12 Movies That Wasted Great Twist Ideas

11. My Bloody Valentine 3D— The Hero Is The Killer

Life Itself Twist
Lionsgate

Released in 2009, My Bloody Valentine 3D is a largely agreeable slasher effort from Scream editor Patrick Lussier.

A remake of the eighties film of the same name, this cheesy psychological horror follows a miner returning to his hometown on the anniversary of a gory murder spree, and it's filled with inventively gory death scenes and even a few tense chases. Okay, so only one sequence can muster up much in the way of truly chilling atmosphere (the house chase, for the record), but this flick does see one victim fed head first into a ceiling fan, so it's hard to hate.

However, the audience goodwill the remake musters is squandered by its bizarre ending. Desperate to twist the original film's admittedly uninspired killer reveal, this flick goes for a hokey "it was our hero all along" twist.

It's a particularly frustrating decision as the reveal may well have worked if the audience watched the entire preceding film from the hero's perspective, allowing the director to throw them off the scent.

Instead the film jumps seamlessly between his distorted view of proceedings to a more objective detached reality, and as such the ending becomes a cheap trick which adds little to the flick.

In this post: 
Life Itself
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.