10 Worst Horror Prequels Ever Made

You know, the bit that happened before the important bit. Sometimes you're better off not knowing.

Red Dragon Anthony Hopkins
Universal Pictures

From psychiatrist to cannibal. Mummy's boy to slasher in the shower. Jedi to Sith Lord. Kiddie-killer to Dream Demon. No matter how iconic the villain, everyone has to start somewhere. And there's a particular fancy, particular in horror movies, to pore over every aspect of a monster's rising, no matter how mundane.

And so, as the recent Wolf Creek TV series allowed us a brief insight into outback bastard Mick Taylor's earliest days, so spook 'em up Ouija: Origin of Evil will go back 50 years into the history of Ouija's haunted house. Next up, Texas Chainsaw Massacre man Leatherface is set to explore his upbringing in 2017's Leatherface.

Whether it's the beloved TV series Hannibal, the smart Saw III, or the intriguing Prometheus (yes, really), there's no denying a place in horror history for the prequel. Letting us get to know our heroes and villains better, a good horror sequel can show how certain elements came to fall into place (thematically, like Prometheus, or historically, like Hannibal) and enrich your franchise and its heritage.

In other cases, however, it's simply a way for studios and filmmakers to wring a little bit of extra cash out of a character they foolishly killed too early in the series, or wrote into in a corner.

In the case of the next ten movies, we'll learn that some stories might be better left untold...

10. Red Dragon

red dragon edward norton anthony hopkins
Universal Pictures

Where to go next? Everybody loved The Silence of the Lambs, and we quite liked its sequel, but Hannibal wrote itself into a bit of a corner with the good doctor lopping off his hand and essentially retiring abroad (again). Thankfully, there was one book they hadn't adapted yet: Red Dragon.

Previously made as Manhunter with a different Doctor Lec(k)tor, Red Dragon is Silence of the Lambs-lite: all of the ingredients are there, but not of the finest quality. Lecter in a cage, serial killer on the loose, detective consulting. A miscast Ed Norton stars as Will Graham, on the case of a serial killer known as The Tooth Fairy. You know the story - we've seen it three times now.

In this case, director Brett Ratner finds himself unable to capture the lightning-in-a-bottle feel of The Silence of the Lambs, this prequel simply going through the motions to little purpose. Everyone looks as tired as they do old (much older than they did in Hannibal!) and poor Hopkins is terrible as Lecter, his screen time duly amped up to cater for audience demand. Were it the only adaptation of the story, Red Dragon would be serviceable enough. Unfortunately, it isn't, and it isn't.

Still, there'd be worse to come...


9. Bates Motel

Bates Motel Season 3
Universal

Alfred Hitchcock's classic masterpiece Psycho already got its prequel with 1990's Psycho IV: The Beginning. However, directed by Mick Garris and featuring Anthony Perkins as a Norman Bates recalling his earlier days, it's not a half bad bit of schlock, unnecessary as it might be.

No, the Psycho prequel which really gets our goat is this TV melodrama, painfully dragging out the story of Norman Bates's teenage years over the course of four plus seasons.

Freddie Highmore and Vera Farmiga are excellent as Norman and his surprisingly rounded Mother, but the storytelling is as bland and dull as it gets, and a classic case of TV decompression. The series' problems are only compounded by its achingly boring supporting characters (most notably brother Max) and for the utter waste of Nestor Carbonell, who deserves so much more.


8. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre The Beginning
New Line Cinema

If Platinum Dunes' Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake felt pointless, then this prequel is even doubly so - tacking on a half-baked Leatherface origin story to the thing the filmmakers actually wanted: more screentime for R. Lee Ermey's Sheriff Hoyt.

Hoyt and the Hewitt family 'return' in a story which explains elements of the family legacy nobody ever really cared about in the first place: how Hoyt came by his Sheriff's badge, why Leatherface wears the leather, um, face, and what's with the whole cannibalism deal. Like its predecessor, it's gory, cruel and slickly produced (too slick to be a Texas Chain Saw fick, perhaps), but its narrative dead end makes it impossible for the audience to care.

Still, at least it's not as bad as Texas Chainsaw 3D or - shudders - The Next Generation.


7. Wrong Turn 6: Last Resort

wrong turn 6
20th Century Fox

The franchise that kept on going far longer than anyone ever expected it could - and long after they'd killed off all of the original inbred family of Wrong Turn, 2 and 3. Prequel territory saw the brothers emerge from an old abandoned lunatic asylum in Wrong Turn 4, while the fifth instalment added a horrible Doug Bradley (Pinhead, but not playing Pinhead) to the mix.

Last Resort is the least memorable of the films to date, taking place at an old hotel out in the middle of nowhere, where a young man comes to claim his mysterious inheritance. Tedious, over-sexed nonsense (even by the franchise's standards), it bears little relation to any of the other films to date (no more Doug Bradley) and remains (wait for it) a last resort for those seeking their backwoods horror fix.


6. The Thing

The Thing 2011
Universal Pictures

Many things about The Thing which make it such a classic: John Carpenter's masterful direction, Kurt Russell's beard, Keith David, the fantastic use of special effects. The sense of paranoia and claustrophobia. Barely any of this is represented in 2011's half remake, half prequel, which replicates the setting, alien and visuals, but forgets any of the personality.

The quasi-remake element sees the same story rehashed again, a persistent lack of invention leaving it unable to make its own mark - like individual itty-bitty snowflakes, recently fallen amidst an Arctic tundra. Worst of all, it utterly wastes stars Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Joel Edgerton (see 10 Cloverfield Lane and The Gift for their horror credentials), who could have totally killed in a decent prequel or remake of The Thing. Stick with the videogame instead.


5. Annabelle

Annabelle Movie Poster
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Conjuring and its sequel are two of the better mainstream horror films made in this last decade. Much less good: The Conjuring's spin-off prequel, Annabelle, based on the first film's infamous haunted doll.

Like Annabelle herself, the film is inert and lacking personality, suffering from James Wan's absence from the director's chair. Like many haunted doll movies (see also: much of The Boy), it seems to content to let its porcelain star's terrifying visage do all of the heavy lifting, with little characterisation afforded to anyone else.

No sign of Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson's ghost-hunting Warrens either, depriving this prequel of the best thing (Wan aside) about the franchise. Let's hope The Conjuring 2's Nun spin-off fares a little better.....


4. Exorcist: The Beginning

Exorcist The Beginning
Warner Bros. Pictures

No, not that one - the prequel to the exorcist which was borne out of fear that the other prequel to the exorcist (literally called Dominion: Prequel to the Exorcist) wasn't much cop, and had Renny Harlin make his own version instead. Which, in turn, wasn't much cop, and wound up being worse than the first version.

The Beginning sees Father Merrin travelling East Africa, where he encounters demon Pazuzu - who will later come to possess Regan in The Exorcist. In spite of the best efforts of Stellan Skarsgard, The Beginning is dull studio fare, demistifying Merrin, Pazuzu and so much of what worked in The Exorcist in the process. Dominion is just a little bit better, but neither should have been made in the first place.


3. Dracula Untold

Dracula Untold
Universal Pictures

Vlad Dracula. Interesting guy, right? Even before he became an immortal vampire and the original horror icon, Vlad Tepes was a terrifying prospect, nailing hats to heads and impaling so many of his enemies that he literally became known as Vlad the Impaler. Even without the bloodsucking, a pre-Dracula Dracula story is ripe for horror pickings.

Except in Dracula Untold, where it isn't. Taking its inspiration from Bram Stoker's Dracula (the movie, not Bram Stoker's actual Dracula) as a Gothic romance, it repositions Vlad as a tragic hero, turning vampire to save his people... from Dominic Cooper (a less imposing screen villain has never been found). A transparent attempt to jump-start a Universal Monsters universe, it's pretty, vapid nonsense, awash with an abundance of CGI and boring characters, establishing Luke Evans as one of the two most boring Draculas in screen history (hello, Blade: Trinity!)

In this case, it would have been better left untold.


2. Halloween

halloween 2007
MGM

Part remake, part prequel, but mostly the latter. Establishing his cult horror credentials with the brutal, cruel and sweary Hillbilly 'em up The Devil's Rejects (preceded by the more 'fun' House of 1000 Corpses), Rob Zombie stepped up to the big leagues with his remake of slasher classic Halloween. What, we wondered, would Rob Zombie do with Halloween and Michael Myers?

As it turned out, he simply copied and pastied his already established sensibilities onto the existing template, turning Halloween into a brutal, cruel and sweary Hillbilly 'em up. Gone is Michael Myers The Shape, Lovecraftian force of nature and terroriser of babysitters - replaced with grunting, furious Michael Myers The Bulk, tearing Ken Foree to bits and stealing his overalls. Michael isn't the only character butchered by his Zombification either, turning Laurie Strode into an unmemorable nobody, and Loomis an unlikeable dullard via a phoned in performance from a clearly bored Malcolm McDowell.

This Halloween, you'll wish he'd never bothered coming home.


1. Hannibal Rising

Hannibal Rising
MGM

Finally, the prequel nobody wanted... not even the man who wrote it.

Forced into writing a Hannibal Lecter prequel by producer Dino De Laurentis ("if you don't do [the prequel], I will do it with somebody else"), so Thomas Harris hashed out the unfortunate Hannibal Rising, which details the earliest days and upbringing of Hannibal the cannibal. Making the best of a bad lot, the story has Hannibal hunting the war criminals who ate his sister, learning to become a samurai (really) and himself developing a taste for human flesh...

By far and away the worst of the Hannibal Lecter movies, this prequel is saddled with an atrocious Hannibal (model Gaspard Ulliel), a bad Rhys Ifans performance, an even worse script ("you're always hurting the bullies") and demistifies the horror icon to the point where we never want to see his face again.

Thankfully, eventually we would, in Bryan Fuller's Hannibal, which not only managed to make its prequel status work but also (the bare, bare bones of) Hannibal Rising. Delectable.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

A film critic and professional writer of over ten years, Joel Harley has a deep and abiding love of all things horror, Batman and Nicolas Cage. He can be found writing online and in print, all over the Internet and in especially good bookstores.