4 Reasons Why Paul Thomas Anderson is The Master

There are a number of things which combine to make him the closest thing to a perfect filmmaker we have seen.

Of all the directors out there, I have the hardest time analyzing Paul Thomas Anderson films objectively. I look at each Martin Scorsese picture realizing I may not like certain elements; I examine Darren Aronofsky and the films he directs with the understanding his next movie may not be as good as his last, and with any auteur out there I am able to view their films from a certain distance, where I can spot flaws. I cannot seem to do that with Paul Thomas Anderson, and for some time now have tried to figure out why. Finally, I have come to the realization that, in my opinion, Paul Thomas Anderson exists on another level than any other working director. I haven't been able to criticize his films because I have found no flaws in his work. It isn't because my own personal adoration for the power in his direction has clouded my critical vision; it is because my love of each and every PTA picture is warranted. In every case, it can be justified. But what makes Anderson a Master? There are a number of things which combine to make him the closest thing to a perfect filmmaker we have seen.

1. A "Full-Vision" Director

For the sake of argument, let us keep Hard Eight on the side as this debut Anderson film was cropped and marginalized to the point of barely counting as a PTA picture. But his five features beyond Hard Eight, despite certain motivations behind them, were written by Anderson. He has had control over the creative process from start to finish. There Will Be Blood may have been inspired by the Upton Sinclair novel Oil!, but I have read the book and there is hardly anything mirroring the film. Each of Anderson's films has been a creation from his own mind, with sparse amounts of external inspiration. They are full visions from his mind and the creative process functions in such a fluid manner, nothing feels manipulated from outside sources. And this full-vision functionality of PTA's work speaks to the confidence he has in what he has to say.

2. Performance Power

Of the four major releases in Anderson's career (The Master notwithstanding), there have been four Academy Award nominations in the acting categories. There were two for his breakout debut, Boogie Nights (Burt Reynolds and Julianne Moore), one for Tom Cruise in Magnolia, and a nomination and win for Daniel Day-Lewis in There Will Be Blood. As The Master nears its release, consensus is that Joaquin Phoenix is a shoe in for Best Actor and Philip Seymour Hoffman and Amy Adams have legitimate chances at their own nomination. This is an impressive group of nominees, but arguably Anderson's finest work came when Adam Sandler stepped away from his goofball persona to play Barry, the protagonist of his small romantic film Punch Drunk Love. Sandler has never again reached the heights of Punch Drunk Love as an actor, and the inspiring direction and writing of Anderson must be credited for this turn.

3. Taking Chances

All good directors take chances. That is what makes them good, and it is what makes some great. Aronofsky is constantly testing the waters of endurance in his audience, and Cronenberg pushes buttons each time out. But even their daring moves seem to function within the framework or tone of their films. Anderson started small with the chances he took in Boogie Nights. The film was intense in the end, but he showed the confidence he had as a director in his extended close up of Mark Wahlberg's Dirk Diggler as he sees his life and hope crumbling around him. Punch Drunk Love took a chance on Adam Sandler, but the dreamlike quality of the entire film was juxtaposed to his central character, a lonely man prone to outbursts of violent behavior. There was the milkshake scene in There Will Be Blood, endlessly parodied over the years. But the scene works. In the framework of a serious film, here is Daniel Day-Lewis' Daniel Plainview, mocking Eli Sunday with a ludicrous and condescending speech full of fury. It generates laughter, but the laughs are uncertain, nervous of what might happen, which is why it is so effective. But Anderson's most daring and awe-inspiring moment exists in his melodramatic epic, Magnolia. A serious film about the damage of fathers and children floats along one day of despair in Los Angeles. And then, in the third act, Anderson incorporates a musical number where each of the central characters sings an Aimee Mann song. The song is an immediate departure from the melodrama of the film, and a moment which 99% of directors would never even consider let alone put in their film. Anderson went for it, and the result is a stunning moment of calm and clarity amid the chaos of these characters' lives. And on top of everything, after the musical number, it rains frogs. And, alas, it works. Big surprise.

4. Getting Stronger

With each passing film, Paul Thomas Anderson gains more confidence as a director. Of course we all realize Boogie Nights is a stunning film, especially for a 27 year old, Magnolia carries even more emotional power, and Punch Drunk Love is a crafty experimental picture. But with There Will Be Blood, the epic scope and storytelling power of Anderson reached new heights. And judging by the early reactions to The Master, I expect nothing less here. Anderson has grown more powerful and more confident with each and every frame he shoots, and there are any number of reasons why.

Contributor
Contributor

Self-made film aficionado with a background in creative writing. Proprietor of www.themoviesnob.net. Lover of all things cinema. Follow me at @LCTmoviesnob and enjoy the ride.