13 Incredible Performances By Otherwise Terrible Actors
The good from the bad and the ugly.
When a good actor offers a terrible performance, it tends to be big news. All of a sudden, the Internet is awash with speculation as we all seek to find blame for this uncharacteristic drop in form from such usually dependable talent. It must be the director or the material or something obviously just wasn't right behind the scenes...There's always a reason, as fans try desperately to stop the one rotten apple ruining their entire CV.
And luckily for them, there does tend to be a lot of forgiveness out there for a rare miss - especially if they manage to get back on track with their next movie. After all, the world of bad movies is one built on quick-sand and not managing to get out straight away can be catastrophic.
That's why there are so many actors who seemingly make careers out of never actually being any good. They're there to take on the bad material so better talents don't have to, and most of the time they seem to know their lot. But then, every now and then these poor actors somehow manage to show flashes of uncharacteristic brilliance, shocking everyone who assumed they didn't have it in them.
And to be honest, that can end up being frustrating: because it's very clear that they've simply been squandering their potential in every other movie...
13. Vin Diesel - Find Me Guilty
When you look back at Vin Diesel's CV, it's fairly clear that you get what you should expect from the actor. His are the shoulders upon which the Fast & Furious franchise has been built (even if there are more charismatic individuals in there) and he's been the foundation for xXx and Riddick franchises too. Not to mention having a voice so deep that he's the only viable choice for giant robots and tree men...
But he's rarely offered up any performances that can reasonably be considered great. He's pretty good briefly in Saving Private Ryan and his turn in Boiler Room is okay, but since then he's mostly bounced around action films that rely more on muscle and might than nuance and subtlety. And when he's been asked for more range, he's come up somewhat short.
But that wasn't the case in Find Me Guilty, the courtroom drama from Sidney Lumet that sticks out so much on his CV you almost wonder whether he was lost on set. It's actually not that great a fill, but Diesel is excpetional as real-world gangster Jackie DiNorscio - a spiritual cousin to Joe Pesci's My Cousin Vinnie, who seeks to represent himself. He's vulgar and jokes a lot, and there's far more charm here than Diesel has managed anywhere else in his career.
12. Orlando Bloom - Lord Of The Rings
When Orlando Bloom broke out and into Lord Of The Rings as shimmery-haired, enigmatic elf Legolas, it looked like we had a big star in the making. He had those ethereal elven good looks and a youthful glimmer in his eyes that seemed to suggest he'd go far.
And while he's since been in some pretty huge blockbusters - mostly related to Pirates and the Caribbean, to be honest - he's never been anything like as good as he was as Legolas. For that role, he was both regal and boisterous (thanks to his dynamic with Gimli) and his involvement in the action sequences is some of the best in the entire series.
Sadly, his high-points since then have been few and far between and even his dependability as Legolas evaporated somewhat when he returned for The Hobbit.
11. Tim Allen - Toy Story
In Home Improvement and the Santa Clause movies, Tim Allen essentially plays the same character - a man-child not quite suited to his situation, which inevitably leads to hi-jinx. He's charming enough in them, but he's far from a great actor, with painfully limited range and appeal.
But he's legitimately brilliant as Buzz Lightyear in the Toy Story movies, where another culture clash role comes off perfectly thanks in part to the arrogance and self-confidence that underpins most of his roles. Lightyear is an old school jingoistic military man dropped into a cynical world whose reluctance to see the truth is as hilarious as his moment of realisation is devastating.
He's sidelined a little in the other movies as Woody remains the main character, but in that first movie he offers one of the best ever Pixar vocal performances.
10. Jai Courtney - Suicide Squad
In the run-up to Suicide Squad's release, the idea of Jai Courtney playing a villain as silly as Captain Boomerang was a significant cause for alarm and humour (depending rather on how you wanted the film to turn out). This was - after all - the actor who had been terrible in Die Hard 5, awful in I, Frankenstein and incredibly boring in Terminator Genisys.
Sure, he'd been okay in the Divergent movies, but there was nothing to really convince that he wasn't wholly unsuited to blockbuster movies.
And then, because it seemed like he was the only actor who knew how awful Suicide Squad was, he turned in a performance that felt like he had precisely zero f*cks to give. He was hilarious, unhinged, lived up to his villain-billing and mercifully never got trapped in the idiotic melodrama that undermined all the other characters.
9. Lindsay Lohan - Mean Girls
Lindsay Lohan had a good career as a child actor all the way up to Freaky Friday in 2013, but it's a little unfair to consider those performances next to her... decidedly more adult later roles.
But in 2004, it looked like she had made the jump to grown-up roles perfectly, thanks to the simply wonderful Mean Girls. Aided by a great script by Tina Fey, Lohan is wonderful as 16-year-old Cady Heron, both as the naive but assured outsider and as the "plastic" she initially fights so hard against.
She's a monster of her own making, manipulated and moulded by arch-villainess Regina George, and it is the strength of her performance that makes the whole thing so irresistibly charming.
8. Nic Cage - Kick-Ass
There are very much two Nic Cages. The first was the brilliant, subtle actor who shone in Leaving Las Vegas and Raising Arizona, but he doesn't appear anything like as frequently as he once did.
Now, Cage is an Internet joke known for over-the-top performances with way more commitment than the material deserves. He's an enigma, to be sure, and it often appears that he's driven by some strange agenda to out-Cage himself with every new performance.
And in a strange twist of fate, that agenda actually conspired to put together one of his most stunning performances in Kick-Ass. His excess became an Adam West-like facade for Big Daddy, while he played his secret identity "straight" - it was like we had the full Cage spectrum and the result was a rare moment of quality in the last 15 years.
7. Marlon Wayans - Requiem For A Dream
If you've seen any of his Scary Movie appearances or either of the Haunted House movies, there's a good chance you have a pretty tight handle on what Marlon Wayan's shtick is. He's a clown, all too frequently served by poor, puerile material that seeks to find the lowest common denominator. Fair play to him, he's found an audience for it, but it's by no means a good time for most people.
But if you can look past the gross-out gags and ear-bleeding high-pitched screaming that punctuates them, you might well remember a time when he was actually really great iun Darren Aronofsky's haunting Requiem For A Dream.
In it, he plays heroin addict Tyrone and he's as great in the role as he is insufferable elsewhere. His portrait of drug abuse is horribly authentic and his segue into desperation is subtle and gripping. It's hard not to be completely captivated as his world falls to pieces and it's stunning to think this is the same man behind White Girls and Little Man.
6. Jessica Alba - The Killer Inside Me
For the most part, Jessica Alba's career has been slightly derailed by the material she's been saddled with, which she hasn't always been particularly happy with - especially when it's pushed her into "sex symbol" status. She's also been fairly vocal about her directors being to blame for some of her missteps, which is definitely not the way to get more and better work.
Still, she has had one flash of brilliance so far, which still holds promise that she could do good work given further opportunities. You know, as long as the directors are good enough.
That performance came in the excellent The Killer Inside Me, in which she plays a 1950s Texas prostitute opposite Casey Affleck's sheriff's deputy with a violent secret. Their relationship is dark and volatile - inevitably really, since both are turned on my pain and abuse - and watching her react to being beaten is stunningly affecting. She was so convincing, in fact, that the film attracted major criticism for its portrait of violence against women.
It's certainly not a subtle film, but Alba's performance is artful and hugely impressive, for a change.
5. Burt Reynolds - Boogie Nights
Burt Reynolds has had a career defined more by being Burt Reynolds in movies than any characters, which says everything you need to know about his general ability as an actor. He's certainly a star, thanks to charisma mostly, but he's got some serious black marks on his CV, where he mostly appears to be bored.
Perhaps because of the weight of repeated missteps throughout the 1980s and 90s, it looked like his career was over by the time he turned up in Boogie Nights, but it turned out to be one of his finest ever appearances. His Jack Horner is a huge presence, seedy and charming without ever going over-the-top.
The great irony, of course, is that Reynolds hated working for Paul Thomas Anderson on the film...
“I think mostly because he was young and full of himself. Every shot we did, it was like the first time [that shot had ever been done]. I remember the first shot we did in Boogie Nights, where I drive the car to Grauman’s Theater. After he said, ‘Isn’t that amazing?’ And I named five pictures that had the same kind of shot. It wasn’t original. But if you have to steal, steal from the best.”
Nice way to be grateful for a director making you excel there, Burt.
4. Vince Vaughn - Brawl in Cell Block 99
When he first burst onto the scene, Vince Vaughn was not a bad actor. He is sublime in Swingers, for instance, and he's genuinely not that awful in the misguided Psycho remake. The problems started to come when he ended up being repeatedly cast to play Hollywood's idea of what Vince Vaughn is.
He often turned up in romantic comedies or as the manchild sidekick to more functioning straight men, and whispers of him being difficult to work with added something of a (possibly unearned) black mark in perceptions. Worryingly, his career choices seemed to suggest he was happy with his lot.
But then came Brawl In Cell 99, an under-the-radar actioner from Bone Tomahawk director S. Craig Zahler, who guided Vaughn towards a towering performance that transcends the traditional grindhouse limits of the story. He is so intimidating and so imposing that you wonder why nobody thought to put him in this sort of role before. There's intelligence behind the violence too, which definitely makes it stand apart.
3. Keanu Reeves - John Wick
Though he's had a fairly broad range of roles over his career, it would be fair to say that Keanu Reeves is a limited actor. Why else would he have approached playing characters as diverse as Jonathan Harker, John Constantine and Neo in the exact same way? It's not exactly his fault, though: he's an actor generally hired for who he is rather than what he does.
In other words, he's managed to be a star without being particularly great. Charisma, after all, goes a long way.
But by the time he came to play John Wick in 2014 - his Liam Neeson moment, as it were - he put everything he'd learned up to that point about suppressing his inner Ted Logan together to offer a minimalist, intense performance. His John is a sullen, terrifying force of nature, marked by his slight alienness (the same thing that made Reeves so appealing for sci-fi roles previously), and it's a towering performance from an actor showing exactly the right sort of restraint.
2. Sylvester Stallone - Cop Land
Sylvester Stallone is another actor whose career has mostly been defined by limitations and chiefly because of the genres he's found himself pigeon-holed in. Thanks to his physicality and his suitability to rougher characters, he's been rather lumbered with action material that hasn't always offered a chance to stretch his acting abilities.
There have been occasions where he's been able to add emotional authenticity - as in Rocky and the first Rambo - but as time went on that was hammered out of his franchise performances and his stand-alones. Eventually, there was an idea of a Stallone performance and that's precisely what he was hired for.
But Cop Land stands apart from all of that one-dimensional fare, thanks in part to an excellent script but mostly thanks to Stallone's vulnerable, broken performance. He's not the invulenrable superman of his other action films, instead he's a shuffling hulk, soulful and wounded by lost potential, and his underdog victory is delightful to watch.
You also have to give an honourable mention to Creed, in which he plays an ageing Rocky with the same sort of pathos. But, arguably, there's no way that performance could have happened without what he learned from Cop Land.
1. Adam Sandler - Funny People
Most people will tell you that Punch Drunk Love is Adam Sandler's best performance and while they have a fairly compelling case, his turn in Funny People is even more impressive. And it all comes down to context and self-awareness.
Funny People isn't just a good character creation by Sandler, it's a riff on himself - willingly taking aim at the cash-in comedies he's made and suggesting quietly that he's not all that proud of what he's known for. On top of that there's the pathos of a dying man struggling with an identity crisis and his compulsion to alienate himself, as well as a clever comment on the price of fame. It's subtle and smart and impressively self-aware.
And to think this is the same actor who is currently attempting to make Netflix pay for as much terrible content as possible (The Meyerowitz Stories aside) and who genuinely looked at Grown Ups 2 and thought "yeah, that'll do." That's the great frustration of Sandler: he does terrible work, but he's capable of so much more - it's just a shame he spends so much more time proving the former than the latter.
Which other performances belong on this list? Share your favourites below in the comments thread.