10 Worst Sci-Fi Movie Prequels

Who asked for this?

The Thing Prequel
Universal Pictures

If movie sequels are the lifeblood that keep the wheels of Hollywood turning, prequels are often what happens when studios run out of other good ideas.

Now, that isn't to rubbish all prequels by any means, because in the sci-fi genre alone the likes of Star Trek '09, X-Men: First Class, and Rise of the Planet of the Apes have certainly proven the potential for greatness.

But more often than not, prequels end up feeling less-than compared to what came before, typically just rehashing what worked the first time for a new generation or demystifying elements of the mythology which never actually needed explaining.

Then there are these 10 sci-fi movie prequels, all of which did a sure disservice to their respective IP, whether actively dirtying the established lore, failing to deliver what audiences expected, or just lazily remaking what fans have already paid money for.

Needless to say, if you're planning a marathon of these movie franchises, don't feel obliged to watch these prequels, because there's little in the way of quality filmmaking waiting for you...

10. The Thing (2011)

The Thing 2011 Mary Elizabeth Winstead
Universal Pictures

The fact that this 2011 prequel to John Carpenter's 1982 sci-fi horror classic The Thing literally recycles the same title without variation speaks to just how unimaginative, even pointless a movie it is.

The Thing 2011 attempts to provide a compelling lead-in to the events of its 1982 predecessor, but ultimately feels more like a lazy, warmed-over remake than a prequel with anything new to add to the mythos.

Mary Elizabeth Winstead at least makes for a compelling heroine, but even a basic level of visceral enjoyment is ruined by Universal deciding that the originally shot practical effects had to be painted over in post-production with garish, unconvincing CGI.

As a result, the prequel is not unlike the titular shapeshifter itself - a shambling, grotesque abomination trying to pass itself off as something it isn't.


9. Alien: Covenant

Xenomorph In Alien Covenant
20th Century Fox

As much as Alien fans love to bag on Prometheus, at least Ridley Scott's first prequel to his hit sci-fi franchise brought a totally unique vision to the table, elevated by its visually stunning world-building, Ripley-worthy lead in Elizabeth Shaw (Noomi Rapace), and Michael Fassbender's terrific performance as android David.

Despite its many flaws, Prometheus left fans intrigued to see where Shaw and David's journey would take them, and so disappointment abounded when follow-up Alien: Covenant made an unnecessary dramatic pivot.

Due to the divisive fan response to Prometheus, Scott decided to shift away from the sequel's original intended plotline to make it more of a conventional Alien sequel.

As such, the Engineers were literally nuked out of the franchise, Shaw got an extremely unsatisfying off-screen death, and the Xenomorph was dusted off to try and milk fan nostalgia for every drop it was apparently worth.

But at its core, Alien: Covenant felt like a soulless, half-baked rehash of the better entries into the franchise, while continuing to stock its roster with idiot characters ahead of an hilariously predictable twist ending.

The only real saving grace was Fassbender's marvelous dual performance as opposed androids David and Walter, and the fact that the film's commercial failure ensured the planned sequel never materialised.


8. X-Men Origins: Wolverine

X-men origins wolverine claws
Fox

X-Men Origins: Wolverine was the first of a planned - but mercifully nixed - series of X-Men prequels focused on the genesis of its mainline superheroes.

And though Origins: Wolverine at least benefitted from the charisma avalanche that is Hugh Jackman, it still committed most of the cardinal prequel movie sins, namely over-explaining the title character's beginnings and overloading itself with low-effort fan service.

And "low-effort" really describes the film all around. Even with its stonking $150 million budget the CGI frequently looks terrible, and the film's butchery of fan favourite hero Deadpool (Ryan Reynolds) should've been enough to have everyone involved sent to movie jail.

Basically, watch the first 10 minutes for the undeniably snazzy opening title sequence - which depicts Logan and Sabretooth (Liev Schreiber) fighting through historic wars - and then turn it off. Nothing else good to see here.


7. Cube Zero

Cube Zero
Lionsgate

1997's ingenious indie-horror film Cube clearly should've been a one-and-done affair, given that there's only so much that can be done with the premise of people waking up in a series of trap-filled, interconnected cubes.

If the original film sensibly refused to reveal who was behind the cube, the preposterously-titled 2002 sequel, Cube 2: Hypercube, revealed that it was created by a weapons contractor called Izon. Yawn.

Realising the series had no more forward-momentum, the decision was then made to release a prequel in 2004 with Cube Zero.

Though the film is smart enough to shift the focus to those controlling the cube and tones down the silly CGI-infused hooey of Cube 2, there's really only a short film's worth of quality material here.

Between its atrocious dialogue, stupid characters, and over-reliance on gross-out gore, Cube Zero lacks the creativity to be anything more than a boring, me-too exercise in brand extension.


6. The Cloverfield Paradox

The Cloverfield Paradox
Netflix

Remember when the prospect of a Cloverfield Universe was actually exciting?

Following the success of spin-off 10 Cloverfield Lane, a third film in the series was released, which would at once serve as both a sequel and a prequel to the events of the two prior movies.

The Cloverfield Paradox - which like 10 Cloverfield Lane was an original sci-fi thriller adapted into a Cloverfield movie during production - is set in 2028, and is centered around a cataclysmic particle accelerator accident that opens portals to parallel universes in the past. Basically, the film explains how the monsters in the first two movies showed up.

It's a pretty solid idea, honestly, except that despite some enticing visuals and a fantastic ensemble cast, The Cloverfield Paradox's clunky script has nowhere interesting for its promising elements to go.

Beyond that, anyone expecting it to have more than a cursory, last-minute tie-in to the Cloverfield Universe is sure to be left miffed, making this a film which effectively got slapped with the franchise branding out of sheer desperation.


5. Tremors 4: The Legend Begins

Tremors 4 Michael Gross
Universal Pictures Home Entertainment

Tremors truly is the cockroach of the movie world, given that the modest success of the 1990 original sci-fi horror-comedy would've led few to believe it'd still be clinging to life 30 years later, with the seventh film, Tremors: Shrieker Island, due to release later this year.

And to be fair, the franchise as a whole is hardly awful, largely thanks to the continued involvement of Michael Gross, the only actor to have appeared in all seven films, having been upgraded from an initial supporting player to flat-out lead once Kevin Bacon and Fred Ward bailed.

But not even Gross' presence as gun-totting survivalist Burt Gummer can save franchise prequel Tremors 4: The Legend Begins, because Gross is instead forced to play Gummer's great-grandfather Hiram.

Though the Wild West-set concept had potential enough, Hiram makes for an uninteresting Burt substitute, while the movie's depressingly low action quotient and generally uninspired origin story make it feel wholly undercooked.

As amusing as the idea of a western-themed Tremors movie is, The Legends Begins doesn't even begin to take full advantage.


4. Underworld: Rise Of The Lycans

Underworld: Rise of the Lycans Michael Sheen
Screen Gems

The first two Underworld films were servicably entertaining trash, largely thanks to Kate Beckinsale's red-blooded performance and Len Wiseman's slick, knowing direction.

But rather than stick to what worked, the third film opted to go the prequel route, focusing on the beginnings of the Vampire-Lycan war while relegating Beckinsale's vamp protagonist Selene to a last-minute cameo.

There are two big problems with Rise of the Lycans. First and foremost, few but the most hardcore Underworld fans actually care about how the damn war got started, and secondly, shifting the focus to werewolf character Lucian (Michael Sheen) isn't nearly enough to conceal Beckinsale's absence.

Underworld is a franchise which thrives on giving audiences exactly what they expect, and so it's little surprise that this prequel was the lowest-grossing of the original trilogy.

Better still, when Beckinsale returned for the fourth film, Underworld: Awakening, its box office haul was almost double that of this movie.

And while we're at it, can we retire "Rise of the..." sub-titles already? Over a decade later, Hollywood's still obsessed with it.


3. Dead Space: Downfall

Dead Space: Downfall
Anchor Bay Entertainment

Dead Space: Downfall is a different kind of sci-fi prequel, given that it's actually an animated prelude to a video game rather than a movie. Furthermore, it was released mere days after the original survival horror game Dead Space actually hit stores.

Though the world of Dead Space is certainly rich with lore-expanding possibilities, it has to be said that Downfall is a depressingly generic origin story for the series, further hamstrung by cheap animation, atrocious dialogue, and laughable voice acting.

While loaded with brutal gore and profanity-laden dialogue, it feels too much like a film desperately trying to portray itself as "mature," despite being no better written than your average fanfic.

For a film overspilling with so much violence, it's shocking just how boring it is for the most part, even at just 75 merciful minutes in length. Really, there's no excuse not to just play the first two games again instead.


2. Star Wars: Episode II - Attack Of The Clones

Star Wars Attack Of The Clones Anakin Padme
Lucasfilm

What can be said about the Star Wars prequels that hasn't already?

Though all three movies certainly count themselves among the weaker entries into the series' canon, The Phantom Menace at least introduced some awesome new characters and touted a few thrilling action sequences, while Revenge of the Sith delivered a satisfyingly fan service-laden climax.

But the second movie, Attack of the Clones, is a textbook example of the awkward middle chapter in a movie trilogy, because despite so much happening during the film, it is such a relentlessly dull, stamina-draining endurance trial of a sit.

A huge problem is George Lucas' insistent focus on a guffaw-inducing romance between Anakin (Hayden Christensen) and Padme (Natalie Portman), which with its howlingly hokey dialogue and wooden acting basically resembles a Lifetime movie with an obscene budget.

Combine this with an agonising 142-minute runtime and garish, aged-like-milk visual effects and you have the recipe for the single Star Wars prequel which well and truly sucks.


1. Aliens Vs. Predator: Requiem

Alien vs Predator: Requiem
Fox

Though Paul W.S. Anderson's original Alien vs. Predator movie wasn't particularly worthwhile, it seems positively competent compared to its 2007 follow-up, Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem.

At once a sequel to the prior Predator films and a prequel to the Alien ones, AvP:R somehow manages to be an intensely forgettable film about two of the most beloved movie creatures in history beating the snot out of each other.

Like so many monster movies, there's way too much of a focus on the human element, made worse by some unforgivably awful dialogue - a homophobic gag about a "sausage lover's pizza" was cringe-worthy in 2007, let alone 2020.

Despite boasting an R-rating and offering up a slew of grisly kills - even having a young boy get chest-bursted early on - Requiem is most fatally hobbled by how freaking dark the whole movie is.

Literally, the film is graded to be so visually murky that it's tough to savour most of the violence on offer, ensuring Requiem isn't simply a dumb bore, but actively frustrating to watch.


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Thing
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.