10 Worst Changes Peter Jackson Made To The Hobbit
This story was like butter spread over too much bread.
They say lighting never strikes twice. Well that was certainly true when it came to Peter Jackson's second venture into Middle-earth.
Adapting The Lord of the Rings from book to film, was a tasked deemed impossible. Tolkien himself never had much faith in the movie business doing his books justice, and indeed he was proven right with several early, and less than favourable adaptions. In 1978 Ralph Bakshi delivered an animated account of the first half of Tolkien's epic tale, but it never received a sequel. In 1980 fans got an unrelated telling of The Return of the King from Rankin/Bass.
Neither production was all that successful, but eventually the Lord of the Rings got the treatment it deserved. Against the odds, Peter Jackson negotiated a three-movie deal with New Line. He spent years of pre-production to design the world and fine tune the script, bringing it as close to Tolkien as possible. It was a masterpiece.
So what the hell went wrong with The Hobbit? Two directors, three over-bloated movies, and studio interference, all contributed to a story that was ultimately less than the sum of its parts.
10. Trying To Stretch The Story Into Three Parts
Way back when Guillermo del Toro was scheduled to direct The Hobbit, it was originally intended to be a two-part movie. During these early stages, del Toro worked closely with the design teams, creating a world, wholly different to what we'd seen before. Like the original book, the story was intended to have a more "fairy-tale" like quality, in comparison to The Lord of the Rings.
The first film would depict a more fantastical world, and the second would see a subtle transitioning into a more gritty realm, inline with Jackson's original trilogy. The two-movie format also seemed to make sense in terms of the book's structuring. There are several fairly obvious places to divide the story. With two parts, you could adequately, but concisely tell the tale, while giving fans that cliffhanger moment. This seemed to be the direction del Toro was going in.
But he was forced to leave the project; the details of why are still somewhat mysterious. After a scramble for a new director, Peter Jackson agreed to step in.
A year of a half of pre-production was thrown out, and Jackson was given mere months to prep. He had none of the planning time of Lord of the Rings, and essentially started shooting without a finished script. He shot the story as a two-part movie, but a late decision was taken to create a third film. This third film was essentially cobbled together with excess footage and a number of reshoots and CGI sequences - could you tell?
9. Legolas
Officially Legolas does not get a mention in Tolkien's The Hobbit. It's doubtful the writer had even conceived of the character at the point he wrote the book. But it would make sense for him to be knocking around at the time of the story. He is after all, an elf, and therefore old enough to have been alive. Being the son of Thranduil, he likely would have been at the Battle of Five Armies, as well.
So his inclusion in the films wasn't necessarily unwarranted, or even unwise, but it was poorly executed. Portraying Legolas as a somewhat moody and even arrogant teen-elf seemed to be what Jackson was going for. But given that this was only 60 years before The Lord of the Rings - Jackson specified Legolas was almost 3,000 years old in his original trilogy - it left the whole angsty-teen elf thing feeling inconsistent with Jackson's established world.
The real issue was all the logic-defying acrobatics Orlando Bloom displayed throughout the story. It was one thing to see him using a shield as a skate board in The Two Towers, but when he defied the laws of gravity by walking on falling rocks, it just got silly.
8. Diminishing The Part Of Beorn
The task of expanding two movies into three, obviously left Peter Jackson fried. So fried, that he seemed to neglect one of the most memorable characters from the book.
Jackson hired Swedish actor Mikael Persbrandt to play the shapeshifter Beorn. It was a great choice. He commanded the imposing menace of the character with ease. His design was one of the hardest to nail down and took the longest to create, but ironically he had one of the smallest parts.
The filmmakers introduced Beorn during the second movie, setting him up as a formidable character, only to make the laziest callback to him in cinema history. The Eagles turned up to save the day (again), and airdropped Beorn into the midst of the orcs... and that's it, we don't get any further references to the character. Considering all the other long-winded fight sequences Jackson threw into the Battle of Five Armies, you'd think he could have given Beorn a slightly better climax. It's not like Tolkien didn't give him material to go off.
In the book, Beorn arrives late to the battle; he manages to rescue an injured Thorin, carries him to safety and then returns to kill Bolg. He pretty much helps turn the tide of battle, saving the day. Sadly Jackson deemed it wiser to cut all this out, and dedicate precious time to a forced dwarf/elf love triangle.
7. Adding The Legolas, Tauriel, Kili Love Triangle
Perhaps the most egregious mistake Jackson allowed to happen, was the love triangle that killed the second and third movies' momentum. He essentially reduced one of the more interesting characters, to nothing more than a damsel in distress.
Tauriel was invented for the movies, and she was a welcome addition. Up until her appearance, Middle-earth had been a sausage party. Not only was it refreshing to have a female character slaying fools, but Jackson set up the potential for an interesting examination of elven hierarchy.
Legolas and his father are both Sindar elves, ruling over the Silvan elves like Tauriel. We get a brief mention of this, but rather than letting it be a source of friction between the characters, Jackson instead focused on an incredibly surface level love story.
Instead of Tauriel's character having any real weight, she ends up serving as the love interest for the 'sexy' dwarf of the film. And apparently all that was required for her to fall for Kili, was him delivering the line, "I could have anything down my trousers". Nice.
We didn't even get any real friction from it. Legolas just mopes around looking stern, but at no point does he confront Kili for trying to get it on with his girl. This could have set up Legolas' distain for dwarves, making his future relationship with Gimli all the more poignant.
6. The Whole Sauron Sub Plot
In order to turn a fairly simple and short story into three movies, Peter Jackson was required to pull from Tolkien's expanded writings. In the books, Gandalf disappears for a huge section of the narrative. We're told he had other business to deal with, but it's not integral to the plot. Tolkien basically sent Gandalf away in order to have the Dwarves and Bilbo face a few challenges on their own.
But with the decision to add another movie to the franchise, more material was required to justify the extended run time. Tolkien did specify that Gandalf was off dealing with the Necromancer during his absence from The Hobbit, so it made sense to make a nod to Sauron. But it only needed to be a nod.
It would have been far more satisfying to hint at the evil simmering away at the corners of the story, rather than blatantly forcing it down our throats. All it served to do was detract from the plot-lines, set up in movie one. It was hard to go back and take Azog, or even Smaug seriously when Sauron was presented as the true concern.
Sure, it was cool to see Elrond, Galadriel and Saruman duke it out with the Nazgûl, but it was little more than cheap fan-service.
5. Having Too Many Antagonists
In Tolkien's original story, Azog was not the main antagonist. In fact he didn't even make an appearance. In the book, the dwarves manage to stir up the goblins of Misty Mountains, after they slay the Great Goblin King. At the end of the story, the goblins reappear, led by an ancient enemy, Bolg son of Azog. Their motivation is one part greed - after hearing about the death of Smaug - but also revenge for the death of their king.
Jackson was right to flesh this out for his movies. It was important that we had some sense, that the goblins and orcs were plotting away, rather than just appearing out of nowhere at the end of the third film.
But the movies suffered from having far too many villains being presented as the main antagonist. Firstly, we had Smaug - the reason for the entire quest of Thorin and co. Then, Azog gets thrown into the mix, along with Bolg, who's only purpose is to give Legolas someone to fight. On top of that, Sauron gets plastered in at every opportunity, just in case we forgot about his presence in Middle-earth.
Smaug was essentially pushed to the side to focus on Sauron, and Bolg and Azog just wrestled for screen time, with their only real motivation being that they are evil.
4. Using CGI For F**king Everything
One of the things that grounded Jackson's original trilogy, was the use of prosthetic make-up for his characters, and expansive set designs for his locations. When you're creating a fantasy world, you want to do everything you can to help the audience suspend disbelief. You're already asking them to believe in dragons, orcs and dwarves, so anything you can do to make the world feel more grounded in reality, is essential.
Jackson understood this for The Lord of the Rings. Sure, he used CGI, but only when other means wouldn't work; it augmented his scenes rather than made them. Well, Jackson threw all that out the window with the Hobbit. Go through frame by frame, every other shot has some form of CGI in it. The orcs were mostly CGI, everything looked like it was shot on green screen, and entire sequences were created in a computer.
The gritty realism, that was so well captured in The Lord of the Rings, was replaced with obvious and cheap movie trickery, born out of a need to extend sequences way beyond what was necessary.
3. Turning The Barrel Sequence Into A Water Ride
H*ly s**t was this scene terrible. Put aside the fact that every bit of action defied the laws of physics, forget about those low quality GoPro shots, and ignore the fact the sequence looked like a computer game cut-scene, this was just utterly boring.
Jackson seemed comfortable taking his time to engross you with The Lord of the Rings world. It was enough to see the captivating landscapes and the strange cultures, but apparently he thought an audience needed cheap thrills to keep them entertained for The Hobbit.
Everything that was wrong with The Hobbit can be summed up in this sequence. It was bloated, he looked fake; it didn't obey the in-world-rules and just became more ridiculous and tedious as it dragged on.
This was an iconic moment in the books, when admittedly not a lot happens. Bilbo hides the dwarves in the barrels and sends them down the river, making their silent and sneaking escape. But that's just fine, we didn't need to have this turn into a big action sequence.
As we've mentioned, Jackson needed to flesh everything out to warrant the three-movie format. The result looked like an advert for a trashy ride at a Middle-earth theme park - which no doubt, will get made someday.
2. Including Radagast
Radagast is a great character, and to give Sylvester McCoy his due credit, he played him brilliantly. This wasn't just another version of Saruman or Gandalf, this was a different kind of wizard entirely. His character portrayal was actually one of the few things that helped give The Hobbit some depth.
His obsession with nature and his ragtag, shabby appearance was a brilliant homage to Tolkien's original character - who was described as being so enamoured by the world of plants and beasts, that he sort of lost his way. And that's what we saw.
But. And this is a big but, we didn't need to spend so much time on him. Jackson spent a ridiculous chase sequence introducing the character, time that could have been used fleshing out all the dwarves - who by the second movie were mostly pushed to the side, in favour of the aforementioned love triangle.
Radagast was a nice nod to Tolkien, but he didn't appear in the books, and wasn't integral to the plot. Like so many aspects of these films, his inclusion only served to bog Peter Jackson's story down, rather than help drive it.
1. The Smaug Chase Sequence
By the time the second Hobbit movie was half way through, we knew the trilogy could not be saved. The first movie was by no means perfect, but there was enough there to leave the audience thinking the second two might save it.
Sadly that was not to be. We were subjected to the ridiculous barrel ride sequence, an imagined rivalry between Legolas and Bolg - which only served to show us how boring action scenes could be - and then we were hit with the sh*t show of the Smaug chase scene.
By this point it was clear Jackson had lost his way. The careful planning with which he crafted sequences in The Lord of the Rings made way for scenes made on the fly. It's clear the whole project got away from Jackson. He was essentially forced to pick up the reins of a multi-million dollar franchise, without the creative control or planning time he'd had for The Lord of the Rings.
Scenarios were cobbled together with a few real-time action shots, all plastered over with an obscene amount of rushed CGI. All this scene served to do was kill 20 minutes of screen time, for a movie that didn't warrant existing.