10 Worst Fox Marvel Movies
After two decades of making Marvel movies, which of Fox's contributions to the genre were the worst?
With the exception of New Line Cinema's adaptation of Blade in 1998, films based on Marvel Comics hadn't ever really been taken seriously before 2000, and for good reason, as the few the world had ever gotten ranged somewhere in quality between 1986's disastrous Howard the Duck or direct-to-video dreck like 1989's The Punisher and 1990's Captain America.
It wasn't until 20th Century Fox took a chance on the original X-Men that the tide really turned, ushering in a comic book movie boom that has brought us to where we are today.
For the last two decades, Fox has been pumping out films based on Marvel properties every few years, though that era has now come to an end with Disney's acquisition of the historic studio. From the X-Men to the Fantastic Four to Daredevil, Fox tried to keep up with the ever-changing landscape of the modern comic book movie genre it helped create over the years, resulting in beloved successes like X2: X-Men United, X-Men: Days of Future Past, the Deadpool films, and Logan.
But throughout the studio's run, it also churned out quite a lot of duds, a few considered some of the worst superhero films ever made, others disliked simply for being subpar. With the era of Fox-produced Marvel movies behind us - barring the release of New Mutants, if it ever sees the light of day at this point - let's look back over the studio's legacy to sort out the 10 worst Marvel adaptations they released...
10. The Wolverine
2013's The Wolverine isn't a terrible film by any stretch, but it's also not necessarily a great one. Upon its release, it had the unenviable task of luring audiences back who had been turned off by 2009's X-Men Origins: Wolverine while also carrying forward Wolverine's story following the events of X-Men: The Last Stand.
To its merit, The Wolverine really offered up something unique by sending its titular mutant to Japan, giving Hugh Jackman some good material to work with in dealing with his grief over the loss of Jean Grey and in the arrival of characters like Mariko and Yukio in his life. There's even some great action here, such as a battle atop a bullet train or a sequence where Logan is pierced by dozens of rope arrows fired by ninjas.
Unfortunately, there's also a lot that doesn't work, like the villainous Viper, whose campiness often feels out of place with the tone of the film, and a final act involving the Silver Samurai that ultimately feels lifeless simply because of how generic it is in comparison to an otherwise unique film. As part of the X-Men franchise, it's a decent entry whose biggest sin is being average, director James Mangold's warm-up for the far superior Logan.
9. X-Men: The Last Stand
In the 13 years since its release, X-Men: The Last Stand has been picked apart for all its failures in ways that a few paragraphs couldn't really do justice. In a world where trilogy-enders like Blade: Trinity and Spider-Man 3 exist, The Last Stand remains a poster child for simply getting so much wrong - to the point it was eventually wiped from continuity - which is even more frustrating because it does get some things right.
Take, for instance, the pitch-perfect casting of Kelsey Grammar as Beast, the fact that Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, and Ian McKellen are just as good as ever, or that we get to see cool comic book things happen, such as the Danger Room being utilized or Iceman finally icing up, all of which are great elements of the movie taken on their own. It's just too bad that they're sandwiched between so much the film gets wrong that it all feels like a wash.
Of course, the film's most infamous sin is that it served as a terrible adaptation of "The Dark Phoenix Saga," but it also well and truly wasted characters like Cyclops, Mystique, and Angel, tried to cram in the mutant cure plot, and carried no real emotional weight. As a film on its own, its a disappointing mess, but as a follow-up to two great films, particularly X2, which set a real high bar for it to reach, it's rendered all the more of a letdown when it had every chance to send the trilogy out on a soaring high.
8. X-Men: Apocalypse
After the one-two punch to the gut of the franchise with X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the series worked to regain its footing starting with the soft reboot that was X-Men: First Class, the apology letter that was The Wolverine, and then the beloved X-Men: Days of Future Past, which really restored a lot of faith in the franchise.
That film offered up the films a clean slate from which to move forward even as it set a high bar - like X2 did - for what came next: X-Men: Apocalypse. Like The Last Stand, the most frustrating thing about Apocalypse is the fact it does get a lot right, like the performances of James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender or that we get to see a handful of the mutants use their powers on a scale the franchise hadn't shown before.
But all of the good is bogged down by a bloated story, a high stakes finale rendered hollow due to its lack of a real emotional core, and the wasting of Oscar Isaac as the titular villain. It's entertaining in fits and bursts, but could've been so much more had more thought been put into making it something truly special, especially when all the pieces were there to build something worthy of following up Days of Future Past.
7. Daredevil
Let's get something out of the way: The director's cut of Mark Steven Johnson's Daredevil is a much better film than the theatrical version unleashed upon the world, and if you're someone who at least enjoyed the original version of the film, you do owe it to yourself to at least check it out, even if it doesn't suddenly turn a subpar film into a phenomenal one.
And subpar really is what the theatrical version of Daredevil is. At the time of its release, the film was only following X-Men, Blade II, and Spider-Man as the Marvel boom started to really take off, and didn't really do any favors to the superhero genre, failing miserably where those films succeeded. Even Ben Affleck himself hates the film, though he's far from the worst thing about it.
It suffers severe tonal whiplash, for example, oscillating between dark moments of violence and an unhealthy heaping of over-the-top camp present in scenes like the playground "fight" or the mere existence of Colin Farrell's scenery-chewing Bullseye. Even creative decisions like loading the film up with early 2000s rock music has dated it painfully, the film standing as a relic of a time when the genre was still finding its footing, whose only upside is that its failure ultimately paved the way for the far superior television series on Netflix.
6. Dark Phoenix
As mentioned at the outset of this article, unless New Mutants finally sees the light of day theatrically, Dark Phoenix marks both the end of the X-Men franchise as we've come to know it over the past twenty years and the end of Fox's run of making Marvel movies.
It truly is unfortunate, then, that the X-Men are sent off with such a lack of enthusiasm. Surely a case can be made that it's no worse than, say, X-Men: Apocalypse or even X-Men: The Last Stand, but what makes Dark Phoenix such a colossal disappointment in ways those films necessarily weren't is the fact it marks the end of the franchise. This should've been something truly special as a goodbye to both these characters and this world, and yet it wasn't.
Aside from messing up "The Dark Phoenix Saga" yet again, it has a painfully uninteresting villain in Jessica Chastain's Vuk, never quite knows what to do - as usual - with characters like Cyclops, Storm, and Nightcrawler, and wastes James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender in particular. They've carried much of the franchise since its soft reboot in X-Men: First Class and deserved a send-off on par with Logan or Days of Future Past, which makes the fact that Dark Phoenix limps across the finish line all the more egregious.
5. Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer
To its credit, Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer is a slightly more enjoyable movie than its predecessor, though that's not quite high praise. It was released only two years after Fantastic Four released to less-than-stellar reviews and far from earth-shattering box office numbers, yet its mild success meant a sequel was inevitable.
Unfortunately, the sequel feels like few lessons were learned from the first film's failures, the final product enough of a goofy mess that it killed any chance at another sequel. What high points it has, like Michael Chiklis as Ben Grimm, Chris Evans as Johnny Storm, or the Silver Surfer himself, are essentially lost amidst the cringe-inducing movie they're a part of.
Jessica Alba still feels completely miscast, Doctor Doom is a complete joke, and - lest we forget - the film's interpretation of Galactus as a giant cloud is infamous for how abysmal it is. And even with all that going against it, it still managed to produce something even worse: Reed Richards' dance scene.
4. Fantastic Four (2005)
Even though it was successful enough to spawn a sequel that slightly improved upon it, Fox's first stab at bringing the Fantastic Four to the big screen really didn't deserve it. With franchises like X-Men and Spider-Man were in full swing, every studio with rights to Marvel properties was eager to launch their own franchises and ride the superhero wave.
Naturally, Marvel's First Family was pushed out as soon as possible, the end product feeling more like a cash grab from executives seeing green than a film made by a studio invested in these characters and their world. When it was released, it felt cheap and hollow, and time hasn't changed that.
Michael Chiklis and Chris Evans practically carry the film on their backs, the duo remaining both this film and its sequel's true saving grace. It's harmless, sure, but utterly pointless, frustrating because it's such a waste of great characters with so much cinematic potential, the first of not one, not two, but three failed attempts by Fox to get it right.
3. X-Men Origins: Wolverine
Is it really a surprise to anyone that director Gavin Hood's 2009 disaster is on this list? Though it's been a decade since its release, X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the fourth film in the X-Men franchise, continues to be regarded as both one of the lowest points of the series and one of the worst comic book movies period, and for good reason.
Though Hugh Jackman and Liev Schreiber really do give it their all here, the actual film itself is a completely downhill experience. It says a lot when a film's best sequence is its opening titles, in this case a cool sequence showing Wolverine and Sabertooth fighting through history, something that everything that follows strays further and further away from in quality.
From absolutely abysmal CGI effects to the utter waste of Deadpool, Origins - like The Last Stand before it - was so bad that it was effectively wiped from continuity, the best thing about it being jokes made at its expense in the Deadpool films. At the least, though, its failure meant there was nowhere to go but up, and set the franchise on a path that eventually led to Logan.
2. Elektra
Up to this point on the list, all the films have had some sort of redeeming quality present in them if you're willing to look hard enough. Even though it's an absolute disaster, something like X-Men Origins: Wolverine at least has performances from Hugh Jackman or Liev Schreiber going for it, while X-Men: Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix have cool action moments.
At the very least, in comparison to 2005's Elektra, there's something - however small it may be - memorable about them all. The same really can't be said of Elektra, which is so oppressively boring and unengaging that I was honestly dreading even having to expend time writing about it for its inclusion on this list.
At the time of its release, it brought absolutely nothing new to the table for the genre, which was just about to enter its dark period where films like Fantastic Four, Ghost Rider, The Last Stand, and Spider-Man 3 would surface, which says a lot about Elektra when it's still the worst of the bunch. From wasting its cast and comic elements like The Hand and more, there's nothing here that justifies its existence, a film better left forgotten.
1. Fantastic Four (2015)
Let's keep this simple: Even compared to an utter trainwreck like X-Men Origins or a boring slog like Elektra, Josh Trank's Fantastic Four is just abysmal. The film's production woes are a thing of infamy now, things having gotten so bad that Trank lost a sweet gig directing a Boba Fett movie for Lucasfilm because of his antics behind the scenes here.
Say what you will about Fox's first two Fantastic Four films, at least they recognized that these heroes are not meant to exist in a dark, gritty, joyless world, something that the 2015 reboot swung for and missed completely. It's not pleasant to watch in any way, from the story itself to the visuals, squandering all sorts of potential it had by being able to recognize why its predecessors weren't received warmly.
The fact that Fox failed to succeed with the Fantastic Four - and their iconic villain Doctor Doom - three times in ten years is rather impressive, standing as Fox's worst Marvel movie simply because of how monumental a failure it is, and hopefully in time their return home to Marvel Studios can follow in Daredevil's footsteps in finally giving these characters their due.