15 Worst Movies That Somehow Won Oscars

Rappers, clowns and Sir Anthony Hopkins as a killer hamster...

Oscars Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

It's sort of an unwritten rule of the Oscars that bad films can't make it through the filtering process. Only the very elite of films can even be recognised, even with campaigning playing some part in what gets recognised as great and what misses out. After all, it's not like the Academy would pick garbage simply because the studios lobbied harder than the true greats of the year.

And yet, despite the Academy occasionally limiting the number of films they even put up for the top Best Film gong because of a lack of perceived quality options, they've given out gold to some seriously iffy films. Some you'd class as mediocre on more charitable days, but there's no getting around the fact that the bottom rung of the quality ladder of Oscar winners is very close to the gutter.

Just imagine what happens if Suicide Squad manages to win this year as well. Cats and dogs will marry in the streets, horses will eat one another, a sequel might actually get made with Mel Gibson... You know, real end of days stuff. But the most surprising revelation is that it might not even become the worst ever Oscar winner.

It doesn't always take a masterpiece to win an Oscar...


15. 8 Mile (2002)

Eminem 8 mile
Universal Studios

Won For: Best Song

You can claim that "Lose Yourself" is one of Eminem's most blistering tracks all you like, but it's no more than a tub-thumping anthem for middle aged men to psyche themselves up to go to their plumbing job and imagine there's a bigger space in the universe for them. Sure, it has an infectious knack for getting under your skin, but it cannot do anything to elevate the film it was released for out of mediocrity.

And for all that Eminem spits impressive lines on the track - and at times in the film - the rags to riches rise of the most comically named rapper of all - B-Rabbit - is not a great showcase of his acting skill. It does show off Michael Shannon's excellent range, but aside from a few stand-out moments, it ranks somewhere below Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas in terms of authentic, engaging story-telling.


14. Earthquake (1974)

Universal Pictures

Won For: Best Sound Mixing, Special Achievement Academy Award for Visual Effects

Earthquake winning an Oscar (actually two, since it got its own special acknowledgement for Visual Effects) in 1974 is the equivalent of someone like Michael Bay or Roland Emmerich picking one up now for exactly the same sort of fare. It just wouldn't happen, barring some truly exceptional practical or special effects - and even then, disaster movies are so far out of fashion, it'd be a stretch.

In actuality, Earthquake makes Emmerich's work look vastly superior, because of its curious decision to focus on entirely the wrong thing. Where modern disaster movie makers would go for straight disaster porn, director Mark Robson instead went hard on the melodrama and tried to squeeze empathy from the audience for his horrible troupe of characters.

So even as a disaster movie, it failed: it's removed from the mindless, popcorn spectacle any fan of the genre would want, and the more human focus just showed up Robson's flaws as a story-teller. Still, at least the effects did look impressive.


13. What Dreams May Come (1998)

What Dreams May Come Robin Williams
Polygram

Won For: Best Visual Effects

What Dreams May Come is not a disaster of a film - and indeed the Visual Effects that won it Oscar are stunning in places - but it simply isn't up to the Oscar-winner billing you'd usually limit to far better films. And though you can't discount the artist merit of the film's vision of the after-life, the rest of the production is such a litany of mistakes that it's way too easy to forget it.

Robin Williams is horribly miscast, despite his wonderful knack for turning emotionally complex material into irresistible performances. The problem here is that the material just isn't there for him to work with: it's a sombre, thinly-veiled religious meditation that takes in love, family and way too much sentimentality in a way that feels painfully manipulative.

There are flashes of weight and substance to match the style, but more-over, it's a picture of missed opportunities, and there's so little real content that you feel like you're staring at an oil painting while someone shouts at you about crying for the cruel fate of humanity. If there was a better bridge between the two sensations, it might have been better.


12. Harry And The Hendersons (1987)

Harry And The Hendersons
Universal Pictures

Won For: Best Make-Up

Harry And The Hendersons exists in that same protected nostalgic bubble as the likes of Alf, Flight Of The Navigator and E.T. for a certain generation of film fans, missing entirely the fact that it's nowhere near as good as any of them. And when the credits roll, though you've probably just spent a couple of hours enjoying the make-up on Big Foot, there's no getting around the fact that you've also just been preached at quite vulgarly about the sin of eating meat. Not just hunting, literally eating hamburgers, which sort of makes this the anti-Mac And Me.

Putting aside the off-putting politics (it's not so much the message but the delivery that isn't welcome), the film is no more than a silly, light-weight family drama about idiots who try to domesticate a giant, bewildered wild animal. If you've seen Beethoven, E.T., Encino Man or Crocodile Dundee, you've pretty got a handle on the kind of hi-jinx that ensue.


11. Around The World In 80 Days (1956)

Around The World In 80 Days
United Artists

Won For: Best Picture, Best Cinematography, Best Film Editing, Best Music, Best Adapted Screenplay

There's a fairly well established critical community that seem to agree that Around The World In 80 Days is the undisputed worst Best Film of all time. It isn't, but it's a very close run race and there's no way it deserved Hollywood's most prestigious award on merit.

The film, which is only one of several unsatisfying attempts to make the classic story for the screen is an over-long, over-stuffed ordeal and an excuse for lots of self-congratulatory back-slapping and vulgar levels of excess. If it was nominated in modern times, there would be riots in the streets of tumblr as hashtags zeroed in on privilege cut across the air.

It's full of cameos, but in the same sort of way that Movie 43 and Zoolander 2 were: they're trotted out merely to show that the film has famous fans, serving no narrative purpose and over-extending what is already a sickly candyland nightmare.


10. The Greatest Show On Earth (1952)

The Greatest Show On Earth
Paramount Pictures

Won For: Best Picture, Best Story

There is no sense in diminishing what Cecile B Demille did for Hollywood - and probably no way to do it even if you were inclined. He was a protected legend, the inventor of blockbusters who made some of Tinseltown's first great epics. Sadly, he also made The Greatest Show On Earth, which looks even worse in proximity with the likes of Cleopatra.

The Greatest Show On Earth is another exercise in excess, a lavish celebration of circuses the same way Cars and Cars 2 feel like personal tributes to muscle cars and racing by John Lasseter that we were all duped into watching too. It's effectively like watching a soap play out under the big top, knitted together barely by the thinnest plot as talent is squandered all over the place by a lack of focus and an uncharacteristic absence of directing control.

There's some pleasure to be had in the pageantry, but ultimately the substance simply isn't there to match it and for a title like that, for the end result to be dull is just criminal.


9. Flashdance (1983)

Flashdance Hero
Paramount Pictures

Won For: Best Song

Like 8 Mile, most people rather charitably remember Flashdance as a "classic" because of a song (and perhaps for one particular dance sequence whose appreciation has all but been diluted down into one iconic image). That rather misses the point that the film itself is really not that great.

The song adds a faux gloss of relevance to what otherwise would have faded into 1980s obscurity where its writing, acting and character development probably deserved it to go. It could - and probably should - have been another Saturday Night Fever, invested in the adversity and dreams of the lead within the bubble of societal pressures and expectations - but it singularly fails to allow us to know the character and ends up just looking like an under-cooked attempt to rip it off for similar success.

There are too many stereotypes and caricatures of the working class and nothing rings true in the material used to thinly tie together the dance sequences. Still, "...What A Feeling" is still a banger, so there's some value to it.


8. The Wolfman (2010)

The Wolfman
Universal Pictures

Won For: Best Make-Up

Though there is now a concentrated effort to turn the Universal Monsters world into a shared universe to rival... well every other bloody shared universe Hollywood is trying to insist doesn't exist just for money, more recent efforts to trade on the brand have been poor at best.

The Wolfman initially looked promising though: it had a great cast, the effects work looked good and there were hints that it would be legitimately scary... but that all evaporated in a fog of fur-balls as Joe Johnston squandered his opportunity to recapture his glory days. His film feels too familiar, too derivative and too much like it could have been a made-for-TV Sherlock Holmes episode to ever announce itself as anything above mediocre.

And though the wolf make-up looked good in sporadic appearances (much like how the film's brilliance only showed itself in painfully limited flashes), when it was shown on screen too long, it all looked faintly ridiculous. And absolutely no film could ever recover from the revelation that the villain was in fact the genetic results of an unholy tryst between Sir Anthony Hopkins and some sort of hamster...

Anthony Hopkins Wolfman
Universal Pictures

7. My Cousin Vinny (1992)

My Cousin Vinny
20th Century Fox

Won For: Best Supporting Actress

The very idea that Marissa Tomei was handed her Best Supporting Actress Oscar for My Cousin Vinny in error says everything you need to know about the film's suitability to winning awards. But the fact that she was even nominated in the first place should be considered one of the most curious cases of over-inflated reactions in Hollywood history.

My Cousin Vinny is not unwatchable, and nor is it a particularly poor watch: it's just as light-weight and silly a premise as the likes of Uncle Buck and Legally Blonde. It's a fish out of water comedy with entertaining performances and the kind of story you would struggle to remember the ins and outs of even after multiple viewings. It's the epitome of disposable entertainment.

But it is as much an Oscar-worthy film as it is an antique Victorian teapot.


6. Crash (2004)

Crash Thandie Newton
Lionsgate

Won For: Best Picture

You really have to do something pretty impressive to have a collection of characters who rank significantly lower on the likability scale than the stars of New Year's Eve, but that's the feat achieved by Paul Haggis' much-maligned Crash.

The film is as subtle as a sledge-hammer in its portrait of racial tension in LA, and while the message undoubtedly has its roots in an important, nagging reality, it's presented in such a way that the insistence of its message is nothing short of infuriating. It's manipulative, melodramatic and puffed up with self-importance and pomposity that miss the point that every character is a paint-by-numbers cliche.

Was this really better than Brokeback Mountain or A History of Violence or Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind or even Spider-Man 2? Did it even deserve to be nominated for an Oscar, let alone to win Best Picture? No prizes for guessing the answers to those questions.


5. Alice In Wonderland (2010)

Johnny Deep Alice in Wonderland
Walt Disney Pictures

Won For: Best Art Direction

Though Alice In Wonderland is now cited as one of the chief examples of Tim Burton's worrying derailment from the talent who made the likes of Batman and Beetlejuice, there are some things to cherish about the garish, CGI-heavy take on Lewis Carroll's seminal story.

The visuals are glorious at times - but that should have gone without saying, given the genius of Burton's imagination - and Helena Bonham Carter's toddler-like Queen Of Hearts has her moments, but it's all such a vulgar fever dream that even the good vanishes without a smile when you scrutinise too heavily.

The CGI lends the film way too much of a false filter that robs sequences designed to drive empathy or sympathy of their emotional authenticity, and Burton seems to have spent so much time on the background (which was ironically obliterated by the forced perspective of 3D anyway), that he seems to have forgotten how to direct his principle players.


4. The Golden Compass (2007)

The Golden Compass Lyra Iorek Byrnison
New Line Cinema

Won For: Best Visual Effects

The chief crime of The Golden Compass is that it made a book series that is actually superior to The Lord Of The Rings and a good deal of the Harry Potter franchise look like garbage. The source material is dark and rich and gloriously complex with a cast of incredible characters, a genius story and action sequences that fed millions of imaginations.

It should have translated perfectly to the big screen, particularly with a lavish budget and a great cast, but American Pie's Chris Weitz instead conspired to make it dull. This is a film starring giant battle polar bears, and it's literally a boring slog. What sort of mishandling goes into such a foul-up?

It absolutely deserves the acknowledgment of its Visual Effects, but it just would have been nice to see some more substance under the bonnet, and we might not have seen the rest of the franchise cast off forever.


3. Pearl Harbour (2001)

Pearl Harbour Attack Affleck Hartnett
Buena Vista Pictures

Won For: Best Sound Editing

Who the hell thought a historical event as poignant and whose cinematic retelling would require as much delicacy as Pearl Harbour would be perfectly suited to the particular "skills" of Michael Bay?

What should have been a thoughtful meditation on the nature of violence and on a nation forced into action despite turning a blind eye for years ended up being a bombastic, pompous exercise in pyrotechnic porn with a melodramatic, cloying romantic sub-plot that felt like it had taken literally minutes to cobble together.

The dialogue sounds like T-shirt slogans, the characters are one dimensional and delivered by wooden performances and though the sound was pretty good (as you'd expect from someone so obsessed with fetishised violence), it absolutely wasn't enough to add "Oscar Wining Film..." to the front of Pearl Harbour as some measure of overall quality.


2. King Kong (1976)

King Kong 1976
Paramount Pictures

Won For: Best Visual Effects

In 1933, Hollywood was changed forever by the tale of a Great Ape, his girlfriend and the men who wanted to split them up. Well, sort of, anyway. The original King Kong might not have had the technology to be visually dazzling, but it made do with practical effects and screen magic to encourage the audience's imagination, and it's still the best Kong movie ever released.

The first attempt to remake it - in 1976 with Jeff Bridges in the non-monkey lead - was everything the '33 iteration wasn't. Sure, it had a much more impressive budget for visual effects, which got it an Oscar, but those effects have arguably aged worse than the early version. And it really doesn't help the whole tawdry affair that the money spent on effects would have been better spent on a director who would get more out of his cast, or just generally on some acting lessons for everyone involved.

Because King Kong '76 is a shlocky, sloppy mess, roaringly hilarious in places (and never intentionally) and wholly unnecessary from the opening credits onwards. It smacks of the arrogance of modernity, and its disastrous over-reaching is almost poetically pertinent.


1. Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Oscars
Warner Bros.

In the immortal words of Charlton Heston: "You Maniacs! You blew it up! Ah, damn you! God damn you all to hell!"

Which other Oscar winners deserve to be on this roll-call of shame? Share your picks below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.