micheal B. Jordan's Killmonger show the series will feature characters who weren't in the What If? comic - this doesn't entirely close the door on the House of Ideas including some of their best comic issues to date.

Indeed, with the sheer amount of comics to take inspiration from, it seems impossible that a few choice picks will sneak their way onto the big screen, especially with how insanely good many of the concepts manage to be.

With heroes turning evil, villains turning good, and even a surprise presidency run from Captain America, it's safe to say that there are a metric ton of What If? comics that more than deserve to be considered for the show.

10. What If Loki Had Found The Hammer Of Thor? (Volume 1, Issue #47)

Loki Mjolnir What If?
Marvel Comics

The What If? issue that covers how the Marvel Universe would have changed were Loki to have wielded Thor's hammer is a case of a comic where the concept is perhaps better than the execution. Instead of giving Loki the actual hammer, we are essentially shown what would happen were Loki to find a version of the hammer that had transformed into...a stick.

Not a cool wooden bo-staff or tanto, but the kind of stick a dog would refuse to play fetch with.

It's still an interesting exploration of how Loki would react to essentially be given Thor's powers, but an adaption would arguably make the premise even better, as seeing Loki use the actual hammer would make the whole thing so much better.

Anyone who has ever been interesting in exploring the dynamic between Thor and Loki and their odd sibling dynamic should wait with baited breath for this potential episode, as this would open the proverbial Pandora's box in terms of Loki's feelings of unworthiness.


9. What If The Avengers Had Never Been? (Volume 1, Issue #3)

Avengers What If?
Marvel Comics

When you keep in mind the Hulk is pretty much the human equivalent of a nuclear warhead, it makes sense that, in a scenario wherein he isn't working with the Avengers leaves him as kind of an existing threat. Really, the vast majority of the Avengers pose a decent threat when they aren't all committed to the same cause - as evidenced pretty clearly in the Civil War film and comic.

This is the exact premise of What If? #3, which stars our favourite superhero team failing to join forces, and then summarily turning on one another. Although its a very surreal scenario, it doesn't feel entirely unbelievable, as the way the lack of a team affects each character feels very true to them - particularly watching Iron Man gently spiral into despair as he tries to come up with some form of a superhero squad.

The issue - and any potential television conversion - drives home that, as much as the Avengers exist to save the world, they also exist to save the Avengers from themselves, in a way.


8. What If Steve Rogers Had Refused To Give Up Being Captain America? (Volume 2, Issue #3)

Captain America What If
Marvel Comics

Proving that patriotism can be a paradox at times, in order to uphold his responsibilities to his country, What If? #3 sees Captain America fight the majority of said country in order to keep his status as the superhero. With this being close to, but not the same as, the plot of Civil War, it plays into the most interesting aspect of Captain America; how his loyalty to his country overrides his loyalty to the state.

While in the end that status quo is restored - with Captain America pardoned and reinstated as the official holder of the title - the brief period of time that Cap is pitted against all his teammates and closest friends makes for unironically heartbreaking viewing.

This is arguably the strongest reason this issue should be remade for the show, as there's sure to not be a dry eye amongst viewers as America's hero bids them all farewell not knowing if he'll ever get to see them again as friends. Don't worry, Cap - it's not you, it's them.


7. What If The Vision Of The Avengers Conquered The World? (Volume 2, Issue #19)

Vision What If?
Marvel Comics

Proving that Vision could easily be a horror character as a side gig, What If? #19 covers the illustrious and nightmare-inducing realm of a universe wherein Vision uses his technological powers to completely overthrow and rule the entire Earth.

The issue is...well, terrifying, and in being such it reminds us that Vision could be a monumental threat to civilisation were he ever to fully want to. The creepiest part of that Vision doesn't even seem to actively consider his actions evil, as his motives for taking over are to prevent potential nuclear war and keep humanity safe. This escalates to the point that Vision also begins to annihilate other planets, out of fear that they may try to threaten Earth.

Ignoring the weird undertones of the comic that appear to be discussing communism through Vision, it'd make for an incredible translation to television, as the whole thing feels like an episode of the Twilight Zone on steroids.


6. What If The Punisher became Captain America? (Volume 2, Issue #51)

Captain America Punisher
Marvel Comics

In the single biggest character change in Marvel history, What If? #51 looks into the simply hogwild potential of a universe wherein the Punisher has taken up the mantle of Captain America, and uses the role for suitably murderous purposes.

With Captain America being somewhat obviously a symbol of American values, it'd prove doubly interesting to see a character in the role that reminds us of some of America's less virtuous traits that are clearly embodied in the Punisher, such as the questions on gun control and mental health services for war vets that are such blazingly hot topics in the USA today.

As far as Frank Castle is concerned, he is upholding America ideals by indiscriminately murdering anyone with a vaguely shady past, and this raises a lot of questions in regards to the complicated politics behind giving someone an identity that places them at the forefront of a country's representation. Plus, it'd properly introduce the Punisher onto the bigscreen of the MCU, which would be a very pleasant bonus.


5. What If Spider-Man Was A Murderer? (Volume 2, Issue #72)

Spider-Man What If
Marvel Comics

The one issue that's never explored about heroes with super-strength is exactly how a hero discovers it. Given approximately nobody would continually test their own strength, it's surprising that no comic really features someone discovering they have the strength of ten men in the most obvious way; a fight.

No comic, that is, aside from What if? #72, where we watch Spider-man semi-accidentally murder the man who killed his Uncle Ben. Spider-Man has long been one of the more moral superheroes, meaning that seeing him retrospectively struggle with the idea of doing something objectively evil really adds that extra layer of dimension to the character.

With Tom Holland's Spider-Man being so widely adored for his incredibly well-meaning, do-gooder nature, it'd prove more a magnificent change to see what a more morally questionable web slinger would look like.


4. What If Captain America Had Been Elected president? (Volume 1, Issue #26)

Captain America President What If?
Marvel Comics

Although the idea of Captain America becoming president sounds like one almost explicitly made so the comic artists could come up with an iconic cover, the premise manages to be one of the most surprisingly wonderful issues of the entire What If? series.

The impact of the event is shown through a frankly shocking amount of heroes; Spider-Man, the Fantastic Four, and Nick Fury being to name but a few. It would have been incredibly easy to make the issue just about Captain America's journey, but instead we get a full three-dimensional look into how a superhero president would affect the entirety of the Marvel universe.

Add to this the closing of the comic - where we see Captain America sacrifice himself for his country, by preventing Red Skull from wiping America out one monument at a time - and there's ample potential for a beautifully unusual episode of the What If? series.


3. What If Dr. Strange Were A Disciple Of Dormammu? (Volume 1, Issue #18)

Doctor Strange What If
Marvel Comics

In one of the more interesting character changes of the What If? series, having Dr. Strange be the student of the entity he usually strives to control and contain makes for a genuinely thought-provoking comic. Strange essentially takes over the role that would normally be Mordo's - his arch-enemy - in the comics, eventually killing the other magician so as to properly steal his place as an agent of Dormammu.

Seeing the arguably canonically power-hungry Strange be slowly turned to the dark side feels incredibly believable, and the subsequent chaos that this event results in - both externally in the world Strange destroys, and internally in Strange's own consciousness - results in a story that has no right to be as powerful and or as representative of the character as it is.

Strange does turn good again at the end of the comic, everything before this explores the darker side of Stephen Strange that really deserves to be focused on more.


2. What If Thor Had Assumed The Throne Of Asgard? (Volume 2, Issue #107)

Thor What If
Marvel Comics

As the name suggests, issue #107 of the What If? series details what could have happened if the God of Thunder ascended to the throne of Asgard, and took his rightful place as king.

The comic itself is, tragically, not as good as it could perhaps be, as instead of focusing on the intricacies of a King Thor, the issue revolves more around the love triangle between Thor, Sif, and Eric Masterdon, known better as Thunderstrike.

However, an episode surrounding this would be able to take the existing source material, and improve on it. For this episode, there is a literal treasure trove of comics dedicated to exploring the possibility of Thor as ruler of Asgard - in everything from the War of the Realms comic to the Old King Thor character - which means the producers have full license to pick the best aspects of every one of these comics, and join them to create something new and exciting.


1. What If Iron Man Had Been A Traitor? (What If? 1988 Special)

Iron Man What If Fantastic Four
Marvel Comics

In an idea so good that it spanned its own separate spin-off special, this theoretical scenario covers what would have happened had Tony Stark secretly allied himself with the terrorist organisation that kidnap him, and start off his journey to become Iron Man.

This said, Iron Man being a 'traitor' doesn't necessarily have to place him with the people he opposed at the start of the first Iron Man film. Indeed, seeing him turn traitor at any of the key points of the MCU would be absolutely fascinating - especially any potential scenario that saw him either team up with Thanos, or use the Infinity Gauntlet for his own purposes.

Regardless of who exactly Stark allies with, seeing the ramifications of the man who is the beating heart of Marvel's superheroes completely turn against them would make for some endlessly engaging viewing - and more than a few broken hearts.


MCU Quiz: Finish These Iron Man Quotes

Iron man 2 Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

1. "Give Me A ____. I'm Starving."

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.