12 Dumbest Comic Book Movie Characters

Some super-powered stupidity, here...

You always need to suspend your disbelief a fair bit during a comic book movie. Sometimes, though, you have to come to terms with more than just a few wacky superpowers. Every now and then, you need to learn to stomach some seriously super-sized stupidity as well.

The heightened reality of superhero films has always lent itself to silly characters, baffling decisions and infuriatingly dumb moments. Super stupidity can come from any direction €“ from the superheroes, their supervillain enemies or even their supporting cast of characters.

This isn€™t a new thing, either. Even in the days of Michael Keaton and Christopher Reeve, the superhero cinematic landscape has always contained a few goofball characters, often for reasons of comic relief or shoehorned exposition. This has become something of a tradition, with low IQs now considered commonplace in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the X-Men movies and the Nolan Batman films.

Some stupid characters from comic book movies are bearable. Others really aren€™t. Either way, lapses in brain power and/or common sense almost always stand out and take you out of the experience for a moment. Whether you love them or loathe them, here are 12 comic book movie characters without a huge intelligence€


12. Alexander Knox - Batman

Batman Vicki Vale Alex Knox
Warner Bros.

Portrayed by Robert Wuhl, hapless journalist Alexander Knox was a big source of comic relief in Tim Burton€™s first Batman movie. He totally believes in the caped crusader, which actually makes him more intelligent than most people give him credit for. He comes across as a bumbling fool, though.

In particular, he appears pretty dumb when asking questions like €œIs there a six-foot bat in Gotham City? If so, is he on the police payroll? If so, what's he pulling down - after taxes?"

Stupidest moment: Walks into Bruce Wayne€™s arsenal of ancient weaponry and armour €“ doesn€™t clock that he€™s Batman. He doesn€™t even work it out when Bruce tells him he likes his work - loads of which is about Batman - €˜a lot.€™


11. Tony Stark - Iron Man

Okay, yes, Tony Stark is an absolute genius. Scientifically, he€™s one of the finest minds in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. He frequently comes across as lacking in terms of common sense and decision-making, though.

From revealing his secret identity in the first film to doing some impromptu Formula 1 driving in Iron Man 2, Stark is creature of passion who rarely thinks before he acts. This becomes a major problem in Age Of Ultron when his desire to experiment on Loki€™s sceptre results in the creation of sentient murder bot Ultron.

Stupidest moment: €œThere's no politics here, it's just good old-fashioned revenge. There's no Pentagon. It's just you and me,€ Tony says, taunting the terrorist known as The Mandarin before handing out his home address in Iron Man 3. Superhero moments don€™t come much dumber than that.


10. Commissioner Gordon - The Dark Knight Rises

Again, most of the time, Gary Oldman€™s version of Commission Gordon is extremely intelligent. We can even overlook the fact that he doesn€™t work out Batman€™s secret identity, because Bruce Wayne€™s double life remains a heavily guarded secret throughout the Nolan films.

However, there€™s one moment in The Dark Knight Rises that simply can€™t go unpunished. It€™s a spectacular new level of comic book movie stupidity, which got a lot of people killed and almost irredeemably screwed over Gotham City.

Stupidest moment: €œNo more patrols, no more hide and seek. Get every available cop down there and smoke him out€ demands Gordon from his hospital bed, sending every available policeman into Bane€™s hidden base.

This decision leads to a huge number of policemen getting trapped, and allows Bane€™s forces to easily overpower the city€™s remaining defences. Maybe the GCPD should have a rule allowing officers to refuse the commissioner€™s orders when he€™s in a hospital bed on heavy medication.


9. Ian Boothby - Thor: The Dark World

When an unpaid intern offers you a job as her unpaid intern, you€™ve got to be of a certain state of mind to accept the position. Thor: The Dark World€™s Ian Boothby (played by Jonathan Howard) accepted the role, though, which tells you more than enough about his IQ.

He bumbles about throughout the film, pretending to be Erik Selvig€™s son at one stage and startling Jane at another. Finally, he gets things together in the final act €“ epically taking down some Dark Elves and making out with Kat Denning€™s Darcy (before getting dropped on the floor).

Stupidest moment: Towards the end of The Dark World, Ian flails around with Selvig€™s scientific devices, complains that they€™re taped together, then admits that he has no idea what they actually do.


8. Justin Hammer - Iron Man 2

Sam Rockwell€™s role as Justin Hammer in Iron Man 2 is essentially a string of dumb moments interspersed throughout the narrative. He€™s introduced as a threat to Tony in the courtroom, before Tony hijacks his video feed and lampoons all this hard work.

Things don€™t get much from there, with a particular low point coming when Hammer is dumb enough to lie to known villain Ivan Vanko (Mickey Rourke) by bringing him a decoy bird. Didn€™t fool him for a second.

Stupidest moment: €œIt's capable of busting a bunker under the bunker you just busted. If it were any smarter, it'd write a book, a book that would make Ulysses look like it was written in crayon. It would read it to you,€ boasts Hammer about his missile codenamed €˜The Ex Wife.€™ Later, the weapon proves utterly useless, leading Tony and Rhodey to mock him in his absence.


7. Mr. Freeze - Batman And Robin

batman and robin mr freeze
Warner Bros

Pun-happy ice-themed villain Mr. Freeze €“ played by Arnold Schwarzenegger €“ is one of the most frustrating things about Joel Schumacher€™s Batman & Robin. Instead of bringing any really threat to proceedings, he just dispenses lame dialogue like €˜let€™s kick some ice!€™, €˜cool party!€™ and €˜you€™re not sending me to the cooler!€™

He€™s fooled by Uma Thurman€™s Posion Ivy into thinking that Batman killed his wife, before agreeing to a ludicrous plan to freeze the city and let mutant plants take over. He€™s not the sharpest tool in the box by any stretch. He€™s of those unconvincing movie scientists who you really don€™t believe is capable of inventing anything.

Stupidest moment: €œYou know what killed the dinosaurs? The Ice Age!€ is a display of truly terrible historical awareness.


6. Lenny Luthor - Superman IV: The Quest For Peace

How do you make an effective screen villain like Gene Hackman€™s Lex Luthor rubbish? Well, one option is to give him an incredibly unintelligent nephew for a sidekick. That€™s what happened in Superman IV: The Quest For Peace. At one stage Lex even says €œlet€™s keep your IQ a family secret.€ If only they had.

Instead, we get sporadic €˜comedy€™ moments throughout the film where Lenny Luthor €“ played as utterly brainless by Jon Cryer €“ chips in with awful dialogue like €˜you can make a toupee that flies!€™ just to lower the tone.

Stupidest moment: €œYeah, you€™re just an experiment, freako!€ he tells the newly-created Nuclear Man, landing himself in big trouble with the awful super villain, who promptly picks him up and threatens him.


5. Jonathan Kent - Man Of Steel

There are plenty of reasons to hate on Man Of Steel, but one of the film€™s biggest flaws is its handling of Jonathan Kent, played here by Kevin Costner. When Clark first displays signs of heroism, his adoptive father tells him that there€™s more at stake her than €˜the lives of those around us.€™ He shouldn€™t jump in and save people, because the world isn€™t ready for him yet.

This piece of awful advice becomes a driving force for the film, serving to make Kal El somewhat hesitant about embracing his incredible powers. It also results in one hugely questionable scene, though.

Stupidest moment: Pa Kent runs into a tornado to rescue a dog. Clark knows he could easily save him. But to stop Clark revealing his powers to mankind, Jonathan signals for him to stay put. Arguably, he dies as a result of his own dumbness.


4. Curt Connors - The Amazing Spider-Man

Lizard The Amazing Spider-Man
Sony Pictures

Yes, Dr. Curt Connors is a brilliant scientist. However, Rhys Ifans' version of the character from The Amazing Spider-Man, is a little lacking in common sense. It€™s hard to deny that his villainous plan - which consists of turning New York citizens into Lizards for no apparent reason - isn't exactly the stuff of genius.

Connors also dishes out stupidly transparent dialogue straight to Peter Parker's face. Stuff like, €œthere€™s rumour of a new species in New York [€] it can be aggressive, if threatened.€™ He could only be more obvious he had a tail poking out of his lab coat.

Again, though, it€™s in the really tiny details that his true stupidity shines through€

Stupidest moment: Curt Connors leaves a video running in his secret lab that explains his whole plan. It has a video narration, info-graphics and everything. He might as well have just handed himself into the police there and then.


3. Juggernaut - X-Men: The Last Stand

Juggernaut X-Men The Last Stand
Fox

From the second he€™s introduced with the helmet-describing line €œit keeps my face pretty,€ you just know that X-Men: The Last Stand€™s Juggernaut isn€™t going to be the pinnacle of challenging intellectual characters. To be fair, with Vinnie Jones in the role of a hulking brute, it€™d be a little weird if he was.

Even though he can handle himself fairly well in a fight (the scene at Jean's childhood home remains one of The Last Stand's rare highlights), it's hard to build an argument that the Juggernaut isn't one of superhero cinema€™s biggest simpletons. When a villain dispenses dialogue like €œI need to pee€ and €œI€™m the Juggernaut, bitch!€, his idiocy is hugely obvious. There is one more really strong example to back us up, though, if you need further convincing€

Stupidest moment: Despite knowing that he€™s chasing a mutant with the ability to remove other mutant€™s powers, Juggernaut is dumb enough to keep running head first into brick walls. Eventually, the goodies catch him out and send him falling flat on his arse.


2. Max Dillon - The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Amazing Spider-Man 2 Electro
Sony Pictures

From his very introduction, you know Jamie Foxx€™s Max Dillon is going to be a bit of a comic relief bad guy. €œYou know my name?!€ he asks Spider-Man, without realising that he€™s wearing a very prominent name badge.

After this, he becomes instantly obsessed with Spidey€™s superheroic and eventually bases his entire foray into villainy on the fact that the webslinger doesn€™t instantly recall their brief chat when prompted. Well, that and the sad truth that no one cares that it€™s his birthday. To be fair, most grown up€™s don€™t get too worked up about each other€™s birthdays€ right?

Stupidest moment: Shortly before becoming Electro, Max climbs up onto a railing to try and fix a cable. He€™s clearly not wearing enough protective clothing, nor taking any meaningful safety precautions, and subsequently goings flying into a tank of electric eels. That€™s less of a tragic backstory, and more of a simply stupid bit of decision making.


1. Gus Gorman - Superman III

Superman III Richard Pryor
Warner Bros. Pictures

There could, of course, only be one winner. Comic book cinema€™s greatest idiot has to be Richard Pryor€™s Gus Gorman, from Richard Lester€™s Superman III. Like a lot of the people on this list, we€™re meant to believe that Gus is some sort of genius (due to his computer coding skills), but his entire demeanour contradicts that suggestion.

Right at the start of the film he€™s conducting a huge scam at his new workplace by stealing all the half pennies floating around in the system. He doesn€™t even consider trying to hide his new wealth, and decides to buy a fancy red sports car and drive it to work the next day. And that€™s hardly the worst of it.

This is a guy that sides with the villains and barely even seems aware of what he€™s doing. He designs the ultimate killing machine then looks surprised when his bosses try to turn it on Superman (who has foiled their plans consistently throughout the movie). And when Superman takes pity on him at the end of the film and finds him a job, he promptly decides to jack it in less than a minute after Supes has left. He's stupid and ungrateful.

Stupidest moment: It€™d be hard to top the scene where Gus falls off a skyscraper with skis and a makeshift cape on. The reason for this? He forgot to mention that he couldn€™t ski.

Have we forgotten any other stupid comic book movie characters? Let us know in the comments...


In this post: 
Iron Man
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Film & TV journo. Quite tall.