12 Critical Responses To 2017 Films That Make No Sense

The Internet's big mistakes from 2017.

Thor Ragnarok Wampa
Disney

There will never be a film that unifies 100% of its audience. Since film is a subjective medium, it is nigh impossible to find any sort of judgment that can be considered truly objective, despite repeated calls in angry comment sections about "biased reviewers".

That's exactly why we have the various review aggregator sites online that allow critics and audiences to give an average score. Not only is it a handy pass/fail method of assessment for those who deal solely in binaries, but it also offers a broad view of just how divisive even the most successful films can be.

But can these scores be trusted?

Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritc and IMDb all have a major thing in common: they are all absolutely littered with critical ratings that don't make the slightest bit of sense. Every year contains some of these and 2017 was no different. Many films were unfairly bashed while others were hopelessly over-praised. Can online review scores be trusted? Judging by how unfairly these 2017 movies were judged, there's definitely reason to be pessimistic.

12. The Belko Experiment

The Belko Experiment
MGM

The Film:

80 Americans working at an office block in rural Colombia are trapped inside and forced to kill each other. Think The Hunger Games/Battle Royale with suits.

The Response:

Mixed but largely indifferent. It was hard to even find a showing of the film, so it came and went with little fanfare.

Why They Got It Wrong:

The Belko Experiment is admittedly no great movie. It takes itself far too seriously and doesn't take advantage of the premise's potential to work as social commentary or a dark satire. However, this is definitely better than many other modern horror films and deserves more respect.

This is a suspenseful, genuinely jolting thriller with slick direction from Australian horror maestro Greg McLean and surprisingly good acting for a horror movie. The film's sadistic, vicious violence will rattle everyone, while the ludicrous amounts of gore will leave even the most desensitized viewers feeling a little queasy. That's a far bigger effect than many modern horror films with far more exposure will have on anyone.

Extra points for the terrific and darkly ironical use of music throughout the film. There's no doubt this is an absolutely solid genre film with plenty of shocks, and most will find it pretty watchable. Want to know what the insides of people's heads look like? This film is for you.


11. Happy Death Day

Happy Death Day
Universal

The Film:

Groundhog Day meets Halloween, an obnoxious student repeats the day of her murder and tries to work out the identity of her killer.

The Response:

Mixed to positive, with the film generally being seen as a solid bit of genre fun.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Oh boy, did people go easy on this. While it's watchable enough, boasts a strong performance from Jessica Rothe and some of the drama works, in the end, it's just another teen horror film... with none of the adult content many audience members were probably hoping for. How did this even get a 15 certificate?

For a horror film, there's very little actual horror and it's never scary at all. It's clearly aiming for a Scream vibe, but it's most certainly not clever, funny or thrilling enough to be on that level.

The film's core problems come down to a lack of originality, as well as its generally routine execution. This is bizarre since the positive reviews acted as if this was something fresh and new. Hopefully, the potential sequel won't materialize, since there's nowhere else for this already limited property to go. If anything, it'll probably just repeat the first film and then resemble a time loop itself.


10. Alien: Covenant

Alien Covenant Fassbender
20th Century Fox

The Film:

The sequel to Prometheus; this time, the Xenomorph is in it, it's got a Ripley-like lead and it looked as if it would be like Aliens, but directed by franchise creator Ridley Scott.

The Response:

Audiences and fans weren't kind, but critics generally gave it a pass and the reviews were positive on the whole.

Why They Got It Wrong:

We've all convinced ourselves at some point a disappointing film is actually solid because we don't want a repeat of the traumas of the Star Wars Prequels. No-one should be judged for that. This seems to be what occurred with Alien: Covenant.

There is stuff to like here. Michael Fassbender is brilliant in his dual role as David and Walter, it looks pretty and there are various interesting ideas and philosophical musings on display. Focus on anything else in the movie however, and it all immediately falls apart.

This wasn't the return to form critics said it was. It's just Prometheus all over again. The dumb characters and emotionally flat tone that plagued Prometheus remain. As if that wasn't bad enough, it's also simply not scary.

This is a film that just insults its audience across the board. It does this with an arsenal of idiotic plot turns, a lack of emotion to support its actually interesting philosophical questions and all the questions from Prometheus not being answered.

Oh, and there's the most painfully obvious plot twist in recent memory.


9. Mother!

Mother Ending
Paramount Pictures

The Film:

Darren Aronofsky's utterly bonkers allegorical drama - not the horror film as everyone was expecting - revolves around a couple whose tranquil lives are shattered by various guests invading their lives.

The Response:

Polarized but largely unenthusiastic, with the film getting a rare F score from CinemaGrade.

Why They Got It Wrong:

In this case, people weren't expecting the right thing because the marketing was way off. There was no way to market this movie as what it really is, so it was just depicted as a horror film, and while it is horrific, it's something far more interesting than "just" a horror film.

In some ways, the backlash is understandable: Mother! is undeniably self-indulgent, sometimes emotionless and often dull. Despite those flaws, it is still a good work with plenty to say. Thanks to its audacity, artistry and multi-layered themes, there's a certain charm to the film. Well, as charming as any film featuring such horrific violence can be anyway.

Jennifer Lawrence is brilliant and many of the other cast members are strong, while the allegory at the film's center is always interesting and done with artistic flair. There is simply nothing else like this, and it's hard to think of anything else where the entire film is literally a continuous allegory.


8. Lady Macbeth

Lady Macbeth Florence Pugh
Altitude Film Distribution

The Film:

A British art-house movie, this is a small-scale story about a young woman descending into madness while oppressed by a loveless marriage to an older man.

The Response:

Critics responded well, but there hasn't been a lot of awards attention and audiences have just ignored it, with a mere 6.9 rating on IMDb.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Lady Macbeth is one of the very best films of 2017.

The lack of attention this near-masterpiece has received is staggering. It might be a non-commercial film but there's plenty for casual audiences. It's got dark themes. It's got shocking twists. It's got thrills. It's even got plenty of sex for those who desire that stuff. What more could you want?

Light on dialogue, this instead uses its perfectly-crafted images to convey the gripping, powerful story. Now that is good film-making. The film is a testament to how less is more, and gets across so much material in only 90 minutes. Many indie films struggle to do nearly as much in over 2 hours.

It's sad this will likely get no awards attention at all - not even for Florence Pugh's masterful performance.


7. Jigsaw

Jigsaw Spiral
Lionsgate

The Film:

The inevitable reboot of the Saw franchise sees a new game begin 10 years after the death of the Jigsaw Killer.

The Response:

Critics did not respond well to this one at all, and many rankings have said this is one of the worst movies in the series.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Admittedly the negative reviews are justified to some extent: Jigsaw is definitely safe and workmanlike, and it lacks the gore the fans will expect. Nevertheless, the backlash against this one was completely unfair.

It was as if people were expecting it to be high art instead of a Saw movie. As a Saw film, it's got enough suspense and plot twists to stand as a solidly entertaining thriller. Looking at it artistically, the visuals are pretty good, the dialogue isn't clunky and the performances are perfectly OK.

What's also been overlooked is that this is tonally a better film: it's lighter, and as the Saw franchise has always been a pretty over-the-top series, that makesit infinitely easier to engage with. The most 'punch-the-air' thing about this is that some of the themes relating to morals from the series' better installments are finally given a bit of focus here.

Jigsaw is a good Saw movie and the reviews have been far too harsh. Go into this one with low expectations and you'll have a good time.


6. Free Fire

Brie Larson Free Fire
StudioCanal UK

The Film:

Ben Wheatley's latest film depicts a feature-length shootout in a Boston warehouse after a weapons deal goes wrong.

The Response:

Reviews from both critics and audiences were mixed but overall positive and praised the film as a fun genre movie.

Why They Got It Wrong:

This is a terrible movie. In fact, it's the worst film on this list and yet it somehow scored 64% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Free Fire is very occasionally fun, but largely comes down to a bunch of under-used actors crawling around a warehouse and shooting at each other. As a result, it feels too long at only 90 minutes and none of the talented cast, save for the ever-reliable Sharlto Copley, get anything to do. Even Ben Wheatley lets the side down with his messy, confusing direction.

As much as you'll want to like a film which had so much potential, you'll find that a very difficult task. Unlikable characters, incoherent editing and uneven scripting make this pretty much impossible to get into. That this movie was seen as a success despite all these blatantly obvious flaws is truly baffling.


5. Justice League

Justice League Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

The Film:

The long-awaited team-up of the Justice League, everything in the much discussed and much maligned DCEU has been leading up to this.

The Response:

Reviews were mixed to negative overall. Audiences have been more positive.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Justice League is a fun, pleasingly simple blockbuster where the troubled production didn't show (mostly) and it's full of great characters played with skill by its terrific cast.

Factoring in the little emotional moments, the restrained jokes and the overall good action and you have yourself an overall satisfying cinematic experience. After this year's... well, let's face it, brilliant Wonder Woman movie, this is the second best DCEU film.

It's far from a perfect movie, but the reviews seemed to be reviewing the production troubles and the DCEU as a whole without bothering to consider this film's many positives. Considering how much praise certain other blockbusters got, this movie's critical ratings just don't fit.


4. Thor: Ragnarok

Thor Ragnarok Lightning
Marvel Studios

The Film:

The third standalone Thor film, led by an acclaimed director, going a quirky, humorous route and being pitched as a Thor-Hulk buddy cop movie in space.

The Response:

Reviews have been overwhelmingly positive and have praised it as the funniest MCU film to date.

Why They Got It Wrong:

This is a witty, often enjoyable film for sure, but it really isn't anything more than that. It's also just a tonal and aesthetic repeat of Guardians of the Galaxy and that movie wasn't that great either.

In addition to that, the action is forgettable, pathos is non-existent and worst of all, it's just another safe Marvel movie which feels like a factory product.

Have you ever noticed how you're find something funnier if other people around you are laughing? The thing is, most people who found this so hilarious will have watched it in a theater full of people laughing and that will have made the film seem far funnier than it actually is.


3. Baby Driver

Baby Driver Ansel Elgort
TriStar Pictures

The Film:

The latest movie by the amazing Edgar Wright, this is an action movie set entirely to music.

The Response:

It's one of 2017's best-reviewed films and got a lot of 5-star ratings from critics.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Critics complain endlessly about style-over-substance. Here is a film that is entirely style-over-substance yet suddenly it's a great masterpiece?

Baby Driver is extraordinary in regards to action and visuals, so no points removed there. The performances are solid as well, especially from Jon Hamm, but other than that it doesn't live up to the hype.

Fundamentally, it feels like Edgar Wright sacrificing his identity. The Cornetto Trilogy and Scott Pilgrim were lovable, warm, geeky and painfully hilarious. In contrast, Baby Driver is too dark, too cold and very rarely funny. The Cornetto Trilogy had a wonderfully British feel to them, while Baby Driver just feels too Americanized.

The characters and plot are painfully mediocre, yet for some reason, it's been praised as very well-written. In the end, it is perfectly watchable, but would've worked better as a short film. One gimmick cannot sustain a two-hour movie.

The backlash against this film has already begun and it's fallen off the IMDb Top 250 with considerable speed. When you watch it again, you're likely to enjoy it far less and not just because of how uncomfortable it is watching Kevin Spacey following recent revelations about him.


2. Detroit

Detroit John Boyega
Annapurna Pictures

The Film:

Oscar-winning director Kathryn Bigelow and frequent collaborating screenwriter Mark Boal tackle the horrifying true story of the Algiers Motel incident during the 1967 Detroit riots.

The Response:

The film didn't do well at the box office, but was praised by critics and by audiences to a slightly lesser extent.

Why They Got It Wrong:

Great performances, a strong recreation of the time period and a terrifying recreation of the Motel incident aside, this is too emotionless and superficial to be the great film it could easily have been.

Detroit is like reading a Wikipedia article about an event. It tells you what happened, but it doesn't go into why it happened or the human side of the story. It's just a flat, mechanical summary of events.

Meanwhile, Bigelow and Boal are up to their old tricks - filming in a generic documentary style and failing to include actual emotion respectively. Maybe they're the new Tim Burton and Johnny Depp; a pair of frequent collaborators that need to stop doing movies.

The questions about why white people are making a film about black history are just the icing on the cake here. This has already received some backlash and it's easy to see why. It's certainly not a terrible film, but it definitely doesn't need any Oscar nominations.


1. Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Star Wars The Last Jedi Rey Kylo Ren
Lucasfilm/EW

The Film:

The hugely anticipated eighth episode of the beloved Star Wars saga, no-one knew how this one would go before its release.

The Response:

Many have been very positive, but there has been an overwhelming backlash against the movie online. Its discarding of the many fan theories from The Force Awakens, plot twists, different story and the presentation of certain characters have divided many.

Why They Got It Wrong:

The Last Jedi is legitimately one of the best movies of the year. Everything - the acting, emotion, direction, action, story - it's all near-flawless. The backlash it has received doesn't do the film justice.

The Force Awakens faced a backlash for being too similar to A New Hope, yet now TLJ is being trashed for subverting expectations. TFA and Rogue One were endlessly bashed for being a nostalgia-fest but now TLJ is being panned for ruining people's childhoods by moving away from the older films.

The film actually moves the story forward in a fascinating way as well as honoring the franchise's core themes and ideas. It is unsettling to see it move away from previous franchise material at first, but that doesn't make it a bad film. It should be judged on its own merits and not constantly compared to the Original Trilogy which, let's face it, can't ever really be imitated or topped.

It would be wonderful if, like The Empire Strikes Back, this saw a critical re-appraisal but only time will tell.


Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.