20 Most Critically Adored Comic Book Movies

Who says they're just for kids?

Heath Ledger Joker
Warner Bros.
It’s no longer taboo to admit your insatiable appetite for comic books, and it's cool in a strange sense to understand the mythology behind modern blockbuster heroes. Comic book movies used to be inspired by comics, but now they are quite literally bringing panels to life; the interwoven MCU has shown this already, and DC's latest venture looks set to be heavily inspired by the New 52 line of comic books. With Hollywood pouring more and more money into comic book inspired action flicks, it is hardly surprising that these movies have racked up some pretty high percentages on Rotten Tomatoes as well as pulling in a lot of money. Critics no longer see these films as fodder for children and nerds; comic book films have shown that they can have multifaceted characters and layered plots, as well as spectacular special effects. In short, they're legit. Far from the sixties Adam West Batman movie, the current take on films inspired by funny books allows them to fit in with their contemporaries - The Dark Knight Trilogy is hardly out of place among the action flicks of the day, and everyone is trying to emulate Marvel's success at the moment. And with that shift in mentality comes critical adoration: something that was unthinkable when Sly Stallone was recklessly taking off his Judge Dredd helmet...

20. The Dark Knight

Heath Ledger The Joker The Dark Knight
Warner Bros.

Rating: 94%

Heath Ledger's final complete performance rocked the world, and he has given a whole generation their definitive Joker.

But beyond his stunning performance, Christopher Nolan's second Batman film had an intricate plot, which is still captivating, and it remains incredibly quotable to this day.

The special effects are astonishing, and the movie cemented Batman's integrity as a character - a far shout from the Schumacher days of nipples and unwelcome camp.


19. Spider-Man 2

904447

Rating: 94%

It goes without saying that it is hard for any sequel to beat the first movie, but Raimi managed to top his first Spider-Man film with this fan-favourite effort.

It had a great story behind it, and Doctor Octopus was a villain whose tragic transformation towards villainy was entirely understandable, with no awful Mr Freeze style trade-down.

It's just a shame that the franchise was squandered by the final movie.


18. Iron Man

Iron Man Downey Jr
Marvel Studios

Rating: 93%

Robert Downey Junior’s performance alone could warrant the movie’s place here, but the fact that the entire MCU has exploded out of this film means that it deserves its accolades.

Despite Tom Cruise being attached to the adaptation for a long time, Downey Jnr was perfectly cast, drawing on his own experiences to add textures to the character that cynics might have thought impossible of the genre.


17. Superman

904911

Rating: 93%

Until this point comic book franchises had been laughable, which is unsurprising since Adam West’s Batman offered the prevailing tone of comic characters.

But Christopher Reeve’s debut as Superman was stunning to say the least, and it set the tone for all future superhero movies. How different it could have been had Sly Stallone got his way and been cast.


16. Avengers Assemble

Avengers Assemble
Marvel Studios

Rating: 92%

How is this not number one?

Capping off the phenomenal Phase One of Marvel movies, this spectacular movie showed how the interconnected MCU could flourish, and now all kinds of other studios are trying to catch up with Marvel's runaway success.

Let's just hope that Age of Ultron can live up to this film's brilliance.


15. Men In Black

904909

Rating: 92%

Taking a break from the DC/Marvel dominance for a minute, this Sci-Fi comedy and action flick remains amusing to this day - especially in light of its God-awful immediate sequel. Will Smith and Tommy Lee Jones were spectacular as the bizarre buddy cops, and the special effects were mind-blowing at the time.

It looked like the franchise was dead in the water after the disappointing third instalment , but the Sony e-mail leaks revealed that they may cross the characters over with the 21 Jump Street crew... somehow. Don't ask.


14. X-Men: Days Of Future Past

Michael Fassbender X Men Days Of Future Past
20th Century Fox

Rating: 91%

The cast of this movie looked like a roll call of nominees for awards; James McAvoy, Sir Patrick Stewart, Jennifer Lawrence, Sir Ian McKellan, Hugh Jackman, Halle Berry etc... Bryan Singer’s return to the Director’s chair saw him unite the original X-Men cast with the new First Class bunch, and complete with an engaging and well written story, this movie blew audiences minds. Rebooting an entire franchise is no mean feat, so you've got to respect how well written this movie was.


13. Guardians Of The Galaxy

Guardians Of The Galaxy1
Marvel Studios

Rating: 91%

Marvel’s surprise hit of the summer needs to be recognised; turning an obscure comic featuring a talking tree and a sarcastic rodent is no easy task, yet James Gunn’s Sci-Fi flick has gotten everybody excited about the new dynamic within the MCU.

With characters like Groot and Rocket Raccoon the film couldn't be taken too seriously, and the writers clearly acknowledged this early on in development. This is the movie that has shown Marvel has the Midas touch - who else could have made this movie such a commercial success?


12. Spider-Man

904904

Rating: 89%

Sam Raimi’s trilogy went off the rails a little with Spider-Man 3, but the first movie was genuinely great and remains a classic.

This was a time when Hollywood was still uneasy about using comic book movies, but Raimi’s first effort showed that audiences would show up to see these types of movies.

Without the success of this we wouldn’t have the thriving comic book movies we see today, so it's hard to argue against this one.


11. Captain America: The Winter Soldier

Captain America The Winter Solider Chris Evans
Marvel Studios

Rating: 89%

After the excitement of the Avengers glossed over the inadequacies of Iron Man 2, the MCU needed shaking up, and boy did this movie manage it.

It played with important political issues, it had fantastically written dialogue, and it saw Black Widow’s character developed in a way that makes her more than just a token woman hero in the male dominated MCU. That's no bad thing.


10. Superman II

Superman Ii
Warner Bros.

Rating: (89%)

Terence Stamp’s portrayal of General Zod was exhilarating, imposing and somewhat scary – everything it needed to be.

The special effects were stunning for its time, and the success of the sequel was very much based on the same selling points as the original. This time though, Superman was fighting against evenly matched villains, meaning that he had to use his brains and not his brawn to beat them.

Superman III and IV were pretty dismal by comparison, but this was a great movie.


9. The Dark Knight Rises

Dark Knight Rises
Warner Bros.

Rating: 88%

It wasn’t as good as The Dark Knight, but Nolan's final Bat-film gave the trilogy a sense of closure.

Bane was a great tactician and a formidable foe (until Talia’s revelation demoted him to a pawn in her plan) and the final sequence continues to spawn debate as to whether Bruce survived or not.

All-in-all, the movie was a great way to end a fantastic franchise before it became too drawn out.


8. X2: X-Men United

X2 Nightcrawler
Fox

Rating: 87%

Coming straight off the back of Bryan Singer's first X-Men movie, this sequel explored Wolverine’s origins and wove interesting social themes throughout the film. Bobby’s ‘coming out’ about being a mutant directly mirrored the experiences of many homosexuals, while Pyro’s switching of allegiance showed how Xavier and Magneto were simply two reactions to the same stigma.

The first three X-Men movies could have been a spectacular trilogy, it’s just a shame that Brett Ratner let The Last Stand go to waste, squandering this potentially explosive trilogy.


7. X-Men: First Class

904889

Rating: 87%

X-Men Origins: Wolverine was hardly well received - and rightly so - so critics and audiences were understandably apprehensive about this prequel movie.

Thankfully, any concerns proved to be unfounded, and the movie turned into a global success, with this cast now continuing to tell X-Men stories for the foreseeable future.


6. Batman Begins

904499

Rating: 85%

It took a brave soul to take on Batman after the mess of Batman Forever and Batman & Robin, but Christopher Nolan did a spectacular job of reinventing the caped crusader.

Batman Begins was a dark and gritty superhero movie, spawning swathes of attempts to emulate this success, but none have managed to beat this so far. Batman's origin is pretty well known, but this movie made it interesting with a new direction that also profited from a fantastic villain turn from Liam Neeson.


5. X-Men

904492

Rating: 82%

Joel Schumacher had tarred the reputation of comic book movies in the mid-nineties, so Bryan Singer’s X-Men movie needed to be amazing in order to throw away any preconceptions that audiences might have about the genre.

Luckily, it was.

The movie drew from the source material, but it also reinvented the entire comic book movie genre, putting flamboyant and powerful heroes into a semi-realistic world. The movie deserves recognition on this basis alone, but the fact that the franchise is still going strong speaks volumes about the quality of this masterpiece.


4. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World

904475

Rating: 82%

Too many comic book movies take themselves seriously these days, but this hyper-stylised effort from Edgar Wright is definitely not cut from that cloth.

The film fully embraced the fun and colour of comic books, and it translated pretty well onto the big screen despite a not universally positive reaction.


3. Batman Returns

Batman Returns
Warner Bros

Rating: 80%

As of late Tim Burton has let his loony ideas flourish to an unwelcome degree, but back when Batman Returns was released he was in his prime.

The gothic tone of the movie was incredible, and it matched the great tone of his first movie, which perfectly capitalised on Michael Keaton's uneasy, beautifully broken portrayal of Bruce Wayne. This was truly one of the first dark superhero films, so it certainly deserves this high standing.


2. Captain America: The First Avenger

Captain America First Avenger
Marvel Studios

Rating: 79%

The star spangled leader of the Avengers might not have seemed like a prime candidate for Hollywood success, but this movie launched the patriotic hero into newfound popularity with a younger generation.

Hugo Weaving’s Red Skull was frankly brilliant, and Tommy Lee Jones just about redeemed himself for the terrible Two-Face audiences had endured. The movie set up Avengers Assemble, and it was a great final solo film for Marvel's Phase One.


1. Dredd

Dredd
Lionsgate

Rating: 78%

Karl Urban’s portrayal of iconic British comic character Judge Dredd in 2012’s eponymous movie gave the character an exciting new opportunity, especially after the mess that was 1995’s Sylvester Stallone film. Sadly, there hasn't yet been a sequel, but there are rumblings about a second part being in the works.

The tone perfectly captured the tone of the comic book, and the modern reinterpretation has breathed new life into the fascinating character.


Contributor
Contributor

A 21 year old History graduate looking for someone to listen to his ramblings. Lover of comic books, movies and all other superhero related things. Published in The Independent, always looking for interesting things to write about...Follow me on Twitter at @samclements1993, and check out my blog: http://samuelclements.wordpress.com/