21 Monstrously Stupid Pieces Of Writing In Godzilla

Join us as we tear Godzilla to pieces.

WARNING: This article contains MAJOR plot spoilers and a whole heap of whining so if you haven€™t seen the film yet, or you liked it, then this probably isn€™t for you. If, however, you appreciate good writing and expect a big budget movie to spend at least some of that budget on a writer who can make sense, please come with me as we tear Godzilla to pieces. It is rare to leave a film feeling angry unless that was the intention of the writer or some major injustice is playing on your mind. Watching Godzilla, though is a rage inducing experience and you leave with a bruise on your forehead from all the face-palming that goes on throughout the movie. WhatCulture.com writer Simon Gallagher has already mentioned some the major flaws in his excellent piece but let€™s examine some of the more detailed reasons for the ire this big budget flopbuster causes.

21. It€™s My Birthday, Is It?

The hints are there fairly early on that the script wasn€™t given the love and attention necessary to make a Godzilla film actually credible. We€™re talking about a film concerning a prehistoric, radioactive god-lizard who somehow survives to present day. We€™re willing to suspend a little disbelief OK? But what we won€™t stand for is criminally bad writing. Right there, right at the start is evidence that this film was written by more than one person over several drafts and that none of them talked to each other. Ford makes his dad a Happy Birthday sign with the intention of putting it up before his dad wakes up. Joe is already up and about though so the plan in scuppered. When Joe and Sandra are sitting in the car she tells him that Ford made a sign for him, Bryan hangs hid head like €œaw damn, I upset my poor boy€. Not 30 seconds later she says €œHappy Birthday by the way€ and he asks €œIs it? I totally forgot€ So what did you think the frikken sign was for then?

20. Arrested Where Now?

The first time Joe is arrested he is taken to a consulate and his son is called to come and get him, in Japan, like there wasn€™t a local US diplomat who would have been called in. The second time though, they are taken straight to the epicentre of the secret military location for no apparent reason. Why wouldn€™t they just have been taken straight back to a police station rather than to a secret installation with a monster in it? While we€™re at it, remember that sign we just mentioned? The one Ford didn€™t have time to hang up before he went to school? How did it end up hanging in the living room?

19. Bryan Cranston Dies

OK, hands up who thought €œGodzilla, nah, not that bothered. Oh, wait, Bryan Cranston€™s in it? I€™ll give it a shot€. That guy from Malcolm in the Middle showed the world he could ACT in Breaking Bad and if you went to see this monster movie expecting to see a bit of gravitas brought to it you weren€™t to be disappointed. For the first 20 minutes or so he is clearly the best part of the film. Emotive, believable, compelling, you are gripped watching his performance. Then they kill him off. The circumstances of his death are, of course, contrived but as someone has pointed out, the stated reason for his actual demise was eminently survivable. Either Bryan decided he didn€™t want to be involved anymore and they wrote him out or the producers thought that a bait and switch for Aaron Taylor-Johnston would be perfectly fine with the audience. What they neglected to do, though, was pick an actor who was capable of filling his shoes so the rest of the film feels like there€™s a gaping hole it. If they thought that character was superfluous there were many other ways of getting rid of him. In fact, why he didn€™t die when the entire nuclear plant collapsed around him is a complete mystery but the fact is that killing him killed the movie. There were only 3 good things about this film, Bryan Cranston, Elizabeth Olsen and Godzilla and all three were criminally underused.

18. The Dog

Let€™s ignore the fact that Godzilla swimming ashore would never have caused a Tsunami in the first place and go straight to the most annoying part of that scene. The dog getting away. Simon touched on this briefly so we won€™t labor the point too much, but that dog was tied to a tree. It wasn€™t getting away, it was definitely a gonner. Then in the next scene it€™s managed to break free from the leash and is running down the street faster than the humans. Dog saved, everything cool. Except, no, it isn€™t. This is either a ridiculously cynical move or one borne of a focus group saying that the didn€™t like the bit where you killed the wee doggy. We€™re fine with all the kids and families being washed away but don€™t kill that one dog! Please.

17. Diving Under The Ship

Godzilla is quite happily swimming along on the surface when, for no apparent reason, he suddenly dives under the ship with all the main characters on it only to pop up a second later and wipe out 2 other destroyers. He€™s clearly big enough and hard enough to have ripped right through the hull so why dive under the boat? Or, for that matter, why is the boat even directly in his path? It€™s a fairly big sea and if they know he€™s coming why is nobody firing at him? It all makes for nice CGI and a big spectacle but what it doesn€™t make is any sense at all.

16. Where Has Godzilla Been For 50 Years?

Godzilla lives on the ocean floor to be near the radioactive core of the Earth right? And he€™s the same Godzilla that was hit by all those nuclear blasts in the 50€™s so spectacularly ineffectively yes? So where has he been for the past 50 years or so? Napping? Nuclear power stations aplenty, nuclear submarines, hell, even Chernobyl, not a peep. Then two creatures show up that aren€™t even his competitors or prey and he€™s all over it? Did their echo-location calls wake him up and piss him off royally? If he€™d turned up then killed and eaten them then fine or if they were fighting over land or resources cool, but exactly what was Godzilla€™s motivation (dahling) to risk life and limb killing these two massive creatures and then slink off back to the sea? Oh, and while we€™re at it, aren€™t they supposed to be parasites and the word spores is mentioned on more than one occasion? Could someone not have opened a biology text book from high school and looked up the mating behavior of parasites because these things don€™t act like anything other than standard eat, sleep, mate creatures.

15. Nobody Saw The Mountain Side Being Ripped Open

Running around a nuclear waste dump in Nevada trying to find out which €˜cell€™ has been opened, lifting the hatch and saying €œclear€ in each one only for one of them to be empty. The big reveal being that the whole side of the mountain has been ripped open, helicopters are all over the area and the MASSIVE creature is lumbering its way towards Las Vegas. Exactly how was this MASSIVE creature supposed to grow to that size and break out without an alarm going off somewhere? Was there any need for the soldiers to be running about trying to find out which vault had been opened or would there have been a manifest with €œbig nuclear beastie €“ vault C4€ written on it? The whole point of the scene was the big reveal but are we really to believe that nobody pointed out the huge hole in the mountain on the drive up?

14. Flying Jets Near An EMP

One can imagine that a military person, advisor or strategist would avoid seeing films like this since their kind are so often portrayed as stupid but did nobody on the writing staff pick up a phone and call one of them for advice? Or Bing for €œmilitary jets EMP€? For a start, all electronics on a military jet have to comply to standards that make them less susceptible to EMP but as one site (fairly easy to find) noted, there is almost nothing that can be done to shield completely against such a weapon. The military KNOW for an absolute FACT that these creatures can emit high powered EMPs so what do they do? Send in mult-million dollar aircraft to get knocked out of the sky and kill people that€™s what. Not a drone with a laser targeting that a Tomahawk missile could use as a marker, not even a guy on the ground to paint the target but no, full on loud as hell aircraft that are guaranteed to get destroyed. The US don€™t even like sending planes in when they can hit a target with pin point accuracy from miles away so this is just a childishly stupid mistake. One that they gleefully commit again later on in the film.

13. Thinking Something Powered By Radiation Can Be Killed By A Nuke

The primary destructive forces of a nuclear explosion are heat, light and the blast wave. The radiation is a largely secondary factor that kills living cells and DNA but not for these creatures, they feed on it. Has nobody on the staff of the Navy boat ever seen a monster movie? To be fair, at least one person does mention that it€™s a monumentally bad idea but she is of course roundly ignored. They know that Godzilla was hit directly with a whole bunch of Nukes in the 50€™s to no effect so why would this time be any different? Oh, right, that€™s it, this one is so much bigger it makes the ones from the 50€™s look like a firecracker. This is the same nuclear weapon that you€™re about to send to a population centre right? Surely this whole plan is roughly akin to trying to kill a 5 year old by throwing more gummi bears at them? Might make them sick for a while but they€™ll soon be running about with more energy than you can handle.

12. Catching The Kid, Nobody Saying Thanks

Let€™s not go on too much about this one but if you lost your kid on a train the way those two parents did, some random guy said he€™d take care of him, a monster appears and you think he€™s dead, then he shows up at a rescue centre, do you think you€™d look for the dude that saved his life? Damn right you would. You€™d hug him to within an inch of his life and at the very least get his address so you can send him a card every year. But no, little kid gets saved, his parents pick up him then bail. No €œwhere is the man who saved your life€ nothing.

11. Surviving The Bridge Jump

Nobody would survive that. It€™s more than 200 feet down into a river. You would, at the very least, snap your spine or be knocked unconscious and drown. If a train then falls on top of you too it€™s fairly certain that you€™re a gonner. But no, Ford is just a little dazed and is perfectly fine to continue on to jump out of a plane at 30,000 feet and perform a HALO jump, as Simon noted, with ZERO training. Given his track record he shouldn€™t even have bothered with the parachute since he€™s clearly Captain Jack Harkness in disguise. The most the guy ends up with in the whole film is a bit of a limp and even that disappears a few seconds later.

10. School Busses On The Bridge

This needs almost nothing more to be said other than the title but why would there be a bunch of school busses evacuated across a bridge that we know Godzilla is likely to be coming near? Is there no communication going on? Also, the dumbass driver who decides to floor it and nearly kills several soldiers along the way, what was he thinking? His bus gets blocked in one second then he€™s driving off the next? No sense, no consistency, no point other that to introduce the €œoh the children, what of the children!?€ suspense. Are we so immune to the loss of adult life that we only care if it€™s children in danger?

9. Not Shooting At The Egg Sack

People miss the obvious in films all the time but when the big bad beastie walks past you with its ass glowing red and unprotected by leather it might as well have had a huge bullseye painted on it saying €œweak spot, please shoot here€ yet no one bullet is leashed. Quite happy to fire round after ineffectual round at the bullet proof skin but the big glowing target full of eggs? Nah, let€™s leave that well alone. At least if someone had tried and failed or it turned out to bounce bullets off fine, at least the question would have been answered. But not firing at an obvious target like that is just ridiculous.

8. Firing Missiles Into The Air

We know Americans have a reputation for fire first think later and an almost criminal disregard for human life but are we seriously to believe that they would fire high powered missies near a population centre like that? We€™re almost led to believe that Godzilla takes the hit for the sake of the kids since he€™s portrayed, not as a bad guy, but as a hero. But the idea that an experienced Navy commander would risk hitting civilians in a futile attack on something you know for a fact can withstand a nuclear blast is utterly incredulous. If it had been the MUTO they were firing at there is maybe an argument that the risk would have been worth the potential gain but since it€™s Godzilla they€™re firing at, not so much.

7. 5 Guys Are Going To Lift A Bomb Down To The Pier?

This same bomb that was so big and heavy it had to be loaded onto a train was to be carried down to the pier by 5 dudes. Now, realistically, that€™s not entirely implausible. The actual warhead of a nuclear bomb isn€™t that big. What didn€™t make sense was why it needed a whole freight train to carry it in the first place or why they took the missile portion at all. €œAim the pointy end at the bad guy€ was the line from the grunt, except there was no intention of firing the missile at anything, it was to be set to explode on a timer. So you take the smallest possible portion to keep weight down, not something that looks to be the size of a Saturn V rocket.

6. Physics Of Flight

There is no way that creatures that size could even live in our current atmosphere. Millions of years ago when there was far more oxygen in the atmosphere, yes, but now they would just die of asphyxiation. But let€™s ignore that for now since it€™s a Godzilla movie and go to the truly impossible part. There is a not a chance they could have taken to the air. The downbeat of one wing would have been enough to level buildings never mind that the weight of the creature is clearly enough to crumble skyscrapers. It just wouldn€™t get off the ground. The largest prehistoric creature to fly had a wingspan of about 12 metres and were mainly gliders, but these things are far bigger than that and have powered flight. Even if it was made of carbon fibre there€™s no way it could take off from a standing start. You canna change the laws of physics captain.

5. Conveniently Placed Doors

Whether it€™s the doors closing just when we€™re about to see a kick ass fight or the inexplicably placed wooden doors leading to a crater in the ground the director used the same €œbig reveal€ technique so often for it to utterly ridiculous. Are we really to believe that the doorway stood firm and that there was no other way down? The €œta-da€ nature of the direction is childish at best and incompetent at worst. If you want to reveal something like that to the audience the best way is a close up on a character€™s reaction following by a camera pan to show what they were reacting to. But at least mix it up a little rather than using the same thing 12 times throughout the film. Honestly, was this his first movie or what?

4. Eggs Placed Perfectly

Big momma digs herself a hole in the ground, accepts a nuclear pressie from her suitor and starts laying eggs in the ground, presumably unfertilised as Simon noted. But the main bug-bear here is that instead of just being dumped in a big hole, the eggs somehow end up arranged perfectly in a nice web structure. All in the space of about 5 seconds. How on Earth did the creature manage this? There are no doubt creatures in nature that will lay their eggs in a fractal pattern or in some form of structure but they would take their time doing it. What we have here, then, is a creature who can excrete a work of art in under 5 seconds. Complete nonsense.

3. Plasma Breath

After battling said MUTOs for a decent portion and getting bitten a few times for his trouble, Godzilla suddenly remembers he has plasma breath than can charge up within a few seconds. If this one a one-time deal or he could only do it once every few hours then OK but he clearly fires twice in a very short time-frame. So why didn€™t he use this earlier? Is he a cat? Was he just playing with them? That he has this in his arsenal is of course ridiculous, but having it and not using it until the last few minutes of the film? Give us a break.

2. Boat Starts Itself After Having Been Hotwired

Someone needs a lesson in physics methinks. This boat is a piece of proverbial and it had to be hotwired to get it going. Then an EMP shuts it down and would have fried all the electrical circuits on the boat. The battery would have been goosed completely, generator circuits burned out and the whole thing useless. Yet it starts itself back up a few seconds later with even the light bulbs still working fine. We also have the situation where the GPS had been set automatically BEFORE the EMP hit, so how did it switch back on and keep the same heading after the power miraculously came back on. Also, when there are only 14 minutes left until baddaboom, why would any helicopter pilot agree to risk his crew for one man? And why didn€™t Ford just jump in the water? Surely the sensible thing would have been for the pilot to have been ordered to pick up the bomb and fly it out as far as he could since the helicopter could fly faster and further than the boat could possibly travel in the allotted time.

1. EMP Would Have Knocked The Helicopter Out Of The Sky

Given the circumstances and the time involved, the size of the bomb used and the proximity of the helicopter the good ol€™ EMP would have come into play again and knocked that bird right out of the sky just like its jet brethren earlier in the film. In fact, why was it even flying in the first place since it would have had to have been grounded, switched off and shielded in order to survive the initial EMP that knocked the other jets out minutes earlier. So, I don€™t know about you, but I feel better having got all that off my chest. Maybe you think €œit€™s just a movie€ and don€™t care about any of the above but if we set the bar that low for our entertainment we do ourselves, and genuinely good writers, a disservice. There is nothing to say that a monster movie or CGI blockbuster has to make no sense and in fact many manage to keep at least some internal consistency. This film, though, has so many mistakes as to end up in a hall of infamy. A few mistakes are forgivable, this many is just careless. What did you think of the movie? Am I being too harsh? Sound off below!

Contributor
Contributor

I.T. Consultant, technophile and Doctor Who fan. I like to talk about tech, take films apart and make excuses for Doctor Who's continuity errors. No other show has the power to make me feel like a big kid.