4 Reasons Why The Avengers is Overrated

Do you agree that The Avengers Assemble is overrated or are you one of the 244,563 (at time of writing) that has helped put it in at #42 in the IMDB top 250?

Welcome to That€™s So Overrated! Each week (or so) I€™ll be bringing you a different film/actor/performance etc. which I believe is overrated. Simple enough really, of course this means that I€™ll likely be venturing into territory that many will feel the complete opposite about and will get some of you frothing at the mouth, but wouldn€™t life be boring if we all thought the same thing? For this inaugural instalment I€™ll be treading fragile ground€I invite you to read on good people! Are we all quite done shouting about how awesome and kick ass the Avengers was? I suggest we take a few minutes and calm ourselves down. I know it was a long time coming and everything, but I think we could all do with taking a second to mop the pool of drool from our laps. Feeling better? Ok good. Now don€™t get me wrong, I just want to say now I€™m by no means saying The Avengers was a BAD film, in fact I rather enjoyed it. I just want to take things into perspective. As your average popcorn blockbusters go, The Avengers is certainly up there with the best of them. But do you honestly think that it€™s one of the best films ever? I find it mind boggling that based on user ratings, The Avengers comes in at No. 46 in the IMDB top 250, coming above so many true classics such as Taxi Driver, The Shining, Lawrence of Arabia and Gladiator. It even has the same average point score as Citizen Kane, AFI€™s official greatest film of all time. Personally I don€™t even think it€™s the best comic book film, I€™m no expert on the world of comics but I enjoyed the two Nolan Batman films and Kick-Ass much more. Let€™s break it down shall we?

1. The Plot

There€™s nothing revolutionary here, it€™s all standard stuff. (Insert Villain) threatens to destroy/conquer earth, (insert hero/heroes) must battle to save it. This template serves its purpose time and time again, it€™s good, it works, but it€™s not mind blowing either. This isn't such an important factor when establishing the value of a blockbuster, but when it comes to 'greatest of all time' territory, average just ain't gonna cut it.

2. The Antagonist(s)

Loki is solid, but for me he€™s not the epic villain that the film really needed. Surely a film based on a team of superheros needs at least a more threatening villain or a team of less threatening villains? Again, I€™m no comic book expert, and I know Loki is a god/ demi-god or whatever, but there€™s just nothing about him in the film that makes you think €œshit, this guy€™s pretty damn badass!€. €œYeah but it€™s not just him, he has a badass army of alien type people trying to mess crap up€, true you make a good point. But who were they? Maybe someone with knowledge of the comic book verse can tell me in the comment box below, but for the casual viewer they were just faceless, nameless villains€and for bad guy€™s to be truly threatening they need to have a recognisable personality to them. If you ask most people who the best super-villain has been in recent years, I€™m sure the vast majority of people will say The Joker. Why is that? He has no excessively threatening abilities or powers afterall, except perhaps his winning smile. What makes him such a great villain is how well crafted his character was (and of course Heath Ledger€™s performance). There was a real sense of evil, a kick ass sinister streak and this depth of character was what made him so threatening. Loki didn€™t have this; the strength in character just wasn€™t there and he never truly felt like a force to be reckoned with.

3. The Acting

The acting in The Avengers was a mixed bag. This ranged from the awesome (Robert Downey Jnr., Mark Ruffalo, and Clark Gregg) to the average (Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth, and Jeremy Renner) to the downright terrible (An unfortunately miscast Cobie Smulders). It's difficult to stand out whenever Robert Downey Jnr. is around, and frankly Captain America and Thor really suffer when sharing the screen with Iron Man. The only character able to interact well with him being Mark Ruffalo's Bruce Banner. Scarlett Johansson was hot as usual, but other than that I€™m not sure what else she brought to the film. But we€™ll let her off because she did look damn good.

4. The Dialogue

Again, it was good but nothing special. The surprise package in this sense was of course The Hulk, taking everyone unaware by not being completely terrible like in the past two attempts at bringing the classic character to the screen. But let€™s not get ahead of ourselves, yes there was a couple of funny lines from him and Downey Jnr., but there were actually people laughing out loud around me in the Cinema€come on people, a soft chuckle would do the trick, it wasn't that funny! Other than that, the rest of the dialogue is very average, X doesn€™t trust Y, Z wants X and Y to play nice to save the world, X and Y finally work together etc etc. I honestly enjoyed The Avengers, it was fun, action packed and entertaining. I€™m not disputing that. But how it can be considered one of the best films of all time is absolutely beyond me, when you think of all the films out there that are deeply meaningful, challenge you, engage you or just make you down right laugh out loud, how can The Avengers really compare? It was a little bit funny, had some good characters and had some pretty cool action sequences. A great popcorn blockbuster, but no classic€ can€™t we just leave it at that? What do you think? Do you agree that The Avengers Assemble is overrated or are you one of the 244,563 (at time of writing) that has helped put it in at #42 in the IMDB top 250? Sound off below.

Contributor
Contributor

Music Editor for What Culture! Follow me on Twitter: @CurtisEvans90