11 Powerful Movie Deaths Devalued By The Sequels
Well, he did say he'd be back.
Death in film is only as meaningful as the impact it has on the story going forwards. Whether a second act shocker or a drawn-out endgame swansong, it's the void the character's departure leaves that lingers on in the minds of the viewers, however big or small.
And a lot of the time, death of a major character is every bit as weighty as it wants to be - until the sequel rolls around and turns it completely on its head.
Ever been sat in the cinema, speechless that your favourite character has just bit the dust, only to find out months later that they're making a sequel and end up thinking, "well, guess we know where this is heading..."? Annoyingly, this trend seems to be occurring more and more these days.
Sometimes, a character should just be left to rest. Other times, when said character does, indeed, stay dead, they shouldn't then be mentioned every five minutes until you're sick of hearing about them. Whatever the case, their 'role' in the sequels often robs their original exit of some or all of its value, as the following 11 examples show.
11. Jaws - Jaws 2 (1978)
Now, hear me out.
The original Jaws was blown up in spectacular fashion by Martin Brody aboard the Orca, as we all know. It was a definitive end to the great white menace, and neatly closed the book while assuring us that the waters of Amity Island would be sufficiently shark-free thereafter.
So, when Jaws 2 introduced another great white shark, just as deadly and prolific as the first (and hunted by Brody once again, no less), the film's very existence created an unfortunate implication: that the first Jaws was not just a one-off, and that the risk of great white sharks wandering in and snacking on swimmers is practically constant, effectively making Brody's efforts for nothing.
It's a terrifically awful way of belittling the threat that the shark in Steven Spielberg's 1975 original posed. And if that wasn't bad enough, this problem is drawn attention to even further in the two sequels that followed Jaws 2. What a way to ruin a timeless classic.
10. T-800 - Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines (2003)
This entry is a standout for much of the same reasoning as Jaws 2: a character that definitively and unambiguously DIED in the previous film is replaced by something identical in both appearance and intent. How are we not supposed to wonder, "well, what was the point in killing them then?"
Of course, the Terminator series has the excuse of the T-800 models being mass-produced soldiers of Cyberdyne Systems, so obviously more than one Arnie was bound to show up sooner or later. The original Terminator film, released in 1984, introduces the character as an antagonist, and, sure enough, he meets his end in that one, too. But the thought-provoking self-sacrifice of the good T-800 in 1991's Terminator 2: Judgment Day is easily the one that people remember the most.
Naturally, then, any sequels featuring yet another T-800 model would surely take away from this dramatic death scene, right? And lo and behold, that's exactly what happened. Don't even get me started on Terminator Genisys.
9. Letty Ortiz - Fast Five (2011) And Fast & Furious 6 (2013)
The longer the comeback of a presumed-dead character is hinted at, the more of an afterthought it often appears as. "Ooh, this character was popular, let's retcon them back into the series years later!", you can hear the writers saying from their lairs. In this person's case, it was four years and two sequels later that they seemingly rose from the dead.
In the first four instalments of the Fast & Furious series, Letty Ortiz is the girlfriend of Dominic Toretto and one of the franchise's main characters. It came as a great shock in 2009's Fast & Furious when she was revealed to have been killed in a high speed crash offscreen, setting in motion Dom's quest for revenge against the drug lord Arturo Braga.
Admittedly, she's never explicitly seen to have died, but for her survival to be teased in Fast Five's post-credits scene and then full-on confirmed in Fast & Furious 6 (as an amnesiac trained killer, of course) makes the whole of the fourth film seem rather pointless in retrospect.
What really rubs salt in the wound is that Dom seems to have moved on from Letty's death, settling down with police officer Elena Neves. When Letty finally returns to him, he unapologetically drops Elena like a hot brick - which is an extra kicker when a later film reveals her to be pregnant with his child.
8. Dr. Brackish Okun - Independence Day: Resurgence (2016)
Pressed up against the glass of Area 51's operating theatre, the eccentric Dr. Brackish Okun is used as a puppet by the captive alien in the first Independence Day (1996), its telepathic orders being expressed through his vocal cords. After an officer shoots the alien, Okun is not seen or heard from again, making it pretty safe to assume the good doctor is a goner.
That is, until 2016's Independence Day: Resurgence, where the film pulls the old "Oh no he isn't!" pantomime trick yet again. Turns out that Dr. Okun was just left comatose by his encounter with the alien, only to wake exactly 20 years later, just in time for the next big world-threatening invasion.
Okay, yes, it's not quite as convenient as it sounds, as there's actually a reason he and other returning characters are at the heart of this once again. However, something about it still seems tacked on, as if the writers were most concerned about getting actor Brent Spiner back first and figuring out the details later.
As such, what was once quite a chilling moment in the original movie now feels rather lukewarm.
7. Harry Hart/Galahad - Kingsman: The Golden Circle (2017)
Given how little effort 20th Century Fox put in to keep this character's return a secret - what with it all over trailers and posters long before its release - perhaps this entry deserves to be higher up the list. Alternatively, one could even say that announcing it so brazenly kind of devalues its devaluing of the original. But I digress.
Kingsman: The Secret Service sees Eggsy's mentor, Harry Hart aka Galahad, shot right in the eye by Samuel L. Jackson's Richmond Valentine. The pivotal moment forces Eggsy to learn to stand on his own two feet, as well as allowing him to take Hart's place as the new Galahad.
In any other universe, Harry would be D-E-A-D after that point-blank shot. But, as revealed in the sequel, Kingsman: The Golden Circle, the Kingsman agent was rescued moments later by the American Statesman, by means of an experimental serum. The shock reveal (though only a shock to the characters at this point) of an amnesiac, one-eyed Harry being held at the Statesman headquarters is, indeed, a powerful moment in and of itself - but at the same time, a death that is not permanent is barely a death at all.
6. Spock - Star Trek III: The Search For Spock (1984)
Tell me, dear readers: how is one of cinema's most iconic deaths supposed to hold onto its meaning if, before you've even seen it, the very TITLE of the following film tells you that the character isn't actually dead?!
...Well, actually, he is, technically speaking - at least, in body. Learning that Spock transferred his katra (spirit) to Dr. McCoy right before he died, the crew are able to restore his life by reuniting the katra with his body, which, conveniently enough, has been reengineered on the newly created Genesis planet (albeit as a child).
He's an extremely fast-growing child, however, and before long, Spock is back to his correct age. On his home planet, an ancient ritual brings together his soul and body, and, though a tad forgetful at first, the stone-faced Vulcan quickly returns to his old inscrutable self.
It's as if nothing ever happened - and that's precisely the problem. As entertaining as the film is, its entire premise is nothing short of a complete U-turn; for Spock, whose death in The Wrath of Khan now holds little to no value, and for Khan himself, who has technically been robbed of his greatest victory.
5. Gamora - Avengers: Endgame (2019)
Thanos's quest to find the Infinity Stones comes at a terrible price when he is forced to sacrifice his own daughter, Gamora, as a trade for the Soul Stone.
Having been a leading member of the Guardians of the Galaxy, Gamora's death was no small thing in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and, as explained by the stone's keeper, the Red Skull, what is done cannot be undone. Unless there's time travel, of course...which there is.
True, by going back in time in Avengers: Endgame, Gamora's fate is neither undone nor altered in any way. But, in the alternate reality they create, the past version of the green-skinned warrior is still very much alive, and by the end of the film, the rest of the Guardians are determined to track her down when she goes off on her own.
Aside from being from the past and therefore a little behind on things, Gamora is exactly the same person, so, once again, her death basically needn't have happened at all. And, given how permanent the 'soul trade' is supposed to be, finding a way of bringing her back like this really feels like a cop-out.
4. Jack Sparrow - Pirates Of The Caribbean: At World's End (2007)
In most cases, the death of a film franchise's lead character is the telltale sign of that franchise coming to an end. In other cases, the series continues on via spin-offs, or, as the Pirates of the Caribbean saga so nonchalantly demonstrates, undoing the character's death altogether.
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End introduces the concept of Davy Jones' locker, an unseen place at the literal end of the world to which Davy Jones is charged with transporting those lost at sea. This is where Jack ends up, having been devoured by the monstrous kraken at the end of the previous film. Led by another recently deceased character, Captain Barbossa (who could just as easily have made this list), the crew of the Black Pearl travel to the locker to rescue Jack from his fate - which they do - and suddenly, everything is just peachy again!
Bacon-saving mystical plot device or no, it's undeniable that having Captain Jack back in this film (and every subsequent one, it's worth noting), seriously cheapens his supposed departure in the one preceding it. Fair enough, a world with barnacle-faced crab men piloting ships is obviously not too concerned about realism, but why ruin such a good death scene with umpteen more Pirates films after it?
3. General Zod - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)
The death of Kryptonian General Zod at the hands of Superman himself is a true cinematic shock to the system. The Man of Steel's pain is palpable as he is forced to snap his rival's neck, ending the life of one of the only other surviving members of his race.
In true Hollywood fashion, that's not nearly enough of a burden for Kal-El to carry on his shoulders, so what does the sequel do? Not bring Zod back, no, no. More like have Lex Luthor use his corpse to create a genetically engineered Kryptonian-human killing machine.
It's the disrespect here that really makes Zod's 'return' that much worse. Why the writers didn't think to leave him well enough alone as a haunting memory in Superman's otherwise hopeful mind is anyone's guess. Instead, they tarnished not one, but three classic DC characters - Zod, Doomsday and Lex Luthor - for the sake of raising the stakes in a way that could flimsily serve to unite Batman and Superman against a common enemy.
2. Ellen Ripley - Alien Resurrection (1997)
Of all the entries on this list, this example of a devalued movie death is not so much egregious as it is just... sad.
Say what you want about the film itself (I like it, personally), but the death of the series protagonist, Ellen Ripley, in 1992's Alien 3 is easily its most poignant and memorable moment. On the verge of birthing an Alien Queen, Ripley makes the ultimate sacrifice, jumping willingly into a red hot furnace and ending her own life.
That doesn't stop the Weyland-Yutani corporation, however, and, in order to obtain this queen's foetus, they make several clones of Ripley. Seven hideously unsuccessful attempts later, Ripley 8 is born, identical outwardly to the real Ellen Ripley but possessing alien qualities too, such as corrosive blood.
On one hand, the cloning of Ripley really shows the brutality and sociopathy of Weyland-Yutani, and the lengths to which they are prepared to go to get what they want. But on the other hand, in seeing the mashed-up, homuncular failed clones begging for death, one has to wonder why Ripley 8 isn't doing the same.
If Fox wanted another Alien film so badly, couldn't they have just created a different protagonist instead of contriving a truly grotesque way of bringing the old one back? As history shows, apparently not.
1. Emperor Palpatine - Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker (2019)
Why this entry is at the top of this list is mainly due to the ripple effect the film has on those that come before it. Once the elusive ruler of the Galactic Empire, now a decrepit, festering evil in a far-flung corner of the galaxy, Emperor Palpatine has (somehow) returned from the dead.
Yes, the film practically ignores the question of how the Emperor survived being thrown hundreds of feet down a reactor shaft by Darth Vader in Return of the Jedi, instead assuming we're all okay with it and carrying swiftly on. What it does answer, however, is something we'd all have rather it hadn't. Palpatine has been the puppet master behind the First Order the whole time - quite literally in the case of Snoke, who is revealed to have just been a genetically grown body with Palpatine's consciousness.
What this means is that Palpatine's existence not only devalues his own decades-old death scene, but it also drags several majorly important characters down with him. Darth Vader, for sacrificing his life to save his son; Snoke, who could have been a character of formidable power and significance instead of a mere shell; and Luke Skywalker, who is revered for saving the galaxy when, in reality, Palpatine's survival shows he didn't achieve much at all.
The modern Star Wars trilogy is free to contradict itself all it likes. But when it starts retroactively tainting the originals? That's where the line has to be drawn.