12 Common Movie Criticisms That Make No Sense

5. "It's Factually Inaccurate"

Outlaw King Chris Pine Aaron Taylor Johnson
Netflix

We've all got at least one friend, perhaps they're a doctor, a lawyer, an historian or a scientist, who just loves to point out insignificant inaccuracies in movies as though it's a personal affront to them and their field.

Nothing quite boosts the ego like telling a room full of people all the scientific flaws in Interstellar or that Taken wasn't, believe it or not, a factually accurate depiction of the complexities of human trafficking. Oh, and did you know that Lucy's claim about humans using just 10% of their brain was total bulls***?

Though there are obviously limits to the tolerance of factual inaccuracy in films, ultimately it comes down to this - does it affect the heft of the story or betray the world depicted therein?

Filmmakers frequently sacrifice historical veracity - usually unintentionally but sometimes not - in favour of capturing the spirit of a moment or time, and they'd be the first to chide you for ever assuming that a period epic was supposed to be an authoritative representation of anything.

Basically, if you take your entire knowledge of a human being or event from an Oscar-baiting movie, more fool you. And if you can't watch a movie for more than five minutes without complaining about how it disgraces your own professional field, you need to build up some damn suspension of disbelief.

Advertisement
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.