10 Worst Oscar Winning Actors Ever

The Academy screwed up.

Jean Dujardin The Players
Mars Films

When it comes to the movie awards circus, one thing's for sure: the Oscars can't please everyone. By the sheer nature of the competition, the Academy Awards are inherently divisive, and when the movie or performance you've been passionately cheerleading doesn't win, it's easy to start attacking the actual winner as not worthy of a gold statue.

But what about those rare instances where a genuinely bad, mediocre or utterly forgettable "talent" manages to scoop an acting Oscar, resulting in an enduring embarrassment for the Academy?

Whether these 10 actors triumphed through dubious means or just stopped caring once they won the award, not a single one of them has delivered the career full of home-runs you'd both hope for and expect from someone deemed "Oscar-worthy".

It's easy to lose perspective in the insanity of the Oscar race, but with the benefit of hindsight, it's tough to imagine what Oscar voters were thinking when they gave these utterly unremarkable talents the world's most prestigious acting honour...


10. Gwyneth Paltrow

Actress Gwyneth Paltrow attends the premiere of the feature film
Dan Steinberg/AP

1999's Academy Awards was full of shock victories, and if Shakespeare in Love beating Saving Private Ryan for Best Picture wasn't bad enough, the film's star Gwyneth Paltrow also scooped a Best Actress Oscar over her far more deserving rival, Cate Blanchett for Elizabeth.

Whether you feel Paltrow was deserving or not, the point here is that she's done virtually nothing of merit either side of her Oscar win, and is basically just remembered for being Chris Martin's ex in real life, Tony Stark's "fiancee" on the big screen, naming her daughter Apple and being a mildly controversial celebrity blogger.

It's widely accepted that Paltrow only won the Oscar thanks to Harvey Weinstein's extremely aggressive awards campaign for the movie, and nothing else in her filmography has suggested her acting talents were remotely worthy of a gold statue. Honestly, when was the last time you got excited about a Gwyneth Paltrow movie?


9. Cuba Gooding Jr.

Cuba Gooding Jr Machete Kills
Open Road Films

Cuba Gooding Jr. is a textbook example of an actor who won a (semi-dubious) Oscar and almost immediately torpedoed his own career with terrible choices.

Following promising early performances in Boyz n the Hood and A Few Good Men, Gooding scooped a Best Supporting Actor for his memorable turn in 1996's Jerry Maguire, after which he instantly stopped caring and took whatever paycheck role was offered his way. "Show me the money", indeed.

Soporific performances in the likes of Pearl Harbour, Rat Race, Snow Dogs, Boat Trip, Daddy Day Camp and Machete Kills were basically enough to have everyone question whether Gooding was even a good actor in the first place.

His effervescent, Oscar-winning performance beat out the far more deserving Edward Norton (Primal Fear) and William H. Macy (Fargo), both of whom are still Oscar-less over 20 years later.

Though it seemed like Gooding's career would enjoy a resurgence in 2016 when he played O.J. Simpson in the Emmy-winning show The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story, Gooding's performance received mixed reviews, and now he's back to doing little of anything.

It was a waste of an Oscar, basically.


8. Renée Zellweger

FILE - In this Oct. 20, 2014 file photo, actress Renee Zellweger arrives at ELLE's 21st annual Women In Hollywood Awards in Los Angeles. Zellweger says she looks different because shes living a different, happy, more fulfilling life. The 45-year-old Oscar
Jordan Strauss/AP

The Academy clearly fell head-over-heels for Renée Zellweger in the early 2000s, giving her three consecutive Oscar nominations from 2002 to 2004, before finally awarding her a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her work in 2003's Cold Mountain.

While Zellweger was arguably the most amusing part of the bloated, dreary historical drama, her cartoonish performance shouldn't have been a serious Oscar contender with such impressive competition as Holly Hunter (Thirteen), Marcia Gay Harden (Mystic River), Patricia Clarkson (Piece of April) and Shohreh Aghdashloo (House of Sand and Fog). Literally anyone else in the category would've made more sense.

But again, the crusty old Oscar voters really, really liked her, hence why they previously nominated her for her fun but hardly awards-worthy performances in Bridget Jones's Diary and Chicago.

Zellweger only acts occasionally these days, but there's nothing in her filmography that suggests she's anything more than a passable performer who somehow managed to charm her way to an Academy Award once. Totally baffling.


7. Jon Voight

Jon Voight Transformers
Paramount

Jon Voight is a once-talented actor who stopped giving a damn a long, long time ago, and his general acting rep has taken a major hit as a result.

After delivering memorable early performances in the likes of Midnight Cowboy and Deliverance, Voight scooped a Best Actor Oscar for his turn in 1978 war drama Coming Home.

Even ignoring the fact he blatantly robbed Robert De Niro of a win for The Deer Hunter, Voight's performance was merely decent in a schmaltzy, over-sentimental movie. From the 80s onward, Voight basically pimped himself out for a paycheck for the most part, starring in card-carrying schlock, TV movies and, eventually, four Baby Geniuses movies. Oof.

Though he still picks up an occasional awards nomination largely for appealing to the old-guard of Hollywood - he was admittedly decent in Ali and fine in TV show Ray Donovan - he's a prime instance of an actor who hasn't really cared about his craft for literally decades.

By slumming his way through so many awful films over the years, he's fatally diluted his brand to the point that his appearance in a movie is a sign of caution rather than a ringing endorsement.


6. Jennifer Hudson

Jennifer Hudson arrives at the Oscars on Sunday, Feb. 22, 2015, at the Dolby Theatre in Los Angeles. (Photo by Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP)
Jordan Strauss/AP

Jennifer Hudson's 2007 Best Supporting Actress win for her performance in Dreamgirls remains one of the most puzzling Oscar wins in recent memory, not because it was a bad performance, but because it wasn't really acting.

Almost the entirety of Hudson's performance in the movie revolves around her singing ability, and little is actually asked of her when it comes to a dramatic rendition. Even so, the Academy misguidedly gave her the gong over the far more worthy Cate Blanchett (Notes on a Scandal), Abigail Breslin (Little Miss Sunshine) and Rinko Kikuchi (Babel).

While it would've been satisfying to see Hudson prove her Oscar worth in her post-Dreamgirls career, it sadly never came to fruition, instead appearing in movies both terrible (Sex and the City 2, Winnie Mandela) and totally forgettable (Sandy Wexler). She's a great singer, but as an actress, she's utterly unambitious and unremarkable.


5. Roberto Benigni

Pinocchio Roberto Benigni
Miramax Films

Roberto Benigni is the quintessential lightning-in-a-bottle actor, who enjoyed a fleeting period of success in an otherwise anodyne career.

The Italian actor came to prominence with his 1997 smash hit dramedy Life is Beautiful, which scooped the Best Foreign Language Film Oscar and won Benigni a wildly unexpected Best Actor award, beating out an incredible slate of rivals: Edward Norton (American History X), Ian McKellen (Gods and Monsters), Nick Nolte (Affliction) and Tom Hanks (Saving Private Ryan).

Benigni gave a not-bad performance as a father trying to protect his son from the horrors of the Holocaust in an overly sentimental film that hasn't aged well. Even as decidedly average as his work is, it's easily the best of his career.

Either side he's done very little of merit, culminating in his spectacularly misguided 2002 live-action Pinocchio movie (pictured above), which somewhat poetically won him a Worst Actor Razzie. Ouch.

Since Pinocchio, Benigni's barely done anything at all, last appearing in Woody Allen's 2012 movie that nobody remembers, To Rome with Love. He got his Oscar and the fleeting love of millions, but in the two decades since he's only reinforced how thoroughly undeserving of the award he was.


4. Cher

Cher Burlesque
Screen Gems

Cher's status as a force of nature is undeniable: by the early 1970s she was a successful singer and had a hit TV show, but desperately wanted for more: namely an Oscar.

After being nominated for her surprisingly solid performance in 1983's Silkwood, the iconic singer won the Best Actress Oscar outright for 1987's Moonstruck, and as history remembers it, she stopped trying almost immediately afterwards.

These roles, while entertaining, didn't exactly dissuade that Cher's range was fairly limited, and it didn't help that she developed chronic fatigue syndrome in the early 1990s, which severely limited her ability to capitalise on her awards success.

In order to make cash, Cher starred in a series of embarrassing, widely-parodied infomercials, and so mere years after she won the Oscar, Hollywood and general audiences both stopped taking her seriously as an actress.

Her acting work became increasingly sporadic, reaching its nadir with atrocious appearances in 2010's Burlesque - which scored her a Worst Supporting Actress Razzie nomination - and voicing "Janet the Lioness" in the horrid 2011 Kevin James vehicle Zookeeper.

With her scant acting range and questionable Oscar win - was she really better than Glenn Close (Fatal Attraction) and Sally Kirkland (Anna)? - Cher peaked quickly and has failed to back it up in the three decades since. After all, it's not likely her upcoming appearance in Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again will persuade otherwise...


3. Jean Dujardin

The Artist Jean Dujardin
Warner Bros.

Much like Roberto Benigni, Jean Dujardin's awards success was a pure flash-in-the-pan moment, a fleeting beat of blinding glory in an otherwise totally mediocre career.

Dujardin won a Best Actor Oscar for 2011's The Artist, perhaps the go-to instance of the Academy tripping over themselves to laud a film only for it to drop out of the cultural conversation almost immediately. Dujardin's performance was light and enjoyable, but he was ultimately upstaged by a dog, and when you take the silent movie homage away, is there really much nuance to his work?

Looking back, Dujardin beating out Brad Pitt (Moneyball), George Clooney (The Descendants) and especially Gary Oldman (Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy) seems absolutely ridiculous.

As for the rest of Dujardin's career? He's best known for the moderately entertaining OSS 117 spy comedy movies, but his post-Oscar work has largely been forgettable appearances in Hollywood fare (The Wolf of Wall Street, The Monuments Men) and foreign films alike.

Looking back, it's pretty crazy that anyone, least of all an entire voting body, felt he was worthy of a nomination, let alone a win.


2. Mira Sorvino

Mira Sorvino Mimic
Miramax

Just a few years into her career, Mira Sorvino scooped a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her frothily entertaining performance in Woody Allen's 1995 film Mighty Aphrodite...and has done almost nothing of mention ever since.

Sure, a lot of people have a soft spot for both Romy and Michele's High School Reunion and Guillermo del Toro's Mimic, but in the two decades since, she's starred in just three mildly-praised movies, and literally more than 20 critical duds.

Sorvino certainly keeps herself busy, with seven projects currently in some stage of production, but her films tend to go straight-to-VOD almost exclusively these days, and there's little indication she's doing anything but turning up for a paycheck.

Her career began so promisingly, but her failure to prove herself capable of carrying a major movie presumably discouraged her from, well, actually trying.


1. Mary Pickford

Mary Pickford Poor Little Rich Girl
Artcraft Pictures Corporation

And finally, we conclude with a classic pick and an undeniably pivotal figure in the history of cinema itself. Mary Pickford not only appeared in a staggering 248 projects between 1909 and 1933 - though the majority of them were shorts - but co-created movie studio United Artists, and was one of the founders of the Academy itself.

Her work as a younger actress was much-loved by audiences, but she struggled to transition into being taken seriously in fully-fledged adult roles. With the end of the silent era, Pickford boldly presented herself as a front-line star of talking pictures, resulting in her winning the second-ever Best Actress Oscar for her performance in 1929 drama Coquette.

It's since been widely accepted that Pickford essentially schemed her way to an Oscar win, using her Academy standing to her advantage and also inviting voters for tea at her luxurious mansion.

The performance itself doesn't stand up to modern scrutiny at all - as is true of most early talkie acting, in fairness - with Pickford's excessive overacting proving more embarrassing than entertaining. Four years later, Pickford decided to retire from acting completely at the mere age of 41, aware that she wouldn't be able to succeed in the more demanding sound era.

Though Pickford is an undeniable Hollywood icon, she never managed to demonstrate the range of a truly good actress, and her contributions to the business side of the industry will always be far more impressive.

What do you make of these questionable Oscar-winning actors? Got any of your own picks? Shout them out in the comments!


In this post: 
oscars
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.