13 Gloriously Hammy Performances In Comic Book Movies

Respected actors that just put it all out there!

The release of the first promotional still from the upcoming Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, featuring Ben Affleck€™s Batman engaged in an intense staring contest with his feet, has inspired less fevered speculation and more widespread mockery. €˜Sad Batman€™, as the image was quickly christened, seems to be the culmination of DC€™s fumbled campaign to distinguish its new cinematic universe from its embarrassing funny book origins, like a teenager who rebels with a particularly awful haircut. No bad puns or maniacal laughter here, folks: this is serious business. As the marketing department responsible for Sad Batman presumably has had to write on the blackboard 100 times, the line between seriousness and self-parody is a thin one. Comic books are filled with implausible situations and larger than life characters, and their film adaptations tend to work best when they embrace that fact rather than wilfully ignore it. It follows that some of the most memorable moments in comic book film history, if not necessarily the best, come courtesy of otherwise perfectly respectable actors who left restraint behind and set about devouring the scenery. €˜Less is more€™ couldn€™t be further from the truth when it comes to these performances, so prepare yourselves for a countdown of gloriously hammy comic book movie stars.

Honourable Mention: Brian Blessed (Flash Gordon)

Although 1980s cult classic Flash Gordon is technically a comic strip adaptation, it does excel in the campy theatricality which was a hallmark of early comic book films. It was hardly revolutionary on its release and it€™s considerably dated now, but one actor has managed to forge a career and reputation in its wake. Brian Blessed€™s infamous bellow of €œGORDON€™S ALIVE!€ remains the most enduring legacy of Flash Gordon aside from its Queen soundtrack, and it set a high standard for overenthusiastic actors in the future. Blessed is also notable amongst these entries because Flash Gordon is almost entirely populated by actors sorely lacking in indoor voices. Everyone involved apparently thought they knew exactly what kind of movie they were making and decided to enjoy it accordingly, so it must have been a pleasant surprise to find it was actually the kind of movie which would be remembered for decades to come, if only for one very loud line.

13. Christian Bale (The Dark Knight Trilogy)

Christopher Nolan€™s reinvention of Batman for the current film-going generation intentionally bears very little resemblance to the far hammier Tim Burton interpretation, but that€™s not to say that the film is a master class in understatement. Neither Heath Ledger, Cillian Murphy nor Tom Hardy holds back in their respective villainous roles, but Christian Bale is a rarer example of a heroic character who regularly propels spittle into his opposite number€™s face.
It€™s not just the voice, but it is mainly the voice, isn€™t it? Bale as Bruce Wayne is strangely composed, at odds with his more flamboyant persona in some versions, while as Batman he is all imposing physicality and that gargling voice which he uses for basic conversations and interrogations alike. Most actors in this list are ranked for only one film, but Bale apparently realised that his interminably angry and/or choking Batman was becoming a meme and decided to up the ante for the sequels. He€™s never quite unintelligible, but he€™s never far from it, either.

12. Faye Dunaway (Supergirl)

Faye Dunaway€™s presence in box office bomb and critical dud Supergirl, which also features Peter O€™Toole phoning it in, doesn€™t quite make the film watchable, but it€™s as good as we get. Her melodramatic performance as the wicked witch Selena makes it obvious that she knew exactly how seriously to take her cardboard cut-out of a villain, and admittedly, her lines don€™t require much in the way of subtlety. It€™s difficult to command the €œpower of shadow€ quietly. Instead, Dunaway draws out all of her lines with absurdly long vowels and misplaced emphasis, which only highlights the script€™s shortcomings. When Selena uses her magic, Dunaway conveys it with a fixed stare and increasingly strange gestures, which does nothing to distract from the awful special effects. It€™s almost a calculated attempt to take all of Supergirl€™s many flaws and turn them up to eleven, which is both unnecessarily cruel and somehow satisfying.

11. Jeff Bridges (Iron Man)

€œTony Stark was able to build this in a cave! With a box of scraps!€ Until that beautifully overwrought line, Jeff Bridges is unremarkable as Obadiah Stane. It€™s not difficult to pick out Stane as the villain of the piece, and Iron Man rightfully spends its time introducing Tony Stark rather than misleading us about a character who€™s known as one of Iron Man€™s earliest enemies in the comics. The character is fairly flat until, out of nowhere, Jeff Bridges cuts loose on an unsuspecting Stark Industries employee, who barely manages to stand up while Bridges shrieks in his general direction. Bridges also relishes Stane€™s monologue about his overlooked work for the company, which is of course delivered while smashing up vehicles in the giant Iron Monger suit. Quite why Jon Favreau felt that voice modification was necessary in that scene remains a mystery, because if nothing else, Bridges proves that he sounds more terrifying without it.

10. Gerard Butler (300)

Zack Snyder€™s lurid interpretation of the Frank Miller comic book miniseries earned him a reputation for stylish action sequences and box office success which likely won him the director€™s chair for Man of Steel, but 300€™s leading man isn€™t overshadowed by Snyder€™s odder directorial flourishes. In part that€™s simply because Butler€™s ability to bellow unconvincing lines of dialogue rivals even Brian Blessed€™s; it€™s no accident that 300 spawned so many memes. Any number of action flicks have silly scripts, but it€™s Butler€™s unflinching commitment to roaring Leonidas€™ lines that we have to thank for the film€™s enduring popularity seven years later. That€™s a dubious honour if ever there was one.

9. Nick Nolte (Hulk)

Ang Lee's Hulk remains divisive over ten years and two more live action Hulks later. It has a meandering storyline, which introduces Bruce Banner€™s father and a genetic predisposition to transformation, and it also tries to deal with some bigger themes (daddy issues, anyone?) rather than providing an hour and a half of excuses for Hulk to smash. The focus on the dramatic gives Nick Nolte an opportunity to ham it up as the unstable David Banner, and his appearances are a much-needed diversion from the constant angst. Nolte also offers perhaps the only example in cinematic history of an actor literally and metaphorically chewing the scenery at the same time, as he gnaws on a cable in one of the film€™s climactic scenes. He€™s electrocuted in the process and emits a noise somewhere between a howl and a wail before transforming into a messy CGI version of the Absorbing Man. After Nolte spends the best part of the film alternately shrieking and rasping at Eric Bana€™s Bruce, this hardly seems strange at all.

8. Anthony Hopkins (Thor)

2011€™s Thor was never going to be subtle. Directed by one of Hollywood€™s most notoriously hammy actors, Kenneth Branagh, and drawing inspiration from the often gleefully camp Thor comics, it only needed an over-the-top performance to complete the comic book adaptation trinity. Chris Hemsworth does give it his best shot and makes his way through the film with the enthusiasm of a Labrador puppy, but he€™s no match for Anthony Hopkins, whose Odin is truly the King of Ham. Even when Hemsworth musters his greatest bellow and pouts like a beefier Zoolander, Hopkins responds by delivering his overwritten lines with all the grandeur of Lear. At one point words apparently fail to muster enough emotion for him and he simply unleashes a guttural growl towards Tom Hiddleston, who steps back in quite possibly genuinely fear. Rumour has it that the Odinsleep was the only way to preserve the scenery for the duration of filming.

7. J. K. Simmons (The Spider-Man Trilogy)

There€™s a reason that comic book fans pick over castings rumours about supporting roles in as much detail as those concerning the protagonists. Superheroes who€™ve been around for decades have acquired supporting casts which are as famous and as integral to their stories as they are themselves, and it€™s gratifying when the supporting players are given the attention they deserve. Maybe the general public hadn€™t heard of J. Jonah Jameson prior to Sam Raimi€™s Spider-Man trilogy, but J. K. Simmons has made him one of the most memorable parts of Spidey€™s cinematic universe. Simmons remains one of the most perfectly cast actors in any comic book adaptation. His Jameson is just the right combination of misguided, paranoid and unquestionably dedicated to the job, with an uncanny knack for reading the audience€™s mind: €œGuy named Otto Octavius winds up with eight limbs. What are the odds?€ He€™s also hamming it up spectacularly in every scene; the spittle is almost palpable through the screen whenever he shrieks at an employee, but it€™s impossible to imagine anyone surpassing Simmons in the role.

6. Kevin Spacey (Superman Returns)

The vitriol levelled at Superman Returns has largely dissipated in the wake of Man of Steel and in the build-up to Batman V Superman. It€™s almost possible to re-watch Superman€™s adventures as a deadbeat dad without that familiar righteous anger. Kate Bosworth is miscast as Lois Lane but inoffensive in the role, and Brandon Routh does his best with subpar material. Then there€™s Kevin Spacey in the overactor€™s role of a lifetime, Lex Luthor, as whom he delivers a performance which seems more credible with each passing year. Spacey€™s most famous scene in Superman Returns sees him explaining his master plan to Lois Lane in the tradition of villainous megalomaniacs everywhere. If you can momentarily ignore the plan itself (to sink America, raise sea levels, and create real estate opportunities), which is ridiculous, and the presentation, which involves a slideshow of remote-controlled maps including one of the planet helpfully labelled €˜World€™, you can spend the scene thoroughly enjoying Spacey at his hammiest. He smirks, waves his hands up in the air, giggles, and wiggles his ears, and still nothing prepares you for that ear-splitting yell: €œWRONG!!€ Fortunately, Luthor€™s a character who lends himself to exaggeration, and Spacey€™s performance was acclaimed at the time as one of the only redeeming features of the film. It remains to be seen whether Jesse Eisenberg can match it.

5. Arnold Schwarzenegger (Batman & Robin)

Batman & Robin killed the original Batman film franchise and the careers of several of its stars, but at least it managed to commit dozens of ice puns to the silver screen, right? Arnold Schwarzenegger€™s Mr Freeze exists only to deliver these puns efficiently and loudly. If he had much else to do, he might be even higher on this list, but Arnold essentially has no choice but to be hammy in the face of lines like, €œDo you know what killed the dinosaurs? THE ICE AGE.€ Much like almost every actor conscripted to play a one-note villain in a Batman film, with the aforementioned exception of Tommy Lee Jones, Schwarzenegger also looks like he€™s enjoying himself. Why wouldn€™t he when he gets to exit one scene with a thumbs-up and the words €œcool party€, and another on a rocket? It€™s said that Schumacher used to remind his actors, €œRemember, it€™s just a cartoon!€ Almost the entire cast of Batman & Robin could have featured in this article, but Schwarzenegger€™s performance is as cartoonish as it gets; with a character like that, it couldn€™t really have gone any other way.

4. Nicolas Cage (Ghost Rider And Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance)

Nicolas Cage€™s taste for scenery is well documented elsewhere, and his starring turns in comic book films are by no means the most heinous examples of overacting in his filmography. In fact, although his Adam West pastiche in Kick-Ass is fun in places, they are collectively disappointing, and none more so than the Ghost Rider films. Of course, since it€™s Nicolas Cage, he still earns the number four spot on the list even when he isn€™t firing on all cylinders. Cage is a lifelong comic book fan (who named his son Kal-El, if you recall), and after Hollywood deprived him of the chance to play the Big Blue Boy Scout in Tim Burton€™s failed Superman project and consequently redefine the term €˜overacting€™ for ever after, he turned to Johnny Blaze and Ghost Rider. Both films were received poorly, but whenever Cage is onscreen, he does deliver his usual brand of insanity; his pained expressions in the transformation sequences have likely never been made by another human being. Unfortunately, the cinematic Ghost Rider is an otherworldly CGI skull, and even Cage can€™t do anything with that. He€™s relegated to the background while the CGI obligingly fulfils the requirements of the plot until he can return to human form and unleash Cage upon the scenery once more. It makes for two films which are difficult to watch even for fans of Mr. Cage€™s wilderness years, if only because it€™s almost sad to think of what could have been.

3. Terence Stamp (Superman II)

Terence Stamp€™s portrayal of Zod in Superman II is so iconic that Michael Shannon, who took on the role for Man of Steel, was asked in interviews whether he would repeat the catchphrase, €œKneel before Zod!€ (He didn€™t, sadly.) Stamp never failed to deliver that line with the combination of menace and smugness which he brought to his entire performance, and which made for one of the most memorable supervillains in any comic book adaptation. Zod speaks almost constantly in the third person at a glacial pace and at one point, as the broadcast cuts out on his message to Superman, just shrieks his own name for no apparent reason. One eyebrow is always slightly raised in mockery, and he also rivals Nick Nolte for Most Spectacular Wail as Superman crushes his hand in his final scene. All of this is accomplished while Stamp is dressed in what appears to be a fashionable black bin liner. Stamp€™s version of the character differed from his comic book counterpart, but the former proved so popular that it was adopted in the comics shortly afterwards. Live action Superman has yet to face a more compelling or hammier foe.

2. Tommy Lee Jones (Batman Forever)

The jarring tonal shift between 1992€™s Batman Returns and 1995€™s Batman Forever was a deliberate one. Tim Burton€™s two Batman films adhered to his typically gothic style, and Returns had been darker and less family-friendly than its predecessor, which was seen as a factor in its comparatively low box office haul of $163 million in the U.S. and Canada. Joel Schumacher was conscripted to lighten up the Batman franchise, and Batman Forever was the camp and messy result. Those fans familiar only with Aaron Eckhart€™s nuanced portrayal of Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight will balk at Tommy Lee Jones€™ ludicrously over-the-top interpretation of Two-Face. Even Jim Carrey is powerless to match the desperation with which Jones chews the scenery, and that€™s saying something. Barely a minute passes in which Jones doesn€™t either double over in maniacal laughter or utter a series of apparently involuntary grunts and snickers, as if lines are suddenly beyond his power. When he is forced to be silent, he looks hilariously uncomfortable, and moments later usually ends up bouncing around the set like a toddler on a sugar rush. Jones€™ Two-Face actually has more in common with Jack Nicholson€™s Joker than the comic book character he was supposed to represent, but his incredibly goofy performance is at least an enjoyable antidote to film€™s sluggish plot.

1. Willem Dafoe (Spider-Man)

To be fair to the casts of the Schumacher Batman movies, even those with semi-developed character arcs were forced to deal with some of the most outlandish costumes ever seen in a comic book film. Willem Dafoe likely could have sympathised, since the Green Goblin€™s suit in Sam Raimi€™s Spider-Man resembles a Power Ranger suit which has undergone a Pimp My Ride makeover; it doesn€™t ooze gravitas. Then again, the Goblin has never been the straight-faced type, and Dafoe surpasses all expectations with his enjoyably nutty performance. In fact, Dafoe€™s most triumphant scene doesn€™t feature the suit at all. Norman Osborn confronts the manifestation of the Goblin in the mirror, and Dafoe switches from the clear terror of Osborn€™s human side to the snarling reflection seamlessly. He could obviously have given Christian Bale some tips when it comes to a suitably gravelly voice, but it€™s his wide-eyed, toothy facial expressions which haunted children€™s nightmares. Dafoe€™s Goblin doesn€™t even die without a dramatic gesture: he delivers a final breathy line and then falls forward onto his glider with what can only be described as gusto. In hindsight, it€™s a little bit sillier than we remembered, but Dafoe cast a long shadow over future cinematic Goblins. His performance is a fine example of a gloriously hammy performance which should be ridiculous, but somehow circles back around to fantastic. It seems unlikely that it€™ll be topped any time soon.

Contributor

Grace Murray hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.