10 Worst PG-13 Horror Films Since 2000

The Diet Coke of horror.

Is it too much to hope for in a multiplex horror movie that it'll deal with adult themes, have a few memorable lines and won't be shot like a music video? Yes, it is, so the most you can ever hope for is a visceral thrill. If nothing else, the so-called €œtorture porn€ fad delivered that, but far more profitable (and hence attractive to studios) was the trend for PG-13 horror pictures. When The Sixth Sense made $672 million worldwide, making it one of the highest grossing horror films of all time, studios interpreted its success as a sign that non-restrictive ratings were key in developing the next blockbuster. They were seemingly proved correct when, a few years later, Gore Verbinski€™s remake of The Ring made nearly $250 million worldwide. As studios rushed to find material that wouldn€™t tax the average adolescent overmuch, the trend initiated by these films quickly became monotonous, if not downright cynical. If Rupert Wainwright€™s remake of The Fog proved anything, it was that the PG-13 crowd would pay to see anything, even if it was slapped together in 11 months. €œTorture porn€ movies such as Saw were eventually overtaken by the Paranormal Activity and Insidious franchises at the box office, but PG-13 horror is still with us, rearing its ugly head with the recent Poltergeist remake and the forthcoming Rings movie. For 10 reasons why PG-13 horror doesn€™t work, read on.

10. Darkness Falls

This is the movie that Rolling Stone magazine dismissed in 14 words: €œDo you really need me to tell you how scary this horror show isn€™t?€ It€™s a riff on A Nightmare On Elm Street, with a suspected child killer returning from the grave to wreak vengeance on the inhabitants of the eponymous town, but the movie€™s too bland to provide much in the way of entertainment. All the adult characters, particularly the cops, act like frightened children, so it€™s up to The Hunky Guy and The Blonde Hottie to save the day which €“ spoiler alert €“ they do, but the final scene suggests the monster isn€™t dead. All the usual clichés are present and correct: when people start to disappear, suspicion falls on the hero. The power goes out during a storm. Characters die in reversing billing order, with the dumb rednecks getting their just desserts first. The director later made the American classics The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

9. The Village

In order to maintain the illusion that they€™re living in the Nineteenth Century, which they do for oh some reason, William Hurt, Sigourney Weaver and Brendan Gleeson dress up as €œthose we don€™t speak of€ in order to keep the children from venturing into €œthe towns€ (ie the normal world). But when Joaquin Phoenix is stabbed by village irregular Adrien Brody, someone needs to make the journey to fetch medical supplies so€ they send the blind girl. Cue scenes of Bryce Dallas Howard wandering through the woods with her white stick while Hurt, Weaver and Gleeson continue speaking in the language of the time, even as Phoenix bleeds to death. After being nominated for numerous awards, including two Oscars, The Village exposed Shyamalan as a charlatan, but the lesson went unheeded and he received the money to make Lady In The Water, The Happening, The Last Airbender etc. Like 9/11, these pictures may have come as a shock, but they were no surprise.

8. Prom Night

Here we go again: more teenagers, another crazed killer, plus the usual quota of dark corridors, locked doors, idiot victims etc. If you haven€™t seen the lame and forgettable 1980 original, it paired Jamie Lee Curtis with €“ why not? €“ Leslie Nielsen, so the people behind this remake sensibly ignore it and start over. Unfortunately, those people are Nelson McCormick and JS Cardone, the €˜creative€™ duo behind the Stepfather redux, so it€™s still a lame and forgettable effort. All you need to know about the plot is that is that Donna (Brittany Snow) is preparing for her senior prom when teacher-turned-wacko Ramsey, who attacked her three years earlier, escapes from the booby hatch and comes after her pursued by some inept cops. So it€™s 88 minutes of and-then-she-woke-up false scares and bimbos wandering off by themselves, plus there€™s a pure-evil villain who changes his appearance by shaving and wearing a baseball cap, which of course allows him to evade capture until the climax.

7. Soul Survivors

Let no one say that Hollywood left a stone unturned in its hurry to replicate the success of Scream, even hiring a director who€™d enjoyed a minor hit with The Kindred (1987), but hadn€™t made a movie since. Stephen Carpenter must€™ve gotten the job on Friday, written the script over the weekend and started shooting on Monday because in story terms, Soul Survivors is as smoothly conceived as Plan 9 From Outer Space. Soul Survivors helps itself to bits of other, better films, throws in a gratuitous shower scene, then spends the rest of its length ticking off the clichés. You€™d call it slung together, if that wasn€™t an insult to slung-together movies. So incredibly disjointed that its opening sequence appears to have nothing to do with the rest of the film, Survivors at least starts as it means to go on, with a masked maniac pursuing a starlet to the strains of John €œno relation€ Carpenter knock-off music. Over the course of 85 painful minutes, we€™ll be treated to more Halloween €˜homages€™, plus a recreation of Cat People€™s chase scene, and the most shameless theft of all €“ the entire plot of Carnival Of Souls, with all the good stuff removed.

6. Swimfan

Swimfan is slickly-made and technically well-crafted, but it€™s all in the service of a Bugsy Malone version of Fatal Attraction, whose target audience was born the year Adrian Lynne€™s movie came out. In keeping with the original, The Blonde is cunning-but-psychotic, The Brunette is wholesome-but-bland and The Hunky Guy gets caught up in a number of increasingly silly situations. You see, Madison (Erika Christensen) is a teenage psycho who wants revenge on Ben (Jesse Bradford) for being dumped, so she gives him steroids without his knowledge. When Ben€™s urine tests positive for drugs, he€™s thrown off the school swimming team forever. It used to be a truism of Bad Movies that only beautiful people had great sex, but Swimfan goes one better: they also live in the finest neighbourhoods, attend the best schools and only listen to bland and inoffensive pop songs. If you€™re looking for the spawn of Fatal Attraction and Friends, this is it.

5. Pulse

When there€™s no more room in the afterlife, murderous ghosts will stalk college students on the internet. That was the general idea behind Kiyoshi Kurosawa€™s 2001 film, so this American remake distils it into a bunch of false scares: characters sneak up on each other, the heroine sees things that aren€™t there etc. Set in Ohio but shot in Romania, which does a terrific job of resembling a crumbling former Soviet Bloc country, Pulse seems to be about bald monsters that emerge from computers to suck the will to live from their victims, causing them to turn to ash. This leads to the downfall of mankind. The End. In his DVD commentary, director Jim Sonzero seems to admit that he didn€™t quite €œget€ Kurosawa€™s film. €œThere really wasn€™t much of a plot,€ he says. €œIt was just kind of an idea. And about loneliness. And about themes. And kind of random.€

4. The Roommate

The Roommate thinks it€™s an ersatz Single White Female, but it€™s really the Beverly Hills 90210 of psycho thrillers €“ there€™s no plot, and no characterization beyond good and evil, so it€™s just 91 minutes about the lives of good-looking people you couldn€™t care less about. They wear the clothes the producers want you to buy, listen to the CD soundtrack and chase the MTV Awards demographic, who nominated Minka Kelly in the Best Scared-As-Sh*t Performance category. Because we€™re talking PG-13, Rebecca (Leighton Meester), the movie€™s ersatz Jennifer Jason Leigh, conducts the kind of bloodless rampage unseen since the days of Poverty Row quickies. When she€™s not subtly suggesting her fragile mental state by stabbing the furniture, Ersatz Jennifer is blackmailing The Creepy Teacher or threatening The Slut which, considering she€™s about as menacing as a Smurf riding a unicycle, proves remarkably successful. In fact, waiting for her to achieve critical mass is such an ordeal that you€™ll be reminded of Terry Southern€™s advice to a writer of limp screenplays: €œWhy don€™t they just get stoned and f**k?€

3. One Missed Call

Let€™s say that you€™re being haunted by a ghost who€™s using cell phones to take revenge on the living, and you receive a call informing you of the date and time of your death. What would you do? According to One Missed Call, you should accept a sleazy producer€™s offer to be exorcised on a reality show. That€™s what Taylor (Ana Claudia Talancon) decides to do, and picture her best friend€™s surprise when she sees the trailer: €œA cell phone rings and Death is one the line! A beautiful co-ed, a ticking clock of ghastly murder€.NEXT on American Miracles!€ However, that€™s nothing compared to the reaction of the fire-and-brimstone exorcist, who can€™t figure out why the exploding lights, choking starlet and sudden appearance of the Antichrist weren€™t in the script. This is the American remake of a Japanese rip-off of The Ring, a movie about a ghost that used a videocassette to attack people, so it€™s not to be confused with Dark Water, the American remake of a Japanese movie about a ghost that uses water to attack people. Nor should it be confused with the American remake of a Korean movie about a ghost that uses mirrors to attack people (Mirrors) or the American remake of a Thai movie about a ghost that uses photographs to attack people (Shutter). And it€™s completely different from Cello, Wishing Stairs, The Red Shoes or Acacia, where ghosts used Cellos, staircases, shoes and trees to attack people. Also, any similarity to The Wig, a Korean movie about a hairpiece possessed by a ghost, is purely coincidental. Platinum Dunes is producing a remake called Hell Toupee.

2. When A Stranger Calls

Probably gunning for Halloween€™s sophisticated suspense, the makers of this needless reboot turn the killer into a barely seen psycho who€™s a dab hand at finding hiding places and enjoys taunting people more than killing them. It€™s also one of those movies where the cops say, €œThere€™s nothing we can do€ despite the mounting death toll and the screaming damsel in distress backs herself into a corner, shouting, €œWhat do you want?€ Merry tales of psychotic child-killers don€™t lend themselves to PG-13, so the filmmakers do away with all the nastiness from Fred Walton€™s 1979 original as well as 86 of its 97 minutes, which leaves the opening sequence of a babysitter being informed by police that the malicious calls she€™s been receiving have been coming from€.inside the house! Anyway, the filmmakers€™ attempts to stretch an eleven-minute sequence to feature length means that WASC often feels like a one-act play, with a single character on a single set reacting to shadows, strange noises, the sudden arrival of a stranger etc. This is apt because we€™re watching a two-act movie, whose makers forgot to give it a rousing finale. The scene is set, the €˜tension€™ is ratcheted up by false scares, then ten minutes before the credits roll, the killer puts in an appearance, gets captured by police and that€™s all she wrote.

1. The Stepfather

Speaking of tawdry rip-offs, here€™s a new €˜vision€™ of Joseph Ruben€™s 1987 movie, updated to the era of cell phones and America€™s Most Wanted by JS Cardone and Nelson McCormick, the €˜creative€™ duo that also remade Prom Night. If you€™re not familiar with Ruben€™s version, it had Terry O€™Quinn (Lost) in a career-making turn as Gerry Blake, who roamed the country marrying widows before erupting into violence every time his €˜perfect€™ new family failed to live up to his harsh standards. Blake becomes David Harris (Dylan Walsh) in this remake, and like every other adult in the film, he€™s a one-dimensional clown. Pure evil and so indestructible he must be made from liquid metal, David has two facial expressions: a fake smile that somehow fools everybody, and a sour snarl that means Duck And Cover. When we reach the final confrontation €“ which takes place on a rooftop, during a thunderstorm, while Hitchcock knock-off music plays €“ it€™s a reminder of how low-key the original was. Gerry Blake was stabbed and shot and€.died. He didn€™t get up and walk away after being stabbed in the neck, thrown through a wall, tossed off a roof and sent crashing through a greenhouse. He died. He ceased to be. He was bleeding demised. He was an ex-stepfather. Until resurrected for the sequel, anyway.

In this post: 
Eliza-Dushku
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'