20 Huge Horror Movie Hits NOBODY Expected
Nobody saw these smash hit horror movies coming.
There's no denying that horror is one of the most reliably lucrative of all film genres, because while trends come and go, audiences have never lost their love of being terrified. And studios love the genre too, given the ease with which low-budget horror offerings without name casts can print money by offering up solid scares and maybe lashings of gore.
But there are still instances where the genre has managed to surprise us all by serving up a film that outperformed even the most optimistic of expectations. And that's absolutely true of the following 20 horror films throughout the genre's storied history, which most expected to either flop or simply perform extremely modestly.
However, fate had other plans, and each picture ended up generating colossal profits, enough that in many cases it also spawned a wider franchise.
These films are all a testament to the fact that there's always the potential for a relatively unassuming film to surprise us all and end up doing so, so much better than the pre-release hype would have you believe. And even if you thought these features would do well, nobody saw them doing quite this well.
20. Get Out
When the first trailer for Jordan Peele's Get Out dropped, few could've ever anticipated that it'd become a bona fide pop-culture phenomenon and Oscar-winning smash hit.
Given that Peele was primarily versed in comedy prior to this, few were expecting him to craft such an effective genre piece, and even when the rave reviews dropped from Sundance a month before release, it still didn't seem like a huge breakout was on the cards. Yet despite its socially conscious premise - ever a turn-off for mainstream audiences - Get Out showed up with its mere $4.5 million budget and ended up grossing a stupendous $255.4 million globally.
That's well over 50 times its cost, ensuring that Peele's film outgrossed far more high-profile releases like Alien: Covenant, Paddington 2, Baby Driver, Pitch Perfect 3, and John Wick: Chapter 2, to name just a few.
Get Out immediately established Peele as a serious force to be reckoned with, and his two subsequent features - Us and Nope - were both strong hits in their own right. A decade ago, though, one half of Key & Peele becoming an iconic horror auteur seemed completely absurd.
19. Paranormal Activity
For an entire decade, The Blair Witch Project appeared to have caught lightning in a bottle, being an ultra-low-budget horror film that captured the public's imagination and went on to become one of the most profitable movies of all time. But in 2009, Paranormal Activity enjoyed a similar trajectory, as after drumming up buzz at festival screenings in 2007, the $15,000 found footage film was acquired by Paramount.
Even with added post-production costs - including shooting a new ending - Paranormal Activity still only cost $200,000 when it was released to just 12 U.S. cinemas. With such a small initial rollout and the film featuring only unknown actors, it seemed like it would offer a decent return on Paramount's investment and then swiftly disappear. But Paranormal Activity did anything but that.
Due to consistently sold-out showings and strong word-of-mouth online, Paranormal Activity's theatrical run continued to expand, resulting in it ultimately grossing an outrageous $194.2 million worldwide. It remains one of horror's greatest and most surprising success stories, kickstarting a franchise which has netted almost $900 million in total, on a combined budget of just $28 million.
18. Halloween (1978)
John Carpenter's Halloween was in no way expected to be a hit when it released in 1978.
Being an independent film produced for just $325,000 with an unknown cast and crew, not to mention a minimal marketing campaign, there just wasn't much hope for it. But Halloween's unique atmosphere and expertly executed suspense made it a word-of-mouth hit, allowing it to "leg out" in the weeks following release as horror fans flocked to see it.
Ultimately, Halloween grossed a superb $70 million worldwide, making it one of the most successful independent films of all time and helping popularise the burgeoning slasher genre that became horror's bread and butter throughout the 1980s. And this, of course, includes Halloween itself, which has to date released 13 films with a collective box office haul of $885 million, against a total budget of $143.3 million.
While the original Jamie Lee Curtis-led era of Halloween finally concluded in 2022 with Halloween Ends, by 2023, Miramax had secured the rights to a TV series, so we clearly won't be going too long without seeing Michael Myers again.
17. The Devil Inside
Even though exorcism films are among the most lucrative in horror and the found footage subgenre basically couldn't miss in 2012, The Devil Inside is one of the most baffling horror success stories, well, ever.
The film received near-universal critical scorn, and while plenty of panned horror movies have performed well at the box office, The Devil Inside is a unique case, given that just about everyone seemed to hate it.
The movie's infamous non-ending - which abruptly cuts to a title card inviting the viewer to visit a website for more information - thoroughly pissed off the masses, enough that The Devil Inside landed a brutal "F" CinemaScore from moviegoers. And while CinemaScore is typically a water-tight indication of how well a film will perform with casual audiences, in this case, the polling was totally off, as The Devil Inside still went on to gross a flabbergasting $101.8 million globally.
It's an all-the-more insane number given that the film cost a mere $1 million, and yet the discourse surrounding its ending was so vitriolic that Paramount never bothered producing a sequel.
16. The Sixth Sense
Ridiculous though it might sound in retrospect, few had high hopes for The Sixth Sense when it released in the summer of 1999.
Beyond the summer being a dumping ground for cast-off horror films at the time, the movie was also helmed by a little-known filmmaker called M. Night Shyamalan, who only had two middlingly received features to his name at that point. Furthermore, Disney sold the production rights to Spyglass Entertainment during development, seeming to indicate they didn't have full-throated faith in it.
Despite releasing with little hype, The Sixth Sense quickly became a surprise smash as critics and audiences alike tripped over themselves trying not to spoil its big twist, while praising Shyamalan's clever filmmaking and the excellent performances from Bruce Willis, Toni Collette, and Haley Joel Osment in particular.
Ultimately, on a budget of $40 million, the film netted an astonishing $672.8 million, making it the highest-grossing horror film ever at the time - a title it held for almost 20 years until it was dethroned by 2017's It (but more on that shortly).
Because that wasn't enough, The Sixth Sense also received six Oscar nominations, including Best Picture and Best Director, in turn immediately putting Shyamalan on the map.
15. Open Water
Chris Kentis' low-budget shark horror-thriller Open Water had so, so much working against it.
For starters, it was shot on hideous digital video, ensuring it looked every bit as low-budget as it was despite not being a found footage film. Beyond that, basically the entire movie is just two characters bobbing around while lost at sea with very occasional appearances of sharks, and the film also has an extremely bleak ending.
But Open Water struck a chord with critics and audiences regardless, with its tense minimalist filmmaking, use of practical sharks, and inspiration from true events adding up to a feature that delivered the low-fi goods. As a result, Open Water grossed a hugely unexpected $55.5 million - more than 100x its production budget - and while the concept seemed relatively repeatable for at least a few sequels, neither the second nor third film replicated the same success.
Open Water 2: Adrift and Open Water 3: Cage Dive were ultimately standalone films that were reworked into Open Water sequels during production. Open Water 2 ended up grossing just $6.8 million, while Open Water 3 failed to crack even $1 million.
14. Resident Evil: The Final Chapter
Paul W.S. Anderson's Resident Evil films were never embraced by critics, but they do rank among the most commercially successful video game adaptations of all time, with the six-picture franchise rocking over $1.2 billion in box office receipts.
But it definitely seemed like the law of diminishing returns was starting to kick in with the fifth movie, Resident Evil: Retribution, which grossed "only" $240 million worldwide - a fair drop from the $300 million haul of the previous film, Resident Evil: Afterlife.
With the sixth film being dubbed "The Final Chapter" - ever a sign of desperation for a horror franchise - and the marketing selling it more as a Mad Max knock-off than anything resembling Resident Evil, the writing was on the wall for an underperformance. But Anderson's final Resident Evil movie defied the odds, grossing a stonking $312 million, making it the highest-grossing film in the series.
This was largely attributed to its incredible over-performance in China, where it grossed almost $160 million(!) alone.
Despite this suggesting the Anderson series still had financial life left in it, the producers nevertheless pressed on with a reboot in 2021, Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City, which flopped. Next up, Weapons director Zach Cregger will be taking a crack at adapting Resident Evil, so it'll be interesting to see if the acclaimed filmmaker can top Anderson at the box office.
13. It (2017)
Even though the trailers for 2017's adaptation of Stephen King's It racked up huge view counts on YouTube, time and time again, it's been shown that this doesn't always translate to box office gravy. And while it was a fair bet that the $40 million horror film would be an easy hit and gross, say, $300 million, pretty much nobody expected it to become a verifiable genre blockbuster.
After earning $123.4 million domestically in its opening weekend - more than double most analysts' estimates - It went on to end its run with $704.2 million worldwide. This not only made it the highest-grossing horror film of all time, unseating The Sixth Sense, but made It the third highest-grossing R-rated movie ever at the time.
For context, despite being an R-rated horror film about a child-murdering clown, It outgrossed far more accessible films like Justice League, Transformers: The Last Knight, Kong: Skull Island, Dunkirk, and War for the Planet of the Apes.
Though It Chapter Two didn't replicate the same level of success - topping out at $473.1 million - the duology netting almost $1.2 billion combined on a budget of $120 million is utter madness.
12. Lights Out
The track record of short horror films adapted into features is incredibly hit-and-miss, and so it was never guaranteed that David F. Sandberg's expansion of his hugely popular 2013 short Lights Out would do much business. After all, Sandberg had never helmed a fully budgeted feature before, and it could've very well been yet another punchy horror short that just didn't translate to a feature-length execution (looking at you, Night Swim).
But Lights Out blew past modest industry expectations in its opening weekend, grossing enough to steal the #3 spot from the far more mainstream-friendly Ice Age: Collision Course. By the end of its run, Sandberg's film raked in a terrific $148.9 million - a phenomenal return on its impressively low $5 million price tag.
It's a performance that's perhaps even more surprising in retrospect, that Sandberg's low-fi debut ended up grossing more than his 2023 flop superhero sequel, Shazam! Fury of the Gods ($134.1 million). And yet, despite Lights Out seemingly launching a new horror IP, a sequel hasn't materialised in the near-decade since, with Sandberg recently opining that "the moment has passed."
Talk about money left on the table.
11. Unfriended
It's tough to picture a film like Unfriended blowing up the box office in 2025, but even a decade ago, it seemed like a dim prospect. After all, it was one of the very first major "screenlife" movies, where the entire story unfolds on a laptop screen, and there was a perception that even enthusiastic horror fans wouldn't want to leave the house to effectively watch a screencast on a giant cinema screen.
But what did the analysts know? Unfriended went on to gross an impressive $62.9 million against its tiny $1 million production budget, far outpacing industry expectations and making it an undeniable, big fat hit.
A standalone sequel, Unfriended: Dark Web, was released in 2018, though it failed to recapture the same success, grossing just $16.4 million. However, given that it also cost only $1 million, it was likely still profitable for Blumhouse when it was all said and done.
10. Weapons
Considering that Zach Cregger's genre debut Barbarian was not only one of 2022's most talked-about horror films but also a firm box office hit - grossing $45.4 million against a $4.5 million budget - there was certainly confidence that his ambitious follow-up Weapons would do well.
But surely nobody expected it to do quite this well.
Boosted by a killer marketing campaign, rave reviews, and a mighty "A-" CinemaScore - the latter being an incredible rarity for horror - Cregger's film has grossed over $260 million globally at the time of press.
That's a flabbergasting return on its relatively modest $38 million price tag, considering the talent involved and impressive production values, and speaks to the strength of Cregger's voice as a visionary horror filmmaker who has now become a rising auteur in his own right. Needless to say, it'll be interesting to see if Cregger can pull off the three-peat with his upcoming Resident Evil adaptation, though if it's a stonking hit, it'll be considerably less surprising the third time in a row.
9. The Exorcist
William Friedkin's The Exorcist wasn't expected to be much of a hit, with Warner Bros. having low expectations due to it being a horror film without a name cast that also ran over budget.
As a result, the studio didn't screen it for critics and gave it a paltry initial release, but when it began selling out the small number of cinemas it was booked in, it was swiftly expanded to a wide release.
Strong word-of-mouth and media reports about adverse audience reactions to the film's shocking content created a snowball effect where The Exorcist became a must-see pop-culture phenomenon. By the end of its original theatrical run, it grossed an incredible $193 million on a mere $12 million budget, but re-releases over the last half-century have seen that figure balloon to $441.3 million.
That's not all, of course, as The Exorcist unexpectedly became the first horror film to ever be nominated for Best Picture, while also being nominated for nine additional gongs and even winning two, for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Sound.
By the end of its original run, The Exorcist had solidified itself as an all-timer horror film, and though this has led to five other Exorcist movies to date, their combined box office gross doesn't even get close to the original's outrageous haul.
8. Saw
Even accepting its buzzy premiere at the Sundance Film Festival, nobody could've ever expected that Saw would become the film to define horror throughout the 2000s.
James Wan and Leigh Whannell's cagey horror-thriller enjoyed colossal box office momentum thanks to positive word-of-mouth and whispers about its big twist, enough that it ultimately grossed a staggering $104 million against a mere $1.2 million budget.
Some quick napkin maths says that Saw grossed more than 86x its production budget - an outcome that not a single solitary soul could've ever seen coming, least of all Wan and Whannell, who have both enjoyed highly successful filmmaking careers as a result.
Of course, Saw's success led to a glut of sequels, with the 10 films to date generating $1.1 billion at the box office against a total budget of $120 million. While the post-festival buzz and low budget made it likely that Saw would be a modest hit, launching one of the most successful blockbuster horror franchises of all time? Inconceivable.
7. A Quiet Place
While A Quiet Place certainly touted an intriguingly unique premise, that didn't mean it would translate to box office dynamite for many reasons.
For one, John Krasinski had no prior cred in the horror genre as either an actor or filmmaker, and his two directorial efforts before this were both middlingly received. Beyond that, there was the obvious potential for a film about silence to be an absolute nightmare to sit through in a crowded cinema, given the tendency for modern audiences to consider silence a wholly optional courtesy of the moviegoing experience.
And even after the film premiered to rave reviews at SXSW a month before release, it still seemed like Krasinski's film would be a decent-but-not-stratospheric hit. But A Quiet Place topped out at an insane $341 million - over 20 times its $17 million budget.
This placed it ahead of many bigger-budget tentpoles released that year, including Skyscraper, Ocean's Eight, Pacific Rim: Uprising, and Creed II, as well as entries into popular horror IP like Halloween, Insidious: The Last Key, and The Predator. And like that, a new horror franchise was born, and between the two mainline movies and prequel spin-off, it's sitting at just over $900 million worldwide against a total budget of just $145 million.
6. Hellraiser
On paper, Hellraiser really didn't seem like the sort of horror movie that'd get the masses packed into multiplexes.
This was a low-budget $1 million horror based on a very niche novella - Clive Barker's The Hellbound Heart - released the year prior, with no major stars attached and Barker working as first-time director. But above all else, Hellraiser was a body horror film with an emphasis on extreme gore, while revolving around extradimensional entities with a penchant for sadomasochism.
None of this screamed "mainstream hit", and yet, Hellraiser went on to gross $30 million globally - a testament to the film's overpowering originality in an era known for me-too slasher flicks.
It was also distinguished by its striking visuals and Doug Bradley's superbly menacing performance as Pinhead, and while its success spawned a franchise now consisting of 11 films, not one of them has matched the original's critical or commercial appeal.
5. Sinners
Until a few weeks before release, the hype for Sinners was rather muted.
Even with a crackerjack cast and the pedigree of writer-director Ryan Coogler, there was much concern that the vampire film would struggle to break out with mainstream genre fans. Plus, its $100 million budget made it even more of a gamble, not only for being an original IP, but a horror film with a period setting, set against the backdrop of the Jim Crow South, with major musical elements.
As such, Sinners had quite the steep climb to profitability, and so few would've been surprised if it topped out at a modest $150 million or so. But Sinners was thankfully propelled forward by rave reviews and even genuine Oscar buzz, enough that Coogler's film ended up grossing $366.7 million globally, ensuring a sizable return on its hefty price tag.
On top of that, don't be surprised if the film adds a little more to that number with a re-release closer to next year's Oscars.
4. Scream
It's easy for modern audiences to gloss over the surprise success of Wes Craven's Scream, as the slasher subgenre was well and truly on life support by the mid-'90s, and releasing the film just five days before Christmas - when audiences typically flock to frothy comedy fare - seemed like a total own goal.
But Scream is ultimately a testament to the potential power of counter-programming, as it offered a different option for moviegoers and, aided by strong word-of-mouth, ended up grossing $173 million against a low $15 million budget.
Its success both revitalised the slasher genre and led to a wider horror franchise with more than $900 million in box office receipts - and the impending Scream 7 will inevitably push it well over the $1 billion mark.
Still, the original Scream remains the highest-grossing entry in the franchise so far, even though Scream 2 and Scream VI both came within a mouse-hair of dethroning it. That's quite the testament to just how much of a volcanic hit Craven's 1996 film was at the time.
3. The Conjuring: Last Rites
While it'd be ridiculous to call The Conjuring franchise anything less than a massive hit for Warner Bros., it also seemed abundantly clear that the series peaked back in 2018 with spin-off The Nun, which grossed a then-franchise high of $366 million.
Though The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It and The Nun 2 both posted solid results at the box office - $206 million and $269.6 million respectively - it seemed like the series had well and truly found its ceiling.
It seemed like the recently released The Conjuring: Last Rites would probably perform similarly to The Nun 2, then, but it actually ended up soaring past expectations, crossing the $400 million mark after its third weekend and becoming the series' highest-grossing film. This is an especially impressive performance considering the wildly mediocre reviews and general consensus that The Conjuring as an IP has had its day.
Without much direct competition in its immediate future, Last Rites could certainly leg out to around $500 million before it's all said and done. Needless to say, despite this being marketed as the final mainline Conjuring, would it surprise anyone if The Conjuring 5 was announced before year's end?
2. Terrifier 3
Terrifier is one of the most mind-boggling horror success stories of all time, given that Damien Leone's original 2016 slasher grossed just north of $400,000, a solid return on its $55,000 budget, but hardly box office dynamite. Yet the film's success on streaming ensured that Terrifier 2 became a breakout hit, netting $15.8 million against a beefier $250,000 budget.
However, Terrifier 3 is where Leone's franchise well and truly crossed the Rubicon, defying any and all expectations of what a sadistic, mean-spirited, ultra-gory horror movie could be.
Last year's threequel was produced for $2 million and ended up grossing an eye-watering $90.3 million, ensuring it became the highest-grossing unrated film of all time by a massive margin. Notably, it opened at #1 on its opening weekend, even dethroning the far more mainstream-skewing, big-budget superhero sequel Joker: Folie à Deux. What an outcome for an IP that had such humble origins and could so easily have been a one-and-done cult horror film.
With Terrifier 4 currently in the works, it'll be fascinating to see if Leone can one-up himself yet again.
1. The Purge
Before it came out, so much of the discussion surrounding The Purge involved mocking its "absurd" premise, that any American government would dare institute something as dystopian as an annual night of state-sponsored murder and mayhem.
Yeah, about that...
But neither the pre-release skepticism nor mixed reviews did much to hamper The Purge's box office momentum, as it went on to gross $91.3 million on an insanely low $3 million budget. The budget was famously kept low by shooting most of the movie in a single house, and star Ethan Hawke taking a paltry upfront salary of just $10,000 in exchange for hefty backend compensation - a gamble which paid off handsomely as he reportedly walked away with $2 million.
In an era of increasing political turbulence, audiences seemed to connect with The Purge's provocative, darkly satirical ideas, enough that a franchise was born, encompassing five movies which have grossed over $530 million combined to date, against a total budget of only $53 million.