21 Jump Street Sequel: 4 Dos and 4 Don'ts To Make It Work
There has been talk of a sequel to last year's 21 Jump Street ever since the film was released but this week it was made official that a sequel will be hitting cinemas, with a tenative release of sometime in 2014. I really enjoyed the first film, it being one of my favourite films of 2012. It was a surprisingly smart and poignant take on the classic 1980s TV show starring Johnny Depp- subverting and spoofing cop movie cliches without becoming too meta- as well as being a thoughtful story of two guys who get to relive their high school experience over again. While I'm open to seeing Jonah Hill and Channing Tatum reprise their roles of Schmidt and Jenko, respectively, I'm a little worried the sequel won't be as fresh as the original. Still, there's potential for a 21 Jump Street sequel to keep things fresh, touching, and very funny. With that in mind, here are some dos and don'ts that I think the filmmakers should follow in order to make this sequel work. We'll start with the things the studio definitely SHOULD NOT do... 4. Don't: Overstuff
Spider-Man 3 may be the ultimate cautionary tale for trying to put too much in to one film. I think it's best, even when you're doing a follow up film, not to feel you have to do more than you did the last time. As long as the story is fresh and the characters have room to evolve, you don't need to jam in too many new major characters. Moreover, one thing I really liked about 21 Jump Street was, in an age where comedies can, arguably often drag on too long, such as with the Judd Apatow produced joints, it clocked in nicely under two hours and succinctly told its story. Keep the next film moving fast enough while not rushing the emotional stuff, and I think you're good to go.
3. Don't: Send Schmidt And Jenko to College
Now, I know the ending of the first film had Ice Cube's Captain Dickson tell Schimdt and Jenko they were going to college for their next assignment, which is the obvious continutation of the story. But for me, I think the filmmakers should skip the college storyline. Here's why: I don't think the college setting will work as dramatically or comedically as the high school setting. In the first film the high school setting suited Schmidt and Jenko's backstories and their development as characters. In the beginning of the film, we that Schmidt was the uncool kid and Jenko was the popular jock, albeit one that was insecure about his intelligence. When they got older they both joined the police force and became friends, no longer completely defined by their high school stereotypes. When they both go undercover at a high school, they get their undercover identities mixed up, with Jenko taking science classes and Schmidt taking classes that put him in with the cool crowd. The film showed that despite how much Schmidt and Jenko seemingly grew up, they still suffered from their high school era insecurities. Schmidt gets in way too deep with the kids he's supposed to be investigating in relation to a drug ring, which ultimately gets in the way of Schmidt and Jenko's friendship, as well as their assignment. The film also demonstrated how high school dynamics have changed over the years. What is considered "cool" is much different then when Schmidt and Jenko were in high school- thanks in part, as Jenko mentions, to "Glee." By the time you get to college, everyone's pretty much grown out their respective high school sterotypes. College seems dramatically "shallower" a setting compared to high school and I don't think it'll lend itself to as rich character development for Schmidt and Jenko as we saw in the first film. I think the ending of the first film works best as a mocking of the obligatory sequel set-up in Hollywood films, emphasized by Jenko's "No!" that ends the film. In fact, the college storyline may work best as a running gag throughout the sequel as something mentioned in passing- something could have gone horribly wrong during the assignment that we don't completely learn about until the end of film. I don't know what setting the film could utilize but setting the film outside a school environment could allow a more unique story.
2. Don't: Go Over The Top With Action
While the first film did have its share of action beats, they suited the comedic tone of the film and didn't feel the film was on auto pilot when they happened. Sequels tend to go bigger, especially in the action genre but I think a 21 Jump Street sequel, while expected to have some action, needs to keep its focus on the characters and story, the same focus that made the first one feel special. Though if they do want to go a little bigger with the action sequences, I think there's a way to combine big action set pieces with small scale storytelling. While it's a different genre of film, I would say the filmmakers should keep in mind Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2, which balanced epic superhero action and relatable human drama. There were some moments of over-the-top self-indulgence in the first movie, but dialling it all up for the sequel is probably one of the worst possible outcomes for the sequel.
1. Don't: Resurrect Johnny Depp
This probably won't happen anyway, but I wouldn't put it past a studio executive to want Johnny Depp's undercover agent, Tom Hanson, who was killed at the climax of the first film, to magically come back alive for a sequel. Depp's cameo worked because it was a nice send up and send off for his 21 Jump Street character. It allowed Depp to finally make peace with a show he had complicated feelings toward, and the project that made him famous and served as passing of the torch to the new characters and actors. To extend Depp's role in this new franchise beyond a cameo would feel cheap and obvious, and would offer very little creative value, unless someone has a ridiculously clever idea. And I don't mean zombies. And now, on to the things the studio SHOULD do with the sequel...
4. Do: Bring Back Brie Larson
While the main focus of the first film was the relationship between Schmidt and Jenko, I'd argue that Brie Larson's performance as high school student Molly Tracey was as integral as Hill and Tatum's performances in making the film work. Larson's performance had a down to earth and natural charm that rivaled even that of Emma Stone. While Molly's storyline regarding her relationship to Schmidt was resolved at the end of the film, I think there's still room for Larson in the sequel, even if it's a smaller part. It'd be interesting to explore where her character is after the events of the first film, espeically since Molly felt a little more complicated then the typical female character in these types of films. If they do go down the college route for the sequel, she could show up at the same college at which Schmidt and Jenko are undercover. Having her back would also create a nice sense of continuity, showing the audience the first film hasn't been forgotten. 3. Do: Get A Compelling Villain
While Dave Franco's Eric Molson provided some interesting complexity regarding Schmidt's relationship to the assignment- and Rob Riggle definitely scored laughs as gym teach/drug supplier Mr. Walters, neither were rivaling the Joker for a place in the hall of iconic movie villains. For sequels, the tendicity is to up the ante in regards to the villain. Think, of course, of the Joker, Silva in Skyfall, and Benedict Cumberbatch's John "maybe he is, maybe he isn't Khan" Harrison in the upcoming Star Trek Into Darkness. For this sequel, Schmidt and Jenko should face off against a powerful foe, someone who can be both hilarious and dangerous. Maybe Christoph Waltz, two time Academy Award winner, whose performance as Nazi Hans Landa in Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds is one of the stand out villains of the last decade, could be a good fit for this franchise.
2. Do: Fill Out The Cast With Great Supporting Players
One of the joys of the first film was the wealth of comedic talent assembled for the smaller supporting performances: Ellie Kemper as the chemistry teacher who has a crush on Jenko, Chris Parnell as Schmidt's drama teacher, New Girl's Jake Johnson as the high school principal, Nick Offerman as the Deputy Chief of the police department, and of course, Ice Cube as the angy Captain Dickson all provided solid laughs and provided a nicely rounded universe of characters. For the sequel, the filmmakers have to continue to find great comedic pros who can fill out this world. Melissa McCarthy, whose star has risen since Bridesmaids, could be a great addition, as well as SNL's standout new cast member Kate McKinnon. And on the male front, Community's Donald Glover and Danny Pudi could benefit from more film exposure.
1. Do: Bring Back Phil Lord And Chris Miller
The original film's screenwriter Michael Bacall is back to write the sequel but the film's director's Phil Lord and Chris Miller, haven't signed on to direct yet. I hope Lord and Miller come back. They already know the characters of Schmidt and Jenko quite well, as well as how to get strong performances out of Hill and Tatum, which makes them the best choice to move the series forward. Their comedic sensibilities fit the material perfectly- they balanced the humour, action, meta references and character development and made it all click together. If they made it work once, who's to say that can't do it again? Now I turn it over to you. What do you want to see in a 21 Jump Street sequel and what do you think the filmmakers should avoid when making the film. Let me know.