11 Worst Ideas George Lucas Ever Put On Film
"No George, that's a terrible idea," said no-one ever. Unfortunately.

11. Jar Jar Binks

10. The Ewoks
By most accounts, Return Of The Jedi was supposed to be an incredibly bleak film: characters were supposed to die, romances were to be doomed, and innocence lost, and some of this still shows through, especially in the Tatooine sequence that begins the film. The move to lighter fare was apparently decided early in the scriptwriting process as darker, more intriguing ideas were dropped in favour of a "family-friendly" bent - allegedly, in order to sell more toys. You see, George Lucas gave up much of his salary from the first Star Wars to convince the studio to make the film, and in exchange, all he asked for was the merchandising rights. He then turned that around when the film was a success and started to produce a myriad of action figures, playsets, and PVC lightsabers, and ensured himself a giant, pretty much unprecedented pay day. The Ewoks were seen as the most egregious play for children's hearts and piggy banks: they hijack the story for the better part of an hour, get into all sorts of hijinks playing with our heroes' complicated technology, and unthinkably manage to defeat the Empire's best troops with goofy, Rube Goldberg-esque forest contraptions. And the less said about the spinoff the better, quite frankly. George Lucas has defended the Ewoks as an allegory for the relatively "primitive" Viet Cong defeating the advanced American troops, which is not only problematic in the same way as Jar Jar Binks, but also reflects an enduring problem with the Prequel trilogy.9. Turning The Prequels Into Political Allegory

8. Too Many Bad Guys, Too Little Evil

7. Writing And Directing The Prequels Himself

6. Howard The Duck

5. Killing Padme

4. "Reimagining" The Original Trilogy (After Pretty Much Decrying That Sort Of Thing)

"In the future it will become even easier for old negatives to become lost and be 'replaced' by new altered negatives. This would be a great loss to our society. Our cultural history must not be allowed to be rewritten."It would be foolish to deny the rights of creators to alter their works: Blade Runner would not be nearly as adored as it is now without Ridley Scott's Director's Cuts, and the original Star Trek remastering actually added to the creative vision of Roddenberry and Co, but the hypocrisy of George Lucas lies in the excess of his changes. Whole scenes were added that were rightfully cut in the first place, and worse still, many of ILM's original effects were replaced with new digital renderings (though credit to ILM for multiple, harmless uses of their signature "Praxis Effect") which erased much of the beat-up charm of the original. Contrary to what most would think, sometimes charmingly antiquated effects contribute to a picture that feels lived-in and helps with the suspension of disbelief, rather than hindering it. Or maybe all these new effects were a warm-up for one of Lucas' biggest excesses.
3. Pod Racing

2. "Only Imperial Stormtroopers Are So Accurate."

1. Radioland Murders
