17 Actors You Didn't Know Almost Played The Avengers

Be thankful for right decisions...

If David Hasselhoff is evidence of anything in comic book movie making, it's that initial casting decisions aren't always as perfect as the casters might think.

Thankfully, times have changed since the heyday of casting completely inappropriate people in important roles, and now we have solid decisions like Jesse Eisenberg as Lex Luthor... Okay, so maybe the net isn't as tight as it could be, but at least the news that leaks occasionally linking actors to roles they missed out on proves that there is a little more due diligence in the process. Otherwise this would be the world where Bill Murray had played Batman, or Tom Selleck for that matter.

It is of course invariably entertaining to read that an actor bailed on a potentially career making movie or TV show to concentrate on a project that comically bombed. These people are Hollywood's tragic fools, who turned down or missed out on solid gold success, and the comic book movie genre has an incredible number of these nearly men.

With Avengers: Age Of Ultron about to land in cinemas, it's now an appropriate time to look at the actors who could have shaped the universe in a very different way. These particular nearly men are the faces who were almost behind the capes and cowls, and they deserve to be saluted for how close they came to being genre legends...


17. Val Kilmer Was Almost Captain America

Despite being one of the better Batman actors, Val Kilmer has long been considered a Hollywood morality tale: not only was he apparently difficult to work with (including on his career making job in Batman Forever) but he also made some stunningly odd decisions in his career. In fact, the list of films that the actor turned down reads like a lesson in why you should always invest in an agent with your best interests at heart: as well as turning down the chance to return for Batman & Robin, Kilmer also turned down roles in Dune, Blue Velvet, Point Break", In The Line Of Fire and Indecent Proposal.

Imagine how that CV could have looked...

The most intriguing film that Kilmer turned down among the many others was Captain America - not the role that would go to Chris Evans during the modern comic book movie love-in, but rather the 1990 atrocity starring Matt Salinger. For once, Kilmer could count this as a smart move, and a dodged bullet, since he turned the role down in favour of working on The Doors, which was about a million miles away in terms of quality, despite Stan Lee's frankly baffling assertion that the 1990 Cap was good when he saw it, claiming that the re-shoots it underwent were to make it even better:

"Director Albert Pyun did it so well and so excitingly that everyone in the audience kept clamoring for more."

16. Emily Blunt Was Almost Black Widow (AND Peggy Carter)

British actor Emily Blunt was Marvel's first choice for not only Black Widow in Iron Man 2 but also Peggy Carter in Captain America: The First Avenger, but she turned both roles down, as she confirmed to New York Magazine.

She said she wasn't attracted to roles in superhero films, because they tend to be "thankless" - where the option is usually the "pill girlfriend" - and she turned down Black Widow and Carter because "the part wasn't very good or the timing wasn't right."

Presumably, Black Widow was mis-timed and Carter too boring, given the requirements of the role and considering Blunt's subsequent revelation that she'd prefer a role in "a comic-book movie or a science-fiction film that would scare the bejesus out of me." It's a shame on both accounts, as Blunt could have slipped into both roles easily, though it would probably have been more intriguing to see her in a more robust action role like Black Widow.


15. Sam Rockwell Was Almost Iron Man

Given the fact that he was cast as Tony Stark's mirror image in Iron Man 2's Justin Hammer, it doesn't come as too much of a surprising revelation that the Moon actor was in the running to play Stark himself. Even though it seems unthinkable that anyone other than Robert Downey Jnr. Jon Favreau had Rockwell on his short-list for the role:

"He was one of the actors I was looking at for Tony Stark. There was some things he would bring to the role that would have been great. Sam is very charismatic and when I was looking at the character there was a list and he had a spot on it, which might have surprised some people. Robert surprised some people, too, though, and now he is Tony Stark, he owns that role. Sam would have come up with interesting and different things."

You can see the same genetics in Rockwell's on-screen persona as Downey Jnr's, though he is a little more dark and a little less swaggering, so it's not a bad shout as alternate castings go, and Favreau remained a fan of the actor, bringing him in for Hammer - a role adapted specially for him.


14. Rikki Lee Travolta Was Almost Thor

Way back in 2006, before Chris Hemsworth was cast as the blonde bombshell from a whole different world, another far more famous name was heavily linked with the role. Well, a famous surname anyway.

When David S Goyer was charged with writing the film, John Travolta's nephew Rikki Lee Travolta - a Shakespearean trained actor and martial artist, which is two things he has over Uncle John - was reported by a number of outlets as having been given the lead role, somewhat presumptuously. The same actor - who cut his teeth on Broadway - was apparently also considered to play James Bond when the producers decided to put Pierce Brosnan out to pasture, and he was linked to the role for a long time thanks to his formative acting development.

Despite being linked with those two massive roles, Travolta's sole screen acting credit is as a bell-hop in Crime Fiction, and it seems he might well have been linked to the role simply because he looked a bit like statuesque male model Fabio.


13. Billy Crudup Was Almost The Hulk

From one thankfully dodged bullet to one that isn't quite so happy. When Ang Lee was given the difficult task of adapting the big green monster for the big screen, his intention was to cast Billy Crudup, and not the coincidentally named Eric Bana for the lead role. The actor was so firmly wanted that concept artist Benton Jew - who had worked on a bid for Jonathan Hensleigh€˜s unmade 1997 Hulk film and would later works as a storyboard artist on Louis Leterrier€˜s The Incredible Hulk - mocked up shots of Crudup as Hulk.

The versions of the Hulk that didn't make it to the screen included him battling terrorists and insects (there's probably still time for both, to be fair), but it's hard to imagine that Crudup would have failed int he role, considering his exceptional performance as Dr Manhattan in Watchmen. It is clear that he was still attached as the tentative lead when Jew pitched the artwork, but Ang Lee's confidence in getting his star man obviously wasn't met with the same enthusiasm from his end as Crudup turned the offer down, and Bana stepped in (eventually).


12. Eliza Dushku Was Almost Black Widow

Sometimes, no matter how hard you campaign for something, the odds are stacked too high against you, and you end up looking slightly foolish for all the very, very public effort you put in to trying to make your dream happen. Such was the case for Eliza Dushku, who took to the Howard Stern show to campaign heavily for the role of Black Widow in Iron Man 2. While starring in Dollhouse, Dushku expounded her own virtues, including her proficiency in Russian, apparently:

€œThey€™re doing 'Iron Man 2,' and I€™m so perfect for the Black Widow character, that they just need to get into it. They need to understand€ I just learned Russian because I had to play a Russian girl in 'Dollhouse.' Maybe we could all tell them. Let's get on a Black Widow Iron Man 2 campaign.€
Dushku obviously also had the necessary fighting skills from her time on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but neither fact enamoured the casting team behind the underwhelming sequel, who over-looked her, though some say she was considered for the role.

Somewhat ironically, Scarlett Johansson wasn't the first pick to play the character either (more of which later), but her campaign to canvas for the role was more success than Dushku's - possibly because she went as far as to dye her hair red well in advance of even being confirmed for the role.


11. Tom Hiddleston Was Almost Thor

Joining the same brigade as Sam Rockwell of actors who were deemed more attractive for villainous roles rather than their initially desired hero roles, Tom Hiddleston was in line for the Thor role before he was subsequently cast as Loki.

The decision to cast him as the villain, which was made by Kenneth Branagh - who should know villains considering he's played Victor Frankenstein and Shakespeare's Iago in past films - proved an inspired one, considering how much more appropriate Hiddleston's smaller, leaner frame is for Loki, the slightly runt-ish (but not entirely weak) envious brother, and how well the dynamic with the larger, more robust Hemsworth turned out to be.

Still, Hiddleston would have made an intriguing Thor, and there's even footage available of the future Loki in his blonde wig, on the other side of the good/evil divide, as included in the Thor DVD Extras...


10. Jeff Goldblum Was Almost The Hulk

After the mid-1990s Hulk project collapsed, the big screen adaptation was up in the air, and a number of big name actors were linked with the role, including Billy Crudup - who passed - and Jurassic Park star Jeff Goldblum, who tested unsuccessfully for the role.

Goldblum is of course no stranger to body-shock movies, having made arguably the most memorable of all in The Fly, and there is something irresistible in the idea of a Hulk movie played in similar terms, which he may have brought to the role of Bruce Banner, but that sadly was not to be.

Instead the role went to Eric Bana, who was largely shackled by the ponderous tone, and you get the sense that even if Goldblum had been cast, he wouldn't have been a good fit for Ang Lee's vision.


9. Dolph Lundgren Was Almost Captain America

Another nod for the awful 1990 Captain America that Stan Lee so unfeasibly loved even before it was "fixed" by reshoots; and an actor who wouldn't have fit the agenda to cast someone who could play Steve Rogers both before and after his transformation. The film-makers initially intended to cast two actors as a result, but another awful comic book property got in the way, and paved the course for Matt Salinger to be cast.

Lundgren was too busy being the first actor to fail to bring The Punisher to screen, and was spared the potentially damaging association with the Cap production that ran two years late, and suffered catastrophic financial problems. He was also spared the ignominy of having to wear a Cap suit with ear holes that chaffed so badly that they had to use plastic ears to save Salinger's real ones.


8. Johnny Depp Was Almost Bruce Banner

Before Ang Lee came in the make the much-maligned 2003 big screen debut (not including the spin-offs of the Lou Ferigno TV show) Hulk, there were plans to make The Incredible Hulk with Michael France scripting, and (eventually) Jonathan Hensleigh (who made the second Punisher movie in 2004) directing - after Joe Johnston dropped out.

After a couple of years of Development Hell at the early 90s saw several rewrites and several changes in personnel, the script eventually emerged with three villains - the Leader, the Absorbing Man and Zzzax - and absent father Brian Banner. At some point during that gestation period, the initial choice to play Banner was replaced with Crudup, who turned it down - but it's hard not to imagine that Johnny Depp - the first man wanted for the role - might have been a very odd choice for the character.


7. Lindsay Lohan Was Almost... Someone

It's hard to tell the truth with some people, but according to Lohan herself, she was up for a role in the Avengers movie, but the incompetence of her management meant she missed out - because, of course, that would be the only thing standing between her and global success.

Lohan spoke out in her reality TV show to confirm that she had told her manager she wanted a part in the big-budget superhero ensemble, but that they didn't €œpush€ hard enough, and the part was given to an €œunknown.€ Presumably that means Lohan wanted to be Maria Hill, but her somewhat disparaging "unknown" remark suggests she has no awareness of How I Met Your Mother's enduring success.

Whether anyone knows which character Lohan was actually talking about remains to be seen, and whether anyone actually should believe her is also pretty much up in the air.


6. David Duchovny Was Almost The Hulk

The former X-Files lead, who was voted one of the most beautiful people in the world not so long ago, has something in common with Jeff Goldblum - who he does a nailed-on impression of, incidentally - in that he was up for the role of Bruce Banner and the Hulk.

But unlike Goldblum, Duchovny was up for the role in a movie that would never have made it to the cinema, as he was linked with the planned direct to DVD sequel to Ang Lee's 2003 effort, which Eric Bana bailed on when it was cast off to the home release market.

Duchovny was close to signing before the project was pulled completely and Edward Norton did his level best to make the character work with the follow-up sort-of-reboot. Duchovny had already tested for the original film, but missed out to Eric Bana, so goes down as the only actor on this list to be turned down for the same role twice.


5. Nic Cage Was Almost Iron Man (Well, He Tried Anyway)

There is a long and colourful history of movies that Nicolas Cage was almost in - in fact, we've looked 10 such projects that he came within a whisker of ruining before - and while some of those roles never happened because he turned them down, or the films simply stopped existing (like Superman and Batman Triumphant), in the case of Iron Man, Cage's desire to play the character was apparently just ignored.

As far back as 1997, the man who would eventually end up with his comic book movie opportunity with Ghost Rider, was campaigning for the role of Tony Stark, which is not at all surprising given his self-confessed comic book obsession.

Cage has also been involved in a She-Hulk film - or at least he tried to convince Marvel to make one with Eva Mendes - and rather comically ruled himself publicly out of Doctor Strange at one point, despite nobody asking the question.


4. Steve Buscemi Was Almost The Hulk

Ranking alongside Bill Murray as Batman in the left-field alternate casting choices, Steve Buscemi tested for the role of Bruce Banner before Eric Bana was cast.

Buscemi would have fit the bill of actors who have the power to segue easily from slight, convincingly mild-mannered men to monsters: he has an exotic otherness that has made roles like his Nucky Thompson in Boardwalk Empire, and his scene-stealing turns in the likes of Sopranos and Con Air prove his menace.

His intellect would obviously have suited Banner, and though he isn't exactly known for his physical performances, he wrestled varsity at school and spent four years as a fire-fighter before he turned to acting, so it's obviously in him. Clearly, he was deemed too odd an option, and the more traditionally physically imposing Bana was cast.


3. Liam Hemsworth Was Almost Thor

You really have to feel for Liam Hemsworth: he travelled halfway across the world to audition for a career making role, made it to the final two and was ultimately passed up in favour of someone who looked pretty much identical to him. Had he not had a brother, Liam would have been Thor, and would not be remembered as the Hemsworth brother who was in Expendables and dated Miley Cyrus.

The final choice of who would be Thor came down to the Australian brothers and it seems Kenneth Branagh was more enamoured with Chris' audition. But at least Liam is pretty much guaranteed to be able to play an evil Thor clone villain if and when Marvel run out of ideas and start trotting out the same ideas as the failed comic book movies of the past.

It's probably only a matter of time.


2. Tom Cruise Was Almost Iron Man AnD Bruce Banner

Again, it's hard to imagine anyone bringing the role of Tony Stark to screen with quite as much success as Robert Downey Jnr, but considering Jon Favreau's objective to make Stark €œa likable asshole€ - apparently the thing that got RDJ the job - one of the early names linked to the role would have been a good fit.

He would have been suave enough, charismatic enough and crucially, just about snarky enough to pull off a similar performance, and he obviously had enough in his repertoire to convince producers to flirt openly with the idea of casting him (and also bringing him in to co-produce). Cruise was linked for a long time, and Kevin Feige was quoted back in 2004 talking about the possibility:

€œThere have been discussions (with Cruise) over the last several years and there are a number of factors involved. All we know is that we€™re putting all the pieces in place and then we€™ll find the best Tony Stark that we can get.€
It was ultimately the script that turned Cruise off the role - before Favreau came on board and the story was rewritten, presumably to jettison the bit that turned major Hollywood actors off. Cruise was very open about his decision to turn the role down:
€œI don€™t know. It just € they came to me at a certain point and € when I do something, I wanna do it right. If I commit to something, it has to be done in a way that I know it€™s gonna be something special. And as it was lining up, it just didn€™t feel to me like it was gonna work.€

1. Arnold Schwarzenegger Was Almost Captain America

Though Steve Buscemi's almost casting as the Hulk was very nearly the oddest example on this list, that particularly inauspicious accolade must go to Arnold Schwarzenegger, who was yet another candidate to play Captain America for the awful 1990 film that eventually starred Matt Salinger.

With similar concerns to when he ran for the American Senate seemingly getting in the way of his playing a genuine American icon, Arnie eventually missed out on the role because of his thick accent. It's curious that two foreign stars were up for the role of Captain America, considering the fury that initially met the casting of an English Superman, and he doesn't even come from Earth originally.

Considering the atrocity that was Arnie's Dr Freeze, it's probably best he wasn't able to turn Cap into a quip spitting action cliche, but he was probably the only actor in the history of films who could have competed with Rob Liefeld's barrel-chested vision of Captain America.

Which of these stars do you wish had made it through to the Avengers movies? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.