12 Actors Who Basically Guarantee You Make A Flop

Hire these guys at your peril, they are cursed.

The term "box office poison" is one synonymous with actors who, for a multitude of reasons, just can't seem to catch a break. Despite each of these performers having a significant enough profile with audiences, there's something about them that just doesn't entice people to go catch their latest movies, and as a result, they've endured a string of financially unsuccessful efforts, regardless of the critical acclaim they may have acquired (in some cases, at least). Hiring these actors will, for the most part, result in a movie failing to gather any financial traction whatsoever, and while we can't discount the fact that some of these actors willfully picked art over commerce, there's no denying the fact that a string of monetary flops will do little to help any actor's career. Some of these performers are at least lucky enough to do well from animated fare, ensemble work and blockbuster franchises, but when it's their face plastered all over the poster, they're still unable to bring in the big bucks. In this article, we're going to examine each actors' box office history over the last decade, and try and figure out why they just can't open a movie. Which actors immediately put you off a movie? Let us know in the comments!

12. Clive Owen

Over the last 10 years, Clive Owen has had only a number of hits at the box office: Closer and Sin City (both ensemble pieces that weren't sold on his name), Inside Man (likely more successful because of Denzel Washington), and the Pink Panther remake (a hit due to the franchise and Steve Martin's presence). As for other films that at least broke even at the box office, King Arthur did but ultimately made no money for the studio, and Killer Elite just barely made more than its cost. As for the flops? They include Children of Men, Elizabeth: The Golden Age, Shoot 'Em Up, The International, Duplicity, The Boys Are Back, Trust, Intruders, Shadow Dancer, Blood Ties and Words and Pictures. Boy, that's a lot of failed movies. Why Is He A Flop? It's hard to say: he's a handsome and perfectly capable actor in both silly action flicks and dramatic fare. He certainly didn't get a poor choice of movies, yet something about him (perhaps his accent) just doesn't connect with audiences.

11. Uma Thurman

In fairness, Uma Thurman has had a number of financial successes over the last few years, such as Kill Bill Volume 2, Be Cool (an ensemble piece), Prime, My Super Ex-Girlfriend, the first Percy Jackson movie (a franchise, and she only had a small part in it), Movie 43 (as part of an ensemble), and Nymphomaniac (in a small role that's part of an ensemble). As you can see, a good number of her hits are heavily qualified by the fact that Thurman's presence had little bearing on their success. Even the best film of the bunch, Kill Bill Volume 2, was sold more on Quentin Tarantino's name than her own. So, what about the flops? The flops include The Producers, The Life Before Her Eyes, The Accidental Husband, Motherhood (which made only £88 in the UK on its opening weekend), Ceremony, Bel Ami and Playing for Keeps. Fortunately for Thurman, she hasn't got any recent blockbuster flops to her name (though we haven't forgotten about the bombing of 1998's The Avengers or the mediocre showings of Paycheck and Batman & Robin), which keeps her from getting a higher billing on this list. Why Is She A Flop? Because outside of the Kill Bill franchise, she just hasn't done anything exciting or entertaining that audiences want to watch. She's not a bad actress by any means, but she's picked a pretty steady stream of boring movies that do little to enhance her star power and profile.

10. Daniel Craig

Daniel Craig has had a number of hit movies in recent years, such as Munich, Casino Royale, Quantum of Solace, Tintin, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and Skyfall. Notice a pattern? Craig is what we call a "franchise or bust" actor, in that outside of an established franchise (with the exception of Munich, which sold itself on Oscar buzz and Spielberg directing), he just can't open a movie. Don't believe us? Just check out this list of his flops over the last 10 years. His misses include Layer Cake, Enduring Love, The Jacket, Infamous, Renaissance (admittedly in a voice-only role), The Invasion, The Golden Compass (which was a tremendous box office disappointment), Flashbacks of a Fool, Defiance, Cowboys and Aliens (another huge flop) and Dream House. Why Is He A Flop? As much as we hate to say it, outside of the James Bond role Craig isn't the most exhilarating of actors. He's extremely handsome and looks good on a poster, but he's also picked a pretty poor selection of parts outside of his hit blockbusters, so it's entirely possible the movies would have flopped with plenty of other actors as well. Since the billion-dollar success of Skyfall, though, perhaps Craig might enjoy a better time with his non-franchise work, even if he currently doesn't have anything slated beyond Bond 24.

9. Olivia Wilde

Olivia Wilde has enjoyed some box office success over the years, though it's mostly been in supporting roles for movies that were absolutely not sold on her name: The Next Three Days, Tron: Legacy (a franchise film), In Time, The Words, Rush and Her. Not a single one of these movies promoted itself heavily on Wilde's involvement, and for the most part (Tron and Rush excluded), they were pretty small parts. As for the flops? The Girl Next Door, Alpha Dog, Turistas, The Death and Life of Bobby Z, Fix, Year One, Cowboys & Aliens (her biggest flop to date), The Change-Up, On the Inside, Butter, Deadfall, People Like Us, The Incredible Burt Wonderstone, Drinking Buddies, Third Person and Better Living Through Chemistry. Now, excuse us while we grab our inhalers... Why Is She A Flop? This is a really tough one. Wilde is beautiful, frequently hilarious and a good actress to boot. She clearly has a preference for indie films which doesn't help her box office stature at all, though luckily for her, even most of her flops weren't sold on her name, so she's able to get out with her name and integrity in tact. Still, it's not exactly encouraging, and makes it less likely that she will be offered lead work in the future. A career of mostly supporting roles seems likely.

8. Shia LaBeouf

Shia LaBeouf is something of an exception on this list: by typical standards, he doesn't guarantee a box office flop at all. Look at the sheer number of hits in his filmography: i, Robot (albeit a cameo role), The Greatest Game Ever Played, Constantine, Disturbia, the Transformers trilogy, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, Eagle Eye, Wall Street 2, Lawless and Nymphomaniac. By comparison, his flops are pretty minimal: Bobby, A Guide to Recognising Your Saints, Surf's Up, New York, I Love You, The Company You Keep and Charlie Countryman, and the majority of these are art-house flicks which were never going to ignite the box office anyway. So, what is it that makes LaBeouf a flop? Why Is He A Flop? LaBeouf is one of those few actors whose erratic personal behaviour has become so prolifically irritating to audiences that they're just not interested in seeing him on screen anymore. Since leaving the Transformers franchise, his career hasn't exactly been a string of box office dynamite, a combination of his choice to do more artistic fare and the fact that people just aren't fussed about him. His upcoming war flick Fury will likely be his biggest hit in a while, though that'll mostly be because of the Brad Pitt factor, and audiences will simply put up with LaBeouf's presence. As for the future? The actor's slate is completely empty, so we'll have to wait and see...

7. Eddie Murphy

Few entries on this list make us as sad as Eddie Murphy, a tremendously talented comedian who simply stopped putting any effort in around the year 2000, and though audiences stuck with him for a while, his luck eventually ran out. In his defense, Murphy's commitment to voice-over and ensemble work has netted him a few hits over the last decade, such as three Shrek movies, Tower Heist and Dreamgirls (which even netted him an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor), though only a single movie sold on his name alone actually made any money, and that's the terrible Norbit. This appears to be the straw that broke the camel's back, because all three of Murphy's starring projects that followed, Meet Dave, Imagine That and A Thousand Words, flopped spectacularly. If we go back a little further, of course, Murphy also starred in 2002's The Adventures of Pluto Nash, which became one of the biggest box office bombs in cinematic history, and who can forget the massive box office failure that was Holy Man? Still, Murphy has pretty much been lucky enough throughout his career to balance his flops with a few major hits, even if nowadays that mostly means using his voice or appearing within a large cast. Why Is He A Flop? It appears that even casual viewers who sunk their money into Norbit have grown fed up of Murphy's boisterous shtick, because he's not appeared in a movie for two years since A Thousand Words flopped, hopefully signalling a career re-think on his part. With Beverly Hills Cop 4 and Triplets (a sequel to the movie Twins) on the way, perhaps it's time for Murphy's comeback, though the question remains: will audiences be interested in watching Murphy front and center anymore? Essentially, Murphy isn't entirely uncastable, but it looks as though his time as a leading man might be over.

6. Emile Hirsch

Emile Hirsch is a tremendously talented actor, though he's sadly not had a whole lot of box office success throughout his career. His hits to date include Into the Wild (sold on its Oscar buzz), Milk (more likely due to Sean Penn and the Oscar buzz), Lone Survivor (sold on the Mark Wahlberg factor), and well, Savages (an ensemble piece) did just about OK, we guess. As for the flops? The Girl Next Door, Imaginary Heroes, Lords of Dogtown, Alpha Dog, The Air I Breathe, Speed Racer (his biggest flop to date), Taking Woodstock, Killer Joe, Twice Born, The Motel Life and Prince Avalanche. Why Is He A Flop? Speed Racer should have been the movie to propel Hirsch to super-stardom, though its financial failure likely dented his favour with big-budget productions, yet in his defense, much of Hirsch's recent work has been in low-budget indie fare that was never going to be a major hit anyway. Still, the fact that every single one of his hits has an exterior reason for its success speaks volumes: he just might be better-suited for supporting parts, at least in financial terms. Personally, we'd watch him as a lead any day of the week, even if casuals don't seem to agree...

5. Jude Law

Jude Law is definitely one of the most inconsistent actors on this list, starring in a wide range of hits and flops, though over the last 5 years in particular, his box office success is heavily qualified by the presence of other actors and appearing in ensemble casts. His hits from the last decade include Closer (part of an acting quartet including Julia Roberts), The Aviator (sold on DiCaprio and Oscar buzz), The Holiday (again, an acting quartet including Cameron Diaz and Jack Black), My Blueberry Nights, The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (an ensemble piece, and driven by the Heath Ledger curiosity), two Sherlock Holmes movies (unquestionably sold on Robert Downey Jr), Contagion (a huge ensemble work), Rise of the Guardians (animation), Side Effects, and the Grand Budapest Hotel (another big ensemble). His flops meanwhile include I Heart Huckabees, Alfie, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow, Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events, All the King's Men, Breaking and Entering, Sleuth, Repo Men, Hugo, 360, Anna Karenina and Don Hemingway. Why Is He A Flop? Law just doesn't seem to have what it takes to draw an audience on his own, which is a mystery considering his good looks and solid acting chops. This might mean that studios will continue to cast him in ensembles and casts that don't place him directly in the foreground for safety's sake. If anyone can account for why he can't bring in the box office bacon, answers on a postcard, please...

4. Jessica Biel

Now we're getting onto the actors who truly are box office poison. Jessica Biel may not be the best actress out there, but she's gorgeous and generally does a decent enough job in most things she stars in, yet her hits of the last decade truly are few and far between. They include Cellular, Blade: Trinity (a franchise sold on Wesley Snipes), The Illusionist, I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry (sold on Adam Sandler), Valentine's Day (a massive ensemble) and New Year's Eve (another big ensemble). And the flops? Take a big breath: Stealth (her biggest flop), Elizabethtown, London, Home of the Brave, Next, Easy Virtue, Planet 51, Powder Blue, The A-Team (another big flop), Total Recall (yet another blockbuster bomb), The Tall Man, Playing for Keeps, Hitchcock and The Truth about Emanuel. Why Is She A Flop? Poor choices on the part of her agent are one thing, though Biel doesn't exactly have a lot of screen presence in even her good roles, and in most of the aforementioned movies both good and bad, she's not really very memorable (not that this makes her a bad actress per se). She needs a big, juicy role that will endear audiences to her, though we don't see it on the horizon anytime soon, especially with three big-budget bombs under her belt.

3. Taylor Kitsch

Taylor Kitsch has been referred to as "box office strychnine" due to his rather unfortunate track record as of late, even if, all things considered, he's not a terrible actor, just one who has been chewed up and spat out by the Hollywood machine. Kitsch has only acted in a small number of movies, so listing his hits won't take long: John Tucker Must Die, Savages (ensemble) and Lone Survivor (ensemble, and sold on Wahlberg). His flops, meanwhile, include Snakes on a Plane (which was financially successful but severely undercut expectations), The Covenant, X-Men Origins: Wolverine (a disappointing haul blamed on a pirate copy of the movie being leaked weeks in advance), The Bang Bang Club, John Carter (his biggest flop), Battleship (another costly flop) and The Grand Seduction. Why Is He A Flop? Nothing but bad luck. The vast majority of his flops were movies widely expected to be considerable hits, specifically Snakes on a Plane, Wolverine, John Carter and Battleship, and from the perspective of his agent, considering the talent attached and nature of the material, they must have seemed like sure things. It's hard to see how the handsome, solid actor that is Kitsch could have derailed these movies on his own. So prolific are Kitsch's failures that some have even proclaimed him to be "cursed". Make up your own minds on that one...

2. Colin Farrell

Colin Farrell is one of the strongest actors on this list, and so it's all the more depressing and mystifying that he just can't seem to open many movies. His hits of the last decade include In Bruges, Crazy Heart (sold on Oscar buzz and Jeff Bridges' performance), The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (an ensemble film, and Heath Ledger's death certainly stirred up interest), Horrible Bosses (ensemble), Epic (animated), and Saving Mr. Banks (a supporting part in a movie sold on Tom Hanks and Emma Thompson). His flops? Brace yourselves: A Home at the End of the World, Alexander (his biggest flop), The New World, Miami Vice (a huge flop), Ask the Dust, Cassandra's Dream, Pride and Glory, Ondine, Triage, The Way Back, London Boulevard, Fright Night, Total Recall (another huge flop), Seven Psychopaths, Dead Man Down, and Winter's Tale. Why Is He A Flop? With the exception of In Bruges, Farrell just can't seem to open a movie on his own: his successes have been as part of a larger cast in a supporting role, while his high-profile failures have often been movies that on paper should have succeeded (namely Miami Vice, Fright Night and Total Recall). He's clearly another actor who thrives in supporting parts, and despite his immense acting skill, audiences just don't care for him as a leading man, for some reason.

1. Nicole Kidman

Nicole Kidman's movies have made a combined total of over $3 billion worldwide, but would you believe that, these days, casting in her in a movie is a sure recipe for a failure? Let's look at her recent successes first: The Interpreter, Bewitched, Happy Feet (animated), Australia and Just Go With It (sold on Adam Sandler and Jennifer Aniston). Her failures? The Stepford Wives, Birth, The Invasion, Margot at the Wedding, The Golden Compass (her biggest commercial disappointment), Nine, Rabbit Hole, Trespass, The Paperboy, Stoker, The Railway Man and Grace of Monaco. Why Is She A Flop? She's beautiful, she's a great actress, she has a commanding leading lady presence, and yet, she just can't seem to catch a break. In fairness, the likes of The Railway Man, The Paperboy and Rabbit Hole were clearly conscious artistic choices rather than commercial ones, but she's had 5 flops in a row now, and with her next effort Before I Go to Sleep looking to be a low-key limited release, it'll probably be six. Still, the release of Paddington near the end of the year will almost certainly break the streak, if only temporarily. Kidman's gravitation towards flops seems to be a mixture of her ambition leading her to more artistically-minded projects and some really bad luck: who would have expected movies like The Stepford Wives, The Invasion, The Golden Compass, Nine and Grace of Monaco to flop? On paper, they all should've been big hits. Did we miss any actors who can be considered box office poison? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.