12 Worst Casting Decisions In Marvel Movies

Not everyone can be as perfectly cast as Robert Downey Jr.

Superhero movies made from Marvel comic books have been at the forefront of pop culture in recent years. Whenever a trailer is released or a new movie release date is announced, the entertainment industry sits up and takes notice. Part of the success of Marvel comic book films can be attributed to great casting, so much so that it's difficult to imagine anyone else other than Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stark or Hugh Jackman as Wolverine. But not every casting decision can be a home run. For every actor or actress who was perfectly cast in a Marvel superhero movie, there have been some atrocious casting blunders that make you wonder 'how could they possibly thing X could portray X?'. Here are twelve actors who were horribly miscast in some of Marvel's biggest comic book films. Just a reminder, this list covers every Marvel superhero film, so expect to see entries from the X-Men and Spider-Man movies, as well as movies from the Marvel Cinematic Universe.


12. Tobey Maguire - Peter Parker/Spiderman

To be fair, Tobey Maguire wasn't terrible as Peter Parker/Spider-Man and he did capture some elements of the struggle in living a secret life quite well, but his take on the character was far from the multi-layered smart-talking hero of the comic books. Peter Parker is a unique character in that he starts off being a geeky and naive kid who grows up to enjoy being Spider-Man. Whilst everyone definitely got more than enough geeky awkwardness from Maguire's performance (to a fault at times), his Spider-Man was mopey and whiny instead of fun and exciting. All of Parker's trademark wise-cracks and cock-sure arrogance were nowhere to be seen and Maguire's Spider-Man took on a more 'woe-is-me' kind of vibe instead. And for all the comments about his youthful looks, Maguire (and Andrew Garfield for that matter) is just too old to convincingly pass off as a young Peter Parker. And just for all those people defending Maguire's Spider-Man, just remember that awful emo haircut and that terrible dance sequence in Spider-Man 3.

11. Rebecca Hall - Maya Hansen

Maya Hansen was a key character in the Iron Man Extremis storyline and is one of the scientists who created the Extremis virus. So when it was announced that Iron Man 3 was to adapt the Extremis story arc and the awesome Rebecca Hall was cast, there was potential for Maya Hansen to be an interesting character. Unfortunately, Marvel and Hall fumbled the ball on this one. Comic book Maya Hansen was a scientist with a genius intellect who looked out for her own best interests in regards to her work. In Iron Man 3 however, Hall seemed to have taken that character, got rid of any semblance of genius she might've had, and turned her into nothing more than a woman who was scorned and wants nothing more than to get back at Tony Stark for not calling her. Hall's version of Maya was so inconsistent from scene to scene that the character seemed more at home in a psychological horror film than a comic book film. It's hard to blame everything on Hall for this blunder as the material for the film wasn't particularly great and she's normally pretty good at the whole acting thing, but you can't help but feel like she just didn't know what to do with the character.

10. Terrence Howard - Captain Rhodes

Before Don Cheadle took the reins on War Machine and managed to do quite a bit with a relatively smart part, Terrence Howard had the first turn as Colonel James Rhodes in the first Iron Man film. Based on his take on Rhodey though, it's probably a good thing that Howard never got to put on the War Machine armour. Rhodey is meant to be a tough and commanding leader, but Howard's performance was soft-spoken, meek, and definitely not leadership material. It was difficult to picture how such an unassuming guy could lead a bunch of troops into battle, let alone one day commanding the War Machine armour without needing to ask for a book of instructions. Not only was it tough to buy Howard as a high ranking officer in the military, his rapport with Robert Downey Jr. seemed more along the lines of a nagging house-wife than best friend. Thankfully, Howard was fired after the first film and replaced by the infinitely better Don Cheadle. Howard has still made occasional bitter-filled comments about how Marvel treated him and how they didn't want to pay him properly. This stuff might or might not be true, but here's a new theory, maybe they fired him because he just wasn't very good?

9. Natalie Portman - Jane Foster

Natalie Portman has played a teenaged killer, a stripper, a compulsive liar with epilepsy, and a ballet dancer with serious mental issues, so taking on the role of an intelligent scientist should've been a walk in the park. But whatever the reason, Portman's take on Jane Foster was surprisingly tame and unremarkable. Everything starts off well enough when Foster is introduced mid-experiment to audiences. However, when Thor lands on Earth and decides to wander around the place shirtless, Portman takes Foster from being a smart and independent woman to a lovesick teenager making googly eyes at the new handsome stranger. You can literally track the de-evolution of Jane's character when Portman goes from saying stuff like "They stole my life's work, so I don't have much to lose" in the first Thor to being incredibly annoying and saying stuff like "I was right here where you left me. I was waiting, and then I was crying, and then I went looking for you' in the second Thor. Portman seems like a very intelligent woman who carries an air of respectability, so seeing her start as strong and smart character before descending into generic girlfriend territory is tough to watch. After seeing what she can do in V For Vendetta, it's quite disappointing to see Portman waste her time in a sub-par film and giving out a generic performance that basically boils down to 'he's hot so I'm going to help him'.

8. Gwyneth Paltrow - Pepper Potts

Despite the Iron Man films basically being vehicles to showcase Tony Stark's best Robert Downey Jr. impression, Pepper Potts actually takes up a surprisingly decent amount of screen time. This wouldn't be so bad had Pepper been a fun and interesting character, but unfortunately, Gwyneth Paltrow seems to have lost all of her Oscar-winning talents when she was cast. Pepper doesn't exactly have the biggest role in the comic books beyond being brilliant as Stark's assistant, meaning that there was room for Paltrow to give some more substance to a character who grounds and humanises Tony Stark. With uninspired readings of lines such as 'there's only 8,011 things that I really need to talk to you about' and 'I quit. I'm resigning. My body literally can't handle the stress', what Paltrow did instead was turn Pepper Potts into a boring and uninteresting character who basically exists to be annoying and to remind Stark that he's being a douche. At almost no point does Paltrow infuse Pepper with any semblance of brilliance beyond shooting quips whenever some 'humour' is needed, so it's quite difficult to see what makes Pepper so 'special' in Stark's eyes when she is really quite a nothing character who is mostly a damsel in distress. Paltrow's bland and irksome take on Pepper is so unremarkable that it was difficult to get excited when the character got some actual powers in Iron Man 3. You can't help but feel Gwyneth is in the film because they needed some additional star power in case the first Iron Man movie flopped.

7. Julian McMahon - Doctor Doom

Doctor Doom is an incredibly intimidating and diabolical character who happens to be wickedly smart. Putting someone who is basically menace personified on-screen would've been awesome but unfortunately, they got the actor who plays that womanising guy from Nip/Tuck to play the part of a deranged megalomaniac and the results weren't pretty at all. Rather than trying to capture the character's trademark menacing presence or deranged intellect, Julian McMahon decided to turn Doom into a self-obsessed pretty boy who couldn't scare a kid off a swing-set and was more concerned about his hair than with science. The film's script and direction was admittedly awful, but McMahon adopting a 'don't really care' approach to the film and not even having the common courtesy of doing anything eccentric or crazy with the character was probably the toughest thing for Doctor Doom fans to handle. McMahon is a good enough actor on his day and it would've been awesome had he played along, but instead he was nothing more than a lightning-shooting playboy who wore a metal mask because the director told him to.

6. Halle Berry - Storm

Halle Berry rightfully copped a heap of criticism for that terrible Catwoman film, but since this is about Marvel movies, let's focus on her role of Storm in X-Men. The verdict? Not quite as bad as Catwoman, but still pretty terrible. Storm is meant to be a powerful and regal figure who commands respect wherever she goes but Berry made Storm so unremarkable and so passive that the character was more of a distraction than anything else. But worse than making a character who could is afraid of her own shadow is Berry's attempt at giving Storm some stupid and inconsistent accent. If you're going to use an accent for a character, stick with it for every scene and don't just abandon it whenever you feel like it. And after all that, let's not even get started on the horrendous 'toad' and 'lightning' debacle. It seems like Halle Berry and superhero movies are not a good mix so let's just all hope that Storm can be redeemed in the upcoming X-Men movie.

5. Topher Grace - Eddie Brock/Venom

Eddie Brock/Venom is supposed to be an violent and scary thug who uses intimidation against his enemies, not a 90-pound guy with spiky blonde hair who just so happens to be Eric Foreman from That 70's Show. Brock's story in the film is similar to the comics is tragic as the character was simply a guy trying to do the right thing and was driven to do bad stuff after he makes one mistake and his life falls apart. Topher Grace brought a smart-ass frat-boy persona to the character that was completely wrong and made the character into a douche who gets everything he deserves rather than a sad guy just trying to do something right. So rather than draw the audiences' sympathy in by using the character's tragic backstory, Grace eschewed away from the source material and Brock became just another generic bad guy for Spider-Man to beat up. And that's not even the worst aspect of Grace's performance. Eddie Brock is a physical powerhouse of a man who is imposing and athletic, but Grace will forever look like the kid who is always picked last for sports, no matter how much bulking up he does. There's just so little right and so much wrong about Topher Grace as Venom that it's probably for the best that he has shied away from comic book films ever since.

4. Christopher Eccleston - Malekith

Thor: The Dark World is probably the worst film in Marvel's superhero filmography. You can take shots at the film's mediocre story, acting, and spectacle over substance schtick, but everything was dragged down by having Malekith as a lackluster villain and having normally-great Christopher Eccleston do a pretty unremarkable job with the character. With his English accent, Eccleston does manage to bring some sort of regal-ness to Malekith, but everything else was severely lacking. Eccleston isn't physically imposing enough to convincingly take on Thor, he made Malekith incredibly glum and far too serious, and you just couldn't feasibly accept his motivations beyond 'I want to destroy everything'. All these flaws resulted in a boring one-note villain who is blander than the shade of his skin and that is incredibly disappointing as Marvel had cast someone who played Doctor Who and can cycle between drama and humour on a whim. The material was admittedly pretty weak, but there was no reason why someone as talented as Eccleston couldn't at least do something more with Malekith than making him just some forgettable road block.

3. Nicholas Cage - Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider

It feels kind of wrong (and possibly dangerous) to slander the Internet's one true god of acting, but it needs to be said: Nicholas Cage was absolutely terrible as Johnny Blaze in both Ghost Rider movies. As undeniably talented as Cage is, whoever cast him as a daredevil stuntman who rides around on a flaming motorcycle as the personification of hell on wheels was either a monkey or the world's biggest Nic Cage fanboy. Whereas Johnny Blaze is meant to be a young and brash anti-hero who can be badass one second and incredibly scary the next. What everyone got instead was two movies featuring a middle-aged man channeling his best Nic Cage impression. Aside from looking completely wrong for the role (and requiring a hairpiece and CGI abs), Cage took Johnny Blaze from being a dark and serious character to a weird and campy caricature who twitches excessively. It was sort of heartbreaking to put Nic Cage on this list as he is a self-proclaimed big fan of Ghost Rider and comic books in general, but there are just some things that aren't meant to be and Nic Cage playing any comic-book superhero is just one of many.

2. January Jones - Emma Frost

If you've watched January Jones as Betty Draper on Mad Men, then you'll know that her character polarising but she can at least do some good acting as a cold and closed-off house-wife. Well Jones definitely brought that polarising aspect but none of the good acting with it when she was cast in X-Men: First Class. Emma Frost is well known for being an interesting and complex character who has considerably more layers to her personality than the layers of clothing she wears. What Jones did was take an interesting character and turned her into a mono-syllabic, emotionless, and completely forgettable woman who wore skimpy clothing and has a permanent case of resting b****-face. Bored suburban house-wife with daddy issues and a limited emotional range works well in Mad Men, but it just doesn't fit a comic book movie, let alone a character who is meant to be the perfect femme fatale. The only character with an emotional range within Jones' acting ability is probably Wolverine and you can probably imagine how that would turn out.

1. Jessica Alba - Sue Storm

For all the flack the the 2015 Fantastic Four reboot gets, the 2005 film was just as bad. But whilst the 2015 film had a great cast (that was wasted) as one of the few highlights, the 2005 film inexplicably cast Jessica Alba as Sue Storm. The character of Sue Storm is not only smart and brilliant, she is essentially the glue that held the team together whilst everyone moped around. Instead, Alba's take on the character had about as much emotional range as a store mannequin and the 'chemistry' with her co-stars essentially amounted to them putting up with her because they have to. Alba probably is quite a smart person in real-life but nothing she said or did in the film could constitute as being supportive or brilliant. Putting a pair of glasses on a hot girl and having her deliver lines like "You were at 4,000 degrees Kelvin! You were approaching Super-Nova!" doesn't automatically make her smart. Hell, when the movie managed to make up a contrived excuse to get Alba out of her clothes just so she can 'use her powers', you know they cast her just for her looks. The cinematic Sue Storm material has been horrid for all the Fantastic Four movies but whilst Kate Mara could do something with a half-decent script, you can be sure that Alba would still be just as wooden and one-dimensional even if the script was the next Citizen Kane.

Contributor
Contributor

My life story is nothing special. I haven't cured ebola, I'm nowhere near stopping terrorism, and I'm still working on that climate change problem. Instead, all I've done so far is put a few hundred words together in an attempt to make people laugh. You can follow me at @Fry_ying_pan but don't be offended if I don't tweet back. It's usually because I've spent too long trying to think up a witty response that the reply window has closed.