12 Sci-Fi Movies That Purposefully Mess With Your Head

Some sci-fis just revel in melting your mind...

Existenz Jude Law
Miramax

Ah the venerable institution of the sci-fi mind screw. Is there any other genre as perfectly suited to messing with the audience’s heads? Only science fiction could hold host to the imaginings of Philip K. Dick and William Gibson, and it’s the lone genre which could leave directors with track records as bizarre as Alejandro Jodorowsky’s and David Lynch’s vying for the reins of a major studio release like Dune.

Maybe it’s the fantastical possibility inherent in time travel, space exploration, and faraway alien planets, maybe it’s just the increased suspension of disbelief which the genre allows—whatever the cause, sci-fi has been home to plenty of mind warping narratives over the decades, some genius and some unwatchable-y pretentious.

Good, bad, or stuck in between, here are a few sci fi movies which messed with viewer’s head, but did so for good reason, whether it was in service of a twisted moral to their story or just a more inventive and playful way of telling it.

12. Primer

Primer Still
THINKFilm/IFC Films

Shane Carruth’s debut is infamous for its twisty, almost impossible to unravel timeline, and the flick went on to inspire everything from British Bermuda Triangle set chiller Triangle to Spanish thriller Timecrimes, an equally impressive microbudget effort from a fellow emerging genre auteur.

The film follows a pair of scientists as they attempt to understand and experiment with perfecting their accidental discovery of a time travel method, and it leaves the process frustratingly impossible to decipher for mainstream audiences thanks in large part to Carruth’s own real life background in advanced mathematics and engineering.

By the time the film reaches its enigmatic close, the audience is left certain that they can make sense of the storyline and its many versions of the protagonists who exist across various timelines within a stable time loop—we’ll just need a pen, some paper, and a few years to work it all out.


11. 2001: A Space Odyssey

2001 Space Odyssey
MGM

The granddaddy of psychedelic sci-fi, Kubrick’s classic almost defies genre categorisation by the time it reaches its trippy conclusion. Sure, the spaceship-set thriller element of the story is very much rooted in hard sci-fi traditions, and the out-of-control onboard computer H.A.L can be seen as another cautionary tale of unchecked artificial intelligence outgrowing its intended use.

But once the flick reaches Jupiter, our preconceived ideas of where all this is going go out the window in favour of increasingly trippy visuals and a trip into psychedelic time-and-space warping inter-dimensional travel. Believe it or not, everything from the significance of the monolith in the film’s opening to the enigmatic image of the star child is explained in the novel Kubrick was adapting, and canny viewers can actually decipher the existential journey depicted in the film.

Guess we better list this one alongside Stephen King’s The Shining and Anthony Burgess’ A Clockwork Orange as another Kubrick literary adaptation wherein the director took as many liberties as he liked with the source text.


10. Cube

Cube Movie
Trimark Pictures

Released in 1997, the horror-thriller-sci-fi hybrid Cube served as a stylish, unsettling calling card for director Vincenzo Natali, who would go on to helm everything from 2009’s underrated medical experimentation cautionary tale Splice to last year’s Joe Hill adaptation In The Tall Grass.

In a premise that would leave the likes of Franz Kafka and Jean Paul Sartre seething with jealousy at its ingenious simplicity, the film sees a set of mismatched characters awaken inside a small cube shaped room, with the group gradually progressing between shifting rooms of identical dimensions, whilst losing members to both the traps hidden in said rooms and mounting paranoia amongst its members.

And that’s it. We never learn how they ended up there, why this certain set of characters were chosen for this unfortunate fate, or what this is all in aid of. The film’s much maligned sequels began filling in some blanks, but in the process missed the purpose of Natali’s movie—the film is about how the social contract held between people falls apart under duress, rather than the specifics of this group’s brutal plight.


9. EXistenZ

Existenz Jude Law
Miramax

Released only shortly after the Wachowski Sister’s era-defining The Matrix, eXistenZ is a similarly trippy dip into the mind of Canadian sci-fi horror auteur David Cronenberg.

The flick was a departure from the helmer’s usual formula of combining a simple story with mind blowing-ly gruesome effects as seen in everything from The Brood to Scanners and The Fly. Starring Jude Law and Jennifer Jason Leigh, the film owes more to Cronenberg’s adaptation of William S Burrough’s disturbing literary classic Naked Lunch than The Dead Zone, and it still stands out amongst the director’s oeuvre.

The plot follows Leigh’s video game designer as she tests out her most recent immersive virtual reality experience whilst being pursued by assassins (or is she?). However, the film never makes it clear whether the action we’re watching is part of the titular game or reality and also never clarifies which characters know they’re in a game (if, indeed, they are) leaving us in slippy narrative territory where no one can be trusted and it’s impossible to gauge the risk faced by the cast - like a good video game.


8. Stay

Stay 2005
20th Century Fox

A rare flop from journeyman director Marc Foster who has helmed everything World War Z to Monster’s Ball, Stay left critics howling upon its 2005 release. The film was derided as too self-serious and suffering from a burdensome, over-complicated plot, but the complex narrative can actually be unravelled with ease once the viewer is aware of the pivotal twist revealed at its close.

You see, the characters played by Ewan McGregor and Naomi Watts are actually only projections imagined by the real protagonist, Ryan Gosling’s Henry. Suffering survivor’s guilt after a car crash, Henry recontextualises the moments before his death to create a story for the last moments of his life in a new-millennium remix of Ambrose Pierce’s iconic An civil war era short story An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge.

With this twist in mind the film’s myriad turns and hard-to-follow plotting make much more sense, and whilst the film is still no Jacob’s Ladder, its story is made more original and provocative when viewed through the lens of its climactic reveal.


7. The Butterfly Effect

The Butterfly Effect
New Line Cinema

Hated upon its release in 2003 for tackling heavy, disturbing themes with a less-than-subtle stylistic palette more reminiscent of MTV than art cinema, The Butterfly Effect has since gone on to be reconsidered by critics in the decades since. The film follows troubled student Evan as he attempts to undo the many tragedies and traumas which plagued his childhood and ruined the lives of his friends, as well as leaving Evan himself burdened with frequent blackouts.

Does sound like pretty heavy material for That 70’s Show era Ashton Kutcher, doesn’t it?

However, following the logic of the eponymous theory, each attempt only leaves Evan’s friends in worse stead than before. The film illustrates the untraceable effect we have on one another’s live in both its theatrical and (vastly superior) alternate endings, both of which see Evan remove himself from the lives of his friends entirely, thus saving them from their hopeless fates.


6. Cloud Atlas

Cloud Atlas
Warner Bros.

The Wachowski sisters were once critical darlings for their contribution to mind-bending genre cinema, with 1999’s The Matrix being hailed as a landmark for the sci-fi genre on the cusp of the new millennium. However as more instalments in the franchise were released and the backstory of the series became increasingly labyrinthine, the sequels soon fell out of favour with critics even as they continued to impress at the box office.

Cue 2009’s genre-defying epic Cloud Atlas, an adaptation of the singularly strange novel of the same name by British author whose six storylines run from the nineteenth century through to the distant future of the twenty fourth. The same actors play different characters, or possibly the same souls in different bodies, in an ambitious sprawling epic which hopes to move between timelines in order to illustrate some essential truths about humanity and our connection to each other.

As you may have guessed from that description, the film flopped at the box office and failed to connect with audiences, though critics have since said the massive multi-story movie has its merits.


5. Donnie Darko

Donnie Darko
20th Century Fox

No list of sci-fi mind screws would be complete without a visit from everyone’s favourite moody teen and his creepy rabbit best mate Frank. Anchored by a career-igniting performance from Jake Gyllenhall, Richard Kelly’s Donnie Darko tells the story of a small-town teen plagued by cryptic visions of an impending apocalypse and attempting to decipher the clues whilst also getting into standard-issue “misunderstood teen tries to navigate suburban existence” scrapes.

The story may be hard to parse first time around, but unlike Kelly’s later flops The Box and Southland Tales there’s method to Donnie’s madness. Eagle eyed viewers - or those who have watched the film obsessively - will be able to understand that the film actually tells, in glimpses, the story of Donnie’s eventual self-sacrifice, with his pivotal role in the events surrounding him foreshadowing his ability to save the world.

Or you can just keep enjoying it as an impeccably sound-tracked mind f**k, your call.


4. Under The Skin

Under The Skin 600x400
StudioCanal

Directed by Birth helmer Jonathan Glazer, a mercurial talent who rarely puts together projects and never explains them after, Under the Skin sees Scarlett Johansson cast against type - like, way, way against type - as an unnamed alien roaming the Scottish highlands in search of human males to mate with and eventually consume via a strange ritual.

However, despite the description, the film is a far cry from the multiplex-packing Species rip-off it sounds like and has more in common with the meditations of Andrei Tarkovsky than say, Decoys 2: Alien Seduction.

Though critics remain divided on what it all means, man, many have noted that the character’s projections of their fantasies onto Johansson, as well as her own blank slate countenance, make the film an interesting allegory for the gender roles we choose for ourselves as well as the ones foisted upon us by society, making for a good pairing with Anna Biller’s The Love Witch.


3. Beyond The Black Rainbow

Beyond the Black Rainbow
Magnet Releasing

Director Panos Cosmatos delighted audiences in 2018 with his psychedelic horror-thriller Mandy, which benefited from a paper-thin plot that allowed Nic Cage to go full Nic Cage as a grieving husband slaughtering a semi-demonic biker gang who murdered his titular wife. It’s a shame the helmer couldn’t return to collaborating with the beloved (if demented) actor for the acclaimed Lovecraft adaptation The Colour Out of Space, but we guess genre icon Richard Stanley will do.

Before Mandy hit our screens, however, Cosmatos had already impressed genre buffs with his first film, the ambitious Beyond the Black Rainbow. A dark sci-fi indebted to the nihilistic genre fare of the seventies such as George Lucas’ debut THX 1138, Beyond the Black Rainbow tells the strange story of a young woman with psychic abilities been held captive by a strange scientist in a New Age retreat.

Many found the film impossible to read, but a glance into the politics of the director (whose father is legendary Greek filmmaker George P. Cosmatos) reveals that the institute’s machinations can be read as society’s attempts to control and regulate its citizens, with Reagan’s America taking the brunt of the films satirical ire.


2. Coherence

Coherence Film
Metrodome Distribution

Director James Ward Byrkit must have been influenced by Vincenzo Natali’s Cube, also included in this list, for his trippy debut feature. Coherence seems to tell the story of a young woman who is plagued by bizarre encounters the night of a comet’s passing over earth but re-watching the flick will illuminate a whole new layer of meaning for viewers willing to delve deeper into the mind-bending thriller.

What’s actually going on is - spoilers for the uninitiated - our protagonist Em is, along with her assembled friends, able to travel between alternate versions of their universe due to a split in the space-time continuum which has rendered it possible to travel between their versions of reality.

This leads to double crosses, escape gambits, and eventually even murder as each character attempts to leave one reality for another, with our nominal hero reduced to trying to destroy one of her doubles in order to assume her place and failing.


1. Moon

Moon Sam Rockwell
Sony Pictures Classics

Who knew a film from the son of legendary lunatic David Bowie would be weird, right?

In this thoughtful slice of sci-fi from future Warcraft helmer Duncan Jones, Sam Rockwell plays Sam Bell, a lone space station employee left out on the moon, mining nuclear material alone for years at a time.

Only that’s not quite the case, as we discover once he nears retirement - Sam is one of many clones of himself, a warehouse full of whom inhabit the lunar outpost ready to be deployed once each serves their three years and begins to break down. This realization comes midway through the film and throws the opening half into sharp relief, with the reality that our protagonist has never been himself occurring to us the audience at the same time it becomes clear to him.

From thereon out the movie is easier to track, but only upon a re-watch will viewers be able to understand the film’s treatment of themes as diverse as identity, conformity, and the work/ life balance under late capitalism.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Existenz
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.