15 Most Critically Adored Stephen King Adaptations

Surprisingly, they're not all as terrible as the Carrie remake.

Pennywise It
ABC
There's a pretty persistent rumour that Stephen King books don't make good films. Fandom aside, you can sort of see where the accusation comes from: of the massive number of adaptations that have been released since Carrie in 1976, only a handful are generally held as even passably good, while far more are dismissed as utterly garbage. There's not a great deal of middle ground. But such is the enduring popularity of King's work, and the strength of the material that there have been an astonishing 81 adaptations (including ruinous sequels and prequels that weren't down to him at all) in the past almost 40 years. It's just a shame that about 80% of them have been made by and starred people who shouldn't ever be trusted to make a film again. On rare occasions though the pieces fit together perfectly and a film-maker manages to cast of the burden of precedent to make an adaptation genuinely worthy of King's work. He doesn't always offer his blessing, of course, but then neither would you if you'd seen so many idiots try and ruin your good reputation with films that Nicolas Cage wouldn't even star in. According to the people who get paid to give their opinions, these are definitively the best adaptations of Stephen King's work ever committed to screen (as collated by their Rotten Tomatoes scores)...

15. The Shining (1980)

The Shining
Warner Bros.

Rating: 92%

Officially, The Shining ties with Carrie by virtue of scoring the same aggregate RT score, but the fact that it survived an initially disinterested box office and two Razzie nominations to become not just a classic but a cultural phenomenon in its own right.

King seems to flip-flop on how he feels about the film, but the latest thinking seems to be that he does like it, which is obviously a bonus. But regardless of any of his reservations, few films can claim to have the cultural impact that The Shining has had since its release.


14. Carrie (1976)

Carrie Blood
United Artists

Rating: 92%

Ignoring the bland remake and awful sequel, Brian DePalma's spellbinding horror remains a classic, even if Stephen King calls it dated but good.

The film picked up two Oscar nominations for the central acting pair of Sissy Spacek and Piper Laurie, and despite being remembered mostly for THAT prom scene, it is a film-making marvel for far more than one scene.


13. Stand By Me (1986)

Stand By Me1
Columbia Pictures

Rating: Best - 91%

When Stephen King proclaims your film the truest adaptation of his work, you know you've managed a significant victory.

The award-winning film was based on short story The Body (but renamed when someone thought it sounded like a sex film), and was directed by the supremely gifted Rob Reiner and assembled a cast of brilliantly talented young actors at the start of their careers.


12. The Shawshank Redemption (1994)

Shawshank Redemption
Columbia Pictures

Rating: Best - 91%

Who would have thought that a novella based heavily on a Leo Tolstoy short story without even the merest hint of a ghost would be the most nominated adaptation of King's work?

Famously, The Shawshank Redemption wasn't particularly popular in cinemas, failing to make its budget back (until a second release in 1995), but it was nominated for 7 Oscars and is about as close to a classic as you're ever likely to see.


11. The Dead Zone (1983)

The Dead Zone
Paramount Pictures

Rating: 90%

Again, rather than a horror, The Dead Zone is more like a supernatural detective movie, using Christopher Walken's newly found psychic abilities to thwart crimes (and a nuclear holocaust before they happen).

It's not a close adaptation, but despite initially seeing his script rejected, screenwriter Jeffrey Boam enjoyed the conspicuous accolade of being told by Stephen King that he had actually improved the story.


10. Misery (1990)

Misery Kathy Bates
Columbia Pictures

Rating: 89%

Talk about your visceral thrillers. Misery isn't actually a horror movie in the ghosts and ghouls sense of the genre, but its horrific implications build on Kathy Bates' exceptional performance and the horrible familiarity of her obsession.

This is not a world where portals might open to other dimensions, but that doesn't mean the simple awfulness of ankles being smashed with sledgehammers isn't just as provocative.


9. Salem's Lot (1979)

Salems Lot
CBS

Rating: Best - 83%

Between making The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Poltergeist Tobe Hooper managed the previously unmanageable by adapting the lengthy Salem's Lot, after several big name horror film-makers had failed to turn it into a film.

Taking advantage of his fluid camerawork and commitment to atmosphere building, it's a terrifically frightening adaptation and deservedly the best TV adaptation to date.


8. Dolores Claiborne (1995)

Dolores Claiborne
Columbia Pictures

Rating: 82%

Douglas Hackford may have lost something since he made Ray back in 2004, but he scored a run of critical and commercial successes following on from Dolores Claiborne in 1995.

The film - the second King adaptation starring Kathy Bates - is a far more sympathetic affair then Misery's harsh horror, preferring drama to straight chills to great effect.


7. The Green Mile (1999)

The Green Mile
Warner Bros.

Rating: 80%

Bucking the trend of King adaptations hiring poor directors and casting has-beens and never-will-bes, The Green Mile was a genuinely star-studded affair, which soared on the performances not only of Michael Clarke Duncan and Tom Hanks, but also Sam Rockwell, Michael Jeter and Doug Hutchison.

It's a deeply affecting film, aided magnificently by Thomas Newman's score, and it duly deserves the high score.


6. 1408 (2007)

1408 John Cusack
MGM

Rating: 78%

On paper, 1408 shouldn't have worked as a film - it's a little ghost story about a single room after all - but 2007 proved to be a successful year for King adaptations as the John Cusack-led chiller hit the sweet spot.

It was creepy, mind-bending and satisfyingly scary, and while nobody seemed clear on which ending was supposed to be used, it's something of a modern horror gem.


5. Storm Of The Century (1999)

Storm Of The Century
ABC

Rating: 75%

Though not strictly an adaptation (King wrote it specifically as a screenplay), Storm Of The Century was a published work (in screenplay form), and qualifies by virtue of the great man penning it himself.

This is actually one of the rare occasions where any Stephen King film/show actually written by him didn't tank, which scored an unlikely success for stuntman turned director Craig Baxley, thanks to Colm Feore's creepy performance.


4. The Mist (2007)

The Mist
MGM

Rating: 73%

With the horror genre overtaken by torture porn and self-conscious rip-offs, Frank Darabont's take on King's 1980 story was a breath of fresh-air and did exactly what everyone actually wanted from a horror movie.

Instead of looking purely to disgust, it was dark and tense and did justice to the original.


3. Creepshow (1982)

Creepshow - Jordy
Warner Bros.

Rating: 69%

It might not be one of the most memorable of the King adaptations, but this five film collection, directed by horror legend George Romero deserves to be considered a cult delight.

It's self-consciously funny, but doesn't compromise anything in the creepy stakes, and it is genuinely scary. And not just because of King's acting ability.


2. It (1990)

Stephen Kings It
ABC

Rating: 67%

In all honesty, the ABC mini-series is probably most memorable for the central, demonic performance by Tim Curry as Pennywise the clown, rather than for the success of the show itself.

That's something of a shame though, as it's genuinely creepy (and yes it does rely significantly on Curry, but why should that be a problem?) and offers real thrills.


1. Christine (1983)

Christine
PSPublishing

Rating: 65%

King adaptations that hit above 50% are a rarity to say the least and even the dream team of adding John Carpenter to the directing chair didn't stop some critics gunning for his 1983 take on the killer car story.

But the film is an affectionate, spirited take on the original, with lashings of cult appeal and it deserves to be classed as one of the better King reworks.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.