13 Unexpected Actors Who Might Win Oscars Next Year

From a comedy icon to an up-and-coming Star Wars villain...

The Oscars are over for another year, and everyone's got their own opinions about the awards. Was Michael Keaton more deserving of Best Actor than Eddie Redmayne? Was Rosamund Pike really the true Best Actress? Regardless, the awards have been dispensed, and pundits are already looking ahead to who might be clutching one of the small golden men this time next year, be it actors widely expected to scoop nominations (Leonardo DiCaprio for The Revenant and Jennifer Lawrence for Joy), or more uncharacteristic performers looking for awards gold. These 13 actors are not the sort you typically associate with Academy Award material, either because they usually lean towards less-demanding genre fare, their usual material simply isn't Oscar friendly, or to be totally honest, perhaps they were once-great and have stopped putting the effort in (looking at one actor in particular here). Still, each performer has at least one majorly promising project in production, and if it lives up to its promise, any of these actors could be rewarded with a shiny statue on their mantelpiece this time next year. Whether comedy actors transitioning into serious fare, promising up-and-comers looking to make their mark or legendary actors keen to revive their stagnant careers, here are 13 unexpected actors who might win Oscars next year...

13. Seth Rogen - Steve Jobs

The Actor: Seth Rogen's prolific comedic career speaks for itself, with his biggest hits including Knocked Up, Superbad, Neighbors and This is the End. The Role: In Danny Boyle's upcoming Steve Jobs biopic, Rogen plays Steve Wozniak, co-founder of Apple Inc, who plays a pivotal part in Jobs' story. Why They Might Win: Because the Academy loves transformative roles, and just as they've rewarded Jonah Hill and James Franco in the past with Oscar nominations, they'll delight in giving Rogen the rub if he's even half-way good, which he almost certainly will be. Early spy shots from the set make it clear that Rogen has been perfectly cast opposite Michael Fassbender, so his Oscar fate really rests in the hands of Aaron Sorkin's script, and when has he ever let viewers down?

12. Zoe Saldana - Nina

The Actor: Zoe Saldana came to most film fans' attention in 2009 when she starred in Star Trek and then Avatar, the latter of which even saw a small but passionate Best Supporting Actress campaign launched in her favour. Aside from an appearance in 2013's Out of the Furnace, though, she's pretty much stayed away from the prestige movie field. The Role: Saldana is to play jazz musician and classical pianist Nina Simone during her rise to fame, though in fairness, her casting has not been without its controversy. "Blackface" and nose prosthetics were used to make Saldana more closely resemble Simone, which many criticised because it favoured star power over casting someone who just looked like the musician anyway. Plus, director Cynthia Mort sued the producers of the film for apparently taking control of the edit away from her, and though the movie was screened for buyers at Cannes last May, word has gone pretty quiet ever since. Why They Might Win: If Saldana can prove the skeptics wrong and deliver a spot-on performance, none of this controversy will matter one bit. Sure, it could just be another Grace of Monaco in the waiting, but it could also be the movie that elevates the actress to the A-list if she nails it.

11. Alicia Vikander - The Light Between Oceans / The Danish Girl

The Actor: The gorgeous Swedish actress has had quite the year, starring in the acclaimed likes of Testament of Youth, Son of a Gun and Ex Machina, with a multitude of enticing projects (such as Guy Richie's The Man from U.N.C.L.E.) on the way. The Roles: In Derek Cianfrance's (The Place Beyond the Pines) drama, Vikander plays a young woman who, as a baby, washed up on a shore and was adopted by a lighthouse keeper (Michael Fassbender) and his wife (Rachel Weisz). Secondly, Tom Hooper (The King's Speech) directs The Danish Girl, in which she plays Gerda Wegener, the wife of Einar Wegener (Eddie Redmayne), one of the first people to undergo sexual reassignment surgery. Why They Might Win: The former subject is an extremely popular book which always serves as catnip to Oscar voters, while the latter should see Vikander in a heavily put-upon role about a strong woman, which again, the voters love. Plus, she's an on-the-rise talent, and the Academy enjoys rewarding that.

10. Kurt Russell - The Hateful Eight

The Actor: Despite starring in so many iconic movies over the years, indelible leading man Kurt Russell has never so much as been nominated for an Oscar, and in recent years, his cinematic appearances have been decidedly less frequent. Even so, his memorable turn as Stuntman Mike in Quentin Tarantino's Death Proof endeared him to a whole new generation. The Role: John "The Hangman" Ruth, a bounty hunter who transports fugitive Daisy Domergue (Jennifer Jason Leigh) towards the town of Red Rock in order to administer justice, but of course, nothing is ever that easy in a QT movie. Why They Might Win: Because it's a rare chance to actually reward Russell with an Oscar. He hasn't been in a remotely prestige-worthy role in years, and as anyone who has read the script knows, Ruth is imbued with the classic grit everyone expects from a quintessential Tarantino character these days. Russell is superbly cast for the part, so there's just no chance of him not nailing it. Hopefully it plays as well on screen as it read on the page...

9. Thomas Mann - Me & Earl & The Dying Girl

The Actor: Young on-the-rise actor Thomas Mann first made his name known to audiences with his leading role in Project X, though has thankfully graduated onto greener pastures with a slew of upcoming art-house flicks that have played the festival circuit recently, such as Welcome to Me and The Stanford Prison Experiment. The Role: Mann plays Greg Gaines, a socially awkward high schooler who is forced by his mother (Connie Britton) to befriend a leukemia-addled girl, Rachel (Olivia Cooke). Eventually, though, a bond grows, and each learns plenty from the other. Why They Might Win: Because The Fault in Our Stars proved last year that weepie illness movies can court awards success (its campaign for Shailene Woodley and Laura Dern got surprising traction), and the massive acclaim this movie enjoyed at Sundance last month simply cannot be ignored. Mann was singled out for his exceptional lead performance, and though it's a long road to the Oscars, Whiplash proved just this past week how a fine turn can sustain all the way to the finish line.

8. Adam Driver - Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens

The Actor: Adam Driver has fast been making a name for himself over the last three years, playing the most likeable character on Lena Dunham's HBO show Girls, and working on acclaimed projects such as Frances Ha, Lincoln, Inside Llewyn Davis, What If, and Martin Scorsese's upcoming Silence. The Role: If reports are to be believed (despite that suspicious image of Driver in an X-Wing pilot outfit), he will be playing Kylo Ren, the cloaked, lightsaber-totting bada** briefly spotted in the teaser trailer for the movie. Little beyond that is known, but he's expected to be the main antagonist of the movie. Why They Might Win: The Academy isn't totally averse to nominating these movies for acting awards: remember that Alec Guinness received a Best Supporting Actor nod for his work on the first movie, and in recent years the Academy has sprung for more cartoonish blockbuster turns, such as nominating Johnny Depp for Pirates of the Caribbean, and giving Heath Ledger a posthumous win for The Dark Knight. If Driver can deliver a truly memorable villain, this could combine with overwhelming nostalgia to win him a Best Supporting Actor Oscar.

7. Amy Schumer - Trainwreck

The Actor: Comedienne Amy Schumer is better known for her stand-up and TV work such as Inside Amy Schumer, though writing and starring in Judd Apatow's new movie is sure to do wonders for her career. The Role: Schumer plays Amy, the titular trainwreck who has rejected the notion of monogamy ever since childhood, though finds herself questioning her boozy, promiscuous ways when she meets a charming sports doctor, Aaron (Bill Hader). Why They Might Win: Because while Apatow's films aren't exactly synonymous with awards fare, the Academy will take huge note of not just Schumer's transition to big-screen work, but also that she wrote the film herself. Plus, if they can give Melissa McCarthy an Oscar nomination for taking a crap in a sink in Bridesmaids, why can't they reward a female role that looks like it has a little more dramatic meat on its bones?

6. Jason Segel - The End Of The Tour

The Actor: Jason Segel has made a career as a funnyman on TV shows such as Freaks and Geeks and How I Met Your Mother, not to mention acclaimed movies such as Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Jeff, Who Lives at Home and The Muppets. He hasn't done a whole lot of interest over the last few years, though that's all about to change... The Role: Segel plays late novelist David Foster Wallace, who in the movie is interviewed by journalist David Lipsky (Jesse Eisenberg) over the course of a few days for Rolling Stone Magazine, revealing the persona of a genius artist. Why They Might Win: Segel's performance has been described as "career redefining" amid countless other superlatives in reviews, quite clearly landing as the actor's most impressive work to date, something the Academy will be eager to reward as they always are. It really just depends on whether the movie as a whole catches on with voters, or if it's seen as too niche to make it. Still, the Academy got Marion Cotillard nominated this year for a (brilliant) movie that practically nobody saw, so it's certainly possible.

5. Chris Hemsworth - In The Heart Of The Sea

The Actor: Chris Hemsworth is, of course, best known to audiences for playing Thor in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, though he did enjoy acclaim (if not particularly serious awards discussions) for his chamelonic performance as James Hunt in Ron Howard's superb biopic Rush. The Role: Hemsworth plays First Mate Owen Chase, one of the crew members struggling to survive as his whaleship Essex sinks after an encounter with a huge sperm whale. He and the other crewmen are forced to resort to cannibalism in order to stay alive. Why They Might Win: The trailers certainly suggest that more of the focus will be on Chase than Captain George Pollard, Jr. (Benjamin Walker), and if the pic fulfills the promise of its excellent source material, then Ron Howard and Hemsworth could be looking at a Master and Commander-type success, albeit hopefully with more awards attention for its lead actor.

4. Cynthia Nixon - James White

The Actor: Cynthia Nixon is best-known for playing high-flying lawyer Miranda Hobbes on HBO's classic show Sex and the City, and along with prolific TV work, tends to stick to art-house indie flicks for her big-screen work. It's not so much that Nixon earning acclaim is unexpected by virtue of her talent, but simply because she picks so many low-profile roles. The Role: Nixon plays Gail, the dying mother of the titular character (Christopher Abbot), who attempts to make amends with her troubled child in her final days. Why They Might Win: Nixon's performance was described as a "knockout" by Variety, and other outlets have touted it as being awards-worthy right out of the gate. Laura Dern's performance in Wild this year was proof enough that the Academy isn't turned off by the grimness of a role such as this, and as long as the pic gets the opportunity to make an impact on a big enough stage, her supporting turn could be the one to beat.

3. Johnny Depp - Black Mass

The Actor: Johnny Depp's reputation speaks for itself, having starred in some of the most successful movie franchises of all time. While he might not seem like the most unexpected actor to be Oscar nominated (given his three nominations between 2004 and 2008), he's been phoning it in for at least the last five years, and with five box office flops in a row, it seems like the actor's ability to headline a movie just isn't what it used to be. The Role: Depp plays Whitey Bulger, the most infamous gangster in the history of South Boston, who eventually became an FBI informant in order to bring down the Mafia. As you can tell, it's pretty make-up heavy too. Why They Might Win: The Academy loves transformative performances, and though excessive make-up can often encroach upon a performance (just look at Leonardo DiCaprio in J. Edgar), they'll surely appreciate Depp actually trying something ambitious and interesting for the first time in forever. It's extremely worthy material and a fascinating story, so hopefully Depp can remind everyone why he became so beloved in the first place...

2. Lily Tomlin - Grandma

The Actor: Though Lily Tomlin is best known for her TV work these days, the 75-year-old actress was nominated for a Best Supporting Actress Oscar back in 1976 for Nashville. The Role: Tomlin plays misanthropic Elle Reid, whose career as a writer has been on the skids since the death of her partner Violet. She heads out on a road trip with her teenage granddaughter Sage (Julia Garner), who is pregnant and requires Elle's help to get an abortion. Why They Might Win: Tomlin's performance has been described as awards-worthy by many reviews, and given that next year will mark 40 years since Tomlin's last Oscar nomination, that could be enough for the Academy voters (primarily comprised of people in the older age bracket) to push her over the top. It would certainly be a brilliant way to cap a fine career and give her the recognition she has been long overdue.

1. Kirsten Dunst - Midnight Special

The Actor: Kirsten Dunst has balanced herself perfectly in mainstream and art-house fare over the years, be it playing Mary-Jane in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy, or tackling the likes of Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette and Lars von Trier's Melancholia. She's never been Oscar nominated, though, settling for a Golden Globe nod for her work as a youngster in Interview with the Vampire. The Role: Dunst plays an unspecified female lead in Jeff Nichols' sci-fi chase drama, possibly taking the part of Michael Shannon's wife, whose son is endowed with special powers of some kind. Why They Might Win: Nichols is a fantastic actor's director, and while little is known about Dunst's role, perhaps the director's first studio production might be enough for Academy voters to finally start paying attention to the fine work he and his performers are doing. Who do you think might be an Oscar winner this time next year? Shout it out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.