12 Directors Everyone Hates Working With (But Get Awesome Results)

Directors from hell who nevertheless get results...

Being a movie director is without question one of the most stressful and demanding jobs in the entertainment industry, given that potentially hundreds of millions of dollars depend on one person's ability to deliver a movie able to find an audience, while ensuring the gainful employment of hundreds if not thousands of cast and crew members. As such, perhaps it shouldn't come as a surprise that it's a profession that tends to attract passionate personalities, passionate to the point that actors often characterise them as difficult, a real pain to work with, or in some select cases, even flat-out psychopathic. With so much on the line, the weak-willed need not apply, but even so, these 12 directors have especially earned reputations for being directors who actors don't especially like working with, even though they tend to turn out satisfactory if not incredible results every time they step up to bat. Whether the captain of a billion-dollar movie enterprise or a low-key indie director, these 12 filmmakers have all been called out for their on-set behaviours in the past by numerous sources, but the end result of their movies at least in part appears to justify their dictatorial, anti-social attitudes. Because the list is focused on living directors, sadly Stanley Kubrick couldn't make the cut, and because it's about directors who make mainly good movies, neither could Michael Bay, despite being a notorious a**hat. Here are 12 movie directors everyone hates working with, even though they turn up great results most if not all of the time...

12. Michael Mann

His Reputation: Michael Mann is known for being a fierce perfectionist on his film shoots: for instance, while making Ali, he insisted upon shooting a scene set in Muhammad Ali's home at his actual house, despite the fact it was on the flight-path of Miami International Airport, meaning a plane would fly past and make dialogue inaudible every 90 or so seconds. While working on Miami Vice, meanwhile, reports emerged that as the production ran over-schedule and over-budget, he routinely chewed out crew members and clashed with Jamie Foxx's "unconventional" acting method. Furthermore, on the set of gangster flick Public Enemies, Depp reportedly found Mann's shooting style so "chaotic" that the two eventually stopped talking to one another. Why He's Worth Working With: To date, Mann has been nominated for four Oscars (two for producing, one for directing, one for writing), and though his more recent work has hardly been his top output, he remains a world-class director who, with the right script, can knock out quality pics every time. With his distinctive visual style and tendency to get actors nominated for Oscars (Russell Crowe in The Insider, Will Smith and Jon Voight in Ali, and Jamie Foxx in Collateral), it's little surprise that actors are prepared to put up with his roughshod directing style.

11. David Fincher

His Reputation: Another savagely perfectionist director is the legendary David Fincher. After his feature debut Alien 3 was butchered by studio interference, perhaps it's no surprise that he has such a huge desire for control, and if necessary, will put his actors through an excruciating number of takes to get a scene right. Case in point, Jake Gyllenhaal spoke to press about Fincher's tendency for extensive takes, even deleting the last 10 takes in front of Gyllenhaal, to which he said, "as an actor that's very hard to hear." Fincher later confessed that this was a psychological trick to see if he could make the actor burst into tears, in order to better reflect the increasingly fractured state of his character. In his own defense, however, Fincher added, "I hate earnestness in performance...Usually by Take 17 the earnestness is gone." R. Lee Ermey, who worked on Fincher's Se7en, meanwhile called the director a "little chicken s***" for being precious about sticking obsessively to the written word rather then improvising. More amusingly, Ben Affleck and Fincher butted heads on the set of Gone Girl over which baseball team's hat he should wear during an airport scene. Why He's Worth Working With: Still, Fincher's films are almost universally critically acclaimed and financially successful, and in addition to earning two Best Director Oscar nominations for himself, he has steered numerous actors to Oscar nods: Brad Pitt and Taraji P. Henson for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Jesse Eisenberg for The Social Network, Rooney Mara for The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, and almost certainly Rosamund Pike for Gone Girl next week.

10. Bryan Singer

His Reputation: Bryan Singer is something of a black sheep in Hollywood right now, because while nothing has been proven regarding his alleged sexual assault of minors, the rumours have remained persistent for years, and regardless of his innocence or not, mud sadly has a tendency to stick. It doesn't help that in 1997, a 14-year-old extra filed a suit against Singer for reportedly asking him and other young boys to shower in the nude for his film Apt Pupil. This in of itself is sure to deter many actors from wanting to work with the actor. Away from gossip, though, Singer has clashed with a few of his X-Men stars on set: Halle Berry famously told Singer to "watch black a** while walks out of here" during filming of X-Men 2, and Ian McKellen has previously noted that the director's directing methods can be challenging and not for everyone. Why He's Worth Working With: Still, he undeniably gets results, and even in the midst of the latest round of sexual allegations against him, his latest X-Men movie Days of Future Past was easily the highest-grossing film of the lot. His career will be fine, and with Singer lined up to keep the cash cow well-milked with next year's X-Men: Apocalypse, there's no way any major actors will be abandoning a nice pay-day any time soon.

9. Oliver Stone

His Reputation: Oliver Stone is a famously explosive director whose rampant drug use earns almost as many headlines as his films do. His legendary tussles on movie sets are numerous, such as telling Jamie Foxx on the set of Any Given Sunday, "you€™re just not good at all, are you?", while after working with Stone on Savages, Blake Lively rather politely called it "an experience", and bought T-shirts for the entire crew reading, "I Survived Oliver Stone". Unsurprisingly, this didn't rub the director the right way at all. On the set of U-Turn, Sean Penn also said that talking to Stone was like "talking to a pig", and while promoting W., Richard Drefyuss called him a "fascist". Furthermore, the filmmaker has even struck behind-the-camera talent the wrong way, by taking Quentin Tarantino's script for Natural Born Killers and severely altering it for the final film, much to Tarantino's disgust and leading to an eventual lawsuit when he attempted to publish his own original screenplay. Val Kilmer also got on Stone's wrong side by intentionally flubbing his lines on the Alexander set so he got to spend more time filming sex scenes with Angelina Jolie, though that's clearly the infamously difficult Kilmer's fault. The guy even said, "I spent four months doing that all day and someone paid me millions of dollars for the pleasure." Why He's Worth Working With: Stone has been nominated for 11 Oscars (6 for writing, 3 for directing and 2 for producing), and won 3, two of which were for Best Director. He's directed a ton of actors to Oscar-nominated performances, including James Woods (Salvador), Tom Berenger and Willem Dafoe (Platoon), Tom Cruise (Born On the Fourth of July), Tommy Lee Jones (JFK), Anthony Hopkins and Joan Allen (Nixon), and a win for Michael Douglas (Wall Street). Though Stone hasn't released an Oscar-grade film in almost two decades, there's still something exciting and dangerous about him that lures in A-list actors, and with that ever-lingering potential for him to make another Platoon or JFK, why not?

8. Abdellatif Kechiche

His Reputation: Though Abdellatif Kechiche might not be a name you immediately recognise, he has directed 5 films to date, his latest being the widely-praised erotic drama Blue is the Warmest Colour. However, in the months that followed the movie's success at the Cannes Film Festival, its two stars Léa Seydoux and Adèle Exarchopoulos, who play lesbian lovers in the movie, called working with Kechiche "horrible" and even "embarrassing". They complained that he was incredibly demanding and opted not to have the movie's extensive sex scenes planned out in advance, which naturally made it much more difficult for the actresses, both of who said they'd never work with him again. Granted, this is the first of Kechiche's movies to earn major attention in English-speaking countries, but it doesn't exactly paint a flattering image of the director, all the more so when he made Seydoux cry at a televised press conference by berating her "ungrateful" attitude. Why He's Worth Working With: Still, the movie speaks for itself as a modern dramatic masterpiece, and though it was a little too niche for the Oscars, it did score Cannes' prestigious Palme d'Or (which, in unprecedented fashion, was shared with the two lead actresses) as well as almost universal critical acclaim. As such, Kechiche's career has survived the negative PR onslaught following the movie's release, and he's currently directing La blessure, starring Gérard Depardieu. Perhaps young ingenue actresses might be a little more wary of working with him, though...

7. William Friedkin

His Reputation: Exorcist director William Friedkin is frequently known for clashing with actors. He claimed that arguments with Al Pacino on the set of Cruising stemmed from the fact the actor "wasn€™t on time and often didn€™t know what we were doing on a particular day", and that he had a "strained relationship" with Gene Hackman while shooting The French Connection because Hackman struggled with his performance. By far his most famous spat with talent, however, was on the set of his iconic horror film. He yanked Ellen Burstyn around violently in a harness to elicit the necessary screams for her performance, giving her a back injury, slapped a Jesuit Priest actor across the face before a take, fired a gun to elicit shock from Jason Miller, and built Regan's bedroom inside a freezer, requiring the crew to wear protective gear. Why He's Worth Working With: Friedkin has been nominated for two Best Director Oscars, winning one for The French Connection, while also directing several actors to Oscar-nominated turns: Roy Scheider (The French Connection), Ellen Burstyn, Jason Miller and Linda Blair (The Exorcist), as well as a win for Gene Hackman (The French Connection). At the age of 79, Friedkin is still a semi-active director, most recently filming the savagely dark thriller Killer Joe in 2011, making it clear that though he hasn't been Oscar's darling for decades, he's still capable of a cracking film every now and then. While difficult to work with, he's also an industry treasure, and that won't ever change.

6. Lars Von Trier

His Reputation: Lars von Trier has a famously frosty relationship with actors as a whole, once declaring, "they are the only thing that stands between you and a good film", and this seems to only intensify when he's working with females. While making Dancer in the Dark with Bjork, the two clashed frequently, with Bjork branding him a cruel sexist, while von Trier said that working with the singer was "like dealing with terrorists". On filming Dogville, Paul Bettany expressed disapproval of the director's methods, stating, "You're not allowed to talk about the film and there is no rehearsal", and John C. Reilly quit the film Manderlay after von Trier demanded to kill a real donkey in one scene rather than use a fake. In von Trier's defense, this was more a budgetary concern than him being a pure maniac, and the donkey was reportedly fed to the crew after its death, but Reilly had enough and flew home. Why He's Worth Working With: Though he's never going to court much Oscar attention, von Trier is one of the most singular cinematic auteurs working today, evidenced no more than by his recent movie Nymphomaniac, which featured a distinguished Hollywood cast including Uma Thurman, Shia LaBeouf, Jamie Bell, Christian Slater, Willem Dafoe and so on. His previous film, Melancholia, meanwhile roped in Kirsten Dunst, John Hurt and Kiefer Sutherland, so it very much seems that his distinctly European weirdness is attractive to some actors, especially those who perhaps need a break from the insanity of Hollywood excess.

5. Tony Kaye

His Reputation: Tony Kaye filmed over 200 hours of footage for his movie American History X, which he made into his own cut before New Line asked him to make a second, significantly shorter cut. Though Kaye's second cut differed majorly, likely in an effort to force New Line to use the original cut, they had none of it and edited a third version with the help of lead Edward Norton, who Kaye didn't even want for the role in the first place, and dismissed as €œa narcissistic dilettante€ who €œraped€ his film. Kaye attempted to disown the film, but was not allowed to. Then when Bryan Cranston was being interviewed about Kaye's most recent film Detachment, the actor tactfully said that the director had failed to honour what he thought was a "beautiful" script, adding, "Tony Kaye is a very complicated€ interesting fellow...I don't believe that I'll be working with him again...And I'm not the only actor on that film to feel that way." Why He's Worth Working With: Eccentric and antagonistic though he is, the third cut of American History X did net Edward Norton an Oscar nomination, while Kaye's 2006 abortion documentary Lake of Fire earned rave reviews and ended up on a number of "Best Of" lists, while the little-seen drama Detachment starred an insane cast, including Adrien Brody, Marcia Gay Harden, James Caan, Christina Hendricks, Lucy Liu, Blythe Danner, William Petersen and of course, Cranston, despite more muted reviews. Kaye hasn't made a feature film since, though if he does, you can bet there will be a line of actors happy to work with him given the brilliance of his debut feature above all else.

4. Marc Forster

His Reputation: Here's a director who has just been an unfortunate magnet for controversy over the last few years, and it's not all his fault. Despite directing numerous films without trouble, 2008's Quantum of Solace was a production nightmare, with the movie pressing on despite the Writer's Guild strike resulting in an incomplete script which Forster and star Daniel Craig essentially had to re-write and punch up themselves. That the results weren't a complete and utter disaster is a miracle, even if the film is considered a huge disappointment compared to both Casino Royale and the subsequent Skyfall, and Forster is said to have struggled with the big-budget shoot. Forster was again beset by production problems on World War Z, albeit this time something he had a little more control over, as he and producer-star Brad Pitt clashed over various aspects of the shoot to the extent that they stopped talking and began relaying messages through others. When it transpired that the third act just didn't work, extensive reshoots took place to completely reshape the end of the movie, reportedly filming as much as 30 or 40 minutes of new footage. Forster hasn't committed to another feature project yet, and given the stress of these two major tentpole flicks, who can be surprised, even if it's undeniably going to reflect badly on him when studio execs and actors consider working with him in the future. Why He's Worth Working With: Even so, he directed Halle Berry to an Oscar in Monster's Ball, and earned Johnny Depp a nod for the Best Picture-nominated Finding Neverland. Furthermore, against tremendous odds, both Quantum and World War Z were critically and commercially successful, so while these tricky shoots suggest that the director is best-suited to lower-budget fare, the juice has proved very much worth the squeeze in the long run. Unlucky or too "green" for blockbuster fare? It's probably a bit of both, but he got by on the skin of his teeth both times, even if he's clearly better suited for dramas.

3. David O. Russell

His Reputation: David O. Russell has one of the most fiery tempers of any filmmaker in Hollywood, reportedly headbutting George Clooney on the set of Three Kings, causing Clooney to call it, "truly, without exception, the worst experience of life." The worst was yet to come for the director, though, when a video of him calling actress Lily Tomlin a "c***" on the set of I Heart Huckabees was leaked online, in which the director had a lengthy, rage-filled outburst. That's without even considering the unsavoury battery charge filed against him for groping his 19-year-old pre-op transgender nephew, which he admitted though insisted the encounter was completely consensual. That's weird enough to already put some actors off from working with you... Why He's Worth Working With: Still, O. Russell has proven himself to be an extraordinary actor's director over the years, directing Christian Bale, Melissa Leo (The Fighter) and Jennifer Lawrence (Silver Linings Playbook) to Oscars, while also helping score nods for Amy Adams (The Fighter, American Hustle), Bradley Cooper (Silver Linings, Hustle), Robert De Niro (Silver Linings), Jacki Weaver (Silver Linings), and again, Bale (Hustle) and Lawrence (Hustle). Russell has himself earned five Oscar nods, three for directing and two for writing. Though the director does appear to have calmed down a little in recent years and cleaned up his act, he's still got an infamous reputation throughout the industry, and as such Clooney won't be the only actor swearing off working with him, even if Tomlin said she would gladly collaborate again.

2. Jean-Luc Godard

His Reputation: Legendary French filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard has been on poor terms with actors for over half a century. All the way back to 1963's aptly-titled Contempt, he referred to Brigitte Bardot as "unbearable" to work with, while he apparently tormented Maruschka Detmers on the set of 1983's First Name: Carmen, and also came to blows with fellow filmmaker Francois Truffaut in 1973 over his treatment of actor Jean-Pierre Léaud (who played Antoine Doinel in Truffaut's 400 Blows), though considering the two worked together on nine films, could it really have been that bad? This eventually led to Godard pretty much swearing off name actors altogether, and over the last few decades, he's barely worked with famous faces at all, using unknowns as suits the budgetary needs of his recent experimental work in particular. Why He's Worth Working With: Still, he's one of the most ground-breaking filmmakers of all time, and if an offer from him ever came a-knocking, there's few actors from Europe or Hollywood who could surely resist the offer. Even so, he seems pretty satisfied with the strange abstract work these days, so it'll likely never happen anyway, to the nervous relief of actors everywhere...

1. James Cameron

His Reputation: And finally, it's the most dictatorial, mean-spirited director in Hollywood, James Cameron! Though his earlier projects saw him using his sheer ballsiness to blag his way into eventually directing Aliens, once he actually made it to the London set to shoot, he clashed with everyone from the cinematographer to his assistant director, and expressed infuriation at the local crew's laid back attitude to tea breaks and clocking off for beers. At the end of the shoot, Cameron famously said, "This has been a long and difficult shoot, fraught by many problems. But the one thing that kept me going, through it all, was the certain knowledge that one day I would drive out the gate of Pinewood and never come back, and that you sorry bastards would still be here." Cameron's next film, 1989's Abyss, was such a hectic shoot that the crew were given shirts reading, "Life€™s Abyss and Then You Dive" and "You Can€™t Scare Me, I Work For James Cameron". Chlorine-treated water caused some of the cast and crew's hair to fall out, Ed Harris very nearly drowned and broke down in tears, and Cameron himself almost drowned also, resulting in him firing his assistant director and safety diver. While Cameron's next few films were largely incident-free, he did take over the role of camera operator briefly during a particularly dangerous shot during the Terminator 2 helicopter chase, something he also did for a similar scene in True Lies. Things got worse, however, with the $200 blockbuster Titanic, where his over-budget, over-schedule production angered studio heads, and he clashed with Kate Winslet in particular, who felt that the water-based shooting wasn't safe (she ended up chipping a bone in her elbow) and said she'd never work with him again short of earning a lot of cash. Numerous crew members were injured or suffered from flu on set while Cameron was reportedly so tyrannical that a disgruntled employee poisoned some soup with PCP, causing Cameron and others to fall ill (but Cameron, whip-smart as ever, vomited it back up and kept filming). Why He's Worth Working With: Still, he's one of Hollywood's most reliably successful filmmakers, having directed the two highest-grossing movies of all time in Avatar and Titanic, while winning three Oscars (including Best Director) and being nominated for three more. He also directed Sigourney Weaver (Aliens), Kate Winslet, and Gloria Foster (Titanic) to Oscar nominations. Working with Cameron guarantees that a lot of people are going to learn your name, and you're probably going to make a lot of money, so while he's extremely dictatorial on set, he does nothing but get brilliant results. Which infamously stern movie director best justifies their behaviour? Shout it out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.