10 Wildly Overpraised Movies

Don't believe the hype.

Prometheus Engineer
20th Century Fox

It’s not a blazingly original observation, but that doesn’t make it any less true: good presentation covers a multitude of sins, and the slickness of modern films lulls audiences into accepting movies where there’s less going on than meets the eye.

Movies look better now than ever, with sprocket holes, drooping mikes and other imperfections a thing of the past. Modern pictures have a level of technical polish that 70s filmmakers would’ve killed for, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re any better.

Take Pearl Harbor, a three-hour recreation of the events of December 7 1941 as told by the director of Armageddon. It’s a coarse, empty movie, but it was sold as spectacle and spectacle is what it delivered, prompting the Washington Post to call it “the best piece of popular entertainment to come along in years” (which must’ve surprised fans of Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Rings, released the same year).

Digitally created spectacle is all very well, but in an overcrowded marketplace where every blockbuster includes umpteen sequences of epic destruction, there has to be something more to retain our interest. The following films didn’t have it, but they won over critics who were content to worship the surface.

10. Godzilla (2014)

Godzilla Film 2014
Warner Bros.

What The Critics Said: “Orchestrates its thrills with such rare diligence, you want to yelp with glee.” (The Telegraph)

Released to theaters sixteen years after Roland Emmerich’s movie, Godzilla 2014’s remit was simple: make a better movie. Director Gareth Edwards succeeded, but in trying to avoid the 1998 film he’s also minimized the humor and dumb fun.

This version does give the Big G his dignity back, though, and he gets more to do this time around than rampaging through a city for two hours. One of the best calls the movie makes is to give him some actual monsters to fight, but after watching Tranformers, The Incredible Hulk, Pacific Rim et al, the thrill of watching a monster smackdown has been somewhat diminished.

If the movie’s ultimately not that satisfying, it’s still a better launchpad for a franchise than Emmerich’s film, and Godzilla’s fight with King Kong has been promised in a future installment so stay tuned.


9. Super 8

Super 8
Paramount Pictures

What The Critics Said: “The year’s most thrilling, FEELING mainstream movie.” (Time)

Small world dept: J.J. Abrams first movie job was on Don Dohler’s Nightbeast (1982), a threadbare sci-fi movie (shot mostly in the director’s back yard) about an alien on the loose in a small town.

Three decades later, armed with a $50 million budget, Abrams returned to that world with Super 8, a sort of coming of age story mixed with heavy doses of It Came From Outer Space. Set in 1979, there’s nostalgia aplenty as a group of friends investigate a train crash they witnessed and slowly come to realize there’s more to the incident than meets the eye.

Co-produced by Steven Spielberg, Super 8 wants to rub shoulders with the likes of Gremlins and Back To The Future but the poor pacing and undernourished story mean it’s not in the same league. If you really want to see this sort of thing pulled off, you’re far better off going back and watching It Came From Outer Space.


8. Sadako Vs Kayako

sadako vs kayako
Kadokawa

What The Critics Said: “Supremely silly yet undeniably fun.” (Variety)

From Freddy Vs Jason to Batman V Superman, most matchups look great on paper but fall apart once they reach the big screen. Sadako Vs Kayako, which unites the ghosts from Ringu and The Grudge, is another great concept that runs out of gas early on and never recovers.

Originally touted as an April Fools’ Day joke, the idea attracted so much attention that copyright holders Kadokawa went ahead and made the movie, but just like the films mentioned above, Sadako Vs Kayako never comes up with a convincing rationale for why these characters should be appearing together in the first place.

The movie tells two stories, one about a ghost who haunts people who watch a videotape and another about a haunted house, and just like in Freddy Vs Jason the justification used in bringing them together is using one to cancel the other out. The narrative was pretty strained in that movie and it's strained here, but while FVJ at least made good on its title, we never get to see much of Sadako and Kayako duking it out until right at the very end.


7. The Equalizer

The Equalizer Denzel Washington
Sony Pictures Releasing

What The Critics Said: “Stands out from its peers like a wolf among lapdogs.” (The Wrap)

A movie about a mysterious vigilante who tangles with Russian mobsters really belongs in the 1980s, so it’s no surprise that The Equalizer, which reteams Denzel Washington with Training Day director Antoine Fuqua, is based on the TV show that aired on CBS from 1985-9. The trouble is, the film remains stuck there.

Tired clichés are the order of the day, from slimy foreign gangsters to dirty cops, plus there’s also dialogue of the “f**k you, you mother**ker” variety and Chloe Moretz as a teenage hooker (with a heart of gold, obviously) who has Taxi Driver written all over her.

When she’s hospitalized by thugs, Denzel wipes out those responsible, which leads to a cat-and-mouse game with mobster Teddy (Marton Csokas, also a slimy foreigner in XXX and The Bourne Supremacy). You know the drill: they talk in a restaurant, Denzel gives him the “I’ve done things I’m not proud of” speech, Teddy decides to “send him a message” etc.


6. What Lies Beneath

What Lies Beneath Michelle Pfeiffer
20th Century Fox

What The Critics Said: “Goes Hitchcock one better!” (San Francisco Chronicle)

What Lies Beneath is a movie of two halves: the first is a very poor man’s Rear Window with Michelle Pfeiffer’s rich, bored (and dull) housewife suspecting her neighbour might’ve murdered his wife. He hasn’t of course – it’s just a red-herring subplot intended to throw off the viewer, like Tippi Hedren’s pursuit of Rod Taylor in The Birds.

Exactly why Zemeckis keeps attempting to channel Hitchcock isn’t clear, because once the second half of the movie begins, the film becomes a pale facsimile of The Sixth Sense and Ringu as the ghost of a murdered girl uses Pfeiffer to find and take revenge on her killer. So enamoured were filmmakers of this plot in the 2000s that we saw it again in FearDotCom, Gothika, Dark Water, One Missed Call, Mirrors and Shutter.

For all its calculated Hollywood slickness, Beneath is still a dumb movie full of false scares, though bored viewers can at least amuse themselves by anticipating the moment when Harrison Ford uses his acting technique of wagging his finger at whoever he’s addressing.


5. Pacific Rim

Charlie Day Pacific Rim
Warner Bros.

What The Critics Said: “Whatever our ages, Del Toro’s miraculous entertainment boosts us all up to its gleeful point of view.” (The Telegraph)

Pacific Rim has a cute central idea: in the not too distant future, attacks by kaiju are so common that the forces defending humanity create Jaegers, giant robots controlled by two pilots that fight the monsters.

Once the idea’s been established, though, the film doesn’t know what to do with it and it’s a long haul to the climactic battle. A potentially rousing 100 minutes is bloated to two hours by psychobabble intended to give the characters depth that instead just weighs the whole film down.

Toho Studios were doing this sort of thing with more zip in the 1960s, and while Pacific Rim pays homage to its inspiration on several occasions (one Jaeger attacks a kaiju with a ship, just like in War Of The Gargantuas), those old movies knew better than to give their characters hackneyed back stories.

Raleigh (Charlie Hunnam) quit piloting Jaegers after seeing his brother killed in combat while Mako Mori (Rinko Kikuchi) still has childhood flashbacks to when kaiju destroyed her hometown. Who needs characters when you’ve got caricatures?


4. Black Swan

Black Swan
Fox Searchlight Pictures

What The Critics Said: “A tour de force, a work that fully lives up to its director’s ambitions.” (New York Magazine)

Black Swan might be a critically lauded, Oscar winning blockbuster but if you scratch the surface it’s really a Joe Ezsterhas movie with pretensions, the kind of tawdry story where every character has a way with innuendo, including a waiter who says, “Let me know if it’s juicy enough for you!”

Just like the world of (lap) dancing exposed in Showgirls, ballet is really all about sex, as is none-too-subtly shown when Vincent Cassel takes Natalie Portman for drinks, enquires if she’s a virgin and suggests she “live a little” by masturbating. Which, in one hilarious scene, she does – unaware mom’s asleep five feet away.

Eszterhas specializes in cod psychology, but even he’d draw the line at delineating characters by dressing one in black, one in white, and suggesting our heroine might’ve gone off the deep end by having the eyes of her paintings literally follow her around the room.

The movie’s apologists maintain that this is a skilful portrayal of the mental collapse of Portman’s character, but its approach to psychology is still as hokey as William Castle’s Straight Jacket (1964) where Joan Crawford’s released axe murderer develops a phobia of sharp objects.


3. Jurassic World

Chris Pratt Jurassic World
Universal Pictures

What The Critics Said: “A terrifically enjoyable and exciting summer spectacular: savvy, funny, ridiculous in just the right way and with some smart imaginative twists.” (The Guardian)

With a worldwide gross of $1.6 billion, Jurassic World is the highest grossing creature feature of all time, which comes as something of a surprise: it’s a sequel, it was made two decades after the original and it’s not really that great.

The film’s art is in its plot contrivances, and it succeeds in coming up with new ways of unleashing dinosaurs on characters with ‘cannon fodder’ written all over them far better than either The Lost world or Jurassic Park III. All of which is entertaining enough while it lasts, but don’t expect much resonance.

It also has the good sense not to bring back characters from previous installments and starts over with a new bunch of caricatures. There’s Chris Pratt’s lantern-jawed, invincible adventurer whose warnings go unheeded, plus Bryce Dallas Howard as the uptight boss who learns how to loosen up and kick ass once people start being eaten.

Also around are some Cute Kids (of course), a Corporate Villain who meets a sticky end (ditto) and some post-modern blather about the first movie. One character even wears a Jurassic Park t-shirt – acknowledging your own merchandise is a running joke in this franchise.


2. Prometheus

Prometheus Engineer
20th Century Fox

What The Critics Said: “Flawlessly designed, with the beautiful 3D cinematography contrasting the clean white futurism of Prometheus’ interiors with the black corporeal surfaces of the alien catacombs.” (Total Film)

The highest grossing entry in the Alien franchise to date, Prometheus seems to start out with the intention of giving the audience something if not entirely new then at least surprising. But when the surprises fail to materialize it turns into more of a re-tread with supposedly intelligent people behaving in stupid ways.

Not only does Peter Weyland (Guy Pearce) turn out to have an ulterior motive (what’re the odds?) but this crew of brilliant minds are very, very good at putting themselves in harm’s way. Is it Standard Operating Procedure for biologists to wander off from their group or start prodding foreign objects as soon as they see them? You will not find much credibility here.

Nor will you find much in the way of tension. There’s no risk, and when it becomes clear that any attempts to subvert expectations have given way to following the formula, no reason to get involved. Here’s hoping Alien: Covenant makes up for its predecessor’s shortcomings.


1. I, Robot

I robot
20th Century Fox

What The Critics Said: “Fabulous mental escape. It’s fun and playful…. put together in a fabulous package.” (Washington Post)

The best sci-fi movies dazzle us not with their vision of the future but the way they use it to comment upon the present. In the case of I Robot, a movie “suggested” by the works of Isaac Asimov, that opportunity is squandered in favor of product placement.

Within the first three minutes, we get gratuitous plugs for JVC, FedEx and “Converse All Stars, vintage 2004” which is how it goes for the rest of the film, with particular attention paid to Audi, whose fine automobiles will be the only vehicles gracing American roads in 2035. If you find that hard to swallow, then get a load of I, Robot’s plot.

After imbuing a robot named Sonny with human thoughts and feelings, Dr Alfred Lanning (James Cromwell) tells his creation to throw him out of a window, knowing that his death will be investigated by Detective Del Spooner (Will Smith, playing Will Smith, with all his usual Will Smith-isms).

A card carrying technophobe, Spooner is the only person capable of stopping VIKI (Virtual Interactive Kinetic Intelligence), a computer with its own agenda.

Which he does, but wouldn’t it have been easier just to get him on the phone and say, “Hey, Del, I’ve got a problem”?


In this post: 
Prometheus
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'