12 Movie Casting Decisions That Fans Couldn't Handle

The fans threw a tantrum, deservedly or not.

Batman Robert Pattinson
Warner Bros.

Film fandom can be a wonderful thing, a joyous appreciation of life-enriching entertainment - but as we've seen so many times, sometimes that enthusiasm gives way to embarrassing, if not worrying, obsessiveness.

The very worst side of any fanbase tends to come out when a hit franchise makes a casting choice that, at a first glance, seems to come out of left-field.

Rather than stay pragmatic and consider what an unexpected actor could bring to a role, the Internet tends to veer towards doom and gloom with a disturbing efficiency.

But even long before the Internet was a thing, fans of comic book movies and other smash hit IP have acted as fiercely childish gatekeepers, throwing their toys out of the pram whenever a seemingly ill-fitting name lands a marquee role.

Now to be clear, sometimes the fans are actually right - no matter the petulant way they go about it - and sometimes an actor is indeed totally wrong for a part.

But more often than not, fandoms end up blowing peculiar casting wildly out of proportion, to the extent that it embarrasses the overall fanbase and, if the casting pays off, looks mightily silly in retrospect...


12. Daniel Craig - James Bond (Casino Royale)

Casino Royale Daniel Craig
MGM

When MGM announced that Daniel Craig would be the new James Bond back in October 2005, fans were nothing short of incensed.

With rumours suggesting that the more traditionally Bond-y likes of Clive Owen, Dougray Scott, Hugh Jackman, Henry Cavill and Karl Urban were in talks for the part, Craig's casting came majorly out of left-field.

The tabloids quickly dubbed him "James Blond" due to his lighter hair colour than is traditional for 007, while fans also complained about other superficialities, such as Craig's relatively short stature and his more square-faced appearance compared to previous Bonds.

Between this and the inherent riskiness of MGM rebooting the Bond franchise post-Die Another Day, many fans were convinced that Casino Royale would mark a new low for a franchise with its fair share of them.

Did It Work Out?: Absolutely. Anyone who'd seen Craig in Matthew Vaughn's Layer Cake knew he could pull it off, and the actor acquitted himself terrifically with a hard-edged, brutal, psychological Bond like the franchise had never seen before.

Some went as far as to praise Craig's performance as the finest since the Connery days, and regardless of where he ranks among Bonds for you personally, there's no denying that the fan hand-wringing was totally off-base.


11. Topher Grace - Venom (Spider-Man 3)

Spider-Man 3 Venom
Sony Pictures

Spider-Man fans sure were excited when it was confirmed that legendary villain Venom would finally make his big-screen debut in Sam Raimi's third movie.

Yet that optimism quickly cratered once Sony announced that the dual role of Eddie Brock/Venom would be played by...Topher Grace.

Grace, who was still best-known as Eric Forman from That '70s Show at the time, didn't match the bulkier and more imposing Brock from the comics, and fans simply felt that he wasn't threatening enough to play the web-slinger's iconic antagonist.

Did It Work Out?: Sadly not. This isn't a knock against Grace as an actor at all, but he just wasn't the right fit for this part.

The script does at least attempt to re-imagine Brock as a more conniving and pathetic character than in the comics, but Grace doesn't bring much charisma or interest to Brock, nor much physicality to Venom either.

Constantly seeing the Venom mask peel back to reveal Grace underneath was underwhelming if not unintentionally hilarious, and over a decade later, it remains one of the most baffling casting misfires in blockbuster history. Sometimes the controversy is justified, as it absolutely was here.

Thankfully Tom Hardy's playing Venom these days, and a far better fit - to say nothing of the movie itself.


10. Chris Evans - Captain America (Captain America: The First Avenger)

Captain America The First Avenger
Marvel Studios

Casting Captain America was one of the most important tasks in the early days of the MCU, given that he'd ultimately become a cornerstone of the franchise for almost a decade.

And so, when Chris Evans landed the part, fans were wildly divided. At the time, Evans was largely known to audiences for his gregarious role as Johnny Storm in Fantastic Four, and there wasn't much indication that the star of Not Another Teen Movie could match the earnest heroism of his comic book counterpart.

With Ryan Phillippe and John Krasinski among the final contenders for the role, many felt that Evans was a misguided pick - and we later learned that Evans himself even turned the role down a few times for fear of being locked into a restrictive contract.

Did It Work Out?: Obviously. By the end of The First Avenger's first act, even hardened cynics were surely sold, with Evans nailing both Rogers' salt-of-the-Earth likeability and the more exuberant, muscle-bound physicality of his super-powered Cap.

Evans went on to become one of the MCU's most popular characters - second only to Robert Downey Jr.'s Iron Man, surely - and enjoyed a lengthy tenure which met a poignant conclusion in Avengers: Endgame.


9. Kristen Stewart - Snow White (Snow White & The Huntsman)

Snow White And The Huntsman Kristen Stewart
Universal

As much intrigue as there was surrounding a gritty new Snow White movie in the vein of The Dark Knight, hope was almost immediately quashed once Kristen Stewart was cast as the iconic heroine.

Stewart, who was in the midst of wrapping up her tenure in the Twilight franchise at the time, came across as a cynical choice motivated solely by the financial success of Twilight rather than her suitability to the role.

More to the point, the Internet at large felt that Stewart was too "plain" to play a character as uniformly beautiful as Snow White, a problem exacerbated by the casting of Charlize Theron as the evil Queen Ravenna.

Were audiences really to believe that Charlize would fear that her beauty was being usurped by the rather bookish Bella Swan?

Did It Work Out?: No, but it wasn't a total disaster. Stewart's performance turned out more forgettable than bad, and was predictably outshone by Theron in both the looks and acting departments, making her rendition of Snow White ultimately feel a bit flat and wonky.

Unsurprisingly, Stewart opted not to return for the (awful) 2016 prequel-sequel The Huntsman: Winter's War, with Snow White only appearing via brief archive footage of Stewart from the first movie.


8. Hugh Jackman - Wolverine (X-Men)

X Men Hugh Jackman
Fox

Russell Crowe was in fact the first choice to play Wolverine in the original X-Men movie, but he ended up turning it down and recommending his pal Hugh Jackman instead.

Jackman's casting was immediately controversial with comic book fans, given that the actor had precious few film roles under his belt at the time, and outside of his native Australia was known largely for his work in musicals.

Simply, Jackman didn't seem to match the comic book Wolverine one bit, and if you do some digging around online, you can still find the 20-year-old evidence of fans' doubts over the casting.

Did It Work Out?: Unquestionably, and with the benefit of hindsight, it's hard not to laugh at fans ever being concerned.

Jackman may not have been hugely physically imposing in the first X-Men movie, but he brought heaps of charm to the table and quickly established himself as the most popular X-Men movie character.

Jackman further developed and elevated the role over almost two decades of sequels and spin-offs, where he packed on the muscle to create arguably the most definitive screen portrayal of any superhero.

This culminated, of course, with his universally-acclaimed final performance as Wolverine in 2017's Logan.

Jackman was so damn brilliant in the role that Hollywood actually might leave Wolverine alone for a little while, because a hasty recast would only invite unfavourable comparisons to his exemplary work.


7. Tom Cruise - Jack Reacher (Jack Reacher)

Jack Reacher Tom Cruise
Paramount Pictures

Tom Cruise is no stranger to being embroiled in contentious casting, what with Interview with the Vampire's own author Anne Rice initially deeming him miscast as Lestat, and many considering him unsuited to play Germany army Colonel von Stauffenberg in 2008's Valkyrie.

But Cruise's most recent controversy occurred when he was cast as Jack Reacher in Christopher McQuarrie's 2012 adaptation of Lee Child's much-loved thriller novel One Shot.

In the novel series, Jack Reacher is a military police vet with blonde hair and blue eyes, but most importantly, he's 6 feet, 5 inches tall, and weighs between 210-250 pounds.

It doesn't take a detective to figure out that Cruise is a far cry from every single one of these attributes, with his dark hair, green eyes, mere height of 5 feet and 7 inches, and weighing roughly 150 pounds. Fans weren't buying it, and went into the film with a strong air of scepticism.

Did It Work Out?: Yes and no. Cruise gave a characteristically entertaining performance, for sure, but never once did he really feel like the Jack Reacher of the source material.

Nevertheless, the film's success led to a (terrible) sequel, before Child decided to end the movie franchise and reboot Jack Reacher as a TV show.

Child said recently of Cruise's work on the films, "The idea is that when Reacher walks into a room, you’re all a little nervous just for that first minute. And Cruise, for all his talent, didn’t have that physicality."

You can't argue with that, really. Cruise was fine under the circumstances, but fans deserve better than such a loose, unfussed treatment of an incredibly popular character.


6. Heath Ledger - The Joker (The Dark Knight)

Heath Ledger's Joker
Warner Bros.

And now we come to pretty much the Holy Grail of unexpected casting that was (initially) reviled by fans.

Despite rumours swirling that Paul Bettany would be cast as The Joker for Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight, the part eventually went to Heath Ledger, to the baffled bemusement of, well, just about everyone.

Ledger, who was best known for his performances in frothy movies like 10 Things I Hate About You and A Knight's Tale, not to mention his Oscar-nominated turn in Brokeback Mountain, was basically the polar opposite of who fans expected.

Nothing on Ledger's CV really suggested he was an inspired pick to play the Clown Prince of Crime, and fans voiced their displeasure online in droves, claiming he would "ruin" The Joker and consequently Nolan's movie.

Did It Work Out?: Though Ledger tragically passed away before his performance hit screens, it became clear from the release of the film's first trailer that Ledger had defied fanboy salt to deliver a daring, bravura rendition of the character.

Ultimately, Ledger's free-wheeling interpretation became the film's most distinctive and widely-praised aspect - in a film that sure didn't want for plaudits - even going on to win a posthumous Best Supporting Actor Oscar.

And over a decade later, Ledger's Joker remains a high-point for not only cinematic superhero villainy, but movie antagonists as a whole. Whenever fans run their mouths about a casting choice, it's always useful to keep Heath Ledger in mind.


5. Scarlett Johansson - The Major (Ghost In The Shell)

Ghost In The Shell Scarlet Johansson
Paramount

For as long as cinema has existed, Hollywood has been guilty of whitewashing characters to cynical ends, shoehorning whiter-than-white brand names into roles that, by all rights, should be played by people from the character's actual race or ethnicity.

And though we're (thankfully) decades removed from John Wayne donning "brown-up" and a ridiculous Fu Manchu moustache to play Genghis Khan, white actors are still routinely being cast in roles not really meant for them.

Case in point, eyebrows were raised when Scarlett Johansson was cast as The Major in Hollywood's big-budget adaptation of Ghost in the Shell.

In the manga, the character was Japanese (naturally), and many felt that casting a white American actress was insulting if not downright offensive. Petitions were even circulated requesting Johansson to be recast, but to no avail.

Did It Work Out?: Johansson was fine enough in the part, but both her performance and the film as a whole struggled to escape the icky feeling that the casting invited.

Moreover, the script misguidedly attempted to fold the whitewashing controversy into the plot, by revealing in act three that Johansson's shell in fact housed the soul of the original Japanese woman, Motoko Kusanagi.

Some saw it as a bold and ambitious attempt to confront the hand-wringing head-on, but most simply thought it was rubbing salt in the wound - the filmmakers wanted to whitewash their movie and make a half-assed attempt to justify it narratively.

"Justice" prevailed for the complainers, though, as the film tanked critically and commercially.


4. Idris Elba - Heimdall (Thor)

Thor Heimdall
Marvel Studios

Back when Idris Elba was cast as Asgardian sentry Heimdall in Thor, the MCU faced one of its first early casting controversies.

A white supremacist group, the Council Of Conservative Citizens, mounted a campaign to boycott the film on the grounds that a Norse God would never be black (given their European ancestry).

This sparked a general debate about race-blind casting in movies and the difference between whitewashing a character and - wait for it - "blackwashing" them.

Elba himself quite rightly laughed the controversy off, calling it "ridiculous" that anyone would whine about a cast member's race in a movie with so many wilfully ridiculous elements.

And thankfully, most sensible people agreed with him, even if that hasn't stopped a small quarter of definitely-not-racists complaining about it to this day.

Did It Work Out?: Absolutely. Nobody with a fully functioning brain stem cared that Heimdall was black, and though the part was relatively underwritten throughout his MCU run, Elba did a great job with what he had.


3. Zoe Saldana - Nina Simone (Nina)

Nina Zoe Saldana
RLJ Entertainment

After Mary J. Blige had to drop out of playing Nina Simone in Cynthia Mort's biopic, she was replaced with...Zoe Saldana.

A tidal wave of controversy ensued once the first set pictures made their way online, depicting Saldana in garish prosthetics and having been "blacked up" to more closely resemble the legendary crooner.

The issue was ultimately two-fold: Saldana's casting felt like a cynical attempt to lend the movie a brand name above all other priorities, given that Saldana's facial structure is nothing like Simone's (hence the prosthetics), to say nothing of her decidedly lighter skin tone.

When we're talking about a fictional superhero, that's fine, but a real-life figure? It's important to get the facts right. Simone's family added to the dogpile by calling Saldana's casting "Gut-wrenching, heartbreaking, nauseating, soul-crushing." Yikes.

Did It Work Out?: Not remotely for anyone involved. Saldana really tried to make it work, but her lack of resemblance to Simone was distracting - as were the attempts to make her more so - and the film itself was a painfully stodgy, woefully generic biopic.

Released more than three years after principal photography wrapped, the film was a box office dud and is currently rocking a brutal 2% on Rotten Tomatoes.

As much as we all like Zoe Saldana, this was a most ill-advised career move. Thankfully for her, few people actually bothered to watch it.


2. Michael Keaton, George Clooney, Ben Affleck & Robert Pattinson - Batman (Batman '89, Batman & Robin, Batman V Superman & The Batman)

Ben Affleck The Batman
Warner Bros.

Perhaps no prominent role in the pantheon of pop-culture has been as routinely whined-about as that of Batman - which speaks as much to the finicky nature of hardcore comic book fans as it does the Caped Crusader's popularity.

First up, we have Michael Keaton, who prompted 50,000 complaint letters to Warner Bros. after being cast in Tim Burton's '89 Batman.

Best known for his comedic roles prior to casting, many fans just didn't believe he could go to the dark places necessary for the character.

His successor Val Kilmer actually fared relatively well, as aside from his well-earned reputation for being difficult on-set, there didn't seem to be too many complaints about him taking up the mantle.

But when George Clooney took the reins for Batman & Robin, the knives were out, with many fans questioning why That Bloke From E.R. was cast as Batman.

Up next, fans were relatively confident about Christian Bale's casting in Batman Begins for the most part, saving up all their hateful energy to complain about Heath Ledger's Joker.

Yet a veritable s***storm unfolded online when Ben Affleck was unexpectedly cast as the DCEU's Batman, citing Affleck's failure as Daredevil in his 2003 solo movie.

And finally, with the recent news that Warner Bros. is looking to close a deal with Robert Pattinson to play the superhero in Matt Reeves' The Batman, a number of petitions have already started doing the rounds begging WB to pick somebody else. The ink isn't even dry on the contract yet...

Did It Work Out?: Keaton absolutely knocked it out of the park, and despite Tim Burton's filmmaking eccentricities, he nailed the deranged nature of Bruce Wayne better than anyone else.

Clooney was a complete wash, in large part due to the film being absolutely horrendous, but also because Clooney gave a depressingly one-note, charisma-free performance.

Affleck did a wonderful job with what he had, but he was ultimately hamstrung by the material and ended up bailing out of the DCEU far sooner than fans wanted him to.

As for Pattinson, we'll have to wait and see, but given his clear talents as an actor, it's certainly an ambitious and exciting casting pick (assuming it does indeed stick).


1. Renée Zellweger - Bridget Jones (Bridget Jones's Diary)

Bridget Jones The Edge Of Reason Renee Zellweger Hugh Grant
Universal

When it came to casting the titular lead in the movie adaptation of Helen Fielding's acclaimed novel Bridget Jones's Diary, Universal was originally looking at a host of English and Australian actresses, including Helena Bonham Carter, Cate Blanchett, Emily Watson, Rachel Weisz and Toni Collette.

Yet the two-year casting search concluded with the producers selecting American actress Renée Zellweger, who was born in Texas no less.

With her rail-thin figure and vocal scepticism over her ability to convincingly play the Brit protagonist, fans were infuriated, stirred up no end by relentless tabloid coverage of the casting.

Many felt that, just as James Bond is traditionally reserved for British actors - bar a few exceptions - so too should Bridget Jones have cast an actress from the U.K.

Did It Work Out?: Absolutely. Zellweger took the part seriously, gaining 20 pounds to more closely resemble Bridget as written, and working with an accent coach to sound convincing as a Brit.

She knocked the role out of the park, and were viewers unaware of Zelleger's origins, they'd likely never have guessed she wasn't British. The film was a smash hit with critics and audiences, leading to two successful sequels.


Watch Next


In this post: 
The Batman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.