10 Worst Scenes In Otherwise Awesome Movies

Even awesome movies occasionally feature downright bad scenes.

There are plenty of lists scattered around the internet outlining the good scenes in otherwise bad movies: think of the Duel of the Fates in Star Wars: Episode I, for instance, to get a good idea as to how a list on that subject might work. Territory less mined, however, is that relating to bad scenes in awesome movies. Movies with dud moments that are still awesome enough to go unaffected by the stigma of said moment. We tend to associate "awesome" movies with a certain degree of flawlessness, of course. Can an awesome movie contain a truly bad, mis-judged or downright awful scene and still remain awesome? The answer is, "absolutely, yes," as documented and therefore proven by the 10 scenes I've collected up here for your consideration, all of which are downright terrible and yet are a essential parts of movies considered to be rather "awesome." So despite the fact that these scenes are - without question - the stuff of the Devil, they're contained with the frames of movies that are so great that we all kind of forget to consider how bad they are. That's to say, we might have overlooked their inherent awfulness because these movies have been certified brilliant on so many occassions, that it's hard for us to process the idea of there being one poor sequence in the midst of it all...

10. Sonny Beats Up Carlo - The Godfather

This is perhaps the least guilty contender on the entire list (so here it is a number 10), purely because it's more of a technical inclusion than a narrative one. Cast your mind back, then, to the scene where Sonny Corleone (James Caan) takes to the street to get revenge on one of the movie's antagonists, Carlo Rizzi, for beating up on his sister. The scene should have been brutal and kind of disturbing - instead, it's the only scene in the movie that provokes accidental laughter. And I don't mean "fake" in the usual way, where you kind of suspend your disbelief because you know that the actors in question aren't really hitting one another. It's really, really fake, to the point where director Francis Ford Coppola was - for some reason - happy to include shots of James Caan a) missing his target by about three inches on several occassions, and b) punching his own hand to create a sound effect. So whereas the rest of The Godfather is real and gritty, this scene feels oddly out of place and badly done... almost to the point of a Saturday Night Live parody.

9. Esteban Vihaio - Kill Bill, Vol. 2

Quentin Tarantino is, generally speaking, a fairly self-indulgent writer - he's not afraid to write a speech that ends up spanning twenty-five pages if he feels like it's justifiable. Most of the time he's right to be indulgent, because what he's written is usually dynamite, and who cares if it goes on for two whole hours, even? But occasionally Tarantino can misjudge his own abilities, and we end up with entire movies like Death Proof, or scenes like the Esteban Vihaio one in Kill Bill, Vol. 2. Kill Bill Vol. 2 is already a fairly talky movie before the Bride (Uma Thurman) winds up talking to a brothel-owner named Esteban (Michael Parks) - who we've never even heard of at this point - at his premises in Mexico. The scene serves a purpose, I suppose: Esteban is the one who reveals where Bill is hiding out, thus allowing the Bride to complete her journey. Still, this is the starting point at which the movie begins to "drag" - in the grand scheme of things, the lengthy chat that the Bride shares with this minor character adds little to the movie. overall. Tarantino ideally needed somebody in the editing room to suggest he cut this part - it's all just a bit too much.

8. Exogorth - Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back

A potentially controversial pick here, but one that has always seemed a little at odds with the rest of this otherwise awesome Star Wars flick: After Han, Leia, Chewbacca and the Droids leave Hoth towards the beginning of the movie (whilst Luke goes off to train with Yoda), they're caught in an astroid field and chased by the Empire in one of the franchise's most exhilarating sequences. Han eventually manages to pilot the Millennium Falcon inside a giant asteroid, where he sets it down and hopes to wait until the Empire moves on. Soon enough, the Falcon is attacked by a some parasites, and the gang realise that they're not inside an asteroid after all - they're inside a giant worm-thing called an Exogorth. Han manages to get the ship out between the creature's noshers just in time, as the worm - which looks like a cheap sock puppet of sorts - rises from its sleeping place and roars in anger. Given the dark and brooding tone edging into the movie at this point, though, the whole scene just feels a bit naff. The puppet looks terrible, and the moment feels oddly far-fetched - even for Star Wars.

7. The End - Monty Python And The Holy Grail

The Holy Grail is, arguably, the greatest thing that Monty Python have ever done - it's silly, dumb fun, but there's a genuine sense of artistry to be admired about the whole thing. For the sum of its parts, as we move from one ridiculous scenario to the next, and though it's ridiculous, we still get caught up in the narrative - we want to see our band of misfits achieve their goal, regardless of whether or not it's a comedy movie. Alas, here's a movie that bow out on an unresolved note. As we head towards the climax, the movie is suddenly invaded by dozens of modern day policeman, who literally come at the camera, demanding it's turned off, whilst arresting King Arthur and his men. Okay, so some might say that this ending is brilliantly wry - a meta-comment on the very nature of movie ending. I say it's just a cop-out. And though it's certainly a very Python-esque ending, it also comes attached to feelings of disappointment. It also seems to have been ripped directly from Mel Brooks' Blazing Saddles, and - as a result - feels a little stale.

6. Samuel Bass - 12 Years A Slave

The wrong kind of cameo has the ability to break the illusion of cinema - think of Tarantino turning up at the end of Django Unchained for a few lines, and it's easy to recall those times when a cameo didn't quite gel. One of the worst (and rather recent) offenders of this trope, then, occurs in slavery epic 12 Years A Slave, where Brad Pitt's carpenter character, Samuel Bass, turns up in the last half an hour to chat with protagonist and captive Soloman Northup (Chiwetel Ejiofor). There are a few problems inherent to this sequence. Firstly, when this character turns up, we're treated to the first and only "stagey" scene in the movie - one that feels more like a lecture than a natural progression, as Bass discusses the moral issues with slavery with Michael Fassbender's brutal plantation owner. Secondly, because Brad Pitt is in the film for less than 10 minutes, his prescene is inherently distracting. It's too late for Brad Pitt to make a "serious cameo" at this point. Thirdly, Pitt's character is the only truly "nice" white character in the movie. The fact that he's played by Brad Pitt... well, it just all seems a little too convenient and awkwardly messianic.

5. Tess Saves The Day - Red River

Red River is undoubtably one of Howard Hawks' best and most accomplished westerns, and for the length of its running time, this dark and broody story of a cattle drive - and the rivalry between the two men tasked with the job - is cinema at its best. The men are John Wayne and Montgomery Clift, a father and his adopted son, whose relationship begins to break down over the course of their long and arduous journey. At the climax of the movie, we know that one of these two men will have to die: it's been coming the whole time, a storm brewing on the horizon. And then the only one and only bad scene in the whole movie suddenly rolls itself out: just at the point at which these two battered souls look to go up against one another, Tess, an unnecessarily female character introduced after the movie's halfway point, breaks the two men up, tells them off, to which they all end up laughing as the credits roll. And yet Tess hasn't earned the right to play such an important part. The scene stinks of studio compromise, weak when compared to the the dark and rightful ending inherent to the story on which Red River was based. What a shame.

4. Kowalski Returns - Gravity

Another potentially controversial pick here, but here me out: Gravity tells the story of a seemingly routine space mission that goes horribly wrong when the debris from a broken satellite ends up causing major issues for scientist Dr. Ryan Stone (Sandra Bullock) and astronaut Matt Kowalski (George Clooney). After Kowalski is forced to sacrifice himself to save Stone, she goes on a one woman mission to return to Earth in one piece without succumbing to the pitfalls of space. For most of the movie, it's left to Bullock to keep our attention - a job she does remarkably well, given that there's nobody else in the movie apart from Clooney. Stone's solo role makes for the perfect feeling of isolation. For some reason, though, writer/director Alfonso Cuaron opts to include a "dream sequence" where Kowalski returns to Stone to impart some useful advise, but it goes against the lone ranger, survival aspect of the movie - why couldn't Stone have figured out what to do with George Clooney coming back into the picture? The atmosphere was far more tense with Stone as the only character, and his return sort of breaks down the mood that's been frantically building to this point. It feels unnecessary, and even lessens Stone as a character.

3. "Cheer Up, Charlie" - Willy Wonka & The Chocolate Factory

Hands in the air: who skipped this scene as a kid? If you watched Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory as a wee nipper, then your hand is almost certainly in the air right now. Although Roald Dahl wasn't a big fan of the 1971 adaptation of his famous children's book, I think the rest of us can agree that the movie is a great telling - funny, dark, weird and a testament to the imagination (just like the book). Still, the scene where Charlie's mother decides to sing... no thanks. I'm talking, of course, about "Cheer Up, Charlie," that notoriously dull and uneventful song that rears its ugly head at the beginning of the movie, forcing children everywhere to grab for the remote so they can fast forward to the Oompa-Loompas. Whereas there are other, questionable scenes in Willy Wonka (let's not forget the terrifying boat ride into hell), this one is clearly a bit of filler - and it's naff. "Cheer up, Charlie," sings Mrs. Bucket, over and over and again, as Charlie walks around for three minutes, staring at the pavement and generally looking sad. Okay, we get it, Mrs. Bucket - any chance you could have just said it instead, though?

2. Dre Head - Harry Potter And The Prisoner Of Azkaban

The general consensus seem to agree that the third Harry Potter movie, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, is the best of the bunch - it was the first movie in the franchise to feel truly "magical" and full of life, and not at all like a bland and sentimental cut and paste job from the source material. Still, as great as this third chapter is, there's one scene that cannot be described as anything else other than "totally freakin' annoying." Did somebody say "Dre Head?" Seriously - that's the official name for this character and everything. Dre Head then, was - for lack of a better description - a shrunken head with a Jamaican accent, one which director Alfonso Cuaron decided would make a good addition to this movie. Dre Head hangs in the window of the Knight Bus when Harry boards it at the beginning, spouting catchphrases like: "Mind your head!" There's no point to this character and he serves no purpose - I've never met anybody who didn't recall the Dre Head scene without shaking their head in disgust. It really leaves a sour taste in the mouth.

1. The Wedding Brawl - The Searchers

Another western top of the list, this time courtesy of the great John Ford, and his 1956 masterpiece The Searchers. The appeal of The Searchers goes hand in hand with its dark and enigmatic tone, of course - as John Wayne's mysterious veteran Ethan Edwards rides out to "rescue" his niece from the Native Indians who captured her, we spend the sum of the movie pondering his real intentions. As a result of its dense and subtle screenplay, The Searchers stands as one of the most poured over movies of all-time - and it's nearly perfect. Nearly. Fact is, dark and ominous as this western is, there's one scene that is simply awful in its broad, "comedy" intentions - so much so, in fact, that it's genuinely bizarre as to why Ford included such hi-jinks in his movie, which - up to this point - was tonally masterful. The scene in question concerns Martin, Edwards' nephew, who challenges the groom of a girl he loves at her wedding party to a brawl outside. The scene feels like something plucked right out of a Looney Toons cartoon; like something Chaplin left on the cutting room floor. It's ridiculous and a bit cringeworthy to watch, given the carefully maintained tension and paranoia that has brought us to this point. And yet, there the scene is, as unmistakable part of one of all time greatest movies. Big sigh. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.