15 Most Critically Adored Films 2016 - Ranked

The year a crime-fighting rabbit stole critics’ hearts.

Zootopia RT
Disney

Subjectivity plays a huge part in how highly people rate a movie. After all, one man’s Citizen Kane is another man’s Transformers: Age of Extinction and very rarely will a film be beloved by film critics, movie buffs and casual moviegoers alike.

In a sense, this makes things like Rotten Tomatoes ratings, Metacritic rankings and perhaps even film critics themselves kind of redundant. Nevertheless, they’re still a useful barometer for judging the general quality of a film and, to give film critics their dues, they do watch an awful lot of movies so their opinions must have some validity.

If you presume that a lot of this year’s most critically adored film are arty, pretentious affairs you’d be wrong. Yes, there’s a few arty flicks but they rank alongside surprising additions like superhero movies, kid-friendly animations and comedies too.

If Rotten Tomatoes definitive ranking of the year’s critical successes is anything to go by, it looks like film critics snobbery could be on the out.

But how do the Freshest movies of the year rank?

15. Embrace Of The Serpent

Embrace of the Serpent
Diaphana Films

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 98% (128 reviews)

A searing critique of the devastating impact of Western colonialism on unspoilt lands and indigenous cultures, Colombian director Ciro Guerra’s Embrace of the Serpent was released to a shower of almost universal critical acclaim and went on to win the much-coveted Directors’ Fortnight Art Cinema Award at Cannes.

Set in the Colombian Amazon, the film follows two different narratives in two different time periods led by the same character – native shaman Karamakate, the sole survivor of his otherwise extinct tribe, as he guides two Westerners on expeditions deep into the rainforest to find a rare and sacred plant.

Non-professional actors and native Amazonians Nilbio Torres and Antonio Bolivar (who funnily enough is one of the last few remaining members of his own tribe, the Ocaína) give raw and haunting performances as Karamakate, while its stark black and white cinematography perfectly captures the harsh beauty of the Amazon Rainforest.


14. Moana

Moana Disney
Disney

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 95% (208 reviews)

It’s been a big year for Disney. Not only have many of its 2016 releases been showered with praise, they also raked in billions and billions of dollars at the box office and they took a rather progressive step forward with Moana – the first of its movies to feature a Polynesian main character and one that’s a Disney princess whose end goal isn’t snagging the prince charming of her dreams.

Voiced by Auli'i Cravalho in her acting debut, Moana is the daughter of a Polynesian island chief tasked with the quest of returning an ancient, mysterious relic to its rightful goddess owner lest her island home and its people face almost certain extinction.

Though she comes up against opposition in the form of her over-protective father and arrogant demi-god Maui (Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson), Moana perseveres overcoming both her own and other’s doubts and successfully completes her mission.

Beautifully animated and with a positive pro-girl power message at its heart, it’s one of Disney’s most enchanting and inspiring releases this year.


13. Captain America: Civil War

captain america civil war
Marvel Studios

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 90% (329 reviews)

Captain America: Civil War, the latest Avengers instalment, smashed box offices worldwide this year earning a staggering $1.153 billion and claiming its stake as the highest grossing film of 2016 and the twelfth highest grossing film of all time.

Picking up after the events of Age of Ultron, the movie sees a rift form between former allies Iron Man and Captain America as government interference, massive in-fighting and secrets revealed threaten to tear the Avengers apart, culminating in a blistering battle finale pitting superhero against superhero.

Action-packed from start to finish, often funny and with a surprisingly emotional core, it’s been hailed as one of the best superhero movies of all time.


12. Don’t Think Twice

Dont Think Twice
The Film Arcade

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 99% (109 reviews)

It might have flown largely under the radar in 2016, but Mike Birbiglia’s comedy-drama about the hardships of working New York City’s comedy circuit certainly charmed critics. Focusing on a comedy improv troupe and how they’re affected when one of its members finds success and fame by nabbing a spot on the sketch show Weekend Live, a thinly veiled stand-in for the most coveted of all comedy shows Saturday Night Live, it’s been hailed as an honest exploration of the life of working comedians.

Starring a host of comedic talents including Keegan-Michael Key, Kate Micucci and Mike Birbiglia himself that bring a tonne of real-life experience to the movie as working comedians themselves, Don’t Think Twice is as heartfelt and bittersweet as it is funny.


11. Things To Come

Things To Come
Les Films du Losange

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 100% (91 reviews)

Not only did French director Mia Hansen-Løve’s latest film Things to Come scoop her the Silver Bear Award for Best Director at the 2016 Berlin International Film Festival, it’s also won star Isabelle Huppert a good few Best Actress nods from the likes of the Boston Society of Film Critics and the Los Angeles Film Critics Association too.

Huppert plays Nathalie Chazeaux, a disillusioned philosophy teacher forced to re-examine her life after her career starts to wane, her husband leaves her and her cantankerous, drama-prone mother dies. That might sound like a run of the mill female midlife crisis movie, but don’t let that put you off: Eat Pray Love this is not. A beautifully shot, wry and poignant exploration of aging and loss featuring a tour de force performance from Huppert, it’s perhaps fairer to call it ‘coming of middle age’ movie than anything else.


10. Hunt For The Wilderpeople

Hunt For The Wilderpeople
The Orchard

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 97% (168 reviews)

From the same mind that brought moviegoers vampire comedy What We Do in the Shadows, director Taika Waititi, comes Hunt for the Wilderpeople. Based on the book Wild Pork and Watercress by Kiwi author Barry Crump, it’s a charming adventure comedy-drama about a foul-mouthed orphan with a penchant for hip hop called Ricky (newcomer Julian Dennison), his begrudging guardian Hec (Sam Neill) and the manhunt that follows after they purposefully go missing in the New Zealand bush.

Shot in locations including the Central Plateau and Waitakere Ranges, the movie’s cinematography makes much use of New Zealand’s stunning scenery. It’s the brilliant comedic chemistry between Neill and young Dennison, however, that really makes the movie so winsome and no doubt the basis for its huge success both in New Zealand, where it ranks as the highest grossing homegrown movie, and further afield.


9. Manchester By The Sea

Manchester By The Sea Casey Affleck
Roadside Attractions

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 97% (178 reviews)

Since its Sundance premiere back in January, Manchester by the Sea quickly rose as one of the most acclaimed films of year. Recently listed amongst the best films of 2016 by the American Film Institute and currently nominated for six Golden Globe Awards including Best Drama and Best Director, it’s hotly tipped to scoop a few Oscar nominations too.

Directed by Kenneth Lonergan, the movie stars Casey Affleck as Lee – a lonely Boston janitor forced to return to his hometown after his brother dies leaving him as the sole guardian of his teenage nephew. There he is forced to face his ex-wife Randi (Michelle Williams) and the tragic past they share after losing their kids in a housefire years previously. Sounds depressing, and while it is indeed a sad movie it’s also a moving and often very funny meditation on loss and grief.


8. Kubo And The Two Strings

Kubo and the two strings
Laika

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 97% (180 reviews)

Moviegoers looking for a refreshing change to the dominance of Disney and Pixar animations this year couldn’t get much better than Kubo and the Two Strings – a bittersweet but ultimately charming stop-motion animation from Laika, the same studio behind the likes of Coraline and The Boxtrolls.

Featuring the vocal talents of Matthew McConaughey and Charlize Theron, it tells the tale of a young boy who must embark on a quest to find his late father’s magical suit of armour in order to defeat his evil grandfather, the vengeful Moon King voiced by Ralph Fiennes in full Voldemort mode.

It may have flopped at the box office (probably due in part to that aforementioned Disney dominance) but critics were more than taken, praising it for its offbeat and often metaphorical storyline and beautiful animation.


7. Finding Dory

Finding Dory trailer Nemo
Pixar

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 94% (260 reviews)

Disney-Pixar’s long-awaited sort of sequel, sort of spinoff to 2003’s Finding Nemo was released this summer to huge success, raking in a massive $1.028 billion worldwide and ranking not only as the second highest grossing film of the year but Disney’s third highest grossing animation too.

All that money is nice, but without sparkling reviews to back it up it doesn’t mean much. Though thankfully for Disney Finding Dory was as much as critical success as it was a financial success.

Elle DeGeneres returned to voice the forgetful fish as she embarks on a mission to find her long-lost parents alongside familiar faces Nemo and Marlin and a host of new characters including Hank, a cantankerous seven-legged octopus and one of Pixar’s most complex animated characters to date. Just like Finding Nemo did over decade ago, it’s hotly tipped to scoop the Best Animated Feature at the 2017 Oscars.


6. The Jungle Book

King Louie Jungle Book.jpg
Disney

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 94% (268 reviews)

Movie remakes and reboots can be tricky business, but there was one film this year that proved with the right cast and crew that they can be done right. Hint: it wasn’t Ghostbusters.

Part live-action and part CGI-animated, Jon Favreau’s take on The Jungle Book retained all the charm of the original 1967 film but updated for modern, young audiences with stunningly realistic visual effects.

Featuring child actor Neel Sethi as Mowgli in his debut feature and boasting an all-star voice cast including Bill Murray as Baloo, Idris Elba as Shere Khan and Christopher Walken as a supersized version of King Louie, many a critic even went so far as to state Favreau’s Jungle Book was a massive improvement on its predecessor.


5. Love & Friendship

Love And Friendship
Amazon Studios

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 98% (172 reviews)

A Jane Austen adaptation that isn’t Sense and Sensibility, Emma or Pride and Prejudice?! Yes, surprisingly enough it is actually possible to adapt her other works for the big screen and as Whit Stillman’s Love & Friendship proved it can be a very successful move too.

Adapted not from Austen’s Love & Freindship (written when she was just a young whippersnapper, hence the spelling mistake) but from her posthumously published novel Lady Susan, the film stars Kate Beckinsale as a wry, calculating and upwardly mobile widow attempting to marry herself and her timid daughter off to suitably wealthy husbands.

It went on to earn critical acclaim on both sides of the pond and pocketed a not too shabby $19.6 million – not bad for a period comedy made on a tiny budget of just $3 million.


4. Moonlight

Moonlight 2016
A24

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 98% (189 reviews)

Based on award-winning playwright Tarell Alvin McCraney’s In Moonlight Black Boys Look Blue, Barry Jenkins’ critically adored Moonlight tells the haunting and bittersweet tale of a young gay black man, Chiron, growing up in South Central Miami.

Visiting the protagonist during three distinct periods during his journey from boyhood to adulthood – first as a kid under his drug-addicted mother’s care, then as a bullied teen and lastly as a drug-dealing adult meeting up with his former flame and friend – the film seamlessly transitions through the three different actors playing Chiron.

Like Manchester By The Sea, Moonlight has too been listed amongst the American Film Institute’s best films of 2016 and is in direct competition with it for a few Golden Globes including Best Drama, Best Director and Best Screenplay.


3. Arrival

Arrival Amy Adams
Paramount Pictures

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 94% (291 reviews)

It seems like French-Canadian director Denis Villeneuve can’t put a foot wrong. In 2013, his thriller Prisoners was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Cinematography and in 2015 his Mexico-set crime drama Sicario was one of the year’s most highly rated flicks alongside receiving a few Academy Award and BAFTA nominations too. This year, Villeneuve turned his hand to sci-fi with the equally critically acclaimed Arrival.

Starring Amy Adams as Dr Louise Banks, an expert linguist called upon by the military to interpret a complex alien language after several mysterious spacecraft touch down in several locations across the planet, it’s a film that’s both brimming with the kind of tension Villeneuve’s works are known for but also a surprisingly emotional and heartfelt sci-fi.

If the film press predictions are correct, Arrival could be in the running for a few Academy Award nominations too and 2017 could be the year that one of Villeneuve’s finally wins a coveted Oscar.


2. Hell Or High Water

Hell Or High Water Ben Foster Chris Pine
Lionsgate

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 98% (210 reviews)

British director David Mackenzie’s gritty, Texas-set neo-western Hell or High Water was released to a shower of critical acclaim this year and quiet rightly so. Starring Chris Pine and Ben Foster as brothers who carry out a series of robberies at the bank about to foreclose on their family ranch and Jeff Bridges and Gil Birmingham as a pair of Texas Rangers hot on their heels, it’s essentially a heist movie but also a fascinating study of the four main characters at its heart.

Already boasting a few Golden Globe nominations under its belt, with its gripping screenplay, stunning cinematography and a star turn from Jeff Bridges in his best role since True Grit, it’s rumoured Hell or High Water could earn itself a few Oscar nominations too.


1. Zootopia

Zootopia Sloth
Disney

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 98% (240 reviews)

Some see it as a kid-friendly message about social justice, others (the tinfoil hat-wearing types) see it as a political allegory for 1980s America’s crack epidemic but whatever your interpretation of Disney’s Zootopia one thing is clear – it’s officially the most critically adored movie of 2016, at least according to Rotten Tomatoes.

Set in the titular Zootopia, a city populated by anthropomorphic animals, the film focuses on rabbit rookie police officer Judy (voiced by Ginnifer Goodwin) and con artist fox Nick (Jason Bateman) as they team up to solve a mystery surrounding the disappearance of several of Zootopia’s carnivorous inhabitants.

It raked in a huge $1.024 billion at the box office and was hailed by critics for its thought-provoking message, sense of humour and state-of-the-art animation. If current Oscar predictions come true, Zootopia could find itself in direct competition with fellow Disney titles Finding Dory and Moana for Best Animated Feature at the 2017 Academy Awards.

How would you rank the most critically acclaimed movies of 2016?


In this post: 
Zootopia
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Helen Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.