10 Would-Be Franchises That Failed At The First Hurdle

The-Lone-Ranger-900-600

There's nothing Hollywood loves more than a successful franchise. Each summer we see more and more monolithic spectacles constructed via committee to appeal to the widest possible audience. Studios endeavour to hit the worldwide audiences' sweet spot in the hope that they will birth a new cash cow and get a license to print money. Often, as with this summer's The Lone Ranger, Hollywood turns to sure bet properties that have already won over audiences' hearts. Though early estimates show The Lone Ranger is going to be Disney's biggest flop since John Carter (it opened to only $10 million on Friday, likely to do well below the estimated $60 million opening weekend). Sometimes, as with the upcoming Pacific Rim, a studio takes a gamble and rolls the dice on a new premise; unfortunately, in both cases, they often roll snake eyes. I present to you a list of ten such misfires, movies that tried to leapt the hurdle of audience apathy but face planted instead: 10 would-be franchises that failed.

10. Street Fighter: The Legend Of Chun-Li

streetfighterlegendofchunli

Hoping to improve on the innumerable mistakes of 1994's video game adapation Street Fighter, Capcom released a new iteration of the Street Fighter franchise, 2009's Street Fighter: The Legend of Chun-Li. Capcom intended Chun-Li to be the first in a series of origin films that filled in the cinematic backstories for characters from the Street Fighter series of video games. Remarkably, Chun-Li failed to clear the very low bar set by the 1994 Street Fighter and instead produced an arguably worse effort. Audiences and critics alike hated Chun-Li's solo outing. The critic response to this so-bad-it's good fiasco landed Chun-Li at number 44 on review aggregator website Rottentomatoes' list of the 100 Worst Reviewed Movies of the 2000s. Making only $8 million at the box office from an estimated budget of $50 million, Chun-Li's performance ensured any further origin tales where quashed.

9. The Golden Compass

In the wake of Harry Potter, film studios everywhere scrambled to adapt the next Young Adult hit that had multiple instalments ready for a big screen treatment. Enter New Line Cinema's 2007 feature The Golden Compass. Adapted from the His Dark Materials trilogy of novels, New Line Cinema announced the project was underway in 2002 but the film struggled to come to fruition due to script and director issues. When the film finally saw the light of day, after racking up a budget that made it one of New Line Cinema's most expensive projects to date, it met with mediocre box office and immense controversy over its perceived anti-Catholic themes. The Catholic League called for a boycott of the film, worrying that the movie would encourage children to read the source material, whose anti-religious message had been toned down for the feature. The Golden Compass' failure proved the final nail in New Line Cinema's coffin and the once venerable studio found itself in dire straights, enough so the production company was forced to merge with Warner Bros.


8. Leonard Part 6

leonard_part_6_1837028i

In 1987 Bill Cosby, dangerously high on his mammoth success, released on of the most reviled films of all-time. A self-indulgent mess scant on laughs and big on tedium, Bill Cosby's 6th instalment in the imaginary Leonard series of spy films failed so badly that the world was spared the horror of Leonard part 7. Despite starring, producing and co-writing the feature, even Cosby wanted to smother his love child in the crib, publicly urging audiences not to waste their time on it and buying the television rights to ensure it never aired on TV. A glorified Coca-Cola commercial, produced by the Coca-Cola division of Columbia pictures, Leonard Part 6 remains a cautionary example that hubris and product placement can't produce a franchise no matter how hard they try.

7. Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins

Remo_Williams__The_Adventure_Begins_wallpapers_11021

The title says it all. Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins adapated a long-running series of books centred around the thrilling exploits of U.S. government operative Remo Williams, a practitioner of "Sinanju", a fictitious martial art that gives those who wield it nearly superhuman abilities. If the character of Remo Williams took off then the U.S. would have its answer to the deathless James Bond franchise. Despite the bold promise of it's title, Remo Williams: The Adventure Begins met with critical and audience indifference and the world still waits for Remo's continuing adventures.

6. The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

The-League-of-Extraordinary-Gentlemen

In 2003 screen icon Sean Connery attempted to lend some credibility to a would-be franchise that proved stillborn: The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Loosely based on an Alan Moore series of comic books, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen resurrected musty characters from the annals of Victorian Literature in the hope that these once popular heroes could recapture their former glory by engaging in superhero shenanigans. The long-awaited Dorian Gray/Tom Sawyer team-up wasn't the smash hit everyone hoped it would be. Even though it fared decently at the box office, the film was critically lambasted and audiences weren't clamouring for a follow-up, which makes the overly-optimistic, sequel-promising final scene sadder and more ironic as the years go by.

5. Masters Of The Universe

Masters-of-the-Universe-1987-Gary-Goddard-1

Once Mattel successfully adapted its Masters of the Universe toyline to the small screen with the iconic 80's cartoon series He-Man and The Masters of the Universe, it didn't take long for the toy company to set its sights on creating a feature film based on the exploits of the heroic strongman in a loincloth, He-Man. Master schlock-makers, Cannon Films, opted to bring the property to the big screen in the hope that a new franchise would be born. Instead of adapting the popular television series, Cannon decided to directly adapt the comic series that accompanied the toyline. The end product befuddled audiences, as many of the series hallmarks, such as He-Man's alter ego Prince Adam, were excluded. Even the iconic catchphrase "by the power of Grayskull" fell by the wayside. Masters of the Universe failed to recoup its budget and the sequel-baiting ending, which showed the nefarious villain Skeletor (played by Frank Langella) surviving his apparent onscreen demise, never delivered on its promise to bring audiences more He-Man starring adventures. Cannon Films, knowing better than anybody outside of Roger Corman how to stretch a buck, recycled the already made sets and costumes for Masters of the Universe 2 for their low budget Jean-Claude Van Damme vehicle Cyborg.

4. Van Helsing

van_helsing_2004_1920x1280_805530

Like League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Van Helsing reached into the literary past in an attempt to jump-start a new franchise. Hugh Jackman starred in this howling awful rehash of Universal Studio's monster movie crossover phase. Critics heaped scorn on the unintentionally hilarious fiasco that, again, like The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, misguidedly ends on the promise of more whacky adventures to come. Even though it grossed $300 million worldwide everyone involved decided to quit while they were ahead.

3. Prince of Persia: The Sands Of Time

2010_prince_of_persia_the_sands_of_time_movie-wide

Megastar producer Jerry Bruckheimer tried to recapture the magic of his Pirates of The Caribbean franchise with his 2010 video game adaptation Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time. Despite the swashbuckling derring-do promised by the CGI-heavy trailers and Jake Gyllenhaal's admittedly impressive abs, North American audiences rejected the would-be mega-franchise. Although it went on to become the highest grossing video game adaptation of all-time worldwide, Bruckheimer and co felt its paltry North American box office (making a little over $90 million against a $200 million budget) didn't warrant a follow-up. Hopefully, Bruckheimer's next mega-franchise, The Lone Ranger, will return Bruckheimer to his winning ways but the early buzz and box office are not very promising.

2. Green Lantern

Green-Lantern-2011-413286

Before they found success with this summer's Man of Steel, Warner Bros tried and failed to match Marvel Studios' string of big screen home runs with 2011's abortive franchise nonstarter Green Lantern. Warner Bros spent $200 million to bring its B-list DC Comics character to the big screen in what they hoped would be the first in a series of stand alone features that would lead into a Justice League picture a la The Avengers. Warner Bros didn't count on audiences' tepid response to the film's heinous CGI and unwillingness to tolerate star Ryan Reynold's mugging performance. The film struggled to break even making only $219 million against its $200 million budget. Warner Bros put all plans for its Justice League franchise on hold until the summer of 2013 when they released Man of Steel.

1. John Carter

John-Carter-HERO2

Few films in recent years have become as synonymous will the term "flop" as Disney's 2012 feature John Carter. Fans of Edgar Rice Burroughs' genre-defining science fiction adventure series John Carter of Mars waited close to a century for the novels to find their way to the big screen. If the blandly titled John Carter could hit the mark then a cavalcade of sequels would follow. Warning signs loomed early for the bloated production that found the would-be franchise starter's budget spiralling disastrously out of control. Once costs reached $250 million, John Carter's chances of producing a sequel-worthy box office became virtually nil. Paul Dergarabedian of Hollywood.com noted that" John Carter€™s bloated budget would have required it to generate worldwide tickets sales of more than $600 million to break even...a height reached by only 63 films in the history of moviemaking." John Carter went on to make just over $280 million at the worldwide box office. Disney intended John Carter to be the first in a trilogy but once the numbers started coming in the studio put their follow-up into permanent limbo. There you have it, 10 franchises that exploded on the launchpad before lift-off. What other franchise nonstarters did we miss? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm YA writer who loves pulp and art house films. I admire films that try to do something interesting.