20 Most Critically Reviled Films Of 2014

No movies p**ed off the critics more than these.

Despite what a particularly vocal and nasty contingent of gamers might tell you, there's no such thing as objectivity when it comes to reviews. Everything €“ from the latest Michael Bay blockbuster to shadows dancing on the walls of a cave €“ are totally subjective. No two people are going to have the exact same opinion about a piece of art, a song, a book, a film. There is, however, a little thing called critical consensus. That's when everyone pretty much does agree on the quality of film. And that's what Rotten Tomatoes is for: the aggregator site pulls together all professional (or not-so-professional) reviews of a movie, then figures out what the average review of that film is. Using that algorithm, we can figure out the critical consensus for pretty much any major film release. You could use Rotten Tomatoes to find what reviewers decided were amongst the best films of the year, based on their positive reviews. Or you could do the exact opposite of that, if you were feeling masochistic. Sometimes, you feel masochistic. Having celebrated the best and brightest it's time now to turn to the worst and darkest: the failed rom coms, the dramas that fell flat on their face. The Adam Sandler movies. These are the twenty most critically reviled films of 2014, according to Rotten Tomatoes.

20. Very Good Girls

19% - 31 Reviews More like Very Bad Girls, huh? Or Very Much Not Heard Of This Film About Good Girls. 68-year-old Naomi Foner Gyllenhaal was nominated for an Oscar for her screenplay to Running On Empty. But that was in 1988, and that film starred River Phoenix and was directed by Sidney Lumet. Very Good Girls, meanwhile, is directed by Foner, and stars Dakota Fanning and Elizabeth Olsen who fall for the same guy. And they've agreed to both lose their virginity before they go to college! It's American Pie meets every rom com! Choice review quote: €œThis all-around misfire saddles a miscast group of name thesps...with poor word of mouth from the Sundance world preem, this looking-for-distribution indie may go directly to home formats.€ (Variety)

19. Sabotage

19% - 103 Reviews More like career Sabotage, huh? 2014 was the year the Governator tried to sidle back into Hollywood like his hand on a counsellor's buttocks, to mixed results. Whether Arnold Schwarzenegger's return to the Terminator franchise is successful remains to be seen, but this crime thriller was a total disaster. Directed by End Of Watch and Fury's David Ayer, little was made of his second release of the year. Because it was naff. Arnie lead a DEA team that also included, erm, Sam Worthington from that one summer and Olivia Williams, who is not American. Choice review quote: €œIt doesn't really work. It's a bit like finding Mary Berry serving at your local kebab shop - it just doesn't feel right..€ (Daily Express)

18. Transcendence

19% - 193 Reviews Christopher Nolan is one of the most celebrated directors of his time, and this year's Interstellar has topped many critics' best of lists. It was also he first film he'd made in a long time without his usual cinematographer Wally Pfister, because he was off busy working on his directorial debut! Boy, do audiences wish he hadn't bothered. This half-baked AI thriller with Johnny Depp as a scientist resurrected by his technology was one of the most disappointing releases of 2014. But hey, Morgan Freeman was in it! Choice review quote: €œThough Pfister and cinematographer Jess Hall deliver some effective camerawork, it€™s all slaved to a banal sci-fi slog that aims high but falls far.€ (Empire)

17. Devil's Due

18% - 49 Reviews Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett made a name for themselves as part of Radio Silence, a filmmaking troupe who directed a series of supernatural pranks-gone-wrong viral hits on YouTube which lead to them providing the final €“ and best €“ section of the anthology horror film V/H/S. They carried their found footage style over to Devil's Due, but forgot to bring any of their wit or invention with them either. The film has been described as a €œfound footage Rosemary's Baby€ and...yep. It adds nothing else. And subtracts a lot. Choice review quote: €œDredging up horror movie favourites like random nosebleeds...Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett direct with competence but a dispiriting lack of originality.€ (New York Times)

16. And So It Goes

18% - 83 Reviews Remeber when Rob Reiner made good films? It's been a good long while since he's managed it, with his guest spots in New Girl being the best thing he's done in years, but it wasn't all that long ago he was providing iconic movies as diverse as The Princess Bride, Spinal Tap and Stand By Me. At some point, though, it all went wrong. He still attracts the big names €“ And So It Goes stars Michael Douglas and Diane Keaton €“ but he seems to have forgotten the jokes. And the script in general. A wretched twilight years rom com. Choice review quote: €œAnd So It Goes may touch the frayed heartstrings of some older viewers, but it's pretty bad - the failed attempt to Heimlich a venerable movie genre.€ (TIME Magazine)

15. Transformers 4: Age Of Extinction

18% - 179 Reviews Just when you thought it was safe to go back into the toy store...Michael Bay has gotten rid of both Megan €œThe Girl Who Called Hitler€ Fox and Shia €œI'm Not Famous Any More€ LaBeouf, yet continues to play with his spinny cameras and robots in disguise with the fourth €“ yes fourth €“ Transformers film. This time actual racist nutjob Mark Wahlberg provided the acting talent that faltered in the face of a bunch of titanic CGI toys, whilst Kelsey Grammer and TJ Miller debased themselves for money. Of which Age Of Extinction made a lot. Choice review quote: "...an excruciatingly monotonous plunge through the id of our cultural subconscious, which means that it might even be a decent allegory in spite of itself." (The Berks-Mont News)

14. Ride Along

17% - 121 Reviews Ice Cube has turned out to be a pretty solid comedic prospect, with the 21 and 22 Jump Streets making up for any multitude of Are We There Yet? sins. Reviewers were quick to point out the irony of the former NWA rapper playing a cop in Ride Along, too, but that's because there wasn't much more to say. Kevin Hart is a rising star, making the leap from stand up to Hollywood leading man, but you'd be hard pressed to understand why off the back of this lazy, high-concept film about a guy taken on a €œride along€ with his police officer soon-to-be brother-in-law. Choice review quote: €œA butch and uncompromising assault of mediocrity and déjà vu.€ (Daily Telegraph)

13. Legends Of Oz: Dorothy's Return

16% - 55 Reviews L Frank Baum's Oz series of novels are an epic fantasy tapestry, going far beyond what the black-and-white-into-technicolour of the classic thirties film with Judy Garland, the Munchkins and all (and further even that the dark, twisted world of 1985's Return To Oz). There's a lot of Oz books left to adapt. Rather than delve into the original Baum series, though, Legends Of Oz: Dorothy's Return is a loose adaptation of a book by his great-grandson, by a CGI animation studio you've never heard of. Usually, if it's not Pixar or Dreamworks, it's naff. And this film very much is. Choice review quote: €œEven by the standards of allowance-snatching half-term filler, this is pretty indifferent ...€ (The Guardian)

12. Endless Love

15% - 85 Reviews A remake of Franco Zeffirelli's 1981 film (what?) of same name and second adaptation of Scott Spencer's novel (who?), Enduring Love stars Alex Pettyfer from Magic Mike and Alex Rider, and Robert Patrick from Terminator 2, sadly not as a stripper/spy or killer robot, respectively. It's an over-long, really boring and incredibly milquetoast star-crossed lovers film, where the lovers never seem particularly in peril and their relationship manages to develop without any real complications. They fall in love and that's about it. Good for them! Bad for narrative tension! Choice review quote: "It€™s about one hundred pages, and the only ones that were not dreary were sciatica inducing." (Scott Spencer)

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/