12 Actors Who Must Play Marvel Villains Before 2028

The big bad casting decisions to bring Kevin Feige's MCU Master Plan to life...

Mortensen Punisher 2 Earlier this month, Kevin Feige hinted that he had a master plan for every Marvel movie we would see before 2028 - an astonishing claim that brought accusations of empty brinksmanship with a newly determined DC Entertainment who were outlining their own plans - and the world was immediately intrigued. How could any studio have the confidence to plan 14 years in advance when the path of sequels would invariably rely on financial returns? And who were the thousands of characters Feige had suggested could make their way into the MCU? We put together our own take on the MCU Master Plan, and with 28 movies plotted it, attention must now turn to the actors who will take on the key villainous roles. Strictly speaking, the Phalanx and the Kree who should appear in future Marvel movies (as well as the Skrull race, probably) wouldn't necessarily require notable actors, or leading figures who would require measured casting beyond their physical appropriateness, so we'll just assume they'll be the universe's nameless grunts for the purposes of this article. And of course there are a couple of villains who should re-appear, if the 28 Movie Masterplan goes exactly as we have already predicted: Hugo Weaving's Red Skull was great but under-used, Crossbones (Frank Grill) was set up by the end of Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and Baron Von Strucker (Thomas Kretschmann) is yet to see his full role expanded on. And then there's the newly cast Doctor Doom, Toby Kebbel, who could conceivably reappear (even in a supporting villain role) in the MCU, if rights are sorted out, and Ryan Reynolds' Deadpool, who is far more interesting as an anti-hero/villain, and a potential face-off against Hulk should be deemed one of the possible high-lights of the forthcoming slate. Those are the names we probably already know, but what of the so far nameless rogues who will face off against Marvel's forthcoming stable of heroes?

12. Christoph Waltz - Doctor Faustus

Waltz Faustus Having already committed one great villain to screen in Inglourious Basterds' Hans Landa, one very good one in Water For Elephants' volatile August, and two terrible ones for The Three Musketeers and The Green Hornet (mostly because of the films, rather than his performance), Waltz has previous as grotesque villain figures, and with some notable success. Though his background is in TV, he has brought a theatricality to his big screen performances that works particularly well for grand, scheming villains, particularly when they have a flamboyant edge to them, and he has both the intellect and the accent to pull off the Austrian criminal mastermind, Faustus. Like Landa, Faustus would require an imposing, but not quite physically threatening performance - he is menacing without hulking stature, and his power is very much of the mind and of language, and that would suit Waltz beautifully. Alternatively, Michael Fassbender would be an incredible Faustus, given his ability to exude dark charisma and high-intellect, but since those characteristics are basically what landed him the role of Magneto, it's less likely that he would be cast, especially with Marvel likely to at least attempt some sort of X-Men cross-over at some point in the future for the MCU. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Zach Galifianakis, because sometimes a beard is just not enough.

11. Stephen Moyer - Mastermind

Mastermind With ageing actors likely to either be replaced or retired entirely from the Avengers cast (or moved to a less active role, as you have to suspect Tony Stark will be) it's likely fairly soon that Marvel will rethink the Avengers line up, possibly opening up the chance for the likes of Luke Cage and Spider-Man (should rights be worked out) to join. With a New Avengers storyline established, Mastermind would be a significant enough threat to warrant a team-up, and who is exactly the kind of charismatic villain future Marvel films will need to turn to. True Blood star Stephen Moyer would offer the appropriate charm and poise, and is the right sort of age to carry off the character. It isn't enough to just be villainous, there has to be the foundation of charisma that adds complexity and engagement to the best villains, and there's something in Moyer's take on Southern spirit that would work wonderfully. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Joe Manganiello - despite looking the part, the issue here is that Marvel need to cast him as Wolverine if and when Hugh Jackman hangs up his claws.

10. Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson - Dormammu

Some may balk at the suggestion of the flame-skulled antagonist, considering the comparatively greater success of villains who are more relatable in human terms in Marvel movies to date (and the unhelpful track record of the other fiery-headed Marvel character), but Dormammu qualifies as Doctor Strange's most enduring single foe. His longevity is testament to his appeal, and Marvel would do well to heed that. Quite who plays the hulking figure of Strange's nemesis is perhaps not particularly important, given that his face will be obscured by the character's design, but the actor who is chosen needs to boast the necessary size to pull off the character's presence. Considering the pictures he has posted recently having been brought in as the third actor to play The Mountain in Game Of Thrones, Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson leaps to the front of the queue of sizeable actors. The World's Strongest Man contender is incredibly imposing - hence his casting as the formidable Clegane brother, and there wouldn't be too many concerns about selling emotions or dialogue.
Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Nic Cage, who has previous with flame headed demons.

9. Noomi Rapace - Lucia Von Bardas

Noomi Rapace Von Bardas With Nick Fury now underground, and the possibility (however slim) of a stand-alone movie for the erstwhile head of SHIELD in the future - and tied directly into both Captain America 4 as we predicted it and the Secret War comic book event, there is scope to bring in Latveria's second most famous villainous leader, in both human and cyborg forms. In Captain America 4, with Latveria's threat growing, thanks to their harbouring of the returned Red Skull and the false-front leadership of Von Bardas, she could be introduced as an exotic, irresistibly charming leader, darkly charismatic, but obviously sheltering secrets, and after the culmination of that film's events, and Nick Fury's Secret War on her country she could carry off the reborn tech-enhanced version of the Latverian prime minister with considerable aplomb. And there's definitely some appeal in the idea of Rapace channelling the spirit of Alive Krige's Borg queen from Star Trek: First Contact to portray both sides of the character; from cool, calculating politician to devastating, unhinged killing machine. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Halle Berry. Because no roles should go to her ever.

8 Benedict Cumberbatch - Klaw

Cumberbatch Klaw Seemingly no fantasy casting article would be complete without the obligatory nod towards Britain's most wonderfully named actor. Cumberbatch remains big business after breaking out with his Sherlock and cementing his appeal with a powerful, and surprisingly physical performance as Khan in Star Trek Into Darkness. Rumours suggest he may be lined up for another villainous turn in Disney's new Star Wars trilogy, and the comic book movie universe can't be too far behind, even if some might suggest he would make a more appealing Mr Fantastic than a villain. But in former physicist turned manifested sound wave Klaw, Cumberbatch would find the same sort of dual-appeal that made his Khan work despite the obvious and ominous weight of expectations. Klaw - who would appear in a future Black Panther movie - is both supremely intelligent and hugely threatening, and Cumberbatch has already proved himself capable of both aspects. The prospect of his scheming, and threats to destroy Wakanda for their vibranium deposits would be enough of a strong foundation to turn the Black Panther movie from an exotic alternate project into a genuinely brilliant possibility, particularly if they cast the Panther himself correctly. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Jim Parsons. He might famously play a physicist, but it's unlikely Sheldon would pack the necessary punch.

7. Ray Parks/Andy Serkis - Mephisto

It would be foolish to ignore the fact that the devil has appeared four times in failed comic book movies, and the unenviable track record of Constantine, both Ghost Riders and Spawn isn't exactly indication that he should be given another chance, but Mephisto isn't quite the classic horned one (even if the Ghost Rider film - and indeed the comics - replaced Satan with him in the exchange of Johnny Blaze's soul) and he is an enduring enough villain to justify future inclusion in the MCU. Crucially, Mephisto also potentially ties in three major plot-threads, and three separate major characters in Doctor Strange, Thor and Scarlet Witch in a way that lends well to the cohesive narrative threads approach that Marvel have followed so far. The key to making Mephisto work is to hire an actor well-versed in performance capture, or at least predominantly physical performance, which is why both Ray Parks (he who lent his body to Darth Maul) and Andy Serkis (the king of mo cap) both leap to the top of the list. Serkis would have the greater acting credentials, and could perhaps sell the image of Mephisto as a grand tempter, but Parks proved with Maul that he could simply team up with another actor for the vocal side of the performance. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Entirely CGI, like a big cloud of gas (Galactus) or a gigantic, suspiciously fecal blob (

6. Vincent Cassel - Baron Mordo

Vincent Cassel Baron Mordo With Doctor Strange's universe likely to be populated by demons and inter-dimensional creatures (such is the nature of the character after all), his mini-franchise will require a more human-like villainous element to ground the rest of the foes: a Loki-type to balance the supernatural elements - and Baron Mordo fits the bill perfectly. Mordo would also fit Marvel's tendency to employ character mirrors - Iron Man had Iron Monger, Tony Stark has had both Justin Hammer and Aldrich Killian, Thor has Loki, Captain America has the Winter Soldier and the Hulk had the Abomination - since they seem to be under the impression (mostly well-founded) that perverse similarities make for for enduring villains. Mordo fits in with that pattern, since he is basically the antithesis of Strange, trained by the same force (the Ancient One), with Strange basically established by his master in order to nullify Mordo's threat to him. It would make sense then to cast a charming actor with a dark side who could well work as Doctor Strange himself, which is firmly where Vincent Cassel fits. He has that intangible otherness that lends well to villainous roles (much like Mads Mikkelsen - another strong contender for the role) and his dramatic chops would help pull the performance away from pantomime territory. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: The same actor who plays Doctor Strange. Even though similarity is a big winner for Marvel villains, introducing am evil twin gimmick would be awful.

5. Simon Pegg - Elihas Starr

Pegg Starr The man who many thought would be cast as the lead in long-time collaborator Edgar Wright's Ant-Man movie might not yet be completely out of the running for a place in the cast (even if it is further down the line than the first Ant-Man movie) as the film is yet to really cast a villain. There's a strong suggestion that the first Ant-Man will position Hank Pym as the antagonist, since Scott Lang will presumably steal his technology (if the film is set to follow the comic book narrative), and with the announcement that it will be a heist film there may not be room for a traditional villain as well. But if the first film achieves the right financial return, there will be scope to bring in some of Ant-Man's established foes, and Eggman would seem a reasonable suggestion since he fits the same mirroring bill as Baron Mordo. The gifted government research atomic scientist would suit Pegg, who has openly expressed his preference for playing the character, and though he has typically impressed in comical or leading roles, he has some form as a villain in Doctor Who, as well as committing some of his best work to screen when working with Edgar Wright. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Dan Ackroyd. Cone head or no cone head, the Ghostbusters star has gone horribly off the tracks.

4. Michael Chiklis - Kingpin

Chiklis Kingpin When the Daredevil TV show lands, it's likely we will get an answer to the Kingpin conundrum, but until then Michael Chiklis - formerly the Thing, of course - will continue to be suggested as the perfect choice for the hulking arch-nemesis. The first attempt at bringing Daredevil to screen committed many sins, but the casting of Michael Clarke Duncan as Kingpin was one of its more inspired moves: the script ultimately let the performance down somewhat, but what that casting got right was that any actor tasked with that role would need to be a dominant screen presence. And though Chiklis doesn't quite have the lumbering physique of Clarke Duncan, he is a solidly built man, and his powerful performance as Vic Mackey in The Shield is the perfect answer to any questions related to his presence. Chiklis would bring the required menace, and he's the sort of actor who could sell Wilson Fisk's rags to criminal riches backstory as well as the authentic power he has over his underlings. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Kevin Durand in a fat suit (see X-Men Origins: Wolverine).

3. Viggo Mortensen - The Punisher

Mortensen Punisher The problem with The Punisher is that there have now been three separate attempts to bring the character to the big screen, and each has been a disaster, despite the strength of the source, and the enduring appeal of the character. He is the archetypal dark angel of vengeance, pushed to abandon all sense of traditional morality to take down the mob and other criminals that he broadly deemed responsible for the death of his family, and his personal arc is arguably as intriguing and as adaption-worthy as Batman's - there are even genetic similarities in their make-up. But each of those three performances have gone for brawn without the right emotional balance to the character: there was little beyond the surface of the character and his vast armoury, and recasting The Punisher (even for a relatively brief supporting role in a new Daredevil film) would require more depth. Mortensen has proven in performances like Eastern Promises, A History Of Violence and even as Aragorn that he wears the scars of his characters' unseen pasts well, and that he can capture both measured poise with explosive aggression, which is precisely the portrayal that The Punisher needs. We need to see the character as the antithesis of what Daredevil represents; a vigilante without restraint who re-enacts the murders of his family in ever grisly act of violence he commits, and the idea of Mortensen in that role is irresistible. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Ray Stevenson, Thomas Jane or Dolph Lundgren. For obvious reasons.

2. Peter Dinklage - MODOK

Dinklage Modok Though MODOK did not appear as the villain in the second Captain America movie (and probably to the film's credit, given how successful it was), that wasn't for the want of trying from one writer involved on the first movie. Co-writer Christopher Markus apparently lobbied hard for the enduring villain to be considered as the follow-up to the Red Skull, particularly based on the success of Red Skull's design, and the potential for what he called a "terrifying movie with MODOK," but nobody seems to have been on his side. That the villain hasn't yet appeared is not fatal for his chances, even if some might unfairly dismiss the character as too silly for the MCU (Red Skull was met with similarly disapproving grunts), and Markus' fantasy pick for casting the character - Peter Dinklage - is easily the best suggestion for bringing the character to life. Yes, he might require something of a rethink in design, but abandoning his iconic look entirely would be a mistake, even if it would be more important to focus on the elements that have made him a recurring and popular foe for multiple Marvel characters. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Patton Oswalt. Not because he wouldn't be perfect, but because he's already been cast as Eric Koenig for Agents Of SHIELD, and because Marvel allowed Oswalt to joke about the character becoming MODOK as a self-deprecating joke - which would rob any potential development in that vein of its impact...
"When they first told me the character€™s name , I€™ll admit the first thing I did is I went on Wikipedia and looked up the M.O.D.O.K. character to see if Koenig was maybe his name before he became M.O.D.O.K., but it wasn€™t. They keep on talking about the Clairvoyant in the show and I€™m like, €˜is that M.O.D.O.K.? Am I M.O.D.O.K.?"

1. Ron Perlman - Thanos

Thanos Perlman It is surely only a matter of time before Thanos reappears in the MCU: his post-credits Avengers appearance, and that irresistible grin was undoubtedly a call forward to an important future narrative thread, and the way the MCU seems to be setting up the Infinity Gems storyline would suggest that we are heading towards the Infinity Gauntlet story arc, probably in one of the future Avengers movies. Of course, Thanos has already appeared, but like the early version of Voldemort in the Harry Potter franchise, it's unlikely that we will see the original actor returning, since he was something of a stop gap, and there is one actor whose face and CV fits the character far better. Perlman has the kind of interesting face that made him perfect for Hellboy, and in that performance lies the model for his performance as Thanos: he has already proven in that performance, as well as his under-appreciated performance in Star Trek: Nemesis, that he is capable of adding the necessary spark to characters beneath heavy prosthetics, and though he somewhat unfairly attracts accusations that his appeal is based more on cult than ability, he would be the ideal choice for Thanos. Who It Definitely Shouldn't Be: Damion Poitier. He might have been the first actor to put on the Thanos make-up, but the jobbing TV actor is hardly the right profile for one of Marvel's biggest big bad. Who do you think should play villains in Marvel's upcoming slate of movies? Do you agree with our take on Kevin Feige's MCU master-plan? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread. Marvel 28

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.