10 Most Wildly Inconsistent Actors In Movie History

With these guys, you never know what you're gonna get.

Actors aren't like crackers: they don't taste the same each and every time you eat them. Actors are more like sandwiches - each sandwich that you eat offers up an entirely unique experience depending on how well it was made and how good the ingredients are. If you're Daniel Day-Lewis, for example, we're obviously talking about an assembly line of sandwiches that were put together in a Michelin star restaurant. If you're Rob Schneider, on the other hand... well, Rob Schneider sandwiches contain only one ingredient: crackers. Which is an incredibly odd and convoluted way of saying that actors are capable of putting in performances of varying degrees of intensity, memorability and quality, depending on the movie in question. We don't always expect our actors to star in great movie after great movie, of course, but we do depend on them to - at the very least - put in a good performance. So whereas Michael Fassbender, Leonardo DiCaprio and Meryl Streep are almost always great, there are some who seem to thrive on a bizarre kind of inconsistency. Here we take a look a those actors whose filmographies are made up of a strange, otherworldly mix of great performances and insanely bad ones. Often, this comes down to an actors' willingness to take on "paycheck" films purely for the cash - the result is that they simply phone it in on-screen. But in other more mysterious cases, it almost seems as if the actor in question can't make their mind up whether they're good at acting or not. Join us as we explore the 10 Most Wildly Inconsistent Actors In Movie History (and make your own mind up)...

10. Sandra Bullock

It's largely apparently that Sandra Bullock's agent doesn't know what he wants Sandra Bullock to be, and that Sandra Bullock needs to fire her agent. Sandra Bullock - who recently did well for herself in space-based thriller Gravity - has remained a constant force in the movies since she popped up alongside Keanu Reeves in that movie about the bus that refused to slow down, but she's spent much of her career flicking between a variety of bizarrely inconsistent projects like a pinball in a... well, in a pinball machine. So whereas both her Oscar-winning turn in the The Blind Side and her role in Gravity served to remind us that Miss Bullock is, in fact, a talented actress, there's lots and lots of crap clogging up her filmography. I mean, can we forgive the likes of All About Steve, Miss Congeniality 2: Armed and Fabulous, and Speed 2: Cruise Control? These aren't just bad movies, mind - these are movies where Sandra Bullock herself is giving lame, uninspired performances. The most wild about Bullock, of course, is that she famously won a Razzie and an Oscar within a night of one another. Now that's one insanely inconsistent career. Call a plumber.

9. Mark Wahlberg

It's no surprise that movie-goers are often confused when they see Mark Wahlberg in a film. It's almost as if there are two actors who look exactly the same but are operating on completely opposite ends of the talent spectrum, after all. Which is another way of saying that Wahlberg can be a great actor, or he can be the worst actor in the room. Seriously. The man has given confident, memorable performances in movies like Boogie Nights and The Departed... and then he goes a lays down a performance as bizarrely putrid as the one in The Happening. What gives? How does Mark Wahlberg weigh whether or not he's going to act like an A-lister, or a contestant from a reality TV show who won a competition to play the lead actor in a blockbuster? Because those are the categories we're dealing with here, and it can often prove to be a rather frustrating experience - purely for the fact that it's impossible to know whether or not Wahlberg is actually good at acting or not. Seriously, does anybody know? Can we apply some sort of science magic in an attempt to work it out?

8. John Travolta

John Travolta hasn't quite veered into bad actor territory yet - people have too many fond memories of the guy in movies like Grease and Pulp Fiction for that, and was wonderful in movies such as Blow Out and Saturday Night Fever. Fact is, though, Travolta has made tons and tons of bad movies - not just movies where the script sucked or the direction wasn't up to scratch, but roles where Travolta himself seems to be suspended in some sort of restricted acting tank. You never know what you're gonna get with this guy. Travolta is clearly an actor who can only work up a screen presence if he's paired with the right material - that's why he thrived in Pulp Fiction. Tarantino penned the role especially for the actor, and even helped to bring his career back into the limelight. But pluck any recent movie out of Travolta's filmography and you'll find yourself staring into a few admirable performances (Ladder 49, Hairspray) and some real duds where the man seems to have tapped into singular emotions only (The Taking of Pelham 123). These days, casting Travolta in anything is akin to playing a game of Russian roulette.

7. Cuba Gooding Jr.

For a while, Cuba Gooding Jr. looked as though he was set to become one of the leading actors of his generation - and yet, somewhere along the line, it sort of fell apart, and everybody seemed to forget why he was all that big a deal to begin with. You'll remember that Gooding Jr. won an Oscar for his role in Jerry Maguire, of course, and was excellent in roles in Boys 'N the Hood and A Few Good Men before even then. Check Cuba Gooding out nowadays, though, and something's clearly missing: he's been phoning it in for near-on 10 years. Say what? Now and again, there have been moments to savour, but - generally speaking - the last twenty or so movies that Cuba has made have ranged between "meh" and "this is unbearably bad, please take me outside and shoot me." Hyperbolic? Perhaps. What's strange, however, is how an actor capable of turns like the ones in As Good As It Gets and What Dreams May Come has made so little impact in everything else. And given how eccentric and fun he is in Jerry Maguire, it's also weird to notice that - fairly frequently - Cuba winds up being so stiff and boring.

6. Johnny Depp

Johnny Depp isn't really "bad" in anything, but he does tred a fine line: for every good, enjoyable performance, Depp throws us a truly irksome and horribly insufferable one. This ratio is occurring to such an extent nowadays, of course, that's it kind of impossible to remember what Johnny Depp is like when he's not bumbling around with a quirky outfit on, doing a silly voice, and generally pushing the patience levels of his fans and the movie-going public at large. We get that you like hats and make-up, Johnny: now do some acting, will you? We'll always recall great turn in flicks like Edward Scissorhands and Donnie Brasco, and there's no denying that Depp was great in the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie... but the schtick has grown thin now, and all of his recent "performances" seem to rely more on being "crazy" and dressing up than on actually differentiating characters like The Mad Hatter, Willy Wonka, Tonto, and that pale one from Dark Shadows. For a man capable of so much more, it's kind of cringeworthy to see him wasting his talents. Oh, he was also terrible in The Tourist.

5. Al Pacino

HOO-HAH! There was a time when Al Pacino could seemingly do no wrong - one could argue that The Godfather to Glengarry Glen Ross marks one of the finest cinematic runs that any actor, ever, has pulled out of the bag. And then along came Scent of a Woman in '92, which, yes, won Pacino his Oscar, but there was no denying that the performance was over the top - Pacino doing his best version of a Pacino character. There was also a general feeling that the Academy had bestowed the award upon the actor for all the great work in his back catalogue. Ever since then, though, Al Pacino has found himself transformed into one of Hollywood's most inconsistent actors - a good performance here, a forgettable performance there... hey, maybe he'll phone this one in, and - you know - this one might win a couple of awards, why not? Though there have been a few admirable performances, the last 10 years have seen Pacino nominated for a whopping four Golden Raspberries, all for roles which he obviously did for the money. He must need it - why else would he have agreed to the Sky adverts?

4. Uma Thurman

Uma Thurman is the Mark Wahlberg of actresses, in the sense that we all - deep down - know she's a good actress (probably), but she's turned in so many middling, lousy or downright bad performances over the years that it's hard to remember whether or not she's any actually any good. If you took Pulp Fiction and the Kill Bill movies out of Thurman's filmography, you'd have to wade through a lot of sludge to find any worthwhile performances. And yet because of those Tarantino roles, we know she can act. It's complicated. So let's look at what we've got: My Super Ex-Girlfriend, The Accidental Husband, Playing For Keeps... these are all near-disastrous movies with near-disastrous performances, courtesy of Thurman. Can she only function as an actress when she's speaking Tarantino's dialogue? Has she given up trying? Your guess is as good as anybody's. There are bad movies with good Thurman performances of course: Ceremony and Bel Ami, to name just a recent two, but it's not enough. As it stands, this gal remains something of an inconsistent mystery.

3. Michael Caine

Michael Caine has made so many movies, it's hard to know where to start approaching the man as an actor. What we know for sure is that he brings a warmth and energy to pretty much every movie that he's in, but there are only really two kinds of Michael Caine performance: those where he is Michael Caine, and those where he's sort of Michael Caine, but not totally Michael Caine. That sounds like an attack on his range as an actor, but it's not suppose to be: Caine is the success story that he is today entirely for those reasons. Still, good as he very nearly always is, there's a tendency with Michael Caine to feel like his roles are often very "samey" - this largely stems from the fact that the man is an unstoppable work machine, and has even admitted to rarely turning down an offer to be in a movie (hence Jaws 4: The Revenge). So marvel over his wonderful performances in pictures such as Alfie, Hannah and Her Sisters, The Cider House Rules, The Quiet American, and Children of Men - and consider near-on twenty others as mere filler, many of which are largely forgettable.

2. Ben Kingsley

Ben Kingsley has the kind of movie career that causes your brain to break down and the world as you know it to collapse into a kind of explosive stupor of collapsed logic. Which is another way of saying: WHAT THE HECK is up with Ben Kingsley's career? Often thought of as one of the finest actors of his generation, you need only run your eyes over his vast filmography to find some of the most ill-judged and genuinely bizarre performances ever committed to celluloid. Seriously: we're talking about some bad, bad performances, folks. So here's the man who played Gandhi and won an Oscar for it, and has offered up a smorgasbord of insanely inconsistent performances ever since. The weird thing is, Ben Kingsley seems to just get away with his bad performances - they simply disappear, never to be talked about again, almost as if the world at large are fearful of breaking the illusion of this man as a true thespian. But can we really forget such awkwardly horrible turns as those in Thunderbirds, or BloodRayne, or The Love Guru? Fact is: Ben Kingsley is not a consistent actor. At all.

1. Nicolas Cage

Well, here he is: the King of Inconsistent Performances, and the one actor who truly deserves a place on this list for the frankly astounding number of conflicting performances that he's given over the course of the past 30 years. Many are shocked to learn that Nicolas Cage has an Oscar under his belt (he won, deservedly, for his role in 1994's Leaving Las Vegas). But after he won that Oscar, it almost seemed as though this talented actor had achieved his goal, and felt as though it was all right to slink off into mediocrity. That's to say, there have been great Nic Cage performances (Adaptation, Raising Arizona), serviceable Nic Cage performances (Face/Off/Con Air), and downright insane Nic Cage performances (The Wicker Man, Ghost Rider), none of which seem like they're coming from the same place. Which is really what acting is all about, to be fair. The saving grace here is that Cage's performances are never not entertaining - the good, bad and ugly ones all have a strange, inherent like-ability to be associated with them. So as we sit back and watch Cage as he flitters like an injured bird between movies he genuinely cares about, movies he's doing purely for the cash, or movies that even the man himself doesn't know how he ended up in, there's a certain element to be treasured here. In recent years, with the rise of the internet and such, Cage has become a sort of twisted, semi-ironic icon - even his past detractors seem to have admitted that there's something contagious about his giddy, never-ending mania. And they're right: in this case, inconsistency is totally the brand. Like this article? Got anyone to add to the debate? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.