10 Worst Slasher Movie Villains Since 2000

You can scream all you want but it won't make them stop.

Slasher movies have been a Hollywood staple ever since John Carpenter proved you could make one cheaply, without major stars, and still score a runaway hit. Then Friday The 13th showed that audiences were willing to pay for more of the same (done with considerably less sophistication), and a cottage industry was born. By the time of Scream, the movies had become more than a little cartoonish, with machete-wielding hockey aficionados giving way to glorified Scooby Doo villains who gave lengthy speeches outlining their nefarious schemes. In its rush to replicate that film€™s success, Hollywood left no stone unturned and created some of the most obnoxious villains that ever graced the screen. Take Urban Legend, whose bug-eyed female villain decides to avenge her boyfriend€™s death by killing people using urban legends, including The Babysitter and the Tale of the Hook. When her identity is discovered, she€™s shot twice, thrown through a window, sent through a windshield at high speed and drowned, yet still manages to return in a €œsurprise€ ending. €œWith one scene of knockabout looning for every dose of effects-dripping monstrousness,€ wrote Kim Newman, €œthe films provide the MTV generation with something to watch every 3 minutes but are unable to get seriously scary, or even seriously funny.€ Urban Legend seems mild compared to some of Hollywood€™s slasher movie missteps, most of which are so lame they don€™t even merit so-bad-they€™re-good status.

10. Dr Burke (Mark Rolston) - Asylum

While the lights flicker, a group of students, eager to learn why their campus has a high mortality rate, listen to the story of Dr Burke. You see, their dorm was previously a mental institution (of course) where schizophrenic kids were cured by an icepick through the eyeball, but when the doc€™s methods were for some reason discredited, he had a nervous breakdown, began murdering his patients and ultimately got his just desserts. However, the doc still roams the corridors as one of those sub-Freddy Krueger boogeymen whose abilities don€™t need to be explained. Somehow able to lure his victims into a dream world populated by their personal demons, Burke kills them one by one in accordance with their troubled pasts: an abused girl is decapitated by her psychotic ex, the fat kid has his tongue torn out, and so on. Burke must be a huge Krueger fan because he has Ol€™ Pizzaface€™s act down cold, from his ability to appear at random to his predilection for killing whiny teenagers in the most over the top fashion possible. He€™s even outsmarted by the Final Girl, who dispatches him with the zinger, €œGive me your suffering, motherf**ker!€

9. Vincent & Bo (Brian Van Holt)

Vincent and Bo are evil twins who, for reasons hard to discern, have either taken over or created a town named Ambrose, where all the residents are wax dummies. The main attraction here is the House Of Wax, where €“ you guessed it €“ the walls, floors and ceilings are made of wax. The town baits teenagers stupid enough not to turn and run when they realize that Bo€™s home is filled with creepy wax masks and foetus-in-formaldehyde jars, and by the time the penny drops, it€™s too late. They€™ve already been captured and are being shaved in preparation for being turned into a wax figure by Vincent, who by the way looks a helluva lot like Tommy Wiseau. The duo are so nonthreatening that they seem to have taken their scheme from a Saturday morning cartoon. They have a windowless lair with secret tunnels, are fooled by the heroine€™s cunning ruse of disguising herself as one of his mannequins and later chase her through a cinema while the movie plays (without entering through one door and exiting from another, sadly).

8. Slater (Christopher Fulford) - D-Tox

Slater is one of those rent-a-psychos who dials 911 and rants about streets red with blood, a world of pandemonium blah blah blah before signing off with, €œThere will be another body found tonight. Thank you for your time.€ When FBI Special Agent Jake Molloy (Sylvester Stallone) enters the picture, Slater devises filmdom€™s most over-elaborate cat and mouse game to mess with him. Knowing that murdering Molloy€™s fiancé will drive him to drink, Slater then books himself into rehab, figuring it€™s only a matter of time before his nemesis follows suit. Sure enough, when Molloy appears, Slater starts killing the other patients one by one, writing €œICU€ under their eyelids to taunt his opponent. Why don€™t they just leave, you ask? Because the rehab facility is an €œisolated as hell€ former military bunker prone to storms that cut off the roads and communications. In choosing the place, Slater clearly had more than a little help from something known as €œscreenwriter€™s contrivance.€

7. Roman Bridger (Scott Foley) - Scream 3

€œI€™ve heard this s**t before!€ Sidney Prescott (Neve Campbell) tells Roman as he explains his diabolical scheme to her. You know what? The audience has to. In every Scream film, the killer is always the person with some personal link to Sidney, whether it€™s her psycho boyfriend or her psycho boyfriend€™s mother. In Scream 3, it makes sense that the villain should be her hitherto unmentioned half-brother, who€™s decided to carve up the supporting cast for oh some reason or other. Roman€™s plans are more elaborate than those of his predecessors, though. Not only was he found dead earlier in the film (Courteney Cox checked his pulse, just to be sure), but he made sure to trap Sidney in a mansion with revolving walls and one-way mirrors. Wonder which episode of Scooby Doo they stole that one from.

6. Andy (Julian Morris) - Sorority Row

Sorta-kinda-but-not-really based on Mark Rosman€™s The House On Sorority Row (1982), this economically-titled revamp follows the I Know What You Did Last Summer template although here it€™s not a road accident but a prank-gone-wrong that leaves someone dead (or are they?), then after disposing of the body, the teenagers are stalked by a hooded killer and yadda yadda yadda. Unlike IKWYDLS, the killer doesn€™t turn out to be the butt of the joke come back for revenge but someone who has no connection to the event. In fact, Andy has what may be the lamest excuse for being a kill crazy psycho ever. The reason he kills people, he tells his girlfriend Cassidy (Briana Evigan), is because he doesn€™t want her associating with them. You see, her clique consists of spoiled rich girls who just want to marry well and spend the rest of their lives worrying about fashion while abusing the help, so he€™s decided to make the world a better place by dressing up, stalking them and killing each one with a tyre iron. Which is a great idea, but if only he€™d put a little more thought into the motivation.

5. Tom (Jensen Ackles) - My Bloody Valentine

Remember Switchblade Romance, that French slasher movie about a girl being stalked by a killer that existed only in her mind? Tom must€™ve overdosed on the film because he does exactly the same thing here, running away from a maniac disguised as a miner who, in a twist that makes no sense whatsoever, is revealed to be him. You see, the killer was thought to be Harry Warden, who murdered 22 of his colleagues a decade earlier before disappearing in an €œaccident.€ When the killings start again, and the culprit wears Harry€™s outfit (boiler suit, gas mask, pick-axe), it seems like Harry€™s back with a vengeance, especially in a sequence where he comes face to face with Tom, who€™s trapped in a supply cupboard. Then it€™s revealed that Tom was face to face with a figment of his imagination and he was killing all those people because he€™s a little loose in his shoes, which frankly is a cheat. Kind of like having Jamie Lee Curtis run away from Michael Myers for an entire movie, then having Donald Pleasance explain she was chasing herself.

4. Adam Carr (David Boreanaz) - Valentine

At the school Valentine€™s Day dance, young Jeremy Melton was humiliated by a group of teenage girls, which proved so stressful that he underwent a complete breakdown, become a delusional psychotic and signed on to appear in this film. 13 years later, the girls have flowered into Denise Richards, Katherine Heigl, Marley Shelton and Jessica Cauffiel, and Jeremy begins stalking them, leaving maggot-infested chocolates signed €œJM.€ So it€™s going to be pretty easy to track this guy down, right? No, because he€™s had plastic surgery to look like that guy from Angel, meaning he€™s able to befriend Shelton and give her some hoo-haw about being a recovering alcoholic. Even when her friends start disappearing or receiving notes that read, €œThe journey of love is an arduous trek, my love grows for you as you bleed from your neck€, she believes him. In fact, there€™s only one sign that Angel and Jeremy Melton are the same guy €“ they both suffer from nosebleeds. So when Shelton and Boreanaz are reunited in the final shot and his nose starts to bleed, the viewer wonders about an earlier scene where his character was drunk off his ass. Could he even hold a knife, or would he stumble around like Scary Movie€™s villain? Think about that. Never see them in the same room, do you?

3. Professor Solomon (Hart Bochner) - Urban Legends: Final Cut

Once upon a time, Professor Solomon was a Film student whose future looked set €“ he was going to become a world-renowned filmmaker who made simple yet thoughtful art films. That didn€™t work out, so he took a teaching job and began fantasizing about the day he€™d murder one of his students and pass their film off as his own. The trouble is, the student in question has an identical twin brother who turns up and starts digging, prompting Solomon to murder everyone with a tenuous connection to the movie. Concealing his identity behind a fencing mask, he starts killing his own students, on his own campus, one after the other, little realizing the finger of blame will point directly at him when there€™s no one left. When Final Girl Amy (Jennifer Morrison) figures out his diabolical plan, Solomon turns into a Scooby villain, tearing off his mask and giving a speech outlining his motives. He€™s apprehended following a chase, then Shaggy runs into a wall, everybody laughs and Scooby says, €œScooby Dooby Doooo!€ etc.

2. The Stranger (Tommy Flanagan) - When A Stranger Calls

Probably gunning for Halloween€™s sophisticated suspense, the makers of this needless reboot turn the killer into a barely seen psycho who€™s a dab hand at finding hiding places and enjoys taunting people more than killing them. It€™s also one of those movies where the cops say, €œThere€™s nothing we can do€ despite the mounting death toll and the screaming damsel in distress backs herself into a corner, shouting, €œWhat do you want?€ Merry tales of psychotic child-killers don€™t lend themselves to PG-13, so the filmmakers do away with all the nastiness from Fred Walton€™s 1979 original as well as 86 of its 97 minutes, which leaves the opening sequence of a babysitter being informed by police that the malicious calls she€™s been receiving have been coming from€.inside the house! Anyway, the filmmakers€™ attempts to stretch an eleven-minute sequence to feature length means that WASC often feels like a one-act play, with a single character on a single set reacting to shadows, strange noises, the sudden arrival of a stranger etc. This is apt because we€™re watching a two-act movie, whose makers forgot to give it a rousing finale. The scene is set, the €˜tension€™ is ratcheted up by false scares, then ten minutes before the credits roll, the killer puts in an appearance, gets captured by police and that€™s all she wrote.

1. David Harris (Dylan Walsh) - The Stepfather

David Harris might be based on Gerry Blake, the character played by Terry O€™Quinn in Joseph Ruben€™s original The Stepfather (1987), but it€™s hard to tell. In this PG-13 reboot, he comes across more like the T-1000 in Terminator 2: Judgment Day €“ pure evil and so indestructible he must be made from liquid metal. When our hero finally confronts David €“ on a rooftop, during a thunderstorm, while Hitchcock knock-off music plays €“ it€™s a reminder of how low-key the original was. Gerry Blake was stabbed and shot and€.died. He didn€™t get up and walk away after being stabbed in the neck, thrown through a wall, tossed off a roof and sent crashing through a greenhouse. He died. He ceased to be. He was bleeding demised. He was an ex-stepfather (until resurrected for the sequel, anyway). Like every other adult in this potboiler, he€™s a one-dimensional clown capable of being outwitted by a teenager. Moreover, David only has two facial expressions - a fake smile that somehow fools everybody, and a sour snarl that means Duck And Cover €“ so it€™s not really surprising that he becomes a supporting character in his own movie.

Contributor

Ian Watson is the author of 'Midnight Movie Madness', a 600+ page guide to "bad" movies from 'Reefer Madness' to 'Poultrygeist: Night of the Chicken Dead.'