12 Classic Movies That Got Away With Problematic Scenes
Sexual assault happens in a surprising amount of comedies.
The Special Edition rereleases of Tom & Jerry and Looney Tunes starts with a statement read by Whoopi Goldberg. In it, they talk about how attitudes towards race have changed, and rather than delete the racist depictions, the decision was made to leave them in because otherwise, it would be like pretending these attitudes never existed at all.
It was roundly praised as a classy move which met the issue head on but avoided meddling in the past.
But the fact is that not all movies age well, and they don’t come with a similar disclaimer.
Either because of our changing attitudes as a society, more minority representation on screen or just the goal posts for comedy moving, these films (or at least certain scenes in them) likely wouldn’t fly today.
Does that make them bad movies though? Well, not quite. If you’re not part the minority being mocked you might still be able to enjoy them, or even if you are but can appreciate that times change, there’s no need to necessarily throw the whole movie out.
It’s definitely worth bearing in mind before a rewatch though that there are some seriously problematic scenes here.
12. The Fat-Shaming - Love, Actually
Starting off with one that’s a little tame compared to some others here, but it still treats one of its most popular characters unnecessarily harshly.
Natalie, the sweet new employee of the Prime Minister is frequently fat shamed during the opening act. It would be unpleasant regardless of her size, but the fact actress Martine McCutcheon is just a regular sized woman makes it very strange too.
It’s like the script was written for her to be chubby, but they instead cast a woman with a pretty normal body shape but kept the mean jokes in there.
Except it wasn’t, because McCutcheon confirmed the role was written specifically for her. She added that the idea was supposed to be that she saw herself as flawed, but David sees her as perfect. It’s a cliched message anyway and doesn’t really land.
Mark’s obsession with Juliet (Andrew Lincoln and Kiera Knightley) could qualify here too, except that the movie didn’t really get away with it. The creepy, stalkerish tendencies of Mark and his insecure fake apathy towards Juliet are frequently brought up as being very weird. The film wants us to think it’s sweet, but it just plainly isn’t.
11. The Foreign Caricatures - Indiana Jones And The Temple Of Doom
Indiana Jones and the Temple Of Doom is so erroneous and insensitive in its portrayal of Hinduism that the movie is still banned in India.
In the first Indiana Jones movie, they were on safe ground with the Nazis as the villains of the piece. You can pretty much do what you want with them; famously some of the most evil people in history, there’s no limit to how depraved and rotten you can make them.
In Temple Of Doom though, the Hindu cult in the catacombs is just bizarre, and just plays up the evil foreigner trope to ridiculous proportions.
The fact that Indians, a country with one of the highest rates of vegetarians in the world, were depicted as eating monkey brains and eyeball soup also lands with a thud these days.
White saviour movies have frequently been criticised, but Temple Of Doom is perhaps the worst example of this trope ever.
It’s the kind of film that you can completely understand Hollywood making in the ‘80s, but that says more about how blinkered the movie industry used to be than it does anything else.
10. The Rape Culture - Revenge Of The Nerds
Revenge Of The Nerds was always supposed to be raunchy, near the knuckle comedy that toyed with the limits of acceptability. However, in the 35 years since the movie released, the line has moved somewhat, and certain scenes in the classic romp now find themselves well over it.
There’s actually so many that it’s impossible to dwell on them, as the movie throws them at you so fast. The vilest part is Lewis committing rape by deception by having sex with Betty while wearing a Darth Vader mask and having her think he’s someone else. The Nerds selling naked pictures of Betty is almost as bad, too.
Then there’s the panty raid scene, which while in itself is gross (if not enough to wind up on this list), the fact they use the raid to set up cameras to spy on the girls should really make your skin crawl.
Then there’s the issue that gay men and Asians each get a ridiculous stereotype beaten into the ground for laughs, and finally that the Alphas seem deathly afraid of black men is almost nonsensically racist.
9. The Roustabouts & The Crows - Dumbo
Dumbo is bookended by racism, and while that certainly fits with the sensibilities of 1941’s society, it doesn’t make it any better today.
The movie starts with a group of large, faceless black men setting up the circus tent in the rain. The lyrics, sung by the workers themselves, mention how they’re happy to ‘slave until they’re almost dead’ and compare themselves to ‘hairy apes’.
They’re kind of fishing for a self-deprecating, almost ironic tone to the lyrics, but at the same time you can tell it was written by white men with no real idea what life is like for these workers.
Then of course there’s the crows. Being called Jim Crow, they don’t even try to be subtle about it, speaking with almost impossibly stereotypical southern black grammar.
Disney has a few bits of racism in their back catalogue, but with the Roustabouts being more subtle and the crows being sympathetic characters, they tend to get away with Dumbo more.
Certainly, it’s survived the edits unlike Fantasia, and hasn’t been confined to storage like Song Of The South.
Burton’s recent remake treads carefully, avoiding the racist mistakes of the past without needing to completely transform the script.
8. Eating Disorders For LOLs - Miss Congeniality
Miss Congeniality is chock full of eating disorder jokes, with the whole thing becoming quite unpleasant by the end.
It has a very dated charm to it, certainly, and while it’s cute in places (the technology looks hideously dated now), it definitely damages the movie on a rewatch in others.
Models with drug addiction, bulimia and anorexia used to be a safe topic for jokes, but more recently as we’ve gained a deeper understanding of mental health struggles, portrayal has become much more tragic and sympathetic.
Given the lighthearted nature of Miss Congeniality, it would certainly be more delicate around these issues (or more likely would avoid them entirely) if it were to come out today. While Sandra Bullock’s Gracie offers the girls pizza, they tell her they can’t eat it because of the calories, but Gracie jokes they’re ‘gonna throw it up anyway’.
This is supposed to be a sweet, team bonding type scene, but the quite heavy joke only serves to make viewers uncomfortable on a rewatch. Similarly, while Heathers leans dark, the joke about bulimia being ‘so ‘87’ is said quite matter of factly, while Seinfeld and Family Guy have plumbed this cheap we’ll before too.
7. Upskirting?! - The Breakfast Club
The Breakfast Club is a wonderful ‘80s movie, brilliant at deconstructing tropes and is the quintessential story about nothing which actually manages to be about something. However, modern day viewing raises a couple of questions.
The most common critique isn’t anything problematic, just something which is a massive cop out and goes against the intelligence the movie had instilled in its message.
The Breakfast Club is a movie about different people, each high school stereotypes, who realise they’re not that different. So why exactly did the weird girl need a very out of character makeover to end up another pretty girl dating a jock? Indeed, why do Andrew and Allison get together at all?
While their relationship raises eyebrows, it’s got nothing on Bender and Claire; this is where the problematic scene comes in. They too end up together at the end, despite never really showing romantic chemistry until the plot called for it towards the ending.
It’s established that Bender’s behaviour is a defence mechanism, but that doesn’t change the fact he’s truly awful to her for most of the film. The scene where he sneaks under the table to peek up her skirt is especially gross.
6. Mr Yunioshi - Breakfast At Tiffany’s
Breakfast At Tiffany’s is a classic movie, with Audrey Hepburn’s Holly Golightly one of the most iconic characters ever put on film.
It’s a wonderful examination of the lives and natures of people, and was ahead of its time with a female lead who was overtly feminine yet had complete agency of her own storyline.
It also has one of the worst examples of yellowface in cinema history.
Yellowface is essentially blackface but for Asians; particularly Korean, Japanese and Chinese characters. Modern day examples typically involve white actors playing characters who were written as Asian, like Scarlett Johansson in Ghost In The Shell or Emma Stone in Alola. Still something which should be avoided, but not obnoxiously offensive.
Back when Breakfast At Tiffany’s came out in 1961 though, it involved Micky Rooney wearing big fake teeth, slapping yellow face paint on and talking in a ridiculous accent.
Rooney apologised for any offence but also defended his portrayal when asked about it in 2008, saying he was hired as a comedy actor to be over the top.
He did admit that he wouldn’t have done the role had he known people would be upset, but strangely said he forgave those who’d taken offence to it.
5. Another Rape Joke - Sixteen Candles
Sixteen Candles is the second John Hughes film to make the cut here, and while he’s rightly praised as one of the best teen movie makers ever, it’s clear that a lot of his comedy has dated badly.
Sixteen Candles is a fairly simple love story between high school king Jake, and Samantha, a girl so inconsequential that her own family forgets her sixteenth birthday. For most of it, it’s very quotable, very fun, and very, very ‘80s. However, there’s one scene involving Jake which is deeply problematic, as well as one insultingly bad character.
With Jake, we see him pass up the other girls to be with Samantha, which by ‘80s romcom standards is pretty cute. However, it’s the way he does it which makes watching so uncomfortable.
After a boozy party, Jake carries his girlfriend out to his car, handing her over to another character as she’s passed out from drinking. The other character stares at her underwear, as Jake encourages him to ‘have fun’ with her. As in, rape a girl too drunk to consent.
This brings us to the bad character: Long Duk Dong. Chinese people have funny accents... that’s the joke and it’s pounded six feet under the ground.
4. Transphobia - Ace Ventura: Pet Detective
Aren’t transwomen both funny and disgusting? That the dated idea at the heart of Ace Ventura’s villain reveal.
Upon discovering that the villain is a transgender woman (predictably played by a cisgender woman with a bulge in her underwear), everyone starts to throw up. That’s it. That’s the whole nuance of the scene. Even Joe Rogan, a right wing radio DJ who typically goes against the idea of PC culture has condemned the movie as ‘insanely transphobic’.
Family Guy goes a similar route with Brian throwing up over Ida, and that too feels lazy and cheap. That’s not to say transgender jokes need to be off limits though.
Family Guy is much better on Ida’s return. Lois refuses to let Ida use the bathroom, which while in the same ballpark, is much more subtle and more indicative of actual attitudes.
Likewise, It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia gets away with saying ‘tr*nny’ as the whole point is that the gang is deplorable, and their depiction of Carmen is brilliant.
Meanwhile, The Silence Of The Lambs is inelegant in its portrayal of Buffalo Bill, but trips over itself to explicitly tell you Bill’s not transgender, just a maniac.
Ace Ventura’s though is a massive miss with modern audiences.
3. The Deranged Seduction - The Notebook
‘Go out with me or I’ll kill myself’ apparently only sounds charming when you’re Ryan Gosling.
The Notebook is a classic romantic movie, based on the Nicolas Sparks novel and crucial in establishing the careers of both Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams, who ended up dating after filming. It’s not for everyone but it’s extremely sweet and one of the best in its genre.
Its very sugary and very cliched, but it hits all the right notes for a tearjerker. No one would argue it’s a great film, but considering the target audience, it delivers on expectations perfectly.
Undeniably though, the opening scene were Allie agrees to go out with Noah is very, very creepy.
Gosling’s Noah sees McAdams’ Allie and decides, as love affairs often start, that he must have her. Who cares that she’s on a date already? That bozo’s not the main character, Noah is.
He chases Allie but she still won’t say yes, so he grabs the Ferris wheel she’s on and rides the bars to the top. Once he’s in front of her, we’re back to ‘go out with me or I’ll kill myself’.
It’s supposed to be charming and daring, but instead it’s manipulative and deranged.
2. "Gay Men Know Designers" - Legally Blonde
The way Legally Blonde treats its gay characters is just vulgar.
Yes, the movie does have a large gay following, but given that when the film was released in 2004, gay representation consisted of stereotypes or nothing, it’s fair to say it likely wouldn’t be as popular if it dropped today.
Elle Wood’s big victory hinges on outing a gay couple, which in itself is ethically dubious, but the manner in which she ‘cracks the code’ is just insulting. Enrique, a flamboyant man literally wearing glitter and speaking with an effeminate affectation, tells Elle ‘don’t tap your last season Prada shoes at me, honey’.
And just like that, she realises he’s gay, which solves the convoluted courtroom mystery. ‘Gay men know designers’, Elle tells the legal team smugly, ‘Straight men don’t’.
The likes of Prince, David Emanuel, Tommy Hilfiger and Ralph Lauren obviously don’t fit into Elle’s neat little system, but apparently that doesn’t matter.
However, if the film is just going for the full on stereotype, it way overplays its hand when it comes to making Elle a legal genius. Enrique is every gay joke you can think of rolled into one; in their world of binary logic, how did only Elle figure it out?
1. "Did She Put Up A Fight?" - Grease
There’s actually quite a bit wrong with Grease.
The obvious scene is the ending, where Sandy changes everything about herself to appeal to Danny. There would be some salvation if there was a tone of empowerment to the scene, but instead it’s a very basic ‘I’m a bad girl now so please be my boyfriend’ vibe.
It’s difficult to argue Grease ‘got away’ with this though; it’s frequently brought up to criticise the movie.
Fans have even constructed a theory that Sandy in fact dies in the ocean during her first scene, and the whole thing is a coma fantasy as she slips away, hence why the car flies off at the end.
This aside though, there’s a much worse scene that even now passes most audiences by. During ‘Summer Nights’, one of Danny’s friends asks of Sandy ‘Did she put up a fight?’ while getting info on the girl.
Basically, ‘Did you rape her Danny? We’d all be okay with it because you’re so cool’. While the line doesn’t necessarily need to mean rape in the most violent sense, it’s clearly indicative of the ‘70s no means yes culture.