15 Predictions For 2014 Movies Everybody Got Wrong

You thought you had these movies figured out...but you didn't.

Just like every year in cinema, things rarely go totally according to plan, and by the end of the year, the complexion is usually pretty different from what you expected 12 months earlier. A year ago, everyone had firmly-regimented expectations about how these movies would perform, and now that each film has been out in the wild for some time, it's clear that expectations most often count for nothing. Apparent masterpieces merely had to settle for silver, people you thought would ruin upcoming movies actually didn't, seemingly needless spin-offs and sequels actually made themselves feel relevant, and some sure fire Oscar bait didn't even make it to the precursor stage. These 15 movies looked like they would be predictably awesome or expectantly terrible, but in most cases, either the opposite was true or they simply gravitated towards a more reasonable middle-ground of decency. In many ways these movies, whether good, bad or simply disappointing, are a testament to the fun and surprise of being a film fan, of sitting down to watch a film with a rigid expectation of its quality, only to be completely surprised. Looking at 2015's gigantic film slate, predictions have already been running rampant, and no doubt in another 12 months from now, everyone will be laughing at how off-base their original guesses were. Here are 15 predictions for 2014 movies everyone got wrong...

15. Interstellar Will Be Christopher Nolan's Best Movie

The Prediction: With its gorgeous visuals, deeply personal family theme, epic scope and a reborn Matthew McConaughey continuing his ascent to further awesomeness, why wouldn't Interstellar be a classic for the ages, and easily the best movie Christopher Nolan has made to date? The Reality: Of the nine feature films Nolan has directed, Interstellar is the worst-reviewed of the lot, sitting at a respectable if unremarkable 73% on Rotten Tomatoes. While critics praised the performances, the visuals and the staggering ambition of the piece, the usual Nolan complaints about clunky exposition and poor female characters came flooding in, as well as a hugely divisive third act that seemed to deviate from the hard science veneer of the previous two hours. In short, Interstellar is a good and interesting film, the sort of which film buffs should be encouraging more of, but certainly not a masterpiece, and in fact, probably Nolan's worst effort to date.

14. Megan Fox Will Ruin Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

The Prediction: The young woman Paramount and producer Michael Bay sought to cast as the Turtles' iconic sidekick April O'Neil is...Megan Fox? Though few will be complaining about what she looks like, Fox's acting skills have regularly been taken to task, and so it was widely expected that she'd sink this movie before it even got going... The Reality: In fairness to Fox, while she hardly displays extraordinarily acting talent here, she is more than reasonable as O'Neil, playing the part on the right side of bemusement and doing about as well with the relatively flaky dialogue as any actor could be asked to. Fox doesn't sink the movie at all: the creepy, crude humour and inane storyline do that plenty well by themselves.

13. The Lego Movie Will Be Nothing But A Glorified Lego Commercial

The Prediction: The Lego Movie, though promoting a veil of ludicrous insanity, will basically just be an excuse to sell more of the tiny plastic blocks to kids. The Reality: The Lego Movie is that rare gem: it's a movie based on a children's toy that absolutely makes you want to go out and buy more of that toy, but at the same time doesn't at all feel like a 100-minute advertisement. By name alone, this film sounds like a potential corporate-mandated creative disaster, yet with filmmaking wunderkinds Phil Lord and Chris Miller at the helm, they took a potentially crass exercise in consumerism and made it one of the year's most gleefully entertaining and heartfelt movies. With a sweet message about the power of imagination and a widely-praised divergence into live-action during its insane finale, The Lego Movie surpassed virtually all expectations, boasting enough gorgeous animation that it's surely the front-runner for this year's Best Animated Feature Oscar.

12. Penguins Of Madagascar Will Be A Lame Spin-Off

The Prediction: A spin-off film starring the mildly entertaining supporting characters from the Madagascar series? This has unimaginative flop written all over it for sure, right? The Reality: To the surprise of most, Penguins of Madagascar didn't just earn solid reviews from critics (72%), but it's better reviewed than either the first (55%) or second (64%) Madagascar films, and settles in at just a slightly lower score than the third one (79%). Penguins may boast a relatively disposable plot (a claim that can also be leveled against the Madagascar films themselves), but it's absolutely dripping with fun personality, with the movie allowing Skipper, Kowalski, Rico and Private to become fully-fledged characters rather than mere asides in someone else's movie. John Malkovich playing the villain and Benedict Cumberbatch voicing a suave wolf spy certainly didn't hurt either. Frankly, the film was good enough that, for many, there's surely more enthusiasm for a Penguins sequel than Madagascar 4 right now.

11. 22 Jump Street Will Be A Totally Pointless Sequel

The Prediction: Even with Phil Lord and Chris Miller returning to direct this sequel, isn't it just going to be a lame retread of a project that never should have worked in the first place? The Reality: Lord and Miller were several steps ahead of everyone, however, because 22 Jump Street tackles its own sense of redundancy head-on through a series of meta-gags that beg the question: how do you make a sequel that lives up to the original? The entire movie is pretty much one long jab at how most movie sequels suck, and in that stead, the movie actually makes itself feel relevant despite basically repeating the same "infiltrate the dealer, find the supplier" storyline of the first film. It doesn't hurt that Jonah Hill and Channing Tatum's bromantic chemistry is even stronger than before, Ice Cube gets a significantly meatier role (and the funniest scene in the entire movie), and the end credits sequence is a thing of demented beauty. Believe it or not, bring on 23 Jump Street.

10. The Fault in Our Stars Will Be Another Sappy Weepie Movie

The Prediction: Another adaptation of another teen weepie novel? Great, here comes the avalanche of emotional manipulation and cornball cheesiness. The Reality: It's easy to be cynical about movies like this because of how often they're terrible: just look at all those Nicholas Sparks adaptations that deal with death and disease in woefully tacky means. This adaptation of John Green's hit novel, however, is a very different beast, a disease movie with a soul, and lucky enough to feature the brilliant Shailene Woodley in the lead role. What really distinguishes this isn't just its emotional core, but the fact that it's clearly aware of all the disease movie tropes and deliberately tries to avoid most of them. Fine supporting parts for the likes of Laura Dern and Willem Dafoe further class up proceedings, and as a result, the movie wasn't just a staggering commercial success (grossing $304 million against a $14 million budget) but it scored an impressive 80% with critics as well.

9. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Will Be A Significant Improvement

The Prediction: After director Marc Webb and lead Andrew Garfield had to deal with the awkward growing pains and undeniable redundancy of the Amazing Spider-Man reboot, surely the second movie would feel like a proper Spider-Man sequel and get things back on track? The Reality: The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is both the lowest-grossing and worst-received of all five Spider-Man movies to date, in large part because it had clearly failed to learn the lessons of the second-worst movie, Spider-Man 3. Much like that catastrophe, this film is overloaded with villains while seemingly struggling to actually fill its bloated 142-minute run-time. Jamie Foxx is horribly miscast in the role of limp villain Electro, Paul Giamatti is relegated to a glorified cameo, and aside from Gwen Stacy's death, there's just not a lot here that evokes more than a dubious shrug. Due to the movie's tepid reception, production on a third film has been delayed by two whole years to 2018.

8. Transcendence Will Be A Nolan-Level Masterpiece

The Prediction: Christopher Nolan's faithful cinematographer Wally Pfister is directing his own movie? And it boasts an all-star cast including Johnny Depp, Rebecca Hall, Paul Bettany, Cillian Murphy, Morgan Freeman and Kate Mara? And it's an ambitious sci-fi flick with thought-provoking themes? There's no way this one can fail. The Reality: Expectations for this one were high right out of the gate, but it ultimately feels like Pfister attempting to ape the gravitas and style of a Nolan film without really having the script to do so. Pfister's direction is fine throughout, but the plot frequently asks viewers to jump through major logical hoops. and doesn't have a particularly convincing grasp on the nature of technology. The dialogue is also relatively troublesome at times, and the only actor who really escapes without suffering too much is Paul Bettany. The film was dumped on by critics (19%) and made just $3 million more than its huge $100 million budget, making it Depp's fourth starring flop in a row.

7. Unbroken Is A Guaranteed Best Picture Nominee

The Prediction: A biopic of legendary Olympic athlete Louie Zamperini, directed by Angelina Jolie, shot by Roger Deakins and boasting a cast of hungry up-and-comers? The second the first trailer for this inspirational drama hit the web, Unbroken was considered a front-runner for 2015's Best Picture Academy Award. The Reality: The movie began screening for press in November and was embargoed until the end of that month, when word finally broke out that, in fact, Unbroken was merely a satisfactory war drama and not the Earth-shatteringly emotive, thought-provoking film many were expecting. The film ultimately opened to heavily mixed reviews (49%), praising the visuals and Jack O'Connell's lead performance in particular, but also criticising its relatively generic style, failing to distinguish itself from other similar movies as a result. The reviews proved a major shock for anyone following the awards circuit with any interest, for though the film did land on Top 10 lists of both the American Film Institute and the National Board of Review, it's had an incredibly muted presence in terms of major precursor awards, and will struggle to scoop more than a few technical Oscar nominations.

6. Transformers: Age Of Extinction Will Be Significantly Improved By The Lack Of Shia LaBeouf

The Prediction: Early in the pre-production stages of the fourth Transformers movie, it was made clear that Shia LaBeouf would not be returning as prior series protagonist Sam Witwicky, leading to rampant rumours that Jason Statham was being courted as the new leading man for the franchise. In the end, however, Mark Wahlberg won the role, and most fans let out a sigh of relief that the series would now be commanded by a man rather than an annoying man-child. The Reality: Though Mark Wahlberg is a more tolerable presence than LaBeouf ever was in these movies, he can do little to elevate what is in many ways the most irritating of all the Transformers films. Every poor instinct this series has ever shown is concentrated for maximum annoyance over 165 minutes, and though Wahlberg tries to convince as a concerned father (and an inventor, of course), he's mostly helpless amid the onslaught of howlingly awful dialogue and overdone effects.

5. Paddington Will Lose The Essence Of The Character

The Prediction: The early trailers for Paddington focused on gross-out gags including ear wax but failed to depict the dignified charm of the character. There was little doubt this was going to be another big-budget ruination of a beloved children's icon. The Reality: Against overwhelmingly negative expectations, Paddington was actually every bit as charming as its trailers suggested it probably wasn't. Ben Whishaw gives a superb performance as the titular bear, and though the movie does feature its share of silly visual gags, it never loses sight of the distinctly British essence of the character. In short, you'd need a heart of stone not to be charmed by the marvelous digital wizardry on display here (not to mention the fine live-action performances from Sally Hawkins and Hugh Bonneville in particular), a testament to not judging a film by its trailer.

4. Jersey Boys Will Be Clint Eastwood's Best Film In Years

The Prediction: Clint Eastwood taking on the musical genre might not sound like the snuggest fit in the world, but given that he's adapting the life story of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, which is intertwined with the New Jersey crime scene, it sounded right up the director's street. Trailers asserted a Goodfellas-esque tone, and given that Clint's last few directorial efforts, such as J. Edgar (43%) and Hereafter (46%), haven't exactly lit up cinema screens, this seemed like a fine return to form for the actor-turned-filmmaker. The Reality: Though competently made, well-acted and benefiting from the pleasure of Valli's toe-tapping tunes, Jersey Boys is a mostly by-the-numbers musical biopic, simply going through the motions and shot through with a bizarre anonymity that bears few hallmarks of an Eastwood picture. Critical reviews were decidedly mixed (53%), and it seemed like the potential for a masterpiece had been mostly squandered. Eastwood's more recent release, American Sniper, did however score 75%, his best reviews since 2008's Gran Torino.

3. How To Train Your Dragon 2 Will Destroy The Box Office

The Prediction: After DreamWorks' splendid animation How to Train Your Dragon scored $494 million worldwide, was nominated for two Oscars (Best Animated Feature and Best Original Song) and scored 98% on Rotten Tomatoes, it seemed reasonable that the massively-hyped sequel would improve upon the original movie's box office showing with a strong $700+ million haul. The Reality: Despite some of the year's strongest reviews (92%), How to Train Your Dragon 2 scored a respectable if surprisingly low $618 million, the most shocking fact of which was that the movie earned only $176 million in the US compared to the original movie's $217 million. The film did play extremely well overseas, however, accounting for its overall improvement over its predecessor. Still, domestic grosses are often more important to the studio than international (as they take a larger portion of the pot), and Dragon 2's US box office decline has mystified movie prognosticators ever since the film came out. It just goes to show that not every successful hit movie will absolutely hit a home run the second time around...

2. Guardians Of The Galaxy Will Flop

The Prediction: A Marvel Studios film adapted from niche source material, helmed by a largely untested director and starring a giant tree monster and a talking, anthropomorphic raccoon? Sure, that'll put butts in seats... The Reality: Despite a massive uphill struggle to get audiences interested in something so weird, a fantastic marketing campaign, stellar reviews (90%) and contagious word-of-mouth caused Guardians to score a huge $772 million worldwide, making it the second highest-grossing film of 2014. Given the peculiar nature of the source material, Guardians' success is both a testament to audiences willing to bank on something exciting and original, and of course, the fact that Marvel Studios can pretty much sell anything to audiences at this point.

1. The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies Will Be The Best Of The Trilogy

The Prediction: Though Peter Jackson's decision to split The Hobbit into three movies was almost universally derided by all but the most forgiving Tokein fans, it was still widely expected that the third film, The Battle of the Five Armies, would be the gem-stone of the trilogy, given the epic battles and sure closure it would bring to Bilbo's story. The Reality: Though Five Armies does feature the best action of the trilogy and brings things to a close in a relatively satisfying fashion, it's far from the decisively best of the three movies, and in many respects delivers some of the most bloated dialogue and perfunctory comic relief of the lot. It's thankfully the shortest of the three movies by a good deal, but it's typically regarded to be inferior to The Desolation of Smaug, and currently sits as the worst-reviewed of the three movies, scoring 61% compared to An Unexpected Journey's 64% and Smaug's 74%. Which movies completely destroyed your expectations in 2014? Shout it out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.