12 Directors Who Blamed Studios For Failed Movies
Josh Trank swears blind his version would have been better...
There could be nothing worse for a creative soul than to have one's hard work and toil undone by the meddling of some irksome Producers. Sure, they may have financed your film and paid you handsomely to be involved, but forcing you to make decisions against your better judgment almost always leads to failure. Considering that these meddling studio hacks are the very people who approved your vision is bad enough, but to then have your name tarnished due to their actions would be one hard pill to swallow.
While many mild mannered Directors have bit their tongues and refused to paint the studio who gave them their opportunity in a bad light, there are many who have just had to say it how it is. While many have tarnished their reputation in the process, others have had the good fortune to 'right the wrongs' with a Director's Cut (or two).
Like most art, 'failure' is very much in the eye of the beholder, which in this case is how certain Directors have viewed their final product. While several movies on this list proved profitable and one was even Oscar nominated, each entry has earned their place here due to their poor quality, tarnishing of an established franchise or just for angering an honest hard working Director.
So prepare to explore the movies that could have been classics had those damn studios not ruined everything, as we look at the Directors who blamed film studios for movies that failed.
12. David Fincher - Alien 3
David Fincher is regarded these days as one of the best directors going around, with his nihilistic stylings embraced by the studios lucky enough to acquire his services. This wasn't the case however for his directorial debut for the much maligned Alien 3. While the film has garnered a stronger appreciation over time, this hasn't stopped Fincher from disowning the film.
After working in the special effects department of many a blockbuster film and taking the Directorial duties for music videos for artists such as Madonna, Fincher was offered the seemingly dream directorial debut role, that unfortunately turned into a bit of a nightmare.
The third alien film was highly anticipated, but with that anticipation came much studio pressure and 'guidance'. As Fincher noted in an interview with the BBC, "when everybody’s wringing their handkerchiefs and sweating and puking blood because of the money that’s being spent and you’re going ‘Trust me, this is what I really believe in’...they turn around and say ‘Well, who the f### are you, who cares what you believe in?’”
While Fincher's original cut of the movie had a runtime of 144 minutes, the theatrical cut was trimmed down by thirty minutes, with a significant subplot completely removed. Losing this aspect of the film appears to be the biggest bugbear for Fincher, which explored the Xenomorph being captured before the character of Golic released it. A directors cut has since been released on DVD, which hopefully has brought some closure for Fincher on the messy affair.
11. Billy Bob Thornton - All The Pretty Horses
No man has left more of a mark on Hollywood in a bad way than Producer Harvey Weinstein. While nothing can compare to his disgusting treatment of numerous women, the loathed Producer is also responsible for breaking the heart of one Billy Bob Thornton. Weinstein monstered Thornton's second directorial feature, All The Pretty Horses, culling crucial scenes and reediting various aspects in spite of Thornton's protests.
Speaking about his own experiences of the film, lead actor Matt Damon outlined a discussion Thornton and Weinstein had about the film that examined the distress it caused the Director. The conversation saw Thornton begging for his film to remain intact, while Weinstein insisted on significant edits to the three hour runtime, and the integration of a whole new music score.
As Damon states, “Billy’s heart was f#cking breaking. [When] he relented, he said, ‘Harvey, I have a chance to do four, maybe five great things before I die. And what I’m hearing you say to me is this isn’t gonna be one of them.”
Thornton though wasn't the only one impacted by Weinstein's interference, with Matt Damon still hurting many years after the film's release. Damon revealed that the original cut of the film produced by Thornton was the proudest moment of his career, with Daniel Lanois' score making the movie, but was heartbroken with Weinstein's final product, which included the removal of Lanois complete score. A Director's Cut has so far not been possible due to Lanois' refusing to allow his score to be used.
10. The Golden Compass - Chris Weitz
An exceptionally odd entry here, with the movie's failure caused by New Line Cinema's sensitivity to the target audience's religious beliefs. Based on a novel by Philip Pullman titled Northern Lights, The Golden Compass explored an alternate Earth where a religious organisation controls all aspects of life. The decision to soften the anti-Religious themes of the book left director Chris Weitz with little room to move, and was largely responsible for the critical and box office bomb the film became.
The director has little doubt where the blame needed to be placed, unloading on the producers while advertising his new film, Twilight: New Moon. "The last film that I made was recut by the studio, and my experience with it ended being quite a terrible one." Other than the significant changes made to his script and pivotal scenes left on the cutting room floor against his wishes, Weitz was also upset with Ian McKellan being chosen by the as the voice of armoured bear Iorek, despite someone already being cast in the role.
While Weitz was rightfully angry with the studio interference, the Producers actions did have some justification considering the significant campaign against the movie's release. Considering New Line Cinema simply wanted a film to cash in on the success of other 'tween friendly' franchises, the last thing they would have expected or wanted was to create an uproar in the community. Still, reading the script before agreeing to finance the film might have been a good idea.
9. Richard Donner - Superman 2
An extremely interesting entry here, as the film was deemed by most to be a critical success- except in the mind of original director Richard Donner. The film proved to be a box office smash, but this didn't stop Donner holding some major grievances with the studio about how they had 'destroyed' his film. Donner was signed on to film the original Superman movie and its sequel back to back, but escalating costs soon lead things astray.
With the release date for the first movie approaching and some final touches still needed to be made by Donner, Richard Lester was brought in to direct the remaining scenes. Despite the sequel being nearly complete under Donner's direction, Lester deleted much of Donner's scenes and added several of his own, primarily so he could get credit as the sequel's Director. Donner was left fuming, with Gene Hackman refused to return for Lester out of respect for the original director.
After years of protests against Warner Bros. for the shoddy way he was treated, the 'warring' parties eventually came to a surprise compromise. WB allowed Donner to complete a Director's Cut of Superman 2 in 2006, choosing to embrace Donner rather than continue to fight him. Much of the slapstick from Lester's entry was removed, scenes featuring Gene Hackman's Lex Luthor were added, and there was amore epic feel to the film all round. The end result was a win-win that hopefully Warner Bros. will use as a template for dealing with Zach Snyder.
8. Zach Snyder - Justice League
An obvious entry here, although this is one occasion where the Director is perhaps a bit harsh on the studio considering the issues with his own work. While Snyder has never openly trash talked the final product for the film he begun to direct, his continual 'leaks' of what would have happened in a 'Snyder Cut' has proved a very clear statement in itself.
A one off 'in passing comment' in regards to how his interpretation would have been different is one thing, but the concerted campaign lead by Snyder to have his vision 'explained' has clearly displayed his displeasure at the mess that was the Justice League movie.
Initial insider reports of the Snyder Cut declared that the film was "unwatchable", although if this was in regards to the aesthetics or overall product remains unclear. It is also yet to be confirmed if the tragic death of Snyder's daughter during filming was the primary reason for him being released from directorial duties, with rumours abounding that it was instead used as an excuse to bring a new director on board.
It seems more and more likely that the Snyder Cut will come out eventually, and it seems like now would be as good a time as any. While a cinema release seems extremely unlikely, the best hope for the Snyder Cut comes through the advent of new streaming service HBO Max. One suspects there will be many 'free trial' offers utilised by customers to give this much anticipated version a view.
7. David Ayer - Suicide Squad
While the film actually managed to make a profit, there is little doubting that in terms of quality and box office expectations, Suicide Squad was an abject failure. The disjointed nature of the story, inconsistent tone, woeful villains and lack of depth in the characterisations meant that the film was yet another black mark for the DCEU. One man who really took the film's flop to heart was Director David Ayer, who has been extremely forthcoming in his critique of the film's production process.
While initially placing much of the blame upon himself for not having Jared Leto's Joker as the primary antagonist of the film, Ayer has since used Twitter to outline how the studio interfered with his film and ultimately caused it to fail. Responding to fan criticisms, Ayer revealed that his initial cut of the film had a far more complex story arc for Harley Quinn, which was simplified significantly for the studio edit. Further tweets from Ayer revealed that The Joker had several scenes that were removed from his version of the movie that dramatically weakened his character arc.
In the past week Ayer has once again fired up debate re Suicide Squad, explaining the rationale behind Harley Quinn's skimpy outfit while coming to the defence of Leto's Joker impersonation once more. Ayer again commented that much of Leto's work was "unseen", a strong inference that Warner Bros. had made a mistake in cutting so much of The Joker out of the final film.
6. Sergio Leone - Once Upon A Time In America
How do you take an iconic mobster flick by a master director and turn it into a disastrous mess? Cut over an hour of footage from the runtime and completely change the story structure. This is what tragically occurred for the US release of Sergio Leone's Once Upon a Time in America, a project that was insanely culled by US distributors The Ladd Brothers without the knowledge of the legendary Italian director.
Despite having over eight hours of footage to use, Leone had managed to trim down his non-linear script down to a 229 minute runtime at the behest of the Ladd Brothers. This version of the film received a standing applause at Cannes and subsequent rave reviews across Europe. The same was not the case for the US release, with a shortened 139 minute version of the film distributed and the non-linear story structure removed. This version was panned by critics, and proved to be a significant box office flop.
Leone was distraught at the changes made to his film, all without his permission. Most cruelly, his masterpiece had been slaughtered for the very audience the film it had been targeted for. The impact on Leone was so much, that actor James Woods believes it was the major contributor to the heart attack that took his life three years later. Considering the film was very much a passion project for Leone, it isn't surprising that the desecration of his film broke the Italian's heart.
5. Gavin Hood - X-Men Origins: Wolverine
When a single movie manages to derail a studio's entire plans, including the abolition of future Origin movies, then you know a film has bombed big time. Such was the case with the much derided X-Men Origins: Wolverine, the first and ultimately only entry in the 'origins' films. Everything about the film fell flat, from the lame action scenes to the disinteresting story, and the awful first appearances of comic heroes Gambit and Deadpool.
If the film's Director Gavin Hood is to be believed, the blame does not lay with him, but with the big wigs at Fox. In fact according to Hood, he didn't even want Gambit or Deadpool in his film at all. At a press junket for his 2016 film Eye in the Sky, Hood opened his heart about the trials and tribulations he endured making the film, with studio interference occurring throughout all aspects of production. Gambit and Deadpool were added to the film at the studio's behest, and even the name of the film was changed without his knowledge, Hugh Jackman informing him after he read it on IMDB!
Hood also noted that he didn't see eye to eye with his second unit director, who was primarily responsible for the stunt sequences, and loathed the 'stunt casting' thrust upon him. To Hood's credit he was extremely positive of his experience working with Jackman and "owned his mistakes", while still clearly pointing the blame for the disastrous experience at Fox Studios.
4. Ridley Scott - Bladerunner + Kingdom Of Heaven
A double entry for Ridley Scott, who clearly doesn't have the same clout as other acclaimed directors around the world. The story related to studio interference in Bladerunner has become legendary, with the studio enforcing the need for narration to explain the events of the film and a contrived happy ending. The changes were made due to poor test screenings, but couldn't save the film from being a box office bomb. Scott finally got his way with a Director's Cut and Final Cut, eventually finishing with the final product he desired.
This was nothing however compared to Scott's experience directing 2005's Kingdom of Heaven, which managed to somehow have more studio interference than Bladerunner. Worried about the over three hour run time and mixed reviews from test audiences, Fox studios forced Scott to make significant changes, including the removal of 45 minutes of footage. The film received mixed reviews and was a box office flop, failing to break even after advertising expenses.
Ridley Scott eventually managed a Director's Cut for this film, which like his BladeRunner cut, received critical acclaim. While it's hard to determine if the Scott version would have been any more successful at the box office, the much improved reviews suggest so. When asked of his opinion regards preview screenings, Scott was rather diplomatic in stating that "a good director should be experienced enough to judge what he thinks is the correct version to go out into the cinema." When it comes to this revered Director, we wholeheartedly agree.
3. Sam Raimi - Spiderman 3
One has to respect Sam Raimi, the Director for the original Spiderman trilogy who had his film largely ruined by the interfering souls at Sony. While clearly outlining how the studios interfered with his vision, Raimi has always come across as more analytical than angry about the changes forced upon him, without shirking his own role in what he describes as an "awful" film.
The major bone of contention for the director was Sony's insistence on having the character of Venom appear in his film. Raimi wanted to wait for future entires to introduce the iconic anti-hero, as he believed that Venom needed his own film to be explored, rather than fighting for screen time with Sandman and Green Goblin. Raimi admits that he never felt comfortable with the film from this point on, unsure of how to best utilise a character that had been shoehorned into his film.
The inclusion of Venom also lead indirectly to the film's much derided 'Emo dance scene', something which Raimi states he now "cringes about". Raimi was also hesitant to take Peter Parker down a darker path, but acknowledged that this had to occur with the inclusion of Venom.
Raimi was forced to turn down Directorial duties for Spiderman 4, due to budgetary and timing constraints that the Director didn't believe he could make. One has to wonder though if the bad experience on Spiderman 3 played a part, with Raimi just being too nice a guy to reveal the truth.
2. Orson Welles - The Magnificent Ambersons
You know that a Director is truly unhappy with his final product when he asks for the film to be removed from his list of credits. That was the case for Orson Welles' The Magnificent Ambersons, a 1942 film that became embroiled in backstage politics. The story followed the Amberson family, the wealthiest in all of Indiana, with Welles' intending on bringing a dark take on the 1918 hit novel.
With the production running overtime and over budget, and with mixed reviews from test audiences, the producers at RKO Radio Pictures renegotiated Welles' contract, removing his editing and exclusive creative control. When Welles took on a semi diplomatic mission in Brazil, RKO utilised his absence and began dramatically altering the film away from the Director's darker version. Nearly an hour of footage was removed, with a 'happier' ending inserted to end the film. Welles was outraged by the final product, explaining that the removal of the dark ending destroyed the whole film. "Without that, there wasn't any plot. It's all about some rich people fighting in their house."
While the film failed to make a profit and was deemed as a failure in the eyes of Welles, it was actually critically acclaimed, and even landed multiple Academy Award nominations. Due to much of Welles original footage being destroyed, he was never able to make his final version of the film, which he claimed would have been better than Citizen Kane.
1. Josh Trank - Fantastic Four
The film that tops this list may just be the one the most undeserved criticism of the studio involved, but wow what criticism it received. While the movie proved to be an unmitigated car crash, Director Josh Trank's willingness to point the finger at Fox studios for the film's failures was mighty harsh. Subsequent reports of the Director arriving drunk on set and having little to no interest in comics seem more authentic reasons for the film flopping- but Trank very much thinks differently.
With the film set to release, Trank released a now deleted tweet that has since became infamous. Trank didn't hold back, stating "A year ago I had a fantastic version of this. And it would've received great reviews. You'll probably never see it. That's reality though." With the film set to be released the next day, Trank's timing couldn't have been worse. This, combined with the overall atrocious quality of the film, lead to the film being a massive box office failure.
Comments in the past week have seen Trank being a little more contrite, admitting that he was "absolutely responsible" for the poor state of the film- but so were many others. In a press junket for his upcoming film, the Tom Hardy starring Capone, Trank lamented the lack of support he got from "more experienced people in the room". The irony of this statement is quite remarkable, with Trank first lamenting the studio interference, but now wishing they'd interfered more!