4 Reasons Why John Hughes Wasn't So Great
In lieu of the hate I will probably receive for this I would just like to state that John Hughes is a personal favorite of mine as both a director and writer. This list is by no means intended to be a hate fest just to slam the dearly departed. If anything it will probably make you appreciate Hughes all the more. No director is perfect (I think) and each has their flaws. By highlighting them and discussing them I think you come to appreciate the individual better as an artist who despite his/her personal and professional failings was still able to produce captivating and entertaining works of art. If anything it can probably give the fans of Hughes out there something to shoot for. If you were indeed looking to pick up where Hughes left off in the teen drama genre then you would do well to avoid these pitfalls that continually marred Hughes' work throughout his career. Others of you out there who aren't fans of Hughes will probably be glad to see the guy taken down a peg or two. Not that you're a hater but you do realize that there are other better directors out there who made great material for teens to enjoy. Or maybe you're just a hater. Whatever the case I'm sure you readers will find the list captivating and challenging in hopefully the best way possible. If not and this list provokes you to some violent reaction then I suggest you take Charlie Sheen's advice off Ferris Buller's and talk to someone.... 4. He Can't Write Well Rounded Adult Characters
Out of all the complaints I have about the late great Mr. Hughes this is probably his most annoying trait. In John Hughes' world adults are the enemies. Either that or they're the idiots. Here is what the great critic Pauline Kael had to say about the issue in her review of The Breakfast Club:"The writer director John Hughes has fallen back on the standard device of appealing to teen audiences: blaming adults for the kids' misery. Each kid in turn tells the group of the horrors of home: the wrestler's father pushes him to compete, the princess is given things but not affection, the brainy kid is pressured to be a straight A student, the (secretly sensitive) rebel is beaten and burned by his brute of a father, and the shy girl - the basket case - has parents who ignore her. It's she who puts her finger on the source of all their troubles. "It's unavoidable," she says. "When you group up, your heart dies." Young audiences have always been suckers for this kind of flattery. They love hearing kids swap stories about how rotten their parents are, and no doubt they like to see all this viciousness loaded on the school official. The budding neuroses that made these kids antagonistic to one another are cured by their coming to see their parents and teachers as the common enemy."
Look, I get that Hughes has a knack for showing the world through a kids point of view which is commendable, but often that can leave the adult characters, who kids can often tend to vilify, as the monsters of the story. If you were to go film by film you would see how much Hughes is lacking in the area of writing well thought out adult characters. Sixteen Candles = The parents are idiots who only exist in this movie to forget Sam's birthday and apologize for it and the grandparents only exist to be groping old fogies. Breakfast Club = The parents in this movie are basically little demons in station wagons. Everything that is wrong with these kids is because of their parents. Ferris Buller's Day Off = Parents are stupid unassuming idiots so beguiling and easily tricked they make Carol Brady look like a tiger mom Weird Science = Parents are once again evil suppressors who must be punished for being such a nuisance. Imagine the gall of Gary's (Anthony Micheal Hall's) parents for insisting he not go galavanting around with a grown woman with a gun. What monsters! And so on and so fourth. There probably isn't a teen centered John Hughes film out there written or directed that doesn't vilify or stupefy adults. The funny thing is when Hughes switches gear and actually writes or directs stories about adults (Planes Trains and Automobiles, Uncle Buck, and even the overly melodramatic yet undeniably effective She's Having A Baby) his grown up stars are usually well written and complex adult characters. I wonder why there is a disconnect? When he looks at the teens the adult characters suffer. When he looks at the adults the kids usually aren't even a factor. Its a shame he couldn't have met himself somewhere in the middle and perhaps made a great cinematic picture about a complete family from the oldest to the youngest with each stage of life handled with care and dignity. Alas it seems that at best all John was able to do was give us the adults as villains/idiots over and over again. Personally I always thought it would be cool to have an alternate Breakfast Club showing the adults throughout the day and what they do without their kids. They probably have lives and hopes and dreams too and as many shocking and revealing things to say about their kids as the kids have to say about them.
3. He Is A Racist
You ever seen a film called The Palm Beach Story? It's truly a great film. One of Preston Sturges' best. Not as good as The Lady Eve but every bit the comedy that The Miracle Of Morgan's Creek is. Anyway I was reading a review of the film in this collection of film reviews I had and in the review, written by David Ansen, he makes a critical summation in regards to a racially insensitive comedy routine that Sturges placed at a key point in the film. The scene is a bit between a black porter on a train and his particularly foul and deprecating treatment by a traveling gang of all white eccentric millionaire game hunters. Ansen states that: Undoubtedly one of the slapstick summits of the 1939's and 1940's comedy this immortal sequence also contains what has become the movies one mark of shame - its utterly stereotypical treatment of the terrorized black porter as a popeyed servile comic foil. Sturges may have been the most unconventional Hollywood humorist of his day but in racial matters he was a very conventional white man of the 1940'sYou find a very similar situation with John Hughes. He may have been one of the greatest screenwriters of all time. He had a great mind for comedy and a wonderful insight into the affairs of teenage life but in racial matter he was a very conventional white man of the 1980's. Throughout many of his landmark films (both written and directed) there are numerous examples of racial stereotypes and cultural insensitivity. The most famous example of course is his depiction of Asian American Long Duk Dong (played by Gedde Watanabe) in Sixteen Candles. You remember him right? He's hard to miss since a gong sounds whenever he enters the scene. As Susanna Gora recounts in her excellent book detailing the rise of 80's youth culture on screen titled Don't You Forget About Me:
"Dong was a walking punch line, an impossibly uncool teen with a thick indeterminate Asian accent who tries out his English by exclaiming such now well worn phrases as "Whass happenin', haahstuff?" He uses a fork and spoon as chopsticks, gets drunk at the party at Jakes Ryan's house (where he frolics with his newfound "sexy American Girl-friend!"), and ends up passed out on a front lawn pleading, "No more yanky my wanky- the Donger need FOOD!"I can't help but think Blake Edwards sighed a sigh of relief when Sixteen Candles was released because finally someone had another grand example of Asian American stereotyping to acknowledge as horrendous instead of the legendary one he provided in his film Breakfast At Tiffany's.
Yet as I mentioned earlier there are many more racially insensitive low-lights to be found all throughout Hughes work. Other such famous examples include. 1. National Lampoon's Vacation = Car ride through the ghetto.
Sad to say that the only black people the Griswald's see on their legendary trip to Wally World are jive talking pimps and hub cap stealing hustlers. Well.......there is also the other security guard they meet at the park. At least he has a position of power.....which Clark demeans when at gunpoint he makes him get on all fours like a dog and roll over. 2. Sixteen Candles = Pink Guy, Black Car
Ah yes, the great Sixteen Candles. Who can forget Samantha Baker's epic trials and tribulations endured at the hands of Grandparents, nerds, China-men, and a totally inconsiderate family who forgets her birthday. It would be worth it however if only she could share a loving kiss and tender embrace with the man of her dreams. Granted that man has to be pink. But hey give Sam some credit; at least she wanted the car to be black. 3. Weird Science = Hanging at the bar.
Granted Anthony Micheal Hall is hilarious in this scene. Its just sad to see his comedy have to be based solely on Black stereotypes. After Lisa took them on a trip like that I would have to wonder what exactly was put into her programming. Maybe some Aryan philosophy lessons got downloaded by mistake. 4. Ferris Bullers Day Off = "Hey man what country do you think this is?"
Thumbs up for Ferris here. At least he wants to include people of all races in his day off...as long as they're stealing his car or doing an impromptu Thriller dance during a parade. Other than that they can get lost Why Hughes needed to include such reprehensible stuff in his movies is a mystery. Granted, Hughes himself was the first to admit his cultural ignorance when he said that "I'm not going to pretend I know the black experience", which I completely understand. But why oh why Mr. Hughes are the only other cultural experiences you know all stereotypical ones? Perhaps I'm of the mindset that if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. I understand that you may not know a whole lot about Chinese culture, but if that's the case then why do you even have a character like Long Duk Dong in your movie in the first place. Why is that the only thing you chose to recall or emphasize about the people of the orient? Of course there are the people who'll say that Hughes is just being realistic. As Molly Ringwald points out "for that time in the suburbs of Chicago it's pretty accurate" (the racial segregation she means). Okay, I guess I can buy that. Hughes was just trying to be realistic with his depiction of certain all white suburbs and communities. As Susanna Gora put it: "and indeed the world Hughes understood and set his films in was overwhelmingly white, more accurately so than, for example, the oddly Caucasian New York of Woody Allen's movies"To that I would have to ask, why is racial realism the only type of realism Hughes chose to emphasize in his films? He certainly didn't emphasize realistic high school settings like in Sixteen Candles where the flat chested 16 year old ends up with the Calvin Klein model who ditched his ridiculously good looking girl friend to be with her. He didn't emphases realism when in Ferris Buller's Day Off he showed a super charming rouge holding the city of Chicago in the palm of his hand for one day and doing whatever he wanted including illegally sneaking on parade floats and leading the city in a sing a long of Twist and Shout and Danken Schoen. If he was willing to stretch the limits of imagination in those parts of his movies then why not in others. I'm a little bit perturbed and suspicious of this Hollywood tradition of having a grand imagination in every part of the movie making process except casting. Oh sure we can explore other worlds and fight dungeons and dragons which of course is all totally fake, but put a black lead, a Mexican lead, or an Asian lead in the role (who isn't a stereotype) and suddenly you've gone too far and your ability to suspend belief is over taxed. I suppose it all boils down to a sadly warped perspective. Like Hughes himself stated he didn't know anything about the black experience. Well what exactly did he want to know? As far as I know black people speak the same language, have the same parts, experience the same pier pressure and worry about the future just like white people. The same goes for any kind of race you can name. Would it have killed him to diversify his movies a little bit. Great talent doesn't make up for having a poor demeaning vision of other races. If anything it can make your talent seem more hollow and less insightful. I know Hughes made some great strides in portraying well rounded and captivating teen melodrama on the screen and we fans of his are forever thankful for that. It's just sad that many of the great movements in filmmaking culture, be it D.W. Griffiths narrative advancements in Birth of a Nation or John Hughes social explorations in his teen films, always seem to be accompanied by such horrible instances of cultural insensitivity.
2. He's Overly-Dramatic
Did you ever stop and think how many whiners exist in the standard John Hughes teen film. The one that comes to mind for me is Andie from Pretty in Pink. Can you actually believe this girl? "I don't want you to see where I live alright!"
Really!? Because....you're so poor right? How can you be poor and still have a nice house, a job, a car, a scholarship to college, and apparently enough money to have a unique sense of style. I call bull crap Andie. I wish at some point in the film Andie's car would have broken down in the ghetto from National Lampoon's Vacation so she could perhaps get a little view of what real poverty is. And then there is Cameron from Ferris Bullers Day Off. Remember his great little speech at the end of the movie. How did it go? "I am not going to sit on my A*% as the events that affect me unfold to determine the course of my life. I'm going to take a stand. I'm going to defend it. Right or wrong, I'm going to defend it."Nice monologue there Olivier. Not to sell the youth of the world short but I'm pretty sure that speech is something that would never be spoken by a teenager even in a fantasy type movie like Ferris Buller. Unless of course that teenager is an overly dramatic drama queen. What exactly were you going to take a stand against my friend? You stole your Dad's car and took a joy ride around Chicago on a ditch day from school. You better hope you're not taking a stand in juvenile detention center or jail. If Cameron really wanted to make a stand then why didn't he take a stand against Ferris when he bullied him into committing grand theft auto? Or would that have been too hard. Spare me your over written speeches Cameron and stand up to the person who is really taking advantage of you: Ferris "stinking" Buller. The kids on the Breakfast Club aren't any better either. They're even more pathetic than Cameron actually. Of course, as you read in point one, they have a penchant for blaming their parents for the stupid decisions they make themselves. Andrew (the jock played by Emilo Estevez) went on a nice little diatribe in the film about how much his dad has made his life miserable. Save me your tears Mr. Jock. Your dad may be a harsh taskmaster but I'm pretty sure he didn't instruct you to tape a boys buns together. If you wanted to cut loose so badly you could have pulled a fire alarm or stuck a potato in a teachers tail pipe. But taping a boys buns together and pull out the hair... I'm sorry man that's all you. The monologue was nice and Emilio gave a good performance but it was still just a kid still blaming his parents over something he just really wanted to do. Boo Hoo. Don't even get me started on the basketcase. I like the spontaneity of the character and thought Ally Sheedy did a fine job but she lost me with the whole "When you grow up your heart dies" crap. Aren't we going a little overboard there kid. As John Bender so aptly stated following her grand summation of adult life "who cares!" And please spare me the whole my parents ignore me crap. If my kid acted as crazy as her I'd be apt to do a little ignoring myself. Perhaps if she were to access her un-crazy side a little bit then maybe her parents wouldn't avoid her like the plague. Just a thought. Claire could also can take her first world problems and go somewhere as well. You ditched and got caught. Next time don't get caught. Bender didn't grate me so much. He actually had a legitimate reason to complain about his plight. The Brain's story is actually one I can stomach because the group came to the right conclusion about it. Laughing. Not taking things so dang seriously or worse, blaming someone else. Perhaps if they all stopped and looked at their situations with a bit of levity, maturity and a bit less self-centeredness they would all be better off. I'm not saying teens don't deal with hard issues, but to think that is all there is to being a teenager is drama, drama, drama, isn't right either. Sadly that seems to be about all John Hughes thinks teen life is. Even when he manages to bring a little joy into the proceedings as in Ferris Buller's Day off there is still that dark underrcurrent of teen angst that must be dealt with in one way or another. That's why I still think one of Hughes best films is Weird Science. No long overly dramatic speeches or meanderings about growing up. Just two guys creating a big huge fun mess and then owning up and taking responsibility for it.
4. He Steals Thunder Away From Better Teen Films
Hard to believe it but John Hughes was not the only person making teen centered films in the 80's, neither was he the best one doing it. I understand that in the entertainment world there are many cases of people who receive too much praise and those who receive none even thought the latter's work is often as good or better than the former. Its a common occurrence to be sure but never has there been such an egregious example of over-praise than with John Hughes. For many who even have a faint recollection of the 80's his name is remembered far above any other director. Even those who made much better films than his. When asked who the premiere director of the 80's is do people say Steven Spielberg or Martin Scorsese? No. They immediately identify John Hughes. Impressive to be sure but this kind of obsessive praise can cause people to miss the forest for the trees. Some of the better more healthy trees producing good fruit for teenagers during that time were people like Amy Heckerling, Cameron Crowe, Savage Steve Holland, Joel Schumacher, Martha Coolidge, Rob Reiner, and Francis Ford Coppola. I think the reason Hughes is so well remember above all these others is a matter of quantity over quality. He put out a lot of stuff back then and essentially over-saturated the market. The good he did helped to elevate his more mediocre material to a point where everything he produced was seen as legendary. If you wanna be real you would have to admit that Hughes was behind maybe just a couple of movies (both written and directed) that had any sort of real worth in the 80's. Film critic Marshall Fine made a great point when he stated that: "John Hughes was a mediocre director and prolific writer who wrote more than three dozen films and directed eight. And of those, there are about three that stand the test of time: Sixteen Candles,The Breakfast Club and Ferris Bueller's Day Off. Those are the three films in the Hughes' oeuvre which, early on, had me convinced for a moment that Hughes was a genuine talent"To that list of 3 I would probably add Planes Trains and Automobiles and Weird Science but other than that I agree whole heatedly with Mr. Fine and his sentiments. I understand John Hughes probably wanted to be like Preston Sturges in that he wanted to direct so he could protect what he had written but unlike Sturges he didn't posses any real directorial talent beneath his surface deep slick visuals, hokey charm and occasional profound insights. Hughes' talent with a pen was able to take him a long way in Hollywood but one of the places he should have avoided was the director's chair.